9 ms·
Yes, We Get Wiser with Age
- namelost 9y ago> Empirical studies have shown that older people are better than younger ones in terms of control over emotion, knowing themselves better, making better decisions that require experience, and having more compassion and empathy towards others. These are the things I include in wisdom. So are things that are components of wisdom that can increase with aging. How does this explain Brexit? https://d25d2506sfb94s.cloudfront.net/cumulus_uploads/document/oxmidrr5wh/EUFinalCall_Reweighted.pdf https://d25d2506sfb94s.cloudfront.net/cumulus_uploads/docume... 18-24: 71 remain / 29 leave 25-49: 54 remain / 36 leave 50-64: 40 remain / 60 leave 65+: 36 remain / 64 leave Sure seems like a clear inverse correlation between age and things like "control over emotion", and "compassion and empathy towards others". I'm going to suggest that every aspect of the brain degrades as we get older, including 'wisdom'.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- earforu 9y agoMaybe because of differences of education and history between generations. We should compare 65+ yo people with how they were 40 years ago, not with 25 yo of today.
- dijit 9y agoI am curious too, the brexit vote for many people was an emotional one. It was certainly not based in any logic that anyone can cite. That sample is too large to be anecdatum. However to play devils advocate; leave voters were drip fed anti-EU propaganda for decades with nobody on the EU side defending it, and the run up to the referendum there was a lot of lying. So the fault may be that people were more susceptible to misinformation in that state.
- gadders 9y agoJust because someone examines the same facts as you and comes to a different conclusion, it doesn't mean their choice wasn't based on facts.
- vacri 9y agoHow is that funding boost to the NHS going?
- gadders 9y agoHow was the emergency budget that was going to have to be called immediately after a Leave vote?
- dijit 9y agoAnalysing facts has nothing to do with it, and the EU only has europa.eu, not the entire Murdoch media franchise. Regardless, there are simple facts that people seem to ignore in this debate so I can't take what you said as wholesome or objective. For instance, the UK was the only member not to impose an easing period in regards to Poland joining the EU. As such we saw an influx of poles as those who wanted to emigrate had nowhere else to go. Purely self-inflicted. But politicians blame the EU for this. Another instance is: "No way to inhibit EU freedom of movement for those who choose to move here! We have to give them all our benefit money!". Well, you have to afford EU citizens the same rights as UK citizens for 6 months, if they're not economically active they do not have the right to stay. The benefit law could easily be amended to be like Sweden/Denmark in that you get paid based on previous salaries, meaning you had to have held a job in the country before claiming income support. Denmark is surprisingly hostile to immigrants even EU ones, we could have learned a lot from them if the argument is migration. Particular instances of lying are: coercive wording "350M a week, lets spend it on the NHS instead" or, more explicit lies such as "Human rights prevented deportation of a criminal because he had a cat". The full reason he was not deported was because of his relationship, the cat was entered as evidence because he had bought it for his partner, it was an attempt by the defence to make the point that long-term relationships have some credence under the law in this age of declining marriage rates.
- nf05papsjfVbc 9y agoI have no investment in the outcome of Brexit but I have to say that speaking as if it was objectively worse is dismissive of the section of population who showed up and voted in favour of it.
- paganel 9y agoThey deserve what they voted for. Have almost no direct stake in this, I'm just tired of this mantra of "showing respect for what people chose". It's not wrong telling someone that they made a bad decision, no matter if you offend said person by doing so. I personally wish my friends would be the same towards me, i.e. tell me whenever they think I made bad decisions.
- nf05papsjfVbc 9y agoI did use the phrase "objectively worse". I see no substantiation for that yet. Also, this depends a lot on what they were looking for when they voted. I can easily say one of these: I do/don't like the outcome. However, I find it difficult to say: "they collectively chose incorrectly". I do, however, agree that in general a population deserves whatever it is that they voted for.
- reitanqild 9y ago> However, I find it difficult to say: "they collectively chose incorrectly". That might just because you are a tolerant, reasonable person. If you were a bit more arrogant and rude like some others at this site it would be much easier for you. Source: Back when I was an even more intolerant, stupid and annoying guy I had no problems flaming whole religions or nations.
- JBReefer 9y agoHey, it sounds like you're wiser than you used to be, now that you're older! The rest of these posts are so arrogant, it's sad.
- 9y ago
- Scarblac 9y agoThe younger people weren't wise enough to actually show up and vote. If they had voted in the same numbers, there wouldn't be Brexit.
