3 ms·
Treating trust as binary is folly. DANE means the provider could send the correct certificate to most people, but a fake one (along with a fake IP) to specific
by icebraining 9y ago
Treating trust as binary is folly. DANE means the provider could send the correct certificate to most people, but a fake one (along with a fake IP) to specific victims.
Convergence distributes this verification, so the provider would have to give the same false result to everyone, otherwise a notary will catch the discrepancy.
- kuschku 9y agoAnd? The provider can request a lets encrypt certificate for the same domain already, and then give Let's Encrypt a wrong IP. This allows the same provider to get a fake certificate, and MitM only specific users. I don't see any additional attack surface.
- icebraining 9y agoYes, DANE is not necessarily worse than what we have right now. But what we have right now is what moxie is criticizing. His trust agility argument is for a new proposal (called Convergence), not to defend CAs vis-a-vis DANE.
- marcosdumay 9y ago> Treating trust as binary is folly. What? Any trust point being compromised would lead to the same result. Why would anyone use a non-binary comparison?
- icebraining 9y agoThat quote needs the context of the rest of the post to be understood. My point is that you can trust someone more if you increase the cost of violating your trust.