10 ms·
Man convicted after preventing counter-terrorism police search
- raintrees 9y agoAn individual's free speech and privacy rights are very dangerous to governing bodies. Hence, they require significant effort to protect.
- onli 9y agoAnd that's also why authoritarian regimes always undermine them. Anti-terror laws such as that are an attack on human rights and our freedom. A justice system enforcing them is not acting in accordance with what is good and what is right. The law itself in unlawful, and if the system were healthy it would resist. It is not.
- pmoriarty 9y agoDo you think the censorship of Mein Kampf, the anti-hate speech laws, and the illegality of Holocaust denial in some parts of Europe have authoritarian motives?
- onli 9y agoMotives? It is sometimes needed to balance rights. We need to fight nazism, therefor we need to forbid those things. But that's not happening here, there is no balance being stuck. There is just "remove all characteristics of a legal system" (Rechtsstaatlichkeit) on the one side, and the gain is "have the means for absolute power". Edit: I feel that question leans too much into pure politics, and was hesitant answering. The link with HN is that the story is also about criminalizing encryption. Mein Kampf, not so much linked.
- KGIII 9y agoYes, it is authoritarian but it is authoritarianism that some people have justified and like.
- zo1 9y ago"Some" being the key-word there. I wonder how it'll go if it were put down to a referendum on that one, singular issue. Without politics, parties, and candidates to muddy the water.
- KGIII 9y agoA recent poll had 40% of "millenniums" that didn't think that the 1st Amendment covered "hate speech." Though, I'm not really sure you can remove politics from the question and I doubt candidates and parties would not be involved, even if they have to force their way into the issue.
- snakeanus 9y agoAll forms of authoritarianism are justified by some.
- kelnos 9y agoOf course it does. It's censorship and authoritarianism that the majority of people there seem to be ok with, and perhaps actively like, but that doesn't change what it is.
- snakeanus 9y agoI would argue that this is the case indeed.
- gscott 9y agoThere isn't an equivalent to the first amendment in Britain. In Britain people have been sent to jail for tweeting or posting facebook statuses. http://www.thedailybeast.com/can-a-tweet-put-you-in-prison-it-certainly-will-in-the-uk http://www.thedailybeast.com/can-a-tweet-put-you-in-prison-i...
- jdavis703 9y agoThis has nothing to do with free speech (that's the 1st Amendment). This is a problem of illegal search and seizure (at least in the U.S.). Illegal search is covered under the 4th Amendment.
- sp527 9y agoThat's no longer true. The Patriot Act enables government behavior that's functionally equivalent to this incident in the U.K.
- gknoy 9y agoAs does the fact that we now consider "the border" to include anything within 100 miles of the border.
- nobodyorother 9y agoIf you count the US's 98 international airports, doesn't that cover the entire country?
- KGIII 9y agoYou may wish to read the third paragraph on this site: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Border_search_exception
- ceejayoz 9y agoSo, I read that paragraph, and the section I think you're highlighting is this: > the Supreme Court has clearly and repeatedly confirmed that the border search exception applies only at international borders and their functional equivalent (such as international airports) but that line cites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Martinez-Fuerte https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Martinez-Fuer..., which is weird because it says the opposite.
- Kenji 9y agoThe UK is inching its way towards a police state step by step. Well done!
- rtkwe 9y agoSo it's a 12 month probation, not sure exactly what conditional discharge means in the UK but it sounds a lot like probation from a quick search, and a fine for what seems to amount to a contempt of court charge? Not sure why this is particularly remarkable.
- TillE 9y agoSeems increasingly clear that you should never cross a border carrying sensitive data. Encrypt and transfer it separately.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoI wipe and clean everything before crossing a border, encrypting and storing in the cloud, or encrypt and fedex.
- pc86 9y agoBe careful with using private entities to mail your stuff. Yes, it's encrypted, but they also don't need a warrant to open the package. USPS does. Obviously for international shipping this is going to change based on the country of departure/origin, but something to keep in mind if you actually have a need to be concerned with this type of thing.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoFair point. FedEx was a catch all. USPS would be better. It's encrypted so if they seized it ...they'd have more problems than the encryption as my work is government in nature.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoActually it makes having a Chromebook and two Google accounts seem more and more realistic. Now with Google's cooperation you could have a 'duress' password, and log into your account for them and have Google supply an alternate reality.