- j45 9y agoBingo, not all ages groups are present in voting
- vixen99 9y agoInstead of making the ridiculous (i.e. unsupported and wild) generalization to the effect that if you voted for Brexit you were unwise (stupid?) which frankly amounts to little more than name-calling, why not go head to head with the <arguments> made by hundreds of business leaders and intellectuals who voted Leave? I don't hold out any hope because you certainly give the impression of someone who's impervious to argument.
- skissane 9y agoI think part of the explanation is cultural changes over time. The EU is very much a symbol of internationalism/globalism, even if localised into a continental context, while Brexit is a nationalistic rebellion against it. Nationalism was more popular/accepted in the past (especially so for British nationalism), so older people tend to be more sympathetic to nationalism, and hence more likely to support Brexit. Whereas, I think the popular culture is moving away from nationalism and towards internationalism/globalism instead. (Not universally – subgroups like the alt right are moving in the other direction, but they are a minority.) Part of that move is no doubt due to the Internet, which helps people see themselves as part of one planet by interacting with people in other countries on a regular basis. Teenagers watching YouTube are just as likely to watch videos from other countries as their own (provided they understand the language), which is accelerating the process of global unification of popular culture which the media and entertainment industries had already begun. But these sorts of cultural changes always effect the younger people the most, whereas older people are more likely to retain cultural outlooks prevalent when they were younger. The young are naturally a leading indicator of social and cultural change, the old a trailing indicator of it. (It is more complicated in that a lot of younger people can be positive about globalist/internationalist institutions such as the EU and the UN over nation-states, yet also often quite sympathetic to separatist nationalisms such as those of Scotland, Catalonia, the Basque country, Kosovo, Palestine, Kurdistan, Tibet, West Papua, etc. To some extent that seems contradictory, and the idealist tendency of the young to support the underdog may explain that contradiction; on the other hand, to support regional nationalisms can be in a way anti-nationalistic, in that supporting smaller nationalisms against larger ones (e.g. Scottish nationalism against British nationalism, Basque/Catalan nationalism against Spanish nationalism) can be seen as consistent with a broader anti-nationalist outlook–one can foresee a future for Europe in which the existing nation-states are sucked away simultaneously in both directions, upward by the growth in power of the EU and downward by devolutionist and secessionist movements (that are hopeful that the structures of the EU might make their devolutionist or secessionist projects easier and more successful.))
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 9y ago
- coldtea 9y ago>How does this explain Brexit? Brexit is a political decision. It's not inherently good or bad, some people with so and so interests find it good, others with so and so interests find it bad. Similarly, some people think other people voted that "against their own best interests", other people think that they voted according to their interests just fine, and that the condescending ones don't really know better. Countries signed up to the EU because of certain proposed benefits (among them, the idea that they need to keep Germany bound, an openly stated goal of early diplomats and politicians that were fundamental in the creation of ECSC/EEC/EU. Long after that, Germany re-united, took the de facto economic leadership of EU, and now votes for AfD. (For a great overview of the climate and the tensions behind EU's creation and later development, I suggest: https://www.amazon.com/New-Old-World-Perry-Anderson/dp/1844677214 https://www.amazon.com/New-Old-World-Perry-Anderson/dp/18446... ). Furthermore, EU has always been problematic from a democratic perspective, with bureaucrats at the helm, and an opaque process of decision-making (complete with several non-official-bodies, non-accountable to anyone, that nevertheless convene and take decisions that affect all member states). Add to that certain "circles of influence" between countries due to historical, cultural and economic ties, where a country might control several other countries votes (and thus have undue influence in EU decisions) and it's not that great a bundle deal. So, if some country doesn't see the benefits in EU membership, they can always flee. Whether it will hurt its economy is not the be-all end-all question to make the decision "rational" or not, as a) the EU is not exactly a paragon of economic stability, b) economies can rebound, c) the economic impact is not the ultimate criterion by which countries decide everything they do. (As for an open market and open standard they can always happen across European countries without common single law and economic steering from Brussels -- I don't think China and the US for example have much issues in trading, despite not belonging to the same federation). It's also about personal interests. Young voters might vote Bremain for reasons like "it's the progressive thing to do", "we want a united Europe", "I want to be able to work in any EU country" etc. Older voters might be more cynical on to what EU actually offers because of their experience, and they also don't have much to gain by EU mobility (nobody --and by that I mean extremely few-- is going to leave everything and start a new career in France in their 50s and 60s) or other things that might be enticing to young voters. That might be selfish of them, but it's not senile or irrational: it's pragmatic. In other words, no, Brexit is not some "proof" that older British get increasingly unwise. At worst, it could mean that they can be wrong in some decision, as is the case with everyone. But the question was not whether they can never cast a wrong vote, but whether they have more experience, control over emotion, better decision making empathy, and other such traits TFA talks about than their younger cohorts. You can have all those and still make this or that bad decision.
