8 ms·
It seems like there should be a market for low overhead small schools with high paid teaching staff.
by empath75 9y ago
It seems like there should be a market for low overhead small schools with high paid teaching staff.
- moduspol 9y agoThey were looking at doing this at my last job (small private university). We already outsourced custodial and food service. Do student accounts and financial aid really define us as a university? Are they part of our core competency? Do we do them particularly well relative to competitors? Of course not. So why not outsource them?
- gipp 9y agoFor the university "market", the only game in town is prestige, which teaching quality plays into very little, if at all.
- criddell 9y agoThat's especially true for some professions (like law) but less true for most others. For other fields, school prestige can help you get that first job, but the value of being able to say you were educated at X drops quickly once you start working. Once you've been working for a while, your portfolio, social skills, professional network, and track record are far more important than the issuer of your degree.
- chibg10 9y agoRight? I've thought about this as well. My guess is that: 1) Nearly all university students are making their decision when they're 18, so a lot of them are mostly interested in non-academic aspects of their school 2) It seems really hard to actually start a new university. Anecdotally, every university I can think of is quite old. 3) This is probably related to (2). The benefits of universities aren't really dependent on good professors. The advantage of top schools in both educational progress and student outcomes can probably mostly explained by signalling, filtering out weak students before they arrive, university culture, and networking. None of this has much to do with professors.
- dabockster 9y ago> filtering out "weak" students before they arrive This has a huge effect on pushing schools to the top. You can take a public institution (eg University of Washington, since they're notorious for this), put an artificially high bar on entering a program (eg UW CSE since, again, notoriety), and take in all the public money you want while only admitting the top 10% of students. The school is happy for the brain blast, the state is happy to fund a "prestigious" university, and the people are happy to fund so many smart students attending their university instead of another. Everyone wins, right? Wrong. One of the many problems with this technique is how a university quantifies what is considered a "weak student". Is it low test scores? Bad entrance essay? No planning on the part of the student? Whatever Pearson Hall or McGraw Hill will set on their outsourcing offerings? It's a giant can of worms in terms of what individual strengths and weaknesses are, and how they can either enhance or limit academic performance.
- potbelly83 9y agoCouldn't agree more. It's not so much about the prestige but guaranteeing good employment options.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThey're called “community colleges” (faculty are paid less than universities, but they still have a comparatively high-paid overall teaching staff because the faculty get all the teaching duties, none of it is farmed out to really low-paid grad students.) And, yes, there's a market for them. (This is also what a lot of private, non-research schools sell themselves as, and some actually fit the bill without being abusive frauds, though the money available and historical ease of getting away with being an abusive fraud in that area has made it hard to find the wheat among all the chaff.)
- sevensor 9y agoI believe this is the model Olin tries to follow. In general, institutions that don't offer graduate programs can afford to focus on undergrads. You can see this with the small liberal arts colleges, although they generally fail at low overhead and tend to succumb to the donor-industrial adminstrative complex.
- awal 9y agoSeveral years ago in the animation industry things like Animation Mentor, AnimSchool, etc. popped up to provide cheap(er) classes that were much higher quality than what was offered at almost any big 4-year institution. They were able to do this by paying working professionals side money to generate content and provide student feedback. Code bootcamps seem to be a continuation of this theme.
- jimbokun 9y agoPlease please please tell me where these schools are. I have two teenage sons on college tracks in high school, and absolutely terrified at the bankruptcy inducing sums bearing down on me like a freight train.