- jacquesm 9y agoI would not bet against the fact that those two accounts are linked being known to border patrol / law enforcement.
- 9y ago
- mtgx 9y agoThey used the same "counter-terrorism" law to confiscate David Miranda's laptop and other possessions, as well as detain him for 9 hours. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/19/david-miranda-interview-detention-heathrow https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/19/david-miranda-... It's a shame UK doesn't have a real constitution. It would probably help prevent some of this bullshit. Maybe it's time the British people start asking for one.
- r00fus 9y agoThe US constitution doesn't seem to be preventing almost every modern administration and congress from ignoring it. What protects the constitution from those sworn from upholding it?
- valuearb 9y agoIt’s the greatest question, and i often ponder it. I believe the answer is different incentives. The specifics are much harder.
- gruez 9y agonothing, but at least you can try to fight it in court
- r00fus 9y agoRight now, one political party has majority over all three branches of government (including both houses of congress). About the only reason changes aren't being made into law quicker is that this party in control is pushing some very polarizing/unpopular legislation/edicts.
- fit2rule 9y agoAt the moment? Momentum of the general belief that, in fact, the Constitution worked .. for a while. It is only Americas belief in itself which perpetuates the mythos that Americans had rights (in the not-too-distant past) that most of the rest of the world, explicitly did not have... Whereas, the British (and the Australians, who have one of the most embarrassing 'constitutions' of them all) seem to have been fine, all along, to just roll over and expose themselves to their masters, the ruling classes. Nevertheless, these constitutions are nothing more than smart contracts. I'm wondering if anyone has done the UDHR as a smart contract .. seems that might be the right thing to ICO.
- jpster 9y agoI found this article to be a bit more informative than the one submitted here. https://theintercept.com/2017/09/23/police-schedule-7-uk-rabbani-gchq-passwords/ https://theintercept.com/2017/09/23/police-schedule-7-uk-rab...
- dsr_ 9y ago“The Met has retained Rabbani’s phone and laptop and is continuing its efforts to examine the contents.” I'm guessing that means that it's encrypted and, since he still hasn't given them the password, they are stuck. The fine, the cost of a laptop and phone... altogether, I can't see this stopping terrorists, just making people's lives worse.
- komali2 9y agoAs always when this comes up, I wonder about the legality or "legality" of a remote wipe. I have the option using cerberus, and if I did so I'd have a hard time imagining how someone could prove I did it.
- ue_ 9y agoHow would you trigger a remote wipe?
- amiga-workbench 9y agoDead man switch
- rtkwe 9y agoThat's unlikely to work. Police forensics usually work with a drive image instead of with the device itself as much as possible to avoid damaging evidence either through allowing active measures like a dead mans switch or mishandling by investigators. Beyond that simply removing the dive and putting it in another computer would bypass any switch except one in the drive firmware itself. Are there any software out there designed to do that?
- amiga-workbench 9y agoWhat do they do with devices that have soldered in storage? Hilariously enough, an Intel Management Engine-esque system could come in handy here for nuking data.
- bsimpson 9y agoI find this wording especially creepy, given the source is police PR: > argued incorrectly that this gave him the privilege of not sharing information with police
- komali2 9y agoYea I did a double take on the URL after seeing that. So it is a police PR site or what's the story?
- marceldegraaf 9y agoIt's the police's own news site. So yeah, the contents are coloured at best :-)
- confounded 9y agoThe Guardian have more context: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/sep/25/campaign-group-director-in-court-for-refusing-to-divulge-passwords https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/sep/25/campaign-gro... This was very clearly politically motivated to hamper the efforts of CAGE; a UK based group which lobbies of behalf of young Muslim men who have been detained without charge it gitmo, harassed by the security services etc. Regardless of whether readers like CAGE's politics (which are considered inflammatory by the government), this raises a worrying precedent. It's also worth noting that given the UK's recent authoritarian laws, he got off lightly --- this could easily have been spun to possessing encrypted data (while being unwilling or unable to decrypt upon command), which carries a two year sentence, IIRC five if the magic word "terrorism" is conjured.
- komali2 9y ago>possessing encrypted data Is... a crime? Woah.
- tjoff 9y agoIf you don't provide the means to decrypt. Absurd nonetheless.
- mrtron 9y agoWith very selective enforcement. Almost everyone with an internet connected device possess encrypted data.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- graphitezepp 9y agoWelcome to <current year>, where more and more math is considered illegal.
