4 ms·
Inside the Madness at Evergreen State
- meri_dian 9y agoWow, this is really reminiscent of the Cultural Revolution. These retaliatory attitudes towards 'white' people are hostile and racist and do not work towards building an inclusive society. Edit: Why was this flagged?
- dba7dba 9y agoNah, it will never happen again. Not here. That swas the sentiment of many before WW2 broke out. Holocaust happened. Cultural Revolution took off.
- adekok 9y agoWhen your enemies are by definition bad, and your side is by definition good, you can do anything. Any evil is excusable, because it's done by "good" people against the "bad" people. The people advocating this idiocy are unaware of history. The end result of their advocacy is genocide. They will end up being accused of the things they oppose, by people even more radical than themselves. For me, all of the despotic ideologies are the same. This kind of political correctness, communism, anti-semitism, etc. They all want "good" people to destroy the "bad" people. Reality be damned. Consequences be damned. Humanity be damned.
- cupscale 9y agoI guess. As someone who grew up near Evergreen (and knew a few classmates who attended), Evergreen's always kinda been this way. At least for the last 20+ years. I (and many others I grew up with) think of Evergreen in the same way I think of avant garde fashion: It's sometimes a precursor of trends to come, but those trends are heavily watered-down and altered versions of the original. I don't worry about a cultural revolution stemming from Evergreen any more than I worry about a nazi uprising stemming from 4chan. EDIT: That is to say, both can be influential in their own way but in both cases their particular viewpoints get really watered-down by the time it becomes "mainstream" in any way.
- quuquuquu 9y agoIt was flagged because x% of users on this site refuse to have difficult and nuanced conversations about racism and censorship. They ruin it for the rest of us.
- zenkat 9y agoWhy flagged? Read the submission guidelines: "Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Ideological or political battle or talking points. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- quotemstr 9y agoWhy is Evergreen still getting a single cent of public money? This attitude doesn't educate people or serve any public interest.
- wallace_f 9y agoAcademia. 'Anti Whiteness is pro humanity,' according to a professor teaching a course "The Problem with Whiteness," who UW Madison defends[0]. "In this class, we will ask what an ethical white identity entails, what it means to be #woke, and consider the journal Race Traitor's motto, 'treason to whiteness is loyalty to humanity" Any professor teaching anti-(any other race'ness') would be instantly a pariah and unable to keep a job. http://www.cnn.com/2016/12/23/health/college-course-white-controversy-irpt-trnd/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2016/12/23/health/college-course-white-co... I have a question. When I grew up I heard 'colorblindness' was a good thing. What happened to that? It appears we are going in the opposite direction.
- Blackthorn 9y ago> Any professor teaching anti-(any other race'ness') would be instantly a pariah and unable to keep a job. Whiteness isn't really a race, so that's not the same thing. In America, it's been a social construct whose members have shifted over the years. > I have a question. When I grew up I heard 'colorblindness' was a good thing. What happened to that? It appears we are going in the opposite direction. People started to realize that it ignores the lived experience of black people.
- wallace_f 9y agoI feel like I don't understand this. Consider the hypothetical courses: "the problem with Jewishness," or "the problem with Blackness." Are those at all acceptable? I am certain they are not! So what is acceptable about "the problem with Whiteness?" I think you are saying that Whites do not constitute a race in the same way that Blacks do?? Does that make sense?
- 9y ago
- quuquuquu 9y ago>[A student] cited Christopher Hitchens’s variation of Occam’s razor: “What can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.” >[a person who helped organize the Day of Absence] observed that because Hitchens’s razor is an “Englishman’s popularization of a Latin proverb,” it “would seem to itself be the product of at least two traditionally hierarchical, imperialist societies with an interest in disposing of inconvenient questions.” . . Wow, you really can't make this up. Evergreen officially asked "white" students to not show up to campus one day. Those who protested this decision were told that because their logic is of English and Latin origin, it's racist.
- meri_dian 9y agoPeople who can't think for themselves let the fashionable tropes of the day think for themselves instead.
