16 ms·
Refresh Is Sacred
- adrianratnapala 9y agoThe trouble is "The customer never knows anytyhing and requires us to dumb everything down" is also a treated as a sacred principle in our industry.
- s17n 9y agoThen you're doing it wrong - the correct principle is, "the customer should be able to use the product fully without having to read any documentation"
- givehimagun 9y agoI don't know anymore - is that some self fulling prophecy? "the customer should be able to use the product fully once they have experimented, tried, failed, corrected, and learned by mistake the user interface that we have"
- Maakuth 9y agoThere is no need for that prophecy to fulfill itself, because it is a fact that users don't read documentation. As Joel Spolsky noted, they rarely read even anything: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/26/designing-for-people-who-have-better-things-to-do-with-their-lives/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/26/designing-for-peop...
- nine_k 9y ago...except numerous forum posts, when googling for "how do I do X with Y".
- jerf 9y agoI think, but can not directly prove, that you're already talking about a very small minority there, single-digit percentage levels. Lots of people just muddle along, or ask the office grapevine, or just give up.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jimjimjim 9y agohmm, no i think the first quote is probably closer to reality.
- zokier 9y ago/s? Damn Poe's law strikes again
- KGIII 9y agoWhy is that? It used to be that there were help files and you pushed buttons until you figured out what they did. You had pages and pages of comfiguation options. You had manuals that explained things - without needing a browser. You had settings and advanced settings, hidden switches, and tweaks. Now, you get a hamburger icon and there's not even an exit button. Part of the joy of computing was figuring out what all those buttons and options did. VLC is one application that still has a decent settings selection and their advanced options is just about perfect. I don't even know what half those options are for - but I like it. Please give me back my options to break stuff. I am not scared. Breaking stuff helps me learn. I don't even remember the last time I broke things bad enough to need a reformat. That's not for lack of trying, it's for lack of buttons. I'd like to kindly request you put those buttons back. Seriously, discovering features and mashing buttons until you learn is one of the great joys of computing.
- kelnos 9y agoThe result of computing leaving the hands of heavily-technical users and entering the world of the non-technical is that people are terrified of doing the wrong thing and breaking things. Technical people inherently know that there's very little they can do that's irreversible, and that they'll be able to figure out how to reverse even the craziest of breakage. Non-technical people do not assume breakage is irreversible, and even when they do, they do not assume that they'll be able to unbreak it themselves. Finding someone to help is a nuisance and can be embarrassing.
- KGIII 9y agoMaybe if they had to struggle, they'd learn? If we old people could do it, the next generation is smart enough to do it. Hell, they've got Google to help them. It's not like I'm expecting a return of dip switches and multi-binder manuals. Just, maybe, stop designing for the lowest common denominator? People aren't going to learn unless you give them a reason to. People aren't going to learn if they don't have to. Would you rather smarter users, or simplistic software that underperforms and offers only one output option? I favor choice. I do admit that it makes good financial choice to cater to the lowest common denominator, but even many of my beloved Linux apps are getting dumbed down. I haven't even had a kernel panic in years. Hell, I haven't even had to compile my own kernel in this whole decade. (I have, I just didn't need to.) It's not about keeping it out of the hands of the less technical, it's about still keeping it educational for those of us who are. What kind of dystopia is it, when the preferences menu has but three options? Instead of a stylus, maybe you should just give me a crayon! Really, I think VLC has it right. Handbrake is pretty good. Gimp goes a bit overboard, but I can respect that. My VNC server? It's got like eight options, total. Torrent client? Maybe twice that many, spread over four panes. That's like putting four pieces of lettuce on four plates and telling me it's a salad! Mobile apps? Some of them don't even have options! If there are no options, why use an app? Just use the web! Hell, they don't even have a close option, some of them. What if I want to close it and restart it at the default screen? Task manager or reboot, that's what. 'Snot like it has a discernable back button. No options to configure it, either. I think people with mental handicaps should be allowed to use computers, just like everyone else. It doesn't mean you should design with them as your primary target audience. I'm pretty sure it took more work to take the buttons out than it took to leave them in there. I can't even begin to count the number of updates that have removed options. What the hell was that? You worked harder to make the application do less. I don't even understand that mentality. Sorry for the rant but this is a pet peeve. Imma start a Bring Back The Buttons campaign. It extends to other things, too. I noticed a friend's new television. Their remote had 3 buttons on it. It wasn't even broken, it came like that from the factory.
