6 ms·
These type of articles never explore the potential results of the Rotten Tomatoes voting system. As the article mentions the RT rating is not a measure of how
by slg 9y ago
These type of articles never explore the potential results of the Rotten Tomatoes voting system. As the article mentions the RT rating is not a measure of how good a movie is, it is a measure of the percentage of people who viewed the movie positively. A 100% doesn't mean a movie is perfect or even particularly good, it means no one thought it was bad.
A movie designed to do well on a RT score needs to please everyone. The end result is something that tries to be bland, uninteresting, and inoffensive. As an avid movie goer, that is a horrible result. I would much rather see a movie that takes risks and fails than something with little ambition outside turning a profit.
If you ask people why they don't go to the movies more they will often cite the idea that there is nothing new they haven't seen before (besides the complaints you hear about prices). That is another way of phrasing this exact problem. It is becoming more and more risky to innovate and try something new. You end up with lots of sequels, remakes, and other cookie cutter projects. It is safer to invest in the next mediocre superhero movie that most people will be fine with than an innovative middle budget drama that might have a harder time finding an audience. That is what is hurting the movie industry.
- Touche 9y agoThose films are now done by Netflix and Amazon. Just a different model. I used to go to an indie theater twice a week when I was in college and saw every niche film. But those theaters hardly exist any more. The big theater experience just isn't cut out for that. It's barely pleasant enough to go see the latest popcorn movie. The industry really needs to take at-home seriously.
- nebabyte 9y ago"The industry" only cares about its own moneymaking; you're not gonna see them roll over and say "hey, you know what's a really good movie?" rather than keep pushing their own formulaic investments. Even critics aren't going to stop reviewing big-name movies on the grounds that they're all the same recycled shit; reviews of recycled shit likely still earns them far more than their other reviews combined.
- cholantesh 9y agoLately I find the experience of sitting in an auditorium for several hours profoundly unpleasant. The (to me) nauseating smell of popcorn, the sticky floors, uncomfortable seats, and painfully loud speakers are just not worth it for so many forgettable movies (to say nothing of Prometheus). I took my whole family to see the Force Awakens, though, and none of us were noticed any of this because we were so enthralled by the film. But that's a rare exception to the rule these days.
- nebabyte 9y ago> It is safer to invest in the next mediocre superhero movie Thus leading to those "trends" people get faux-excited for (I say that as they completely forget the 'hype' over previous ones when the next one hits) and masking the problem in the first place. Anyways, "safe but boring" is finance's bread and butter, so looking to big-budget flicks to take risks in the pursuit of good art is a lost cause. They only care insofar as they can get emmy attention to up sales.
- Sir_Substance 9y ago>If you ask people why they don't go to the movies more they will often cite the idea that there is nothing new they haven't seen before I have literally never heard someone say this >(besides the complaints you hear about prices) Yup, there it is. But also, to watch a movie in the cinema I often have to sit in uncomfortably off-center chairs. I can't adjust the volume if I think it's too loud, I can't pause the movie to take a piss and I have to listen to the troglodytes behind me eat popcorn with their mouths open. The movies start at rigidly defined times that may not be convenient for me, I'm not allowed to bring a pizza in, I can't do anything about it if someone has an inconsolable baby or kicks the back of my chair repeatedly and to top it all off there's half an hour of ads before the movie starts. And yeah, I have to pay $15 for that. All in all, cinema is still a very 1920's experience, and I don't really want that. I have a 3D home projector man, I got it second hand for like $200. It's not as good as the cinema projector, but I assure you my couch is nicer. I've just delayed my cinema schedule by 6 months. Spiderman: Homecoming is being released soon, I'm pumped. No spoilers please.
- miloshadzic 9y agospiderman wins
- MBCook 9y agoThe way things are setup is also designed to make me feel like I’m being ripped off. Go to see a brand new very popular movie. They know high ticket prices scare people away, so I can easily get tickets for $9/each (no 3D) for most films. That’s perfectly fair. A small bottle of water is $6. A small popcorn is like $10. So the total cost is about $25 but most of that is hidden in two cheap/basic snacks. How about just charging me the real price for the ticket and fair snack prices? Charge $25 for a pack with a ticket and some snacks. A low upfront price and high snacks feels like bait-and-switch. But it works so they keep it up. And I feel ripped off every time I go because of the psychology of their pricing model.
- hrktb 9y agoIs there such a pressure to buy snacks ? 2h without eating doesn’t feel so difficult.
