14 ms·
Drowning in grain: historically high supplies and low prices
- british_india 9y agoHello? Everybody is on a Low-Carb, High Protein diet. Of course it's going to suck to grow carbs.
- owenversteeg 9y agoVery interesting. Modern technology lets you grow corn that would previously take 120 days in 80, and everything is getting cheaper and more efficient. At the same time prices for corn are falling, but nobody wants to stop growing it because they're locked in with expensive equipment.
- mapmap 9y agoA similar oversupply happened right before the Great Depression. Wheat prices were dropping from too much supply partially attributed to newly expanded prairie farming in the US. But these farmers owed fixed costs on their mortgaged land. So to pay their expenses, they plowed up more prairie and grew more wheat. This compounded the supply problem. Eventually, as wheat piled up at railroad depots unable to be sold, farmers left the plowed prairie fallow and the topsoil blew away. Source: The Worst Hard Time by Timothy Egan
- StudentStuff 9y agoThing is, prices for food never really shot back up massively, instead our govt ended up creating price floors for many commodities, insofar as they would give farmers money if what they produced was sold for less than a certain amount[1]. This led to consolidation, whereby family farmers became much fewer in number, and those that owned and operated larger farms ended up working a 2nd job to cover their living expenses. What used to take a whole family to farm is now nearly entirely automated, causing food prices to continue to decline. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_subsidy#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agricultural_subsidy#United_St...
- falsedan 9y ago> What used to take a whole family to farm is now nearly entirely automated, causing food prices to continue to decline I don't see the immediate causal relationship between these: cars are semi-automatically manufactured, but the price of cars hasn't declined anywhere near as much as grain/commodities.
- Pyxl101 9y agoThe quality of vehicles has increased dramatically over that time. There isn't a similar increase in the quality of grain. A vehicle that I purchased roughly ten years ago has operated perfectly fine with half of its scheduled oil changes and very little other maintenance. From an engineering perspective I find that mind-blowing: you buy these machines and they operate flawlessly for years, running for thousands of miles, while performing a complex, mechanical task with many moving parts. It's easy to take for granted how marvelous modern automobiles have become.
- falsedan 9y agoThanks for explaining how car quality has improved, but I still don't follow your link between automation and price decreases. I feel like your explanation doesn't address the market side of farming, and disregards the huge advances in crop & agricultural science.
- danmaz74 9y agoNot the OP, but the point is that the car you buy today has much more value than a car that was sold 20 years ago at a similar price. So, even if the average price paid for a new car didn't go down, the price for the same car has effectively decreased, thanks to automation.
- pavlov 9y agoAlso, the regulatory environment has changed. The car you could buy 40 years ago couldn't be sold today because it's unsafe, too polluting, etc.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThe general phenomenon is the "Backward-S Shaped Supply Curve", and yes, I mention the Dust Bowl instance (from Egan via Burns's PBS series) sepecifically. There are others. https://redd.it/53mcxn https://redd.it/53mcxn You'll see this phenomenon any time an economic agent (individual person, labour market, farmer, extractive resource operator) has some inflexible and fixed minimum set of costs to maintain or they will go out of existence, vs. some variable production function or market price structure. It's similar with the general aviation phenomenon of "failure to maintain altitude". Aircraft fly fairly well through air. Performance characteristics through land or water are rather less optimal.
- nerdponx 9y agoThat's not why. It's because the US government so aggressively subsidizes corn. This is done at the behest of the Ag lobby, which represents corn-buying conglomerates who love low corn prices.
- dogruck 9y agoYes. Also, unwanted farming equipment is easy to sell.
- randomdata 9y agoAs a Canadian corn grower, I'm not sure how the US (or Canadian for that matter) government is subsidizing me growing corn, but the reality is that the prices were still quite strong at the start of the year when we were looking at contracts for the season. I'm very happy with my corn position this year. We may have reevaluate growing corn in the future if the market does dry up (although for crop rotation purposes that is a hard choice to make), but when the market is buying it at a profitable level, why wouldn't we grow it?