- reitanqild 9y ago> How does this explain Brexit? You are framing this like Brexit was a mistake. In a few more years I guess you'll understand better. Note: I'm not saying I'd vote leave but at least I'm old enough to see why others would.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vacri 9y agoLook at it a different way, re: empathy. 90+% of voters 65+ cared enough about the society they live in to show up to that vote. Only 64% of 18-24 and 66% of 25-39s did. How much empathy is there really, if you can't even be bothered to do something as small as showing up to vote?
- mynameishere 9y agoWell, it seems the older people were indeed wiser, more compassionate, more empathetic, thus confirming the study. Young people were mainly voting based on self-interest (ie, "I want to be able to work in Lisbon (or wherever) if a good job opens up") whereas old people were voting for the long-term independence and sovereignty of the whole nation--which would help older people the least.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ThomPete 9y agoNot sure what you mean. There are plenty of arguments for leaving the EU.
- KGIII 9y agoI don't know enough about Brexit to form an opinion, which is good. It enables to to seriously ask this question. Have you actually considered that your opinion on Brexit could be wrong? Have you really given that any consideration? I don't have a nickel invested, so your answer doesn't matter to me. It may matter to you, however.
- Clubber 9y agoAgree. Unlike how most news outlets portray it, most issues have valid points on both sides. If someone doesn't understand both sides and can argue either, they don't really understand the problem. If they don't understand the problem and defer to news coverage, and are being manipulated. Based on most of the coverage of Brexit, I wouldn't have any idea what the pro-Brexit points are. I also don't have a horse in that race, just observations.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI'm not sure if I could argue the leave side fully, but here are the two points they have I believe are very much important: - Many people do like sovereignty of their state, and fear EU is evolving towards weakening, and eventually subsuming nation states. Discussion of the merits of both the position and the fear is a complex thing that needs to go into details, and a one which media failed to do properly. - Many people also dislike the immigration situation within the EU. Again, this is also a very complex topic. Neither of those points, I believe, can be dismissed out of hand, which is often what happens in discussion about Brexit. (Disclaimer: I have no direct horse in this race, but I am a citizen of the EU and kind of like it to stay, so I lean towards the stay side.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- KekDemaga 9y agoI have found that people, despite protestations to the contrary virtually always argue for policy that they believe would benefit them personally in some way. I came to this realization after reading and watching fairly extensively the arguments against income inequality. I personally feel that lack of opportunity is a waste of human resources as surely countless great people who would have shaped society for the better have died without leaving that impact due to lack of access to capitol. Now 80% of the world lives on less than $10 a day, in my view these are the true victims of income inequity yet as I watched debate after debate these people were never mentioned. In fact the people debating seemed to believe that relatively wealthy, often educated Americans would be the beneficiaries of a more "fair" (fairness is debatable and outside of the scope of what I'm saying here) income distribution. That isn't the case as per capita incomes if all global GDP were distributed equally would be around ten thousand dollars per person before taxes, much less than the vast majority of Americans receive as cash income not counting government programs (remember all governmental services must be paid out of that ten thousand. Roads, police, healthcare, food stamps, etc). Thus income inequality isn't the problem they are attempting to resolve instead they are attempting to resolve it in a very limited arbitrary scope that happens to improve their own personal fortunes while ignoring most of the world that is suffering to a greater extent than they will ever experience. This is not to say a particular group is bad, just that their ideas no matter how cleverly disguised are at their core about promoting self interest just like everyone else. I expect the people who voted leave had similar intentions as did the remain voters, naked self interest.
- sophont42 9y agoYou are assuming Brexit is unwise.
- DonaldFisk 9y agoThe objective implications of leaving the EU vs. staying in it -- things like trade agreements, the land border with Ireland, and which decisions were imposed by the EU vs. decided by the UK government -- were poorly understood by most of the population. It was a complex issue and most people, regardless of age, were out of their depth. Wisdom, gained in completely unrelated areas, isn't much use if you don't know the facts.
- jlebrech 9y agowe just get more averse to bad ideas, or have heard it all before.
- nickrio 9y agoMaybe we just too lazy to find out how bad some idea is. LOL
- criddell 9y agoWe also learn from our mistakes and the older we are, the more we've made. When I think back to when I was younger (I'm 47) I realize how simplistic a lot of my beliefs were. These days I'm far more willing to listen to others and I make a lot fewer assumptions about why people do the things they do. I hope the trend continues. I think that's why I was a little sympathetic to that Google engineer that was recently fired for his memo arguing against Google policies on diversity. After I read about what he argued, I actually said to people that he sounds very young. His recent statements about the positive aspects of the KKK reinforce that.