- hashmal 9y agoFor mass market products, maybe. What about photoshop? music production software? what if your customers are developers and your product is a software library? In many cases there is an inherent complexity to a product, and it warrants some learning curve. Removing the need for documentation often removes power and depth. Funnily, now that many products are like this, the opposite trend is surfacing, and in some niches you have customers who love reading manuals. It becomes part of the user experience.
- kaens 9y agoAbleton (music prod software) takes an approach to learnability that works well -- by default there's a dedicated UI element that shows documentation for whatever you're mousing over. It doesn't remove the need to read docs, especially for people who are new to DAWs, but it does alleviate a lot of the intimidation factor and initial learning curve that can come with needing to find what you need to read in a manual for a complex piece of software.
- hashmal 9y agoI know Ableton Live very well, and yes it's a very good example of hard stuff done right. But I wouldn't include it in the list of "apps that are so user friendly that you don't need to read the docs". (that's not a complaint)
- thaumasiotes 9y agoYou can rephrase that principle as "products should be unable to do anything even moderately complicated". It's not correct for anything.
- l0b0 9y agoThe easiest way to achieve that is simply to remove functionality until only the bare essentials are left. I'd argue this (the UI change, not identifying what can be removed) is always going to be simpler than making the existing UI understandable. A solution which is often asked for by advanced users is a toggle between simple and advanced UI, but this has fundamental problems (The following is inspired by the VLC preferences UI). First, It will be triggered by accident by users who definitely don't want it (or by advanced users sharing the account). How do you ensure they can get back to the simple UI? By definition they are now in a mode which is harder to navigate for a normal user. Second, how do advanced users without extensive knowledge of the internals of the software (non-developers, essentially) locate the controls they were used to from the simple UI? The advanced UI will look fundamentally different from the simple one, because cramming all the advanced features in between the simple ones would just look weird and hacky. Things might even be named differently in the advanced UI because there are technical terms for them which will be more familiar to advanced users. And how do advanced users know if there is even a 1-to-1 mapping (a simple "Dolby Surround" boolean setting vs an advanced "Force Detection of Dolby Surround" boolean setting and "Stereo audio output mode" which can be set to "Dolby Surround")? Third, given finite resources one of the interfaces is going to have more effort applied to it than the other one. How do you ensure that they both stay usable when most users will only ever use one of them?
- kps 9y ago> The easiest way to achieve that is simply to remove functionality The easiest way, yes. I am reminded again of the point made by Dave Smith, one of the Xerox Star human factors designers, at the ‘Final Demo’¹: “Star had many fewer commands than today's systems, and it didn't do it by having fewer functions — it just had fewer commands.” PARC weren't trying to make things easy on themselves. Genericity is hard. Orthogonality is hard. Design is hard. (It's unfortunate that Steve Jobs either didn't understand what he saw, or didn't care, and popularized a Potemkin village imitation.) ¹ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_OwG_rQ_Hqw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_OwG_rQ_Hqw (The particular session starts around 54:30.)
- digi_owl 9y ago
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThat is an even dumber principle, and it is what leads to proliferation of products that are mostly useless toys that pretend to be tools. No amount of JS will make a person who never used 2D graphics programs a master of Photoshop. Only God Himself can make a pivot table that's usable by a newcomer without "having to read any documentation". The only way to realize the principle you described is to dumb down your product until bare minimum of functionality remains, and then hope your users somehow learned to use that minimum in the past. Others have managed to touch on this topic in the thread, so I'll just say this: you don't expect people to be able to fully use a car without having to learn anything. You subject them to a training course. And this applies to pretty much any actual tool. You have to learn to use it effectively. "The only intuitive interface is the nipple, everything else is learned." You can embrace that and figure out how to efficiently teach your users, or you can forever be doomed to building toys that don't actually help anyone that much.
