5 ms·
> As an engineering manager, you'll need to put company first, team second and your team members third. Remember that a "company" is an imagined reality that w
by lordnacho 9y ago
> As an engineering manager, you'll need to put company first, team second and your team members third.
Remember that a "company" is an imagined reality that works because a lot of people believe it. "Team" is as well, but fewer people need to believe it. (Compare those to "nation").
Your team members are real though.
- ramblerman 9y agoThe idea that the company doesn't exist was first highlighted to me in "The Software Hegemony" and it's been a super useful mental crutch since. You are absolutely right. The company doesn't make you promises, offer you raises, or in fact owe you anything, people do.
- jerrre 9y ago> "The Software Hegemony" Do you mean this? https://www.daedtech.com/developer-hegemony-the-crazy-idea-that-software-developers-should-run-software-development/ https://www.daedtech.com/developer-hegemony-the-crazy-idea-t...
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoWhat's an ant colony then -- imaginary or real? And if imaginary, who is doing the imagining? I'm not sure I understand your position.
- hycaria 9y agoThis phrasing sounds like the book Sapiens (that I'm currently reading and does not live up to its hype for me). I also think thats a superflous way to describe the world though.
- lordnacho 9y agoI read it recently, and it was a major influence, that passage. It's a bit too ambitious to describe everything we do as a species, so the book does get a bit stale partway through. The central idea isn't wrong at all. It's quite clear that we've created a bunch of cultural shared "items" like the the limited liability corporation and such, which are useful but don't really have a physical existence. That doesn't mean they're easy to create or destroy either.
- jo909 9y agoYou see thousands of individual ants, and call that colony. What if I went around the forest and picked one ant out of thousands of colonies and put them all together? Will you still call this a colony? Even if they begin fighting each other? I wouldn't. It's the behavior of the ants that makes them a colony, which isn't a "real" physical thing.
- brlewis 9y agoThere's nothing more real and physical than the behavior of creatures that choose whether to bite you.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoIsn't the fact that you can't pick a thousand random ants and trick me into thinking they're a colony evidence that there's more to there being a colony than mere imagination on my part? Unless you're alleging that the ants conceive of a colony, the colony is a machine made out of pieces -- it's like saying a puzzle doesn't have a physical reality when clearly it does: a thousand random pieces don't make a puzzle, and that distinction lies in the physical reality of the system under examination. In so much as it makes sense to talk about ants, and not clumps of mobile cells or automata of particles, it makes sense to talk about ant colonies. After all, it's the behavior of the particles that appears to make the ant an entity -- the ant isn't real, only the particle behavior. Your point seems to depend on those entities which we can immediately recognize as entities being more real than other kinds of entities, but that has no logical basis and is an outright appeal to emotion.
- jo909 9y agoImagination is certainly not the right word here. But we seem to agree that "there's more" to a colony than just the physical reality of many thousands of ants in a pile. I can't touch it or extract it from the pile of ants. If I take half the ants, do I still have a colony? If they now form two colonies, where did the second one come from? How many times can I divide the ants and still have a colony? Where did the colony go if I no longer have one? Of course "all the ants that form the colony" is a real physical thing, just the same as all the cells that form the ant, but that's arguing in circles. You need to have the "idea" of the larger (or smaller) entity in the first place to be able to point at it. And it's not the point of the OP anyway, because the ants certainly themselves don't have any concept of the whole colony and don't freely decide if they are one or not. That's just an external observation and classification we made after the fact.