- Retric 9y agoBland movies don't actually rate all that highly in practice. Spiderman homecoming got a 92% from critics and 89% from fans because people got what they expected from the movie. The Hitman's Bodyguard on the other hand rated poorly 38%:71% because it failed to deliver. And really, general ratings need to be in the context of the kind of person that might like the movie.
- paganel 9y ago> A movie designed to do well on a RT score needs to please everyone. The end result is something that tries to be bland, uninteresting, and inoffensive. As an avid movie goer, that is a horrible result. I would much rather see a movie that takes risks and fails than something with little ambition outside turning a profit. I've just finished watching for the second time a non-bland and pretty-offensive (at least for today's sensibilities) 1997 comedy starring Jamie Foxx and Vivica Fox, among others. It's called "Booty Call". It has a 5.3 rating on IMDB (which is comparatively speaking pretty low) and only 25% on RT (which I guess is even lower). It doesn't matter, because this movie has made me laugh so hard that I literally had tears in the corners of my eyes and my stomach-muscles were beginning to hurt because of all the laughing. And remember, this was the second time when I was watching it, but I was still laughing my a.s off. Now, I thought that maybe I'm the crazy one out, a stupid viewer who doesn't understand interesting and thought-provoking movies and who only laughs at "stupid" movies, but when I went to the movie's comment page on IMDB (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118750/reference http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0118750/reference) I saw that I was not alone in this, all the top comments were giving the movie a rating between 8 and 10 and the commenters were mentioning how hard they had laughed while watching it. The conclusion is that there is something definitely wrong with the way some movies are rated. I'm not sure if there exists a fix for that, apart from us, the "normal" viewers, just starting to ignore reviews and movie-critics and then watching movies with no preconceptions.
- Sangermaine 9y ago>A movie designed to do well on a RT score needs to please everyone. The end result is something that tries to be bland, uninteresting, and inoffensive. This is demonstrably untrue. Here is a link (along the left column) of the top RT movies for each year from 2014-2016: https://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/ https://www.rottentomatoes.com/top/ Sure there are some blockbusters, but there are also many excellent, interesting, engaging, even daring films like Moonlight, Hell or Highwater, Manchester by the Sea, Brooklyn, Mad Max: Fury Road, It Follows, Boyhood, Nightcrawler, and Birdman. And those are just among the top 10 scores for each year; if you expanded to movies in the 90% range of each year you'd have a large number of excellent choices. I couldn't find a list of the top-rated RT movies for 2017, but (I think) currently the highest-rated among them is Get Out, a film specifically made to be the precise opposite of "bland, uninteresting, and inoffensive". I submit that you simply choose to watch bad movies.
- jacalata 9y agoNo, they need to please everyone who chooses to see it which means they need to be categorisable before viewing so people can knowledgeably choose not to see it.
- TYPE_FASTER 9y ago> The end result is something that tries to be bland, uninteresting, and inoffensive. "Happiness" is none of those things, and scored 85 on RT. > It is safer to invest in the next mediocre superhero movie that most people will be fine with than an innovative middle budget drama that might have a harder time finding an audience. That is what is hurting the movie industry. That, I completely agree with.
- amyjess 9y ago> It is safer to invest in the next mediocre superhero movie that most people will be fine with than an innovative middle budget drama that might have a harder time finding an audience. That is what is hurting the movie industry. The "innovative middle budget drama[s]" are moving to television. The rise of high-quality programming on cable TV has a lot to do with the state the film industry is currently in. I find it fascinating that ever since television launched, film has gone out of its way to be different from TV, but the specific way it does that constantly changes. Back in the '70s, it was the opposite from where it is today!
- Yen 9y agoA 100% rating doesn't mean no one would think the movie is bad - it means no one who saw the movie thought it was bad. With the exception of critics, most people watch movies that they expect they will enjoy. If that movie meets or exceeds expectations, it'll be fresh. Through this perspective, the way to get a 100% Rotten Tomatoes rating isn't to make a bland, lowest-common-denominator film, attempting to appeal a little bit to everyone. Rather, it's to make a film that a small niche of people will be enthralled by, and market the film in such a way to attract that audience, and no other audience. --- Conversely, when a movie is rotten, it didn't merely fail the average viewer, it failed for the people who were excited to see exactly that movie.
- tarsinge 9y ago> The end result is something that tries to be bland, uninteresting, and inoffensive. So much this. Also conversely I don't understand how the tyranny of the average issue for polarising movies is not brought up more. Many movies I like aren't obviously appreciated by everyone (too gritty, too awkward, too dumb, too sci-fi...) and end up in the 40-70% range which tells me nothing.