- IshKebab 9y agoHe's not saying that everyone should be able to use every program. But someone familiar with 2d graphics program in general should be able to learn how to use Photoshop without reading the manual. Consider a bad example: Blender. Even though I have used 3D graphics and CAD extensively I still always have to look things up in the Blender manual. Why? Because nearly every control is poorly labelled, there are no useful tooltips, and basically no hints in the UI at all. Take a look at this awful screenshot for example: https://www.blender.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Release_notes_279_video_overhaul.png https://www.blender.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Release_n... What does "File Extensions" do? What about "Placeholders"? Why do none of the number inputs even have units? Nobody is saying that users should have an intuitive understanding of what a B-frame is, but I shouldn't have to read the manual to find out whether the B-frame interval is specified in seconds or frames.
- rootlocus 9y ago> there are no useful tooltips, and basically no hints in the UI at all. That's just blatantly false: https://i.imgur.com/MGrA4Ax.png https://i.imgur.com/MGrA4Ax.png Not only are there tooltips, the tooltips also document the python API. > I shouldn't have to read the manual to find out whether the B-frame interval is specified in seconds or frames. You mean Max B-Frames? Yes, you should know what B-Frames are and that's enough to understand what you can configure. If it said "Max Frames" would you ask yourself if it concerned frames or seconds? Blender isn't an App that anyone should be able to use. It's a complex, specific tool with a lot of features. I've seen many hours of 3D software trainig for anything from Maya, 3DS, Zbrush to blender. Industry professionals usualy take a few courses and need time to adjust before switching software. Each tool has different workflows and only after ample training are you able to fully utilise its power. Blender is built to be very efficient while modelling, sculpting or animating with loads of shortcuts and modes to make these processes as fast as possible in the 3D viewport. You're basically complainig that an airplane control panel is ugly and bad when you have no piloting training.
- vortico 9y agoI kill many apps on the hour just to refresh. Since I've basically reinvented the refresh button with an operating system feature, why don't all apps have them? And why doesn't everything have a home button, especially Facebook.
- digi_owl 9y agoAt least on Android, Facebook seems to have redefined the back button as home. Scroll down, hit back, and rather than exit the app i will be scrolled back to the top and the feed "refreshed" (more like randomized).
- vortico 9y agoThis doesn't work when you're several levels deep in photos, within groups, within comment sections, etc.
- jakobegger 9y agoI completely agree. But the example the author notes isn’t the worst. If killing the app refreshes, that’s okay. The problem is a lot worse if the app syncs to disk. All Apple apps have this issue. iCloud is nice when it works, but it’s infuriating when a photo or something doesn’t show up on your other device, and there is no way to force a sync.
- stefco_ 9y agoAgreed. iCloud's antics keep forcing me to seriously consider android. Their refusal to give you FS or cache access is similarly infuriating; I stopped using my old 16GB purely because I couldn't selectively control what was stored on the phone and iCloud photos was too dumb to control its cache. I would have gigabytes of old photos downloaded to my phone until it was so full that apps would regularly crash! I had to regularly toggle iCloud photo storage and basically just wait until my iPhone had locally cached enough of my library that it was full and broken again... And, of couree because Apple thinks their software "just works" or whatever, I couldn't just hit a "clear cache" button or manually rm files from the cache (still a hack, but one that takes all of two seconds). At the moment, I'm keeping myself somewhat satisfied by just using adobe creative cloud for photos I care about, but it's not an ideal solution. And I'm annoyed that Apple basically forced me to buy a new phone a year or two earlier than I wanted to by crippling my old one with broken software.
- pmx 9y ago> And I'm annoyed that Apple basically forced me to buy a new phone a year or two earlier than I wanted to by crippling my old one with broken software Isn't that basically their business model?
