14 ms·
Thomas & Friends is gold. The show is dignified and wholesome. It is always about respect, diligence, and humility. It isn't there for stupid antics and wacky
by paulddraper 9y ago
Thomas & Friends is gold.
The show is dignified and wholesome. It is always about respect, diligence, and humility.
It isn't there for stupid antics and wacky laughs. It doesn't blast color explosions and ADHD-fueled off-the-charts mind-numbing exuburance to capture kids attention. And it's been doing that for decades (pretty much eternity, as far as kids TV goes).
Not since Mr. Rogers has there been a better kids TV show.
> Fat Controller
Better known as Sir Topham Hatt since the 1950s.
> Henry must be punished—for life
Even in the old non-US version (modern one makes it explicit), it was still evident that he wasn't left in their forever, as he showed up again next time.
Blue Mountain Mystery [1] A little green engine hides in the blue hills. Thomas learns that long ago, the engine accidentally caused another engine to roll overboard into the sea. He has been hiding ever since, in guilt and fear and shame. Thomas convinces him to return, and the story shows how silly the little engine's worries were. It's a moral of forgiveness and redemption. (Also, there's a great surprise about who that overboard engine actually is.)
This crap makes me mad. I have to stop reading stuff on the internet. Go back to watching Sponge Bob or Family Guy or whatever crap you watch with your kids.
[1] http://ttte.wikia.com/wiki/Blue_Mountain_Mystery http://ttte.wikia.com/wiki/Blue_Mountain_Mystery
- NegativeLatency 9y agoAs a kid I also really loved Theodore the Tugboat. Similar kind of show, but with boats. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodore_Tugboat https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodore_Tugboat
- danbolt 9y agoI remember watching that as a little kid too. Did it ever get syndicated outside of Canada? EDIT: I skimmed the Wikipedia article, and discovered it had a pretty wide distribution. I'm impressed!
- paulddraper 9y ago> The show premiered in Canada on CBC Television, then went to PBS (Public Broadcasting Service), was on Qubo in the US, and at one time had appeared in eighty different countries. Looks like PBS Kids (the most likely syndication for Americans) ran it to some degree from 1993 to 2002.
- NegativeLatency 9y agoYeah, I watched it on KCTS (Seattle PBS station)
- ux-app 9y ago>The show is dignified and wholesome. really? I always found it to be quite creepy. The constant obsession with being a "really useful" engine. The shaming of engines who don't toe the line. Victimisation of engines who misbehave. The show makes me strangely uncomfortable for some reason.
- pstuart 9y agoAnd what happens to engines that are not "really useful"? I think we all know.
- adolph 9y agoYes, when the small railway was closed down Duke was left behind in a shed where he stayed until urban explorers found him and restored him.
- paulddraper 9y agoIt doesn't make as much sense for our imminent future state, when robots do all our jobs and we sit around all day, but I like the distinctive "really useful engine" complement. Obedience, diligence, and selflessness are admirable qualities. All kids and adults should strive to be really useful, in the best sense of the phrase. There's far too much narcissism in the world.
- ux-app 9y ago>I like "really useful engine" complement That's fine, but in Thomas it's presented as : be really useful or else... I find it mildly sinister, I have a visceral dislike for the show. The moralising does not sit well with me at all.
- Allower 9y agoI have NEVER seen a good explanation of how 'Obedience' is EVER an 'admirable' quality. If you can't think for yourself and make rational decisions, you have much bigger problems than not 'respecting authority'. Any authority that is incapable of demonstrating the rationale behind their directives is a fool and should be treated as such, with the utmost disrespect.
- Blackthorn 9y agoSpongebob is also pretty dignified and wholesome, so try to make your rant a little less "get off my lawn". You don't need to try to drag something else down to build your preferred show up.
- stordoff 9y ago> Better known as Sir Topham Hatt since the 1950s. Seemingly only in the US ("the Fat Controller is always referred to by his real name, "Sir Topham Hatt" in the US"[0]). I was born in 1990 (UK), and as I recall he was almost always refered to as "The Fat Controller". [0] http://ttte.wikia.com/wiki/Sir_Topham_Hatt#Trivia http://ttte.wikia.com/wiki/Sir_Topham_Hatt#Trivia
- toyg 9y agoCan confirm, "fat controlla" is alive and well in UK. I personally hate the character and agree with Ms. Tolentino, the whole setup is very regressive. What angers me most is that it exploits British pride in their early railway industry (which is basically dead now, ok, but is still venerated, especially outside of London) to peddle a worldview completely based around hierarchies and the duty of subordinates.