- protomyth 9y agoFor the US, the subsidy most cited is ethanol subsidy. Might have something to do with the first primary state being Iowa.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Might have something to do with the first primary state being Iowa. This is entirely why the ethanol subsidy remains. I have high hopes the electric vehicle movement kills this.
- thisisit 9y agoUS government has the farm bill which provides some form of insurance: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/01/28/the-950-billion-farm-bill-in-one-chart/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2014/01/28/the-9... This provides a price insurance for farmers. This year's price was set at: $3.96 per bushel for corn and $10.19 per bushel for soybeans (reference - http://www.wisfarmer.com/story/news/2017/03/08/corn-soybean-prices-set-2017-crop-insurance/98891684/ http://www.wisfarmer.com/story/news/2017/03/08/corn-soybean-...) So with the support prices, unless the yield prices goes below support, people will still grow corn. As how does it affect Canada? For one, Canada will surely be having it's own insurance program. Second, It is a simple arbitrage play, if Canadian supply is cheaper people will buy cheap corn from there and import to US. Curious what price level you would say is unprofitable to grow corn?
- randomdata 9y agoThe main reason prices are falling is that we are coming off the biggest commodities boom in history. 2008-2013 saw record setting prices for corn, soybeans, and wheat. Really, things are just returning to normal now that the boom is over. As you would expect, marketing corn is more challenging now, after the boom, but there is still opportunity for money to be made. The thing about these crops is that the market price can swing by fairly large amounts in the matter of days, so the fact that a losing venture today can become a huge profit opportunity next week keeps people interested. There is no lack of people keen to buy land and equipment if someone really wants out of the business, but we're not that bad off yet.
- nikdaheratik 9y agoThe other issue is that many of the "boom" prices are based on the spot market price, but the majority of these commodities are actually negotiated through long term contracts that have a steadier income, but much fewer highs and lows. Which is why a multi-year drop can be especially hard for producers, since that's the price that often gets locked in for several seasons.
- drpgq 9y agoWith global warming, Saskatchewan and Manitoba production could really take off.
- mturmon 9y agoI think you're kidding, but this has already happened in North Dakota: http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2014/08/13/340116405/shifting-climate-has-north-dakota-farmers-swapping-wheat-for-corn http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2014/08/13/340116405/shi... The story leads with climate changes, but other reasons include corn varieties that have shorter growing seasons. According to the query tool (https://quickstats.nass.usda.gov https://quickstats.nass.usda.gov), corn acreage in ND has gone from 1.0M acres in 2000 to 3.7M this year.
- 24gttghh 9y agoWith less storms, and more rain at once; increasing runoff and erosion, lowering predictability/stability of farming. That is, if it doesn't just stop raining all together in a given area...
- Brendinooo 9y agoAny legs left in the ethanol initiative? Could be a decent place to direct a glut of supply.
- thescriptkiddie 9y agoAccording to the chart on e85prices.com, it would appear that ethanol fuel prices are at a 5 year low. I'd be willing to bet that has something to do with low grain prices.
- bluedino 9y agoIt’s barely cheaper than regular unleaded in my area. Like ten cents if that
- kurthr 9y agoAnd it has a lower energy density so you'll get significantly lower mileage with E85.(28% less!) Note that winter gas is only about 2% loss. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_gallon_equivalent https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_gallon_equivalent
- kurthr 9y agoWow, I guess haters gonna hate, because E85 only has 71.94% of the energy of a standard gasoline gallon. Of course Diesel#2 has 114% and biodiesel B100 has only 104% of the equivalent mileage per gallon. They're kind of like a facts... or is it mobile link hate?
- rch 9y agoThat's generally seen as a misguided attempt to maintain artificially high grain prices that ultimately yields almost zero benefit to farmers or consumers (serving only the ethanol producers and politicians).
- Brendinooo 9y ago
- narrator 9y agoHow about growing corn without pesticides and herbicides? They'll get lower yields but can charge more for it if it gets organic certified.
- donarb 9y agoOrganic certified foods are allowed to use pesticides and herbicides, just that those substances come must from organic sources, like rotenone.