- stefco_ 9y agoYes, it seems to be. The privacy and security emphasis is one of the main things keeping me locked in.
- mercer 9y agoI've been running into a similar issue with the HandOff stuff (or whatever it's called). I'll have a chrome tab open on one computer, do the task-switching thing on the other computer which should open the same tab there. Instead I might get a tab I had open earlier, sometimes well over a minute earlier. Obviously the best solution would be to make the syncing of this seamless, but I'd happily go for a system-wide sync button...
- dannyw 9y agoYou don't have to show a refresh button all the time. If the timestamp of the most recent data is more than Xs, and you hash or build a merkle tree of all the data, then you can opportunistically tell the user that the app's view is out of date and automatically refresh.
- setheron 9y agoWhy does everyone want to throw a merkle tree at it.
- dannyw 9y agoA merkle tree could be used for verifying a tree of data (e.g. a JSON state object) that is updated in pieces. The root hash would be sent as part of each update, to validate that you have the right state. If it's different, a hard update isn't necessarily required - you can find missing items in log time. In addition, for large states (e.g. say all cars in a region/partition for Uber), you can use merkle trees to partition and validate that the client has one area right, without downloading all the data. There are many other approaches, but I think a merkle tree isn't a bad method for the use case of client state validation in the use cases I described. What are your thoughts? How would you architect it?
- viraptor 9y agoIt's the solution that works. Random storage - hash it. Log data - merkle tree. You don't even have to do proper one, because log of state hashes is fine too.
- foxylion 9y agoMy hope is that at some point the auto sync is smart enough so we don't need any refresh button. For example: Instagram does auto sync of new posts, but it also has a refresh functionality. So I never know if it is up to date and I must refresh. When you know about a manual refresh functionality the auto update is totally useles. You're never sure if the app tries to stay up to date or does only occasionally sync to show some (not the latest) updates. Another example is google mail, it does auto sync pretty well and I always see the mails when they arrive. But the refresh buttons makes me suspicious if it's really up to date (in my experience it always is).
- Splines 9y agoIf you're confident enough of your auto-sync, you can always keep the manual refresh and just have it no-op. Eventually users realize that clicking refresh never actually brings in new content, and the content they expect is always there. Or maybe they don't, and think refresh is always super fast (you can't make it too fast). If you do this you'd better be certain your sync works though.
- mijamo 9y agoI use the refresh button in Gmail every day. If I don't, some mails take up to 5 minutes to show up. Not so good when waiting for an automated mail (ex: password reset).
- hdhzy 9y agoRefresh is not solely used to fetch latest data but also to reset the webapp, bringing it to clean state. Believe it or not our apps have a lot of undefined states.
- viraptor 9y agoIt feels like the sign of times - the need for instant information. I like to be able to force refresh in Gmail, because sometimes I know I was just sent some notification / receipt / whatever. But normally it doesn't really matter... whether I find a new email I wasn't expecting immediately, or after an hour is irrelevant.
- kelnos 9y ago
- joatmon-snoo 9y agoAlso, even if you can demonstrate or prove that a refresh button offers no tangible benefit, it creates an illusion of control that improves the UI/UX. It's like the close door button in US elevators.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chrismorgan 9y agoI wot not the attitude of others to such matters, but I find the presence of a close button that doesn’t appear to do anything unreasonably frustrating. (After an office move a couple of months back I encountered my first elevator in Australia with an close button that does little to nothing. Fortunately I work from home normally and only endure the elevator every couple of weeks.)
- peteretep 9y ago> wot Strong choice of word.
- dwringer 9y agoI know others have downvoted you, but I want to thank you for pointing that out to me. I had absolutely no idea the word "wit" could be used in that way. Apparently it appears in some biblical passage(s), as well as in a Robert F. Young sci-fi short story. I only found it defined here: [1] [1] http://www.dictionary.com/browse/wot http://www.dictionary.com/browse/wot
- mzzter 9y agoThis~ I've lost count of how many times I've pulled to refresh on a scrollable view in an app that doesn't refresh that way. Feels bad man.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> It's like the close door button in US elevators. The close door button is retained for emergency manual operation, not as a placebo button (they are disabled in normal, non-emergency operation because of ADA minimum open time rules to accommodate wheelchair-bound passengers.)