- Doctor_Fegg 9y agoMore passengers are carried on the British railways now than ever before, so I wouldn’t call it dead. (Posted from the comfort of an HST on the rural Cotswold Line, slated for part closure 40 years ago and now thriving.)
- arethuza 9y agoIndeed - reopening closed lines seems to be very popular here in Scotland - the Borders Line from Edinburgh being the most obvious example although there are others. I enjoy my commute by train into Edinburgh from Fife - not least because it means I get to go over the Forth Bridge.
- toyg 9y agoDead in the manufacturing sense, sorry it wasn't clear. There is basically one manufacturer left in the country, Bombardier, which is actually Canadian. The network is alright, although still shamefully behind most of Europe (very little electrification, still no high speed, etc etc).
- 9y ago
- grahamburger 9y agoAgreed, and there are a few other TV shows that I really like for my kids for many of the same reasons: Curious George, Tumbleleaf (Amazon original), and maybe Backyardigans.
- paulddraper 9y ago+1 for Curious George. We told our son that Christmas was coming up. "Oh no. I have to find a present!" He thinks that Christmas is about giving, not receiving :P
- ux-app 9y ago> Not since Mr. Rogers has there been a better kids TV show. I'm too young to have watched this show. Just googled it and it really does look like a lovely, wholesome show. Personally my gold standard is the original Looney Toons (Mel Blanc era). I could watch that irreverent, slapstick all day. I'd rather my kid take a leaf from Bugs Bunny's F-you style than Thomas' meek, obey, do what you're told and stay on the rails message.
- alsetmusic 9y ago> Personally my gold standard is the original Looney Toons… I find Looney Toons extremely racist and stereotypical. Though I grew up on it, I wouldn’t expose kids to it.
- ux-app 9y agohehe I guess it is (speedy gonzalez, el gringo pussy cat-o, that short dad from the 3 bears that slaps his wife and kid around), but it's so damn charming at the same time. I guess now we have Rick & Morty so we've got a new wave of irreverent cartoon to enjoy
- hirsin 9y agoAre kids not watching Mr. Rodgers these days ? That's really tragic. I think that was one of the best things on TV growing up, in retrospect. I'm biased however, having grown up with it, in Pittsburgh where its filmed.
- mcphage 9y ago> Are kids not watching Mr. Rodgers these days ? It's not really on the air anymore. The modern animated spinoff "Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood" is still on, and is quite good. But I'm not sure when you'd find the original still on.
- paulddraper 9y agoThey're on Netflix. I watched a couple recently. I've gotten way too used to HD :)
- glenstein 9y ago>it was still evident that he wasn't left in their forever, as he showed up again next time. "We shall take away your rails," he said. "And leave you here for always and always and always." They definitely wanted the viewer to believe it was permanent for purposes of that episode. And if you watch the scene (linked to elsewhere in the thread), the dominant emotional themes are stubbornness, arguing, physical confrontation, the giving & revoking of permissions and punishment. That's haunting, not wholesome.
- ballenf 9y agoThe fantasy / fallacy that all things are forgivable in life and nothing has permanent consequences is also damaging. Just had a good friend’s nephew drown in a pool. He had snuck in a backyard pool, skirting past or under the fence. As a parent the whole thing was a nightmare for me to imagine, but I did think about how or if to communicate to my kids that there are things they can do that will have permanent consequences or effects. I do my absolute best to shield and protect them, but I also hope and pray they make the right choice if (when) I fail in that. I’m not saying that the punishment in that episode was appropriate, but simply that the concept of permanent consequences is a life lesson we all must learn at some point. And it’s incredibly difficult to teach kids.
- glenstein 9y agoI'm sorry to hear that, and I share your hope that I can avoid any such nightmare by being sure to talk about those dangers to kids (in my case that would be my teenage siblings just starting to drive cars). But at the same time, I like to think there's a reasonable amount of breathing space between noting the show's excessively haunting atmosphere and indulging in a fantasy of a world completely free from consequences, and that with sufficient good faith I can do the former without having to disavow the latter. But I definitely share your observation about the show's tone, and it's interesting to note that different people can see value in the show for opposite reasons. Some see it as wholesome, others as delivering needed lessons on the severity of life.
