47 ms·
Yes, that's the distinction. With Bitcoin, a codebase prevails if it attracts enough miners, merchants and users. Those parties in aggregate have "fiat power".
by mirimir 9y ago
Yes, that's the distinction. With Bitcoin, a codebase prevails if it attracts enough miners, merchants and users. Those parties in aggregate have "fiat power".
It's arguable that fiat power for each state similarly reflects preferences of banks, merchants and users. However, some of us doubt that money policy typically favors users.
With government fiat, forking isn't really possible, without a revolution, no matter how unhappy users are. But with Bitcoin etc, that is possible.
It's a common misconception that miners drive Bitcoin policy. In my opinion, miners are parasitic. When I first started using Bitcoin, there were virtually no professional miners. Users did all of the mining, locally. So difficulty was very low. Now, with so many professional miners, difficulty is very high. However, blocks get solved in 10 minutes on average, just as they did in the beginning.
Anyway, it's true that Bitcoin is a fiat currency. But governments aren't in control, and that's a good thing.
- labster 9y agoSo you're telling me that government money, where everyone gets a say in policy through republican institutions, is worse than a system where the most wealthy users get more control of the currency. Um, okay. I guess the oligarchy is more explicit in the cryptocurrency.
- kemiller 9y agoIt’s not really government money though, is it? It’s bank money.
- mirimir 9y agoI don't think that it's necessarily the wealthiest users. There could be a fork with lots of interest, no particularly wealthy users, and no non-user miners. One could probably impose the "no non-user miners" rule in code. But even then, I prefer it, because with enough interest, it can always be forked. And that's much easier than changing governmental monitary policy. That is clearly dominated by the wealthy.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoIf you really think you have a say in monetary policy, I suggest you read Barofsky's Bailout.
- musage 9y agoYou have a say in it in principle. In contrast, you have in principle no say what others do with their private property. That's the difference, and it's an important one.
- mirimir 9y agoYou can't control what miners do, sure. But you can fork code that changes the game for them. Contrary to all the noise, Bitcoin does not need commercial miners. They are parasites. Allowing them to dominate mining was a serious bug. It's users who should be mining.
- anigbrowl 9y agoI mined a little in the early days, but it kept my CPU pinned into the red and frankly all the people online patting themselves on the back on the size of their mining operation were offputting. I'm interested in cryptocurrencies because of their potential to liberate the mass of people from financial bullying by governments and corporations, not as a speculative vehicle to easy riches. This will seem pointlessly ideological to most people, but I'm struck by the fact that the bitcoin blockchain is held up as 'proof of work.' There's no work involved besides that to understand the system initially and any code contributions made to the source tree. The actual calculation is carried out by machine. So mining is basically a game for capitalists to invest in industrial hash table production. People who learn about it later and comprehend it in full but don't have any large sums of capital to invest in mining equipment or as a speculative investment don't really derive much benefit from it. Don't get the idea that I consider it a bad thing because of this - its mere existence speaks to the fact that we've run out of accessible natural frontiers where the curious might stumble upon a fortune, and so we are forced to invent them.
- ycombobreaker 9y ago
- mseebach 9y agoJust download a mining program and run it on your computer. Voilà, you now have "a say" that is exactly equivalent to your say in the policy of republican institutions.
- Terr_ 9y agoDon't be silly, that's like saying that incorporating a one-person business automatically puts you on-par with the lobbying power of major industries.
- mseebach 9y agoNo, it's as silly as suggesting that a single voter has any say what so ever in the policies of republican institutions.
- radarsat1 9y ago1 vote for a poor person = 1 vote for a rich person (ideally). In mining, the more mining power you have, the more "say" you have. One stays constant, the other scales. Don't you think that is an important distinction?
- spdionis 9y agoIn a way it's a pretty naive view. The rich person will have more influence over other people that will give him effectively more than 1 vote.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoOP's point is the big mining rig will have more influence than the numpty rig one boots up on their laptop.
- mirimir 9y agoSure, each has one vote. But it's not your one vote that makes any difference, It's how many votes you can influence. And that's all about privilege and money. Campaign funding. Lobbying.
- wuliwong 9y agoIn the specific case of the united states, the money is controlled by the Federal Reserve which is a private bank.
- sethev 9y agoMost private banks aren't established by an act of Congress and run by people appointed by the President and approved by the Senate.
- candiodari 9y agoNo, but in order to get access to the Fed, the bank link systems and so on and so forth, they need to get government approval. In order to be bailed out, which is a necessity, they even need contacts as high up as the president. And even that is ignoring the long history of the government making specific laws specifically to benefit or destroy a single bank. Nope, no government role here at all. This division simply results in privatizing the profits, nationalizing the losses in trade for having politicians name the owners. it is if you want to be a reserve bank of course, which is why anyone wants to have a bank in the first place.
- abritinthebay 9y ago> the Federal Reserve which is a private bank Not true. Literally by design actually. This is a common misconception about Central Banks and it's one the US system makes worse by being explicitly public but functioning extraordinarily similarly to a private company. This particular structure was actually a compromise between various other possible implementations. But seriously, it's not a private bank. Repeating that just makes you looking like you get your information from websites that put their titles in all-caps and have dodgy grammar.
- StanislavPetrov 9y ago>where everyone gets a say in policy through republican institutions You clearly have no idea how money is "created" or how the Federal Reserve works.
- skywhopper 9y agoYour assertion depends on what you mean by "government". There are groups of people who are in control. The ability to fork peacefully is not unique to Bitcoin--see the governments of the UK, Canada, and Australia. And given high enough stakes, there's no reason to believe that the interested parties in the Bitcoin blockchain would not resort to violence to protect their interests from forkers who would impact their profits.
- api 9y agoForking is totally possible for states. Different factions are constantly vying for power and many revolutions are quiet shifts that occur behind the scenes. This is very true in complex democratic republics but is even still true in monarchies and dictatorships. Monarchs have power by consent of a whole hierarchy of people and they are subject to overthrow or silent sidelining. Gold is still the closest thing to a true non-fiat money but even gold has a value based on a consensus and any monetary form of gold will typically come as some kind of coinage for convenience and quick assessment. You can't eat gold. Money is a social construct. You could argue that crypto currency promises a form of fiat that is more transparent, auditable, accurate, and open in general but IMHO that remains to be seen in practice. The shitshow that is most exchanges and the majority of flimsy ICOs is not encouraging. All economic systems have corruption and dumb sheep like speculation but this is ridiculous.