4 ms·
Sears is a textbook case of the evolution of a company. As the Atlantic points out they were really successful at capturing trends, but what Sear's secret was t
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
Sears is a textbook case of the evolution of a company. As the Atlantic points out they were really successful at capturing trends, but what Sear's secret was they were building infrastructure that let them respond to changes quickly.
Then sometime between 1975 and 1985 they seem to have started thinking they were successful because they were 'the best' and took their eye off the core competencies that made them nimble (logistics, accountable management practices) That is according to people who worked there at that time. Suddenly people who should not have been promoted (they weren't 'Sears people') were being promoted, and things were focused less on operations and more on public image.
The challenge is that you start managing to the effect rather than the cause. It is like companies that spend all of their time doing 'market research' and spend their time trying to be better than their perceived competitors at what their competitors are doing. They lose sight of why they were doing so well in the first place. "chasing your tail", "following the followers", lots of names for it, but they were being challenged by many up and coming brick and mortar competitors (K-Mart, Target, Walmart,
Montgomery Wards, Etc.) By worrying about those threats they forgot to watch for the changes in the market, and that led to a lot of what would be difficult pain.
And yes, it is "easy" to see that looking backwards in time at their choices, but even in the 70's and 80's there were voices telling them that they were not focused on the right problems.
- rhizome 9y agoThen sometime between 1975 and 1985 See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_history_of_private_equity#Regulatory_and_tax_changes_impact_the_boom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_history_of_private_equit...
- cat199 9y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_boomers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baby_boomers
- marcosdumay 9y agoYou mean that easy money was the problem?
- njarboe 9y agoThey also moved from their old headquarters to the Sears Tower in 1973/74. Uprooting the whole physical social dynamic of a company to move to a new headquarters often does not go well. Good luck Apple.
- agumonkey 9y agoYou mean that the actual physical habits of people are factors to consider ? And if those aren't recreated, the work won't go as well ?
- njarboe 9y agoI read an article about it many years ago. Who you bump into and are physically near can create and maintain certain workflows and company culture. This was probably more important before personal computers and the internet. You are likely to have lunch with people you see and different business units can cross fertilize with greater ease. Moving from an organically grown bunch of buildings near each other, to a huge building with only elevator access to each floor, will change how people interact quite a bit.
- wahern 9y agohttps://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/241/20-acts-in-60-minutes?act=14#play https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/241/... "Act 14" on this This American Life episode tells the story of what happened when the Vienna Sausage Company moved production to a new, purpose-built facility. If you'd rather read than listen, scroll down to "Act Fourteen" here, https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/241/transcript https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/241/... It arguably exemplifies precisely what you're saying, except in a much more literal fashion.
- WalterBright 9y agoMy father (economics professor) said you can date the start of a company's demise from when they build a palace for a headquarters. For one thing, the design of the palace becomes a huge distraction for top management. Once they move in, they start to believe they are the godlike businessman the palace suggests they are. Yeah, the Apple saucer is a big risk.
- icantdrive55 9y agoI sometimes wonder if retail stores just have a timeline? Even in the 80's, when I walked through Sears, I could tell someting was wrong. I do know they never paid their employees well, but housing was definitely cheaper. And the average employee didn't treat the job as a career. It's gotten so bad, even the extremely desperate worker just looks at Sears as a chit job. That said, there's so many stores I walk through today, where it's obvious they are on the downward curve. An example is Home Depot. I used to enjoy the stores. The employees seemed happy. Now--I just dread going in. The customers are treated terribly, or as potential criminals. The employees seem to hate their jobs with a passion. Plus--their prices arn't the cheapest anymore. There's nothing about HD that entices me these days. Oh, and the cameras. If anyone from HD corportate happens to read this; it's employee theft. Your company managed to piss off every employee, including security. They just don't give a dam anymore. I'm suprised someone hasen't tried to capture the magic HD had twenty years ago? I really think the only reason they are still, supposedly, on the rise, is they are practically a monopoly in many counties. I truly think too much management, too much gimmicky sales ploys; will ruin a retail establishment. A good company manager should be able to walk through a store, and figure out what's wrong. It's not that complicated? I sometimes think we should take away the title of Manager. The most capable, natural leader should be the one in charge. Hell--stop using the word "Manager" all together? We all know the best, most capable, natural leader never becomes a Manager. Or, if they do, they leave because of lousy working conditions. Anyways--I will miss Sears when it closes in my county. They carry some specialized automotive tools that have saved my butt a few times. Times where I couldn't wait on a Amazon delivery. And they have every size combination of Levi's 501 made. I don't have the answer, but just know when the employees start to dislike their job, it's the kiss of a slow retail death.