9 ms·
There's a good book about this whole complex of themes, the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis [1] that basically your language determines the way you think (100 words for
by FabHK 9y ago
There's a good book about this whole complex of themes, the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis [1] that basically your language determines the way you think (100 words for snow, more/fewer words for colours, etc.):
Through the Language Glass: Why the World Looks Different in Other Languages by Guy Deutscher.
TL;DR: no, language doesn't determine how you see the world. There might be one notable exception - there's a tribe somewhere (forgot the details) that doesn't use front, behind, left, right, but the cardinal directions (they'll actually say, "oh, there's an ant on your northern leg"). As they grow up with this, they have an uncanny sense of where north is wherever they are, even in buildings etc.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity
- Osmium 9y agoJust to really emphasize the point -- the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis has been essentially disproved. It comes up a lot because it's a very attractive idea, but it doesn't hold up to scrutiny. > that doesn't use front, behind, left, right, but the cardinal directions I can't remember where I saw this (maybe Language Log, consider this "citation needed"), but apparently there are some Polynesian Islanders that use a language with different direction concepts (inwards/outwards maybe?).
- TallGuyShort 9y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but I think your comment is saying the hypothesis itself has been disproved, and the parent is referring to a book about the hypothesis with the same name that emphasizes criticisms of that hypothesis. Right?
- Osmium 9y agoI haven't read the book the parent mentioned, I'm not sure what the book contains. But I agree with the parent's "TL;DR: no, language doesn't determine how you see the world." There is a lot of literature on Sapir-Whorf, including many pop linguistics books. Note I'm not a linguist, I just know a few and they're very vocal about this :)
- FabHK 9y agoyes, you're both right: the book basically presents and examines Sapir-Whorf, and rejects it (with some very minor exceptions, as mentioned). It's really a zombie/cockroach meme (to use Paul Krugman's terminology) - it's dead, but keeps coming back, just like the Eskimos and their 100 words for snow etc.
- rspeer 9y agoSo I'm fully aware that people have experimented with the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis for decades, and if it were true it would have been conclusively demonstrated by now. But isn't color names one of the last refuges of Sapir-Whorf, one of the places where the weakest form of Sapir-Whorf might be having some sort of effect, because color names are one tool (out of many) that we can use to consciously distinguish colors? As an example, these Munsell tiles are supposed to be perceptually uniform, so just based on the mechanisms of vision, each tile would be as easy to distinguish from its neighbors as all the others. If you showed me tile A5, then later showed me C5 and asked if it's the same color, I would know it isn't. One is red and the other is orange. But I'd have a much harder time with K3 and M3, or J6 and L6 -- and these are colors that the article points out are harder to distinguish in words.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dorchadas 9y agoExcept you could still perceive the differences. You'd just have to resort to other modifiers, i.e. 'light', 'dark' or 'bluish', to describe them. And you could easily invent a word if you needed to. It really doesn't have anything to do with distinguishing them but more to do with describing them.
- rspeer 9y agoI don't think you really addressed my example. I'm talking about a difficult case of distinguishing colors, where you don't get to look at them next to each other, and hypothesizing that it would help if the colors were described with completely different English words. Yes, if I knew I were being tested on this, I could invent a description to try to remember what K3 looks like. But I don't have to invent anything to recognize the difference between red and orange. But maybe jacobolus is right that this is just an effect of RGB monitors and not of language. These tiles are in the cyan range, which RGB screens don't display faithfully, so maybe the actual difference between the tiles is more obvious when you're looking at them.
- woodandsteel 9y agoYou're right, the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis has been thoroughly disproved. A good book on this is The Language Hoax by linguist John McWhorter. The main reason it still hangs on is that it is used by people to try to support the left-wing ideological idea that human nature is entirely a product of socialization, and so can be formed to produce a perfect socialist society. And let me add that, as Marxist writer Norman Geras explains in his book Marx and Human Nature, this is not at all what Marx himself thought.
- dmreedy 9y agoThere are a number of books, throughout history, on either side of the conversation. I would not call the issue settled by any measure. It's hard to settle any issue when it comes to tricky, sneaky, intangible things like qualia, and semantics.
- dorchadas 9y agoYou wouldn't call linguistic relativity a settled matter? Because it pretty much is, especially the strong form. And evidence for the weak form is quite lacking, relying mainly on the work of Boroditsky, whose main article has never been published and who doesn't control for culture, education, etc. in her others. It seems to me that culture has much more influence on how someone things/perceives things than language ever could... Which also explains why very different cultures can use the same language -- if language determined your thoughts, wouldn't, say, Quebecois and French culture be fairly uniform, not to add Algerian or Cote D'Ivoirean (is that even a word?) in.
