6 ms·
This same argument was made when Austin required fingerprinting for drivers and Uber and Lyft left. What happened? Their was a flourishing of new ride share co
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
This same argument was made when Austin required fingerprinting for drivers and Uber and Lyft left.
What happened? Their was a flourishing of new ride share companies, including a local nonprofit, RideAustin. Yes, at first, these apps were nowhere near the level of Uber/Lyft, but they quickly improved, especially RideAustin. The prices were slightly higher, but it seemed those prices reflected the actual cost of the service without the VC subsidy.
I dread taking a taxi and I'm no friend of the formerly entrenched taxi companies, but this idea that making some sensible regulations that these multibillion dollar VC-subsidized tech companies need to follow is "anti-innovation" is BS.
- harry8 9y agoThis isn't sensible regulation. This is an outright ban, which is a whole different ball of wax. Is an outright ban "anti-innovation"? You can't do sensible regulation once you've banned entrants in favour of the taxis.
- parent5446 9y agoIt's not a ban on ride-sharing. It's a ban on a single specific company: Uber. And the ban is because Uber was routinely violating sensible regulations.
- tigershark 9y agoWhat other ride-sharing company operates in London? Addison lee, kabbee and the multiple private cab companies can't offer the same service as uber when you need a ride on the moment. They are fine when you can book in advance, otherwise be prepared to wait half an hour or more.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- saurik 9y agoThe fact that there is only one barber, butcher, or baker (or candlestick maker... whatever) in town should not dissuade us from putting them out of business if they don't pay attention to safety regulations...
- tigershark 9y agoThen if safety is really the concern why taxis and cabs can operate given that they are way less safe than uber? I would rather use the safer option, but instead I'm forced to use the less safe options.
- parent5446 9y agoAre you saying Uber is the safer option? Did you miss the part where they are violating the safety regulations, and where cab companies are not?
- tigershark 9y agoIn the other thread were posted the offences done by taxi drivers and were far more than the ones committed by uber drivers. Considering that you can easily report the behaviour of a Uber driver I can believe it.
- parent5446 9y agoDo you have any data to back that up? If it's so easy to report Uber drivers, where's Uber's statement showing the data it has collected regarding its supposed lower offense rates? Why hasn't the London government taken into account this data? Or is the best evidence available random anecdotes?
- zimpenfish 9y ago> Considering that you can easily report the behaviour of a Uber driver I can believe it. Reporting an Uber driver doesn't necessarily mean any action is taken. https://www.londonreconnections.com/2017/understanding-uber-not-app/ https://www.londonreconnections.com/2017/understanding-uber-... has a story about a driver committing a sexual assault, being reported to Uber who didn't report it to the police -or- fire him, and he went on to commit another which Uber -also- didn't report to the police. > In total, Uber had failed to report six sexual assaults, two public order offences and one assault to the police. This had lead to delays of up to 7 months before they were investigated. This is why MetPol are arguing strongly against licensing Uber.
- marcus_holmes 9y agoNo. It's presented as an outright ban, but that doesn't mean what you think it means. Uber is able to continue business while it appeals. As long as the appeal process is continuing (and it may well continue for years to the High Court) Uber can continue business as usual. Uber can change its processes during the course of the appeal, and if they match what is required, the ban will fail. This is a high-visibility, high-impact method of regulation that Uber can't ignore. Given Uber's habit of ignoring regulations it doesn't like, it seems entirely appropriate. One of the largest problems that the UK has had with the EU is that EU-mandated regulations are not implemented by some EU member countries. This is against all the rules of the EU, but there's no enforcement. In the UK, regulations are implemented and enforced. This is that enforcement in practice. One of the reasons London has flourished as a financial centre is because the regulatory agency doesn't mess around and does its job properly. This gives certainty, stability, and engenders trust in trading partners. The article is entirely wrong, completely misunderstands what's happening here, and why.
- jonknee 9y agoYou forgot the end of that story. They let Uber and Lyft back in[1] and the apps that had sprouted up instantly got crushed[2]. [1] https://www.curbed.com/2017/6/14/15803138/austin-uber-lyft-transportation-ride-hailing-return https://www.curbed.com/2017/6/14/15803138/austin-uber-lyft-t... [2] https://www.bizjournals.com/austin/news/2017/06/06/uber-lyft-squash-their-first-austin-ridesharing.html https://www.bizjournals.com/austin/news/2017/06/06/uber-lyft...
- bsder 9y agoYeah, Uber and Lyft spent VC money to lobby the state government to override what the Austin voters decided. So much for the will of the consumer, eh? But, hey, that's what "DISRUPTION!" looks like nowadays, right?
- pyronik 9y agoWho's being forced to use uber/lyft? Ironic that you believe state intervention into markets as being the "will of the consumer".
- jakebasile 9y agoThe Austin fingerprint law was a voter initiative passed by Austin citizens. The state of Texas overturned it by vote of elected representatives from across the state. I think the latter is much more a "state intervention".
- indubitable 9y agoIt's interesting to precisely consider what "a voter initiative passed by Austin citizens" translates to. And to clarify the fingerprint law was not what was actually passed. That law was passed unilaterally by the city council --- whom a cynic might suggest was driven by what we'll call "lobbying", rather than necessity. The vote was a result of ride sharing services collecting the necessary tens of thousands of signatures that required the City Council to either soften the rules or bring the matter to public vote. The council chose to spend the hundreds of thousands of taxpayer dollars necessary to keep the ordinance intact and hold an impromptu election. These [1] are the results of that election. Austin has a population of 950,000 residents with a voting age population of about 741,000 [2]. In total about 5% of the resident population voted to maintain the fingerprinting law and 4% to soften it. A 1% margin on a voter turnout of less than 12%. I fully appreciate that that is a 'democratic republic in action.' I'm certain you can understand one might find it distasteful, just as one can easily understand your distaste for state level 'democratic republic in action.' I'm certain our systems made all the sense in the world hundreds of years ago. But these sort of things do not feel right today when we live in a country with counties that now have greater population than the entire country did when these laws and systems were developed. [1] - http://traviselectionresults.com/enr/contest/display.do?criteria.electionId=201605&electionId=201605&tabType=C&districtId=310&contestId=3 http://traviselectionresults.com/enr/contest/display.do?crit... [2] - https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/austincitytexas/PST045216 https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/austincitytexas...
- bassman9000 9y agoVC-subsidized Private companies don't subsidize. Private companies invest.