3 ms·
Good document, but I was really hoping they’d go deeper into how they tested some of the fraud detection stuff (masks, etc) or give us some statistics on the tw
by MBCook 9y ago
Good document, but I was really hoping they’d go deeper into how they tested some of the fraud detection stuff (masks, etc) or give us some statistics on the twin/family member issue.
- netsharc 9y agoIt mentions infrared picture. Masks probably have a different infrared signature. But so does your face if it's been wearing a balaclava in the cold (some parts will be cold and some will be warm...
- MBCook 9y agoI seriously doubt they’re using actual infrared emissions (as in heat measurements), I imagine it’s just used as a simple B&W camera so they don’t need visible light.
- MBCook 9y agoSince I’ve been downvoted and I can no longer edit, let me try to explain my theory: I’m guessing they only use the camera to read the positions of the dots projected onto the face. I don’t think they care about the ‘color’ of the face or how hot it is thermally. They’ve said they’re projecting the infrared dots? Have they said they’re doing any other kind of infrared illumination like the kind that can show blood vessels? I’m curious to see if face paint (assuming it reflects IR to a reasonable degree) interferes with FaceID. If it does they’re using more than just the dots for geometry. On the other hand if it doesn’t then the can’t be paying attention to things like IR emissions from the skin since it would be covered and thus heavily dampened. Right?
- MBCook 9y agoIt was brought to my attention in another comment that they do have an IR light to illuminate the face besides the dots. Now I’m even more curious about the face paint.
- The_Double 9y agoJust guessing here, but veins and blood flow are visible in infra red [1]. A color camera can also measure pulse using small color variations. [1] https://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/pulse-detection-with-intel-realsense-technology https://software.intel.com/en-us/articles/pulse-detection-wi...
- MBCook 9y agoApple wants this to work in total darkness. So color wouldn’t work. Do we know if they’re projecting IR light (besides the dot pattern) that they could use to look for blood vessels?
- billyhoffman 9y agoYes. The iPhone X has something literally called the "Flood illuminator" which projects IR light. This is one of the many reasons FaceID is not reactively available to previous iPhones via a software update. > The flood illuminator produces infrared (IR) light, part of the electromagnetic spectrum that's invisible to the naked eye, to illuminate your face; https://www.forbes.com/sites/jvchamary/2017/09/16/how-face-id-works-apple-iphone-x/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jvchamary/2017/09/16/how-face-i...
- MBCook 9y agoOh you’re right, I somehow missed that. Well that makes things more interesting doesn’t it. I guess that leads back to my question (in another comment) about whether or not face paint would effect it.