- alexandercrohde 9y agorotenone is no longer certified in america as a pesticide [other than to kill fish]. May seem like nit, but it was a very dangerous pesticide and citing it as an organic pesticide might incorrectly lead to the conclusion that organic pesticides are not safer.
- splitrocket 9y agoIs there enough food for everyone? http://isthereenoughfoodforeveryone.com http://isthereenoughfoodforeveryone.com
- Nition 9y agoJust noticed that the original(?) website of this type, http://www.isthesunburning.com http://www.isthesunburning.com, seems to be gone. In fact the last working snapshot on Archive.org[1] is from 2010. Guess I'll never know if the sun is burning now. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20100528144706/http://www.isthesunburning.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20100528144706/http://www.isthes...
- mi100hael 9y agoAnnoying that the domain is "is there enough food for everyone" but the site asks the opposite question "do people still die of starvation" so the site has a big YES despite the answer to the question in the domain being NO.
- ddlatham 9y agoI think the point is that the answer is YES to both questions. There's enough food to be able to feed everyone, but people still die of starvation, because it's not well distributed. The other question links to http://dopeoplestilldieofstarvation.com/ http://dopeoplestilldieofstarvation.com/
- quickthrower2 9y agoIt's not the opposite question though. There can be enough for everyone, but not properly distributed so that people die of starvation.
- jackemupguy2 9y agoMake more gas.
- eighthnate 9y agoAnd yet, bread prices have jumped recently.
- Kadin 9y agoMakes some sense. As a result of fast-growing corn, areas previously planted to wheat are switching to corn instead. This has increased the supply, and thus decreased the price, of corn -- but wheat, on the other hand, would see a corresponding decrease in supply, and increase in price. This is also why cash crops can cause food shortages.
- icebraining 9y agoYou can make bread from corn, though. I don't mean that sugary cake called "cornbread" in the US, I mean actual bread, but made from corn flours. It's one of our national delicacies: https://easyportugueserecipes.com/broa-de-avintes/ https://easyportugueserecipes.com/broa-de-avintes/
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe US has nonsugary cornbreads, too.
- icebraining 9y agoNo doubt, I just wanted to be clear what I was talking about.
- Kadin 9y agoFascinating! I am something of an amateur baker and I'd never heard of it. I assume it comes from periods of high wheat prices, since it also heavily uses rye? Sadly rye (which I have something of a personal taste for, mostly in whiskey though!) is also being impacted by the economy's preference for corn; global production numbers for rye have been falling steadily particularly in the former Soviet countries. I have had difficulty sourcing rye flour that's not eye-wateringly expensive. You are perhaps already familiar, but in Mesoamerica where corn originated, it is generally processed into flour only after alkaline processing. The resulting flour, typically sold as "masa" in the US, is distinct from simple ground corn (cornmeal or corn flour in the US). The difference is quite striking, both culinarily and nutritionally. It still doesn't form the gluten that wheat dough, does, so I haven't had good luck making European-style breads with it (though I'd love to, because I live with someone who has a wheat allergy).
- dogruck 9y agoAs a kid, I was taught in school that the world population was growing so fast that soon we wouldn't be able to grow enough food to feed everyone. But, here this article says we're growing an endless bounty of corn.
- wbc 9y agoDid you grow up in 18th century England and Mr.Malthus was your teacher?
- dogruck 9y agoLol feels like it. Perhaps some day people will ask the same question about Al Gore?
- matt4077 9y agoMaybe... And it would be just as foolish. These predictions of doom (Thomas Malthus, Club of Rome, Global Warming, Y2K) all have the 'problem' of being self-defeating: It's unclear to what degree they were wrong only because societies reacted to them. China's One-Child policy, or family planning as a major component of developmental aid, for example, may have been consequences of the prophecies of overpopulation.
- stale2002 9y agoUnfortunately, Malthusian logic is still around in the common era.