- mythrwy 9y agoAgreed. It's something like acquiring dimension in thinking.
- paganel 9y ago> Empirical studies have shown that older people are better than younger ones in terms of control over emotion Is this a puritan/evangelical thing? What's wrong with displaying emotions? Why is the ability to control them seen as "better"?
- gadders 9y agoOf course it's seen as better. Do you lose your temper and get angry after every setback or inconvenience? This is so self-evident I'm surprised it's even discussed.
- paganel 9y agoDoes "emotion" only equal "angry" and "having a temper"? Is this also a puritan/evangelical thing? What about displays of love and tenderness? And even so, the answer to your question is most of the times "yes", at least in my case, as in I do prefer to spill it out in the heat of the moment instead of keeping it all inside. It's not wrong having "emotions" and displaying them, I though that this was established since back in the Romantics' day (with only a resurgence of "showing emotions is bad" in the Victorian era).
- gadders 9y agoThe point wasn't about showing emotions, it was about controlling emotions so that you have conscious choice over whether to show them or not. For instance, in certain circumstances anger may be appropriate to be shown, but in other cases if you show anger it could work against you. Similarly with humour or any other emotion.
- amrrs 9y agoYou can relate this with Young Brash Jobs vs Old Mature Jobs who made better choices!
- paganel 9y agoI see your point now, thanks. Still personally think that this makes people more "stiff" and more "false", so to speak, which I personally don't like. Maybe it's a cultural thing (I live in Eastern Europe, am in my mid-30s now).
- fnwx17 9y ago"But I do feel that I have become wiser over the years. Or I have become less unwise over the years, however you want to put it" - love this. Also, this article does seem to point out that it's ok if by 25 yrs of age you're not a self-made billionaire
- ksec 9y agoRecently I have been thinking about this; a lot. How do we get wiser, not smarter or cleverer much quicker then we could go with age. I dont know if we could quantitatively measure how wise you are. So it is hard to tell if a person is wise or not. And a lot of times, you dont need to read 1000s of books, have a few DR degree or thesis to be wise. It seems wise and Intellect dont necessarily have a linear relationship. A lot of us, might have thought about Time Traveling, like a lot of blog post telling you "Things I wish i knew" or "Things I could prepared before my startup or X". You would travel back in time and tell your younger self what to do now, what to do next, and what Not to do. But nobody came to realize, your younger self failed to understand why those decision were made, and what causes those action to be made. One may wonder, try hard, fail hard and learn. Then you become wiser. But it doesn't seems to be the case, it seems we don't "click" until we move on to certain age / stage. This rhymes with Zen / Buddhism loosely translated to enlightenment or awaken.
- KGIII 9y agoI think intelligence is our ability to learn and knowledge is what we have already learned. I think wisdom is knowing which one of those is not applicable for a given situation. It is a combination of intuition and experience, knowing if you should learn more or if you need to apply what you have already learned. In a way, wisdom is recognizing when your knowledge is deficient. No guarantees that my assessment is correct, but that works for me.
- pjmorris 9y ago""Knowledge is knowing that a tomato is a fruit. Wisdom is not putting it in a fruit salad." - Miles Kington
- tw1010 9y agoUnasked for advice, but maybe use fewer commas in your future writing.
- knrz 9y agoI actually quite like their flow ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- amelius 9y agoWhen we're young we often do foolish things not because we are fools, but because we want to explore. At least, that's how I like to think about it.
- chrisbennet 9y agoYeah, let's go with that. ;-)
- fairview14 9y ago> Wisdom is a balance between cognition and emotion. No.
- throwanem 9y agoNo?
- fooker 9y agoVery profound comment, thank you.
- fairview14 9y agoYes and No are profound indeed, thank you.
- tomelders 9y agoWisdom comes with observation, not age.
- iamNumber4 9y agoAge != Wisdom. Wisdom comes from Experience and living life. If you sit on a couch all day watching t.v. your experiences do not equal someone who goes out of the house, builds things, etc... Wisdom is earned by doing, not by aging.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wruza 9y agoAnd theirs do not equal to yours. While it is generally admitted that "outside" is more experience-rich and your inequality is mathematically correct, you force the statement that interacting with "non-real" entities does not generate experience. This is not true, actually. Ask a gamer, a worker, a stripper, a mother about their experiences and they'll tell you hell of a lot you traveller never experienced or even thought of. Wisdom is a function of time among other arguments, though the application area and the volume of it may vary on many of these. One cannot age and do nothing, except for few percent of extereme isolation cases.