- gaius 9y agoEvergreen is $25k/year, so while not quite as egregious as Oberlin at $65k/year, it's enough that anyone enrolled there is highly privileged themselves. Particularly those without a direct route to monetise their degree such as those taking professional subjects.
- zenkat 9y agoWhy is this article considered suitable for Hacker News? It's political fodder, not sci/tech. In any case, there appears to be many overheated claims around this event, with precious little context. This was a voluntary event, where both minority and white students were allowed to go off-campus for discussions around "identity politics"; https://evergreen.edu/multicultural/day-of-absence-day-of-presence https://evergreen.edu/multicultural/day-of-absence-day-of-pr...
- meri_dian 9y ago>"Day of Absence is a day for community building around identity groups." It sounds more like an event encouraging and celebrating tribalism.
- zenkat 9y agoThat's a valid critique of identity politics. The original article is not. And again, I didn't think HN was a forum for debating these sorts of political / cultural issues in the first place. What does this have to do with science, technology, or startups?
- meri_dian 9y agoPolitics has always had its niche on HN.
- sremani 9y agoHN has a constant stream about current events and opinion discussed on the front page pretty much every day. You can use the hide button if it does not interest you.
- DanBC 9y agoI agree this article isn't a good fit for HN but... > What does this have to do with science, technology, or startups? ...this has never been the criteria for a good HN submission. It has always been "something a good hacker would find interesting" -- this includes history, philosophy, good psychology, etc.
- api 9y agoAm I the only one who sees this stuff and the thinly veiled neo-Nazi ideology of the alt-right as two wings of the same movement? They operate as a kind of dialectic with the antics of both sides serving to strengthen the other. Under the hood they share the same intellectual foundation in biological determinism, identity politics, postmodernism, and anti-rationalism.
- abiox 9y agothe 'alt-right' isn't composed wholly of white identity politics; however such people are clearly there. their boldness has been stoked by anti-white identity politics. between this willing visibility and an ad-dependent 24-7 news cycle hunting for eyeballs, some get the impression that this group is much larger than it is.
- factsaresacred 9y ago> Media professor Naima Lowe...said that “white supremacy is literally ingrained in everything.” In other words, merely defending oneself against the accusation of “white supremacy” is evidence of guilt. Hmm, now what kind of professor uses such an utterly insane attempt at reasoning? https://thebadger14.files.wordpress.com/2017/06/lowe.jpg https://thebadger14.files.wordpress.com/2017/06/lowe.jpg Ah. Honestly, reality is becoming a parody. Why are people with apparent personality disorders (not to mention, intelligence deficits) allowed to wield such influence? Somebody mentioned the Cultural Revolution. Go read Philip Pan's excellent 'Out of Mao's Shadow'. The pages on struggle sessions read exactly like the tales coming out of Evergreen. An excerpt: > But Mao rewrote history and added a new section setting limits on what could be criticized....The lively campus debates over ideas became denunciation meetings, and at times they got physical, with students shoved to the ground and forced to bow their heads....One by one, those who had voiced “Rightist” opinions were identified and summoned to self-criticism meetings, where they were told to confess their crimes, implicate colleagues, and renounce friends. This nonsense has to end.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoPerhaps we can also look at this in terms of power dynamics. It's possible many of the students are not as devoted to their cause as it may seem. Instead, the cause has given these students power, over administrators, and others. That power can be intoxicating. So the students will use any opportunity they can to exert power over others, and expand that power. I think Evergreen is worth examining through the lens of Lord of the Flies.
- dmix 9y agoThe book "Fools, Frauds, and Firebrands" has a recurring theme about how this obsession with viewing everything in the world through the lens of 'power' has resulted in misguided, irrational, and just plain wrong thinking. Often from otherwise smart people. Power plays a role but it's only one of many. But reducing everything to that is a recipe for missing the big picture. Foucault's work is one of the great examples of this. He loved to reduce complex systems with many competing motivations as merely the products of power. https://www.amazon.com/Fools-Frauds-Firebrands-Thinkers-Left/dp/1472935950/ https://www.amazon.com/Fools-Frauds-Firebrands-Thinkers-Left...
- zenkat 9y agoFrom https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html : Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Ideological or political battle or talking points. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.