4 ms·
On the other hand they are in a unified market with fixed fees, are limited in their ability to import outside of the EU, have little to no direct control over
by dogma1138 9y ago
On the other hand they are in a unified market with fixed fees, are limited in their ability to import outside of the EU, have little to no direct control over subsidies and will not be able to afford the same food prices that the richer countries pay nor do they have the ability to economically grow some many of the food items in question like the Mediterranean basin European countries do.
The sad truth is when you are the poor fellow and had given up sovereignty over the many of the economic tools available to sovereign nation states you'll get shafted no matter what.
- rocqua 9y agoI don't think you'll find many Romanians that'd like to leave the EU. Even simply due to the net money flow from the EU into Romania.
- dogma1138 9y agoI didn't say they should leave the EU but they also can't really win in a fight against the purchasing power of wealthier countries in a single market when they can't import out of it other than via the existing EU channels. Denmark imports tomatoes from Italy at the same duty rates as Bulgaria which are zero. Denmark has more money, normally countries would enforce both import and export duties since there are no duties effectively Bulgaria and Denmark and Bulgaria can only compete on price per unit and neither country can use any other tool to control the price. If Bulgaria wants to import Tomatoes from say Turkey or Israel they also have to go through the EU red tape and effectively pay a "fixed" price which is more or less set to protect EU tomatoes growers. Bulgria also cannot subsidize Tomatoes for the most part without violating EU regulations. Now Bulgria gains a lot form being an EU nation, having lesser tomatoes is the price they pay.
- izacus 9y agoI think you missed the part which talks about people actually crossing borders to shop the more expensive versions of products. I remember this happening regularly in the 1990s when people from ex-Yugoslavia drove over to Italy/Austria to shop for better quality (although more expensive) products.
- dogma1138 9y agoSome wealthy people cross the border. The net annual disposable household income in Hungary is $15,000 in Italy it's 25,000, in France it's 30,000. This isn't an argument against the EU, it's the reality of a highly regulatory market with a plethora of constraints but with the general premise of a free market economy in which the highest bidder wins.
- izacus 9y agoHmm, I wouldn't call families that do that wealthy by any account. (At times my family did that the average salary in the country was about $8,000 - in 1995).
- limaoscarjuliet 9y agoI'm 43 years old Pole who has seen commie land times and witnessed progress we made after joining EU. Without EU we would still be 30yrs behind (see Ukraine - no offence but they are way behind). Not saying EU is perfect, just the net effect of EU is progress.
- danmaz74 9y agoMaybe you forgot the part where they can export to other EU countries without any fees and barriers, and this has increased the GDP much faster than their neighbors outside of the EU (like eg Ukraine, even before the Crimea affair).
- dogma1138 9y agoI didn't forget in fact I've specifically mentioned that EU members do not have full control over their trade policies or tariffs. This isn't an argument against the EU as a whole it's the reality of the circumstances. When both rich and poor countries are forced to import from the same sources at the same rates which are designed to protect the producers rather then the consumers the prices rise and they are forced to compete at the price per unit which also directly translates to the final consumer price. Bulgaria, Romania or Denmark can't reduce their import tarrifs on tomatoes from a specific EU country, they can't even control the import tariffs from non EU countries.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- danmaz74 9y agoBulgaria, Romania or Denmark can't reduce their import tariffs on tomatoes from a specific EU country... because tariffs between EU countries are already 0. Moreover, only Eurozone countries have fixed exchange rates, the other ones - which include almost all former Soviet block members - can still change those rates.
- dogma1138 9y agoHaving tarrifs at zero is a problem. You assume that Denmark would enforce the same or lower tarrifs than a poorer nation on some basic goods. Smaller nations also can have negative import tarrifs on some goods in order to allow thier importers to compete with bigger consumers. Which you cannot do in the EU. The EU as a whole also has trade agreements with many of the regional non EU members. These argeemnts also enforce protective tariffs to reduce the competitiveness of non EU imports. The EU also requires its trade partners to meet EU regulations which increase the prices of exports to begin with.
- valuearb 9y agoWhat tools do “sovereign” nations have that could solve this problem? Can’t be tariffs, which are a tool to enrich the few while making the rest poorer. Maybe poorer people can’t afford the same levels of food quality as richer peoples, and the only solution is to grow your GDP faster, which membership in EU seems to enable.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoStronger regulation and enforcement of regulations.
- valuearb 9y agoyou can’t regulate your way to prosperity, regulations are costs, not benefits.
- baq 9y agoi'll take getting shafted while being a part EU instead of getting shafted being alone.