- wallace_f 9y agoYes, exactly. I would go further and say generalizing intelligence, even types of it like wisdom, is one of the most pervasive-yet-close-to-meaningless concepts that exists. Maybe we say the one who went to Harvard--even assuming the rare case they got in on academic merit alone as a particularly incredible prodigy--may have fantastic mathematical ability, but not have ability or willingness to socially adapt or even contribute constructively to society (Ted Kacznyski). In other words, is there positive value in saying he was particularly intelligent rather than good at math and academic coursework, etc? There are infinite other examples: one can be good at engineering, and bad at writing, etc. Granted there are in fact those with more intellectual horsepower, but everyone has it in a different variety. Then their different experiences, skills and knowledge shape them as a different person. The misleading nature of our thinking about particular ability and abstracting that into a concept of intelligence appears to also be part of human's arrogance in their egos. Hubris is something very human that we collectively get caught up in. The reality is we are all bad thinkers relative to omniscience. Arguably the greatest scientist, Newton, had plenty of crazy ideas about secret messages in the bible, and alchemy, etc., and it's not that he was stupid or illogical, it's that he had different mind that existed in a different environment, as we all do. We also have extremely stupid ideas that people in the future will look back on in the same way, and ask themselves "why were they so smart, yet so stupid?"
- jondubois 9y agoWisdom is the degree to which you accept that you don't understand anything.
- ike_yeah 9y agoOut of genuine curiosity for an explanation, that way of thinking seems like a copout to me.
- eximius 9y agoThis is a strange article that doesn't seem to say much of anything. It almost seems like it is just a piece written and published to make people feel better about aging. Even if the premise is true, it is incredibly insubstantial. I, personally, would expect that wisdom does not come with age, but with experience and training in how one thinks. That doesn't come with age, it comes with time. The sooner or later you begin this training, or the harder you train, greatly effect when or if this wisdom comes. Though, in people who pursue wisdom, I doubt their pursuit decreases with age. A final aside, the article's representation of wisdom ("When you’re old, and something goes wrong, you say, “That’s okay. There are other things that will go right.”") sounds awfully like apathy, if not careful. I believe wisdom is more than that.
- brookside 9y agoI am more and more in the HN camp with those viewing the bulk of social science as...not good science. > We have been doing a study of about 2000 people from age 21 to 100-plus. We look at their physical health, cognitive function, and psychosocial functioning. What we find is that physical health declines after middle age, which is not a surprise. Cognitive function starts to decline in older age, not a surprise. But psycho-social functioning, including wellness, quality of life, and happiness progressively improve with age. Older people handle stresses better than someone in their 20s and 30s. When you’re young and something goes wrong you might be crushed. When you’re old, and something goes wrong, you say, “That’s okay. There are other things that will go right.” This is the unroasted scientific nut in an article written with an overwhelmingly authoritative tone. It sounds like the researchers have an online form or sent out a survey. To whom? With what specific questions? Or maybe they are asking in person and older people are more reticent to reveal to a stranger that they are lonely or unhappy. Does "We have been doing a study" mean it is still in progress, and if so, why are they reporting the results already? The answer of course is that an article like this helps justify the grant money / salaries for the UCSD Center for Healthy Aging. > When you’re young and something goes wrong you might be crushed. When you’re old, and something goes wrong, you say, “That’s okay. There are other things that will go right.” This bit is massive, massive blanket statement to extract from whatever survey they are conducting. Both the young and old can be equanimous. Looking at my own grandmother's current life- almost every one of her friends is dead and she has the more limited mobility and health problems people in their 80s often have. She definitely tries to act as cheerful as possible around us, but I know she gets sad. Because having everybody who really understands you and shared common experiences with you be dead is sad. No longer being able to ride a bike or have the health to travel is sad. Its de-humanizing to think that older people somehow don't feel the emotional pain of these experiences.
- MaysonL 9y agoDavid Letterman has. Here he is with Howard Stern: https://www.howardstern.com/show/2017/8/16/david-letterman-howard-stern-together-again-all-highlights-interview-audio/ https://www.howardstern.com/show/2017/8/16/david-letterman-h...
- pasbesoin 9y agoWe get wiser with experience. We get calmer with age (hormonal changes, among other things).
- ionised 9y agoCan't say I agree. Some of the most narrow-minded and ignorant people I have encountered have been much older than me. Age does not necessarily confer wisdom. I also don't agree with the you must respect your elders adage. Respect to is something you should apply to everyone until they give you a reason to do otherwise, but age in and of itself is not a reason to command respect.