8 ms·
How come when it comes to the environment/global warming, the predominant approach is "we believe in science", but when it comes to organic foods, GMOs, and vac
by exabrial 9y ago
How come when it comes to the environment/global warming, the predominant approach is "we believe in science", but when it comes to organic foods, GMOs, and vaccines the "science is questionable"?
- microcolonel 9y agoThe answer is: they don't care about science in either situation, and to think otherwise is probably to kid yourself. That said, there's basically no mechanism by which GMOs would be dangerous to human health if the final product does not contain anything unexpected under test. None of the topics you listed have equivalent conclusive evidence to eachother. For example, the evidence to support the safety of contemporary versions of common vaccines is overwhelming; but when it comes to "organic foods", it depends entirely on the exact specifics of any individual product, from the shape and surface area of the plant, washing practices, specific tendency to absorb or repel specific chemicals (naturally or artificially present) which may not have even been applied to the land for decades (for example, arsenic-based pesticides from old cotton crops leeching into rice crops), the qualities of the soil. Science isn't a belief, it's a method, and not all conclusions are equally conclusive.
- jerf 9y ago"That said, there's basically no mechanism by which GMOs would be dangerous to human health if the final product does not contain anything unexpected under test." There's a handful of times where my opinion on something has been flipped by a single argument that fits into a single paragraph or even sentence, and my opinion on GMOs is one of them. Nassim Taleb argues that while any given GMO product may be in fact entirely safe, that as you consider the whole line of