- coldtea 9y agoWell, more and more math is used for non-math purposes too, so the illegality is not exactly as absurd as it seems.
- andyjohnson0 9y ago> Met Police Counter Terrorism Command officers stopped Muhammad Rabbani, 36 (03.03.81) from east London at Heathrow Airport Giving his age kind of adds context, but I don't understand the reason for publishing his date of birth. Odd.
- jaclaz 9y agoTo me it makes little sense. For Police work, time is "relative", as an example the cop that is held in the US for contempt of the Court for not revealing the password to his drives is suspected of possessing child pornography, whether he is kept in jail because he won't reveal them or because as the sheer moment he reveals them he will be proved guilty doesn't change things much (there is anyway other evidence against him). Here it is not a "Police" case, but rather a "counter-intelligence" one, in these cases time is everything, a delay of hours, or at the most days in gathering the information is vital. AFAIK Mr.Rabani NEVER revealed the password(s), he refused revealing it/them on 20/Nov/2016, now, almost one year later, he is found guilty of obstructing the search, still there is no evidence that he is or was - even tangentially - connected with terrorism. So, £620+12 months' conditional discharge seem to me a lot of time/a very severe punishment if he was in good faith attempting to protect some sensitive data for his non-governement organization, and nothing if he was in bad faith or however protecting terrorism related info. In any case, whatever the Police expected to find on the device(s) they didn't access it/them, and much worse than that they didn't access it/them in a timely fashion (and no charges of terrorism or connections to it were made against Mr.Rabani in almost one year) so - besides seeming more a petty vengeance than anything else - it is not like it helped in ANY way the counter-terrorism.
- tryingagainbro 9y ago>> To me it makes little sense. It isn't supposed to make sense. it's suppose to reinforce the "you do whatever the police ask you or face the consequences." Apparently the law backs them....
- jaclaz 9y ago>It isn't supposed to make sense. it's suppose to reinforce the "you do whatever the police ask you or face the consequences." Apparently the law backs them... I meant "make sense" as a deterrent for next occasion AND useful for counter-terrorism. If you are "innocent" and refuse to give away your passwords, you now know that you have serious chances to be punished in a non-trivial way.(losing your electronic device + fine + 12 months conditional) If you are "guilty" (of terrorism or contiguity with it) you now know that you can refuse to give away your password, effectively preventing the police to read your data and maybe in one year time you will get a slap on the wrist (when compared to the punishments for actual being part of a terrorist plot). So, "real" terrorists will surely continue not giving away their passwords to the Police, whilst most innocent people will be giving them - fearing the punishment[1]. The net effect will be that Police will have not access to relevant terrorism related material but it will lose a lot of time on analyzing gigabytes of - say - lolcat videos. [1] a few innocent people will anyway refuse to give away the passwords for this or that principle, so among the "non-answering" will be both innocent and possibly guilty people, so it doesn't even work as a "screening" method.
- KirinDave 9y agoIncreasingly "real" security not only requires that data be encrypted in a way that frustrates those with greater resources, but does so while maintaining the appearance of compliance. People have known this for awhile, but it seems like actual products suggesting security have been slow to adopt it.
- orbitingpluto 9y agoI don't know why anyone would cross a border with electronics of any sort in this day and age. But not having electronics is also grounds for suspicion.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- grey-area 9y agoThis slanted, misleading title from the police is a perfect example of how important the language we use to describe events is. Like the David Miranda case this had nothing to do with terrorism, but laws put in place ostensibly to fight terrorism were instead used to harass people the security services find troublesome. Just reading the title would give you a different impression. In fact this man was arrested without cause and convicted only of refusing to give up the passwords and data of his devices. This law renders our spies and police above the law and able to intercept the communications of anyone they choose without a warrant. For a more informative take on the arrest see this intercept article https://theintercept.com/2017/09/25/muhammad-rabbani-guilty-of-terror-offense-for-not-giving-passwords-to-uk-police/ https://theintercept.com/2017/09/25/muhammad-rabbani-guilty-...
- akvadrako 9y agoThis paragraph really gives me a better idea what we are facing: PC Tariq Chowdhury, the officer who stopped him, said that he had never come across anyone refusing to give the passwords. Some people resisted initially but eventually complied with the order, he added.
- subroutine 9y agoterrorist /ˈterərəst’/ noun A person who doesnt willfully provide passwords for their electronic devices. /s