- ninguem2 9y agoA lot of apps accept the pull down gesture (not sure how to call it) as a refresh, e.g. mail apps. I suppose that might not work so well when your app shows a map, like uber. Replacing a button by a gesture is ok.
- yuchi 9y ago«pull reload» or «pull refresh» AFAIK
- yorwba 9y agoIt's only OK if you also describe somewhere that this gesture exists and what it does. Gestures are absolutely non-discoverable on their own. Occasionally, I try to show someone something on their Macbook, and I always have to experiment with the number of fingers on the touchpad, because nothing about the interface helps me remember the options. I guess it could be printed directly on the touchpad, but then that wouldn't be as slick.
- subroutine 9y agoI think the swipe-down-to-refresh UI pattern actually seems pretty discoverable. The newest things on a list are added to the top. How do you know if you're at the very top of a list? I think this gesture eloquently addresses several issues at once. (1) The user is going to pull down on the main container to check for new items at the very top of the list, but (2) it may take a manual refresh to deliver these new items; refreshing the list when the user is attempting to pull the main container window beyond the top-most item allows the app to provide the newest content the moment the user is seeking it.
- yorwba 9y agoYes, when you have a list sorted by recency, where the most recent entries are at the top, you can easily discover the refresh gesture by scrolling a little bit too far. But when the gesture is used in different contexts, it is less likely to be discovered. For example most chat apps add new messages at the bottom, so the refresh gesture should be scrolling in the opposite direction. Additionally, I don't tend to scroll through my message history very often, so I'm unlikely to discover this. Fortunately, most chat apps tend to be quite good at loading new messages. It gets worse when there's little reason to attempt scrolling past the boundaries. For example, it took me months to discover that Chrome on Android supports the gesture (before that, I opened the menu to refresh). That's because to scroll on a website, I just pull once and then let go. Inertial scrolling means that the motion will stop as soon as it hits the top of the page. Past that, there's a kind of resistance that needs to be overcome, which you won't do if you don't already know the gesture. My point is, good interfaces shouldn't require the user to make accidental discoveries. There should be an obvious, labeled way to do it; if necessary, it can include a hint to use the less obvious but more convenient way next time.
- beaker52 9y agoAs a user of 1Password, the lack of "Sync" Button is frustrating when trying to use recently added passwords across devices. "It just works" isn't always best - especially when dealing with cross-device data sync - I know it isn't magic, I'm not "fooled", I know it's actually data that needs to be transferred to the new device. Hiding that, not giving me the option to force sync and see the progress of it is a very frustrating experience when I can't see passwords (or any state) that I'm expecting to see.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> As a user of 1Password, the lack of "Sync" Button It does have a sync button doesn't it? 'Settings', 'Sync' on iOS. When you press it you can see the progress. Or do you mean something else.
- beaker52 9y agoHave never found it. Triple checked now. Nada.
- tolien 9y agoYou might have to be using the older Dropbox/iCloud sync method rather than a 1Password.com account. It’s definitely there [1] if you do. 1: https://i.agilebits.com/megan/sync_location.jpg https://i.agilebits.com/megan/sync_location.jpg
- beaker52 9y agoFWIW, I am using a 1Password.com account, which means I can't confirm (but don't doubt) this for Dropbox et al.
- wingerlang 9y agoTheir iOS app has a sync button and the macOS app seems to sync when I restart the app.
- justonepost 9y agoYeah, but the sync button doesn't always work either. For example, my email client has a sync button but I have to go to the web app to really see what's going on.
- toomim 9y agoThis problem would be solved if HTTP provided state synchronization rather than just transfer. Then we wouldn't need a reload button. The invisible college built a solution called Statebus: https://stateb.us https://stateb.us It's a backwards-compatible HTTP but with automatic synchronization. It eliminates these bugs.