- dang 9y ago> to try to support the left-wing ideological idea Could you please not take HN threads on generic ideological tangents? Those are against the HN guidelines (regardless of which ideology, of course) because such discussions are so repetitive. They're black holes from which no light emerges. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- throwaway7645 9y agoNot proved or disproved as I understood it (I'm not qualified).
- dmreedy 9y agoStrong Sapir-Whorf is likely untrue. Sapir-Whorf is contentious. Linguistic Relativism in general is by no means disproved. It just goes through phases of popularity, like any ideas about human experience. At any given time it has some number of critics and some number of advocates, and the majority floats between
- mindways 9y agoI've had friends, linguists, and linguist friends all tell me that Sapir-Whorf has been disproved (at least in strong form), but I find it really hard to believe them, because it contradicts my own experience of the world. I'm by no means perfect at introspection, but I can notice the effect learning new words has on my own thought processes, and it seems about as obvious as the effect of, say, my mood. When I learn words for colors - what "fuchsia" or "teal" or the like actually mean - I mentally distinguish them from similar shades in day-to-day life whereas before I didn't. (And it's not just "hey, new word, let's use that!"; I learned both of those colors about halfway through my life.) When I learn a specialized term in a field that chunks a bunch of complex concepts together in a particular way, I can think about that topic more fluently (letting me go further with those thoughts), but only if I accept the particular chunking of that term. Sure, I have some thoughts which are more visual or spatial or musical and don't involve words as semantic pointers-to-structures-of-meaning. But not _all_ of them. (It's also possible I'm simply fundamentally misunderstanding Sapir-Whorf.) [Edited to fix italics.]
- acjohnson55 9y agoLanguages most certainly helps us hone the way we perceive the world. But on the other hand, it's common for me to have concepts in my mind that seem crystal clear, and yet very difficult to capture in words. Sometimes to the point where it feels like once I manage to start describing it, the concept becomes permanently watered down. Some easy examples are the perceptual effect of looking at my infant daughter, or the experience of hearing certain pieces of music. But often, it's much more mundane. See also, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ineffability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ineffability. In that sense, language gives us a way to approximate concepts that we already have, to varying extents. But it's extremely useful, because we can then manipulate those approximations to generate novel concepts. I don't believe anybody would suggest that that's not the case. But strong Sapir-Whorf would suggest that this is how all thought originates. On another anecdotal note, I used to consider my internal monologue to be me, full-stop, and I have always thought of it as being a stream of words. But I've come to realize that it's not actually real words. Furthermore, at best, its the version of me when I'm under zero stress. However, if I'm upset or threatened, it's clear that "linguistic me" only has illusory control of my behavior, or even my thoughts. In fact, I have realized I often behave first, and then come up with the narrative to understand my own behavior. I posit that this is universal. I think we shape our thoughts to conform to much more primeval motivations, which are surprisingly complex in nature. The entire media industry exists to try to give us linguistic narratives to explain and shape these urges. And I say "shape" because it's not a one way process. I think we train our own behaviors with our thoughts, and when unstressed, we can even exercise linguistic self-control.
- shagie 9y agoYou are likely thinking of the article Does Your Language Shape How You Think? http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/29/magazine/29language-t.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/29/magazine/29language-t.html which describes the Guugu Yimithirr language which is in north eastern Australia ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guugu_Yimithirr_language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guugu_Yimithirr_language ) > But there is more to the effects of a geographic language, for the sense of orientation has to extend further in time than the immediate present. If you speak a Guugu Yimithirr-style language, your memories of anything that you might ever want to report will have to be stored with cardinal directions as part of the picture. One Guugu Yimithirr speaker was filmed telling his friends the story of how in his youth, he capsized in shark-infested waters. He and an older person were caught in a storm, and their boat tipped over. They both jumped into the water and managed to swim nearly three miles to the shore, only to discover that the missionary for whom they worked was far more concerned at the loss of the boat than relieved at their miraculous escape. Apart from the dramatic content, the remarkable thing about the story was that it was remembered throughout in cardinal directions: the speaker jumped into the water on the western side of the boat, his companion to the east of the boat, they saw a giant shark swimming north and so on. Perhaps the cardinal directions were just made up for the occasion? Well, quite by chance, the same person was filmed some years later telling the same story. The cardinal directions matched exactly in the two tellings. Even more remarkable were the spontaneous hand gestures that accompanied the story. For instance, the direction in which the boat rolled over was gestured in the correct geographic orientation, regardless of the direction the speaker was facing in the two films.
- FabHK 9y agoYep, sounds like it, that episode with the shark is also recounted in the book, IIRC.