- vlunkr 9y ago> permanent for purposes of that episode What does that mean though? Generally kids who are old enough to follow the story know that the universe is reset in each episode.
- KirinDave 9y agoI'd rather let my daughter watch SpongeBob or Octonauts or Ghibli movies rather than shows that tell her that every aspect of her self worth should be defined by how useful she is to the rich people in town. And that's the underlying justification for a lot of the episodes: Thomas has an obligation to be grateful for his work and to do as he's told. Even when he doesn't like the job. Even if there are better things for him to do. Even if his friends are sad or in danger. It's a pretty vile lesson.
- e12e 9y agoPfft. Thomas is property - a capital investment of his owners. Of course he should be recycled for scraps, if he doesn't perform... Now, is the message of the series that Man enslaves machines, or that Man Enslaved becomes a machine? And should you aspire to become master of the machines, or slave to the Man?
- dmlorenzetti 9y agoThe comparison with Mr. Rogers is instructive. Both shows seem rooted in a minister's desire to encapsulate ideals derived from the Bible. But while Mr. Rogers is New Testament, the Thomas books are Old Testament. Henry, for example, gets punished for the sin of VANITY -- he doesn't stop in the tunnel in order to shirk work, but rather to avoid getting his nice new paint messed up. To see the difference between the shows, just try to imagine Mr. Rogers presenting a puppet show about bricking a character up in his room as punishment for not wanting to get his new suit wet in the rain. And imagine him, in that Mr Rogers voice, saying "I think he deserved that punishment, don't you?"
- humanrebar 9y agoI think the New Testament disagrees with your characterization of the Old Testament. Pretty much the entire New Testament goes on about how the Old Testament is a series of stories about how cycles of rule making and rule breaking do not lead to real justice, peace, or life. In particular, both Romans and Hebrews (though not exclusively those books) cite Old Testament stories to make the case that the Old Testament (a.k.a. the law and the prophets) is largely misunderstood to be about a world full of crime and punishment. For example, Romans 1 talks about how people (not a vengeful God) set up the worst consequences for themselves. God's "wrath" is unfiltered humanity. Romans 2 goes on about how there's plenty of blame to pass around (so there's no room for "good people" to blame "bad" ones). And Romans 4 holds up Abraham, an Old Testament character, as an example of how life should be lived, in faithfulness to a forgiving God. All through this passage, and in the rest of the book, a case is built from the Old Testament itself. Anyway, I don't have strong feelings about Shining Time Station, but I think the Old Testament is more humane, sensible, and subtle than people seem to appreciate. At least the apostle Paul seemed to think so.
- linkregister 9y agoThis analysis, while novel and interesting to me, is not supported by the bulk of events in the early Old Testament. I will name some examples of God personally meting out the death sentence en masse as punishment for sin in various books of the Old Testament. 1. The Great Flood (Genesis), 2. Sodom (Genesis), 3. The Plagues of Egypt (Exodus), 4. The Exile of the Israelites from the Promised Land (Exodus). Redemption, mercy, and forgiveness are primary themes in the Gospels, and further continue as major themes in the rest of the New Testament. Aside from the Lake of Fire (Hell), which is worse than being killed for being a first-born Egyptian child, references to punishment are secondary. As for Paul's opinion of the Old Testament, that is fine, he wrote that opinion. There is no shortage of contradictory and conflicting opinions and facts in the Bible since it is a work compiled, edited, and written by humans. That said, the mainstream Christian opinion that the Old Testament is vengeful and the New Testament is merciful is prevalent for a reason. Paul cannot retcon, try as he might, the events of the Old Testament.
- daxorid 9y agoWarning: a little offtopic. It must be a lonely existence for you. Your Church is also the only faith in the United States, possibly the world, that is even attempting to push back on modern trends in ever-ratcheting-forward cultural degeneracy. > This crap makes me mad. It may be comforting to realize that the traditional values of Western Civilization are entirely dead, and that getting angry about it is futile. We lost, and the time for acceptance has long been here. It's much less stressful to accept the loss than to rage against it.