- jandrese 9y agoThat sounds a lot like the thinking the author was complaining about in the article. There is a lot going on underneath your protocol layer here, and much that can go wrong. How sure can you be that the system is in a synchronized state?
- self_awareness 9y ago> "When a customer really thinks your app is wrong and they know how to fix it, [...]" The problem is this happens too many times, even in cases when the customer doesn't have any idea how to fix the issue and what the issue really is.
- zestyping 9y agoThis is only because apps are bad at sync. Quality varies; occasionally there's an app that gets it right. For example, I've used Google Docs and Google Sheets for ages now and never wanted or needed to refresh — the content is always in sync.
- djhworld 9y agoGoogle recently changed "Google Drive" to "Google Backup and Sync" and it's _terrible_ I can see some files on the web version of google drive that I uploaded last night, but on my other machine the Backup&Sync tool doesn't even bother downloading them. Time to move to Dropbox I think...
- Robadob 9y agoI had this bug on Google Drive a few months ago, as I recall the solution was to unlink-relink my account.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoI've been using Insync for years, as Google never deigned to make a Linux version of the Google Drive application. It costs $30, and it's a one-time payment, no subscription.
- IshKebab 9y agoIt was awful as Google Drive too. It really blows my mind how bad the desktop Google Drive sync app is, when Dropbox can do it nearly perfectly.
- digi_owl 9y agoAnd here they wants us to trust them with always keeping the ChromeOS state in sync...
- kalleboo 9y agoI have had their JavaScript bug out and require a page reload though - in Chrome of all browsers
- cottsak 9y ago(I fully accept this will prob start a war..) But IMO this tracks back to the MPA vs. SPA problem. Do we actually need to be using a SPA/JS framework (Angular, React, etc) and what do we get in return which outweighs the wildly agreed increased development effort of SPAs? I think the author is referring to mainly "wrapped" SPA web apps that sit inside native apps with a "web view" rendering the SPA (like the browser would). It's not just wrapped apps tho, many native apps have some kind of hybrid where you're using a library directly (React Native?.. dives for cover) which but a whole framework of abstractions on top of the native interfaces. With so many "layers" and all these things being new and vastly more complex than MPA web apps, the statistical likelihood of goofing things up is just very high. Where are the days of old (what? 10 years?) where we got to the edge of MPAs (we didn't even call them MPAs then) and optimised the crap out of them making them fast, and simple and quick and a pleasant user experience? I think we come up with all sorts of poorly justified reasons to go to SPA/JS frameworks these days and the users are the ones who end up paying the price.
- Loic 9y agoFor old people like me not following the latest acronym dances: MPA: Multiple-Page Application SPA: Single-Page Application
- factorialboy 9y agoThe author talks about a mechanism to refresh / reload. Its probably not got to do with SPAs vs MPAs. SPAs can have refresh / reload mechanisms, but not all do. Same for native / mobile apps, some have them and others don't.
- Encaitar 9y agoIsn't the car sharing app's map just 'representative'? Refreshing isn't going to help when they are deliberately lying to you.
- mseebach 9y agoNo. > Since it totally refuses to sync, I have to switch to the Android “recents” screen and kill it. When I re-open the app, it’s OK.
- TorKlingberg 9y agoYes, please! It doesn't have to be a visible button, the scroll hard past the top of the list gesture is fine. Just show a spinner until you actually received a server response. I hate opening a weather app just to see the weather from last time I opened it. Even the most perfect sync code will not work when my internet connection is broken. I'd rather find out so I can fix it than look at old data. Btw, why does the web Gmail refresh button not actually load new emails unless I press it twice?
- enesunal 9y ago... or show an error indication to user when things are mangled. Never seen an out-of-sync error message in any application except for multiplayer apps/games.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoUsually, you can just force a resync instead. Refresh button is needed for the situations when your application doesn't know its state is wrong, but the user does - which does happen whenever your app is displaying the state of a shared resource it doesn't own, like files on disk.