- tzs 9y agoI wonder how this relates to the results of the white room experiment? In that experiment you take a rat and put it in the center of a rectangular room with white walls, and you put a treat the rat wants in one corner, and let the rat see it. You then turn the rat around a few times to disorient and release it. The rat then tries to get the treat. 50% of the time it goes straight to the correct side of the room, and 50% of the time it goes to the wrong side first. If instead of an all white room you do it in a room where one of the long walls is painted blue--the results are the same. Half the time the rat goes to the correct corner first, half the time it goes to the wrong corner first. That's interesting because other experiments show that rats can recognize blue vs. white and can recognize left vs. right. But apparently they cannot put the concept of blue vs. white and concept of left vs. right together to remember that something is on the left side of the blue wall. If you try this with human adults, they of course go right to the treat almost every time. We have no trouble remembering the goody is on the left side of the blue wall. Babies, though...nope. No better than rats. Two year olds...still no better than rats. Same for three and four and five year olds. It isn't until a human is around six years old that they can go straight for the treat. The scientists in the story I heard on the radio talking about this (probably on Radiolab on NPR) had a hypothesis about what is going on. Before around six the spatial language used by kids is not very sophisticated. They would not say that something is "on the left side of the blue wall". Around six their language is developed enough that they would say something like that, and that is the same time they start being able to beat rats in the experiment. The scientists suspect that the rats and the younger kids have the concepts of color and of relative position in their brains and they can apply them, but there are no links between them. When the kids get sophisticated enough that they start composing phrases like "left of the blue wall" that links the relative position concepts and the color concepts, and then they can use the combination of color and position to remember things. This is not quite like Sapir-Whorf, because it doesn't necessarily mean that the kids can start thinking about "left of the blue wall" BECAUSE their language has developed to the point it can express it. It could just as easily be the other way around--they add that capability to their language BECAUSE they became able to think about it.
- stevenwoo 9y agoStupid question, but how did they control for the rats' sense of smell, odors from previous runs?
- cetalingua 9y agoThe Sapir-Whorf hypothesis is controversial, but it is not dead as some try to suggest. See Regier & Xu (2017) or Cibelli et al. (2016)
- dorchadas 9y agoThe thing is, someone needs to firmly prove that it is -language- and not -culture- that causes the influence. To me, Occam's Razor would almost force the latter, unless you can find a way to explain why Quebecois culture is different from French culture. That said, thank you so much for not sharing Boroditsky's work.
- ineedasername 9y agoWhat i was about to post. The weak-version of Sapir-whorf has been affirmed by research, specifically in color labels vs ability to distinguish absolute differences, e.g., here: http://www.blutner.de/color/Sapir-Whorf.pdf http://www.blutner.de/color/Sapir-Whorf.pdf
- KGIII 9y agoAbout that snow claim... It's more nuanced than that. https://www.buzzfeed.com/tomchivers/no-the-inuit-dont-have-100-words-for-snow https://www.buzzfeed.com/tomchivers/no-the-inuit-dont-have-1... Sorry about the source URL, but it is actually a good article. I live in the mountains of Maine. We don't have enough words for snow. We do have lots of phrases to describe the many different types of snow, however. And there are lots of types of snow, both as it is falling, how it is as it lands, and how it reacts after the storm. I love the stuff and can probably come up with accurate descriptive phrases for hours.
- vacri 9y agoThe power of agglutinative languages. Here is an apparently valid German word that takes one minute to say: https://youtu.be/Brt6F4cGFCY https://youtu.be/Brt6F4cGFCY
- KGIII 9y agoAgglutinative... 1. How long have you been waiting to use that in a sentence? 2. German has a word for everything. "My car misfires when I am in second gear and accelerating in a corner that is greater than 45° and on an incline." There is a German word for exactly that. Anyhow, we really could use more words for snow. I've seen stuff falling from the sky that there are no words for. Some of it doesn't defies even simple phrases. As I've said before, I love snow. I do live here for a reason. There are no words for this slush-like substance that falls from the sky, sometimes as small clumps but other times in clumps large enough that you can hear them hit the ground. This happens usually when the air temp is just a bit above freezing, it is warmer down in the valley than it is here, and the higher air remains pretty warm until there is a cut-off a few thousand feet above you and the air gets much colder. Also, it tends to be high ambient moisture content to the point where you have a moderately dense fog. There's probably a German word for that, but there's none in English and I doubt the Inuit people have one either. Seriously, there is a lot of different types of snow. I didn't realize there were this many until I retired and moved here. Now I know... By the way, the locals would call that 'the start of a good old fashioned New England shit-storm.' It often ends with frozen rain or sleet. I could go on for hours about the different types of snow. 100 words wouldn't even begin to cut it.
- ambrosite 9y ago> Through the Language Glass: Why the World Looks Different in Other Languages by Guy Deutscher. Interesting to see Guy Deutscher's name come up in this context. I mostly know him as Alma Deutscher's father.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 0ld 9y ago> "an ant on your northern leg" That looks exactly like my google maps' navigator. "Head north" it says, like I have any idea where the north is