- rukuu001 9y ago> It is always about respect, diligence, and humility My 2yo nephew recently started watching Thomas. It was my first real exposure to it. After watching a few episodes I remarked that the central messages of Thomas are: - Authority always knows best. - Never think for yourself. - You have no value until you are 'useful'.
- dingaling 9y ago> Never think for yourself Independent thinking is lauded ( Toad suggesting how to save the whale ), but unilateral action is not. > You have no value until you are 'useful'. In the wider context of society that's entirely accurate. Community doesn't exist unless people contribute to the group.
- Retra 9y agoThere is a risk of setting up a situation where "useful" is determined by presumed authority rather than any objective sense of utility. There's also the problem of how to deal with things that are not useful now, but presumably will be (in an emergency, for example.) There's also the problem of usefulness that is not communicated effectively; maybe we don't know how to express the usefulness of some activity. This does not mean it is not useful. So it's a mistaken ideology from the start. Usefulness is valuable -- that's practically the definition of the term. But life requires finding a way to be valuable in predictable ways just as readily as it does finding a way to be valuable in unpredictable, circumstantial, and unforeseen ways. So it's not entirely accurate. It's partially accurate; it is as much a lie by omission.
- dingaling 9y agoI see what you mean. But what else can we do other than prepare children to be assessed in terms of now-usefulness? When they come into contact with team activities ( sports etc ), the world of work or even just small social groups they will be graded implicitly and explicitly by the value they contribute. Should we not prepare them for that? Even here on HN those who are lauded as heroic engineers are those seen as Really Useful ( started a space company, have a lot of github contributions, maintain an OS kernel etc ), not the quiet cogs who churn-out CRUD apps in Fortune 100s. It's always great to have a space or a time in which you can slob-out and be not-useful but Western society considers that exceptional and calls it 'vacation'.
- Tloewald 9y agoI have fond memories of Mr Rogers, but really find it pretty unwatchable (and so did my kids when they were of age). They loved Thomas for a while and fortunately they didn't absorb the ideological disaster embedded in virtually every storyline (Topham Hat is a stand in for God and explicitly judges everyone at the end of most episodes based on being "useful" -- to him -- and obedient). There are no significant female characters (my children are girls so that was particular;y annoying; although Dora is more annoying despite having a female main character) and the merchandising is horrible (multiple redundant and incompatible sets of trains and tracks that are all horribly over-priced) Spongebob is a far better show in all respects (I hated it until I had kids). Aside from being hilarious on several levels, it is remarkably socially conscious without being preachy. Oh and it even has some recurring non-pathetic female characters.
- eradicatethots 9y agoIt’s clear you really hate fun, but why?
- westiseast 9y agoIt annoys me too. The interpretation ignores all the obvious positive lessons in TtTE and only accentuates the post-modern and political interpretations as if they're the major themes. I remember one episode where the Fat Controller hires new engines to break a strike. There's obvious political overtones there that reflect the times it was written in perhaps. But in the context of the kids watching and learning, it's about not throwing tantrums to get your way, and the new engines being polite and humble in their work. Conversely, a lot of the modern cartoons around are about breaking rules, getting away with stuff because the protagonist is 'special' and fighting.
- Maarten88 9y ago> ... hires new engines to break a strike... about not throwing tantrums to get your way ... Would you really cast that as a positive lesson? I have never watched this series as a kid, but it seems really awful and confirms the argument of the article. In the moral system I was raised in (EU), people have a legal right to strike and helping break it is highly immoral. To me it seems abusive, and ignoring historical lessons, to teach this kids the other way around.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y ago> I remember one episode where the Fat Controller hires new engines to break a strike. There's obvious political overtones there that reflect the times it was written in perhaps. But in the context of the kids watching and learning, it's about not throwing tantrums to get your way, and the new engines being polite and humble in their work. Do you think there is ever a legitimate reason to challenge authority? I mean, what determines whether going on strike is "throwing a tantrum"? Is it the mere act of disobeying authority?
- samirillian 9y agoI just can't believe that a New Yorker article--some blogger's white-labeled ramblings or not--consists entirely of re-digesting wiki's and comment sections from other corners of the internet. It's really coprophagic.
- justbaker 9y ago> Go back to watching Sponge Bob or Family Guy or whatever crap you watch with your kids. "Go complain about it on the internet."
- nwah1 9y agoSpongeBob is great, but you're absolutely right about Thomas.