- Houshalter 9y agoIt's correct in the long long term. Population rates have stabilized because of birth control (in the first world anyway.) But in a few generations, people that are allergic to birth control, or genetically want large families or whatever, will dominate the population and growth will continue. There are some religious groups that calculate if they can get each of their members to have 8 children, they will become the majority of the population in like 2 generations. Fortunately even the best groups only manage like 3 or 4 per couple on average. But that only pushes it out a few more generations. And the groups that are the best at keeping their members from leaving, and the members that are the most loyal, will naturally be selected for.
- fish_fan 9y agoNaturally, the american tax payer still foots the bill via subsidies.
- generic101 9y agoI'm surprised that nobody has mentioned the reduction of Fed stimulus - reduction of quantitative easing as well as low inflation rate. It's not just grains that have slumped -- almost every major commodity is down from its 5 year high.
- forkLding 9y agoIts almost as if the grain and corn could be fed to starving peoples around the world for a lower price. Sarcasm aside, a lot of starvation could be counteracted with better distribution of excess corn at a lower price so I don't see a real problem. North American farms might be hit but the actual amount of labour needed at a massive corn-producing farm is shrinking every year due to technology (although there is also a agricultural labour shortage).
- rumcajz 9y agoTo further that case, drought resistant corn would be more useful than cold resistant one, I guess.
- chrissnell 9y agoMost of the corn grown around here in Kansas is not the variety that you eat off the cob, it's the kind you feed to livestock. Shipping this corn off to starving people doesn't do much for them unless they want to raise cows and pigs on it.
- skolsuper 9y agoThey probably do? It's got to be better than starving...
- forkLding 9y agoIts still quite edible, I've seen people eat pig corn as corn flour, its not great but it does make an alright stew But then again, we shouldnt steal food from livestock to just feed humans. I apologize for my sarcasm, I couldnt help it
- matt4077 9y agoThe good news is that actual starvation has also been greatly reduced. Malnutrition remains a problem, and US corn and grain aren't really helpful for that. The other problem with the idea is that it runs the risk of destroying local food markets, destroying exactly the structures and institutions these countries need when the US inevitably stops dropping calories on them the next year.
- deepGem 9y ago"For every dollar a shopper spent on breakfast cereal in 1980, today you'd have to spend $2.93" Source from 2015: https://www.cnbc.com/2015/09/28/puffs-flakes-and-dollars-why-your-breakfast-cereal-costs-so-much.html https://www.cnbc.com/2015/09/28/puffs-flakes-and-dollars-why... Which means that the marketing/advertising spends have increased in a disproportional manner. What a world we are living in.
- jcun4128 9y agoWhat about making bio fuel
- tryingagainbro 9y agoLet's eat pork then! They love corn, even though it makes them fat (white meat) For those complaining about subsisides: any country worth its salt needs to make sure farmers and heavy industry don't go caput. People need to eat and someone needs to make tanks and bullets during tough times.
- afarrell 9y agoI note that oil prices crashed 2.5 years ago and oil is needed for the Haber process to make fertilizer. Could that be a cause? I also note that high grain prices led to the Arab Spring which led Arab monarchies to need money to pay to keep their supporters happy...
- Robotbeat 9y agoNo, not oil. The Haber process uses hydrogen. Which almost all comes from natural gas right now. (A note to clean hydrogen advocates: this is a much better market for hydrogen than burning it or converting to synthetic methane as it costs money to convert natural gas to hydrogen. Displace all that natural gas used for ammonia and nitrate fertilizer production before moving to burning it.)
- thriftwy 9y agoAround here people tend to look at unused land and lament that it was all farmed 30 years ago. But the reality is that grain growing operates on ever-thinner margins. It now makes sense to skim grain from the best lands, insolation and precipitation-wise, and leave the rest to grasses, shrubs and marshes. What do people do in depressed regions in the absense of productivity, especially in the country, is another story.
- newsmania 9y agoI have an idea. Corn farmers aren't making money, so let's subsidize corn farming to help them make money. Of course, that will lead to a worse oversupply, but hey, it's been working so far, right?
- MicroBerto 9y agoElephant in the room that nobody wants to discuss: domestic demand is dropping for cereal grains. If you follow dietary trends you would know why.