- illumin8 9y agoLack of a refresh button is not the issue. The issue is that the app developer has never tested their app in real-world network scenarios. Switching between wifi, 3g, 4g, lte, and no network access. Inserting random packet loss, jitter, and latency. There are a lot of tools that can automate this now. You can stick a WAN simulator in front of your integration testing environment and insert all types of crazy network issues into your tests. If developers did this more often, these "sync" bugs would be fixed.
- nmeofthestate 9y agoYes, the developer has never tested their app and if they would "just" make the difficult-to-implement code bullet proof, then there would be no need for a refresh button. facepalm (for the hard of thinking, I am sarcastically disagreeing)
- digi_owl 9y agoI fear i must invoke Poe here...
- jmkni 9y agoHow would you do this on an Android emulator? I'm guilty of not testing this sort of thing thoroughly.
- hex13 9y agoLike they say "There are only two hard things in Computer Science: cache invalidation and naming things." ;) Apps without `refresh` claim to be ones which managed to solve caching problem properly (they usually didn't anyway)
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIndeed. Often they don't even realize they're in the caching business. And yet, showing the state of anything for which the canonical representation doesn't live in your process' memory is caching state.
- bruceboughton 9y agoSurely refresh is just kill for web-apps? The app's state is discarded, the code is reloaded and it re-requests the data. I don't see the differentiation Tim is implying.
- gilrain 9y agoOne requires the push of a convenient button already within the workflow of the app; the other requires knowing how to force close an app, or at any rate losing your flow.
- pimlottc 9y agoIn theory, a good web-app encodes state in the URL as you work, so you don't lose everything on refresh. Google Maps is a good example.
- digi_owl 9y agoGmaps seems like their only good webapp...
- bachmeier 9y agoThis is related to the reason I had to stop using Sparkleshare. A few years ago I thought the idea was pretty cool, so I tried it out. Then I started to get conflicts on some of my documents. A couple days later, I knew for sure that a file hadn't synced. Upon searching for a manual sync option (that would have to be a trivial addition) I came upon this issue[1]: "No, adding an action for this would be a hack. The whole point of SparkleShare is to sync stuff automatically.... Just because something is easy to do doesn't mean it should be added." I haven't touched Sparkleshare since. [1] https://github.com/hbons/SparkleShare/issues/794 https://github.com/hbons/SparkleShare/issues/794
- TeMPOraL 9y agoOh God, this issue thread is a perfect example of the problem with UX trends that's plaguing our industry. Its TL;DR is this: this software is magic. It syncs automagically. You, the dumb user, are not supposed to know and care when it syncs or if it succeeds (hint: it's magic, it always does), and you're especially not supposed to tell the program that it has to do a sync. If your company's firewall interferes with the magic, go talk to your company IT. The article sums up the issue perfectly: sometimes, as a user, I know better when the program is mistaken than the program itself. I should have a way to force it to refresh its state.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gcb0 9y agoI call it "the Microsoft Clippy age"
- jandrese 9y agoIt's the Windows model. Make the easy stuff super easy, and the hard stuff basically impossible. The assumption is that you'll adjust your business practices to match the software assumptions and definitely not the other way around. Which is a little unfair to Microsoft, since they do have a fair bit of functionality only slightly hidden on Windows.
- michaelfeathers 9y agoWhat's interesting is that we've known this in the industry for decades but people seem to forget it at the user interface. https://scholar.harvard.edu/waldo/publications/note-distributed-computing https://scholar.harvard.edu/waldo/publications/note-distribu... https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/11/11/the-law-of-leaky-abstractions/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/11/11/the-law-of-leaky-a...
- digi_owl 9y agoThe impression i get is that this happens because the industry favors gung-ho youth over aged experience, and oh so many are self taught. This combination means that the same hard lessons have to be learned over and over and over...
- dustingetz 9y agoMy git client doesn't need a refresh button.
- baursak 9y agoneeds a fetch command tho
- jandrese 9y agoI'm not sure git is the example I would want to hold up of a service that always synchronizes flawlessly and effortlessly. Maybe I'm alone, but I've more than once gotten my local copy in a state that seems to require me to blow it away and re-clone it to get it working again. Sometimes it seems to get hung up at a particular point in time and I can't get it to pull recent changes, even when I've tried to tell it to pull from the head.
- krosaen 9y agoAgree, though I must say the app suite that has come closest to making it "just work" with no sync button is Trello. It even knows when it might be out of sync and then offers you a refresh button.
- SadWebDeveloper 9y agoThere are only two hard things in Computer Science: cache invalidation and naming things.
- jandrese 9y agoI thought that quote was: There are two hard problems in computer science: cache invalidation, naming, and off-by-one errors.
- SadWebDeveloper 9y agoI like the original version: Source: https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/19836/has-phil-karlton-ever-said-there-are-only-two-hard-things-in-computer-science https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/19836/has-phil-...
- 16bytes 9y agoI this this is a particularly insightful stance and it immediately reminded me of an application that already does this. The thick-client MS Outlook will let you know when you have new mail, but there's also a "send/receive" button that forces a sync with the server and lets you know the result of that action.
- hxtk 9y agoI thought about outlook, too, but for the opposite reason: their web client overrides ctrl+r, making the way I force a refresh incongruous with the rest of the web.
- digi_owl 9y agothat is another reason i am not much fond of "webapps". Take Youtube for example. If i scroll down to read some comments (yeah i know, i live dangerously for some reason that escapes me) and want to go quickly back up to the video, the natural reflex for me is to hit the home key. But for some loony toons reason Google had decided to hijack the home key to mean "rewind video the 0 and start playing"!
- Grue3 9y agoYes, this infuriates me about my city's (Moscow) bikeshare app. It would show you completely outdated state until you restart it with no way to refresh. Later they introduced electrobike option, and I discovered that if you switch to electrobike map and back to normal bike app, it refreshes! Later I found that Citymapper is available in Moscow, and its bike map is much superior so I don't have to suffer the official app anymore.
- jsight 9y agoA lot of web UIs only show a refresh button if something goes wrong. I think this makes a lot of sense, as it is really just a placebo if the app already knows that the data is up to date (for example, if it has an active websocket connection for maintaining state). Of course, it helps that the browsers all have builtin refresh buttons too.
- digi_owl 9y agoReminds me of when Google introduced MTP to Android with their 3.x version. All of a sudden what used to be a simple transfer from tablet to PC was a nightmare. This because while before the PC would read the SD card directly, with MTP it was mediated via a database within Android. And that database easily got de-synced from the actual FS state if i used any kind of file manager on the tablet. Effectively i had to dig up an app that was designed specifically to force the database to sync.
- CaptSpify 9y agoLast time I tried it, MTP was still a POS. I don't even try to use it anymore as it's just less hassle to adb push files. You hear that google? Using adb on the command line is easier than the interface you give your phone? How did you mess that one up? /rant
- Torgo 9y agoJust do what Lotus Notes does: hide the button, but if you click in the same place as where the button is, it force-refreshes.
- gmueckl 9y agoThen how do you know where to click?
- carapace 9y agoKind of an aside, you used to fix wonky TVs by physically banging them on the side once or twice. Vacuum tubes.
- nlawalker 9y agoIt struck me the other day that this is the future that the industry focus on AI is driving us towards - software that knows better than you do, whether you like it or not. In much the same way that the capabilities and usage of today's technologies baffles people who didn't grow up with it, tomorrow all of us will be baffled by the number and magnitude of decisions that the average piece of software assumes its users will delegate to it, and the fact that no one will really be able to debug or diagnose exactly why it made the decisions it did. Zawinski's Law [1] will be modified to read "Every program attempts to expand until it can act as a personal assistant. Those programs which cannot so expand are replaced by ones which can." [1] http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/Z/Zawinskis-Law.html http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/Z/Zawinskis-Law.html
- digi_owl 9y agoThe industry may be trying to build a virtual Jeeves, but i fear that they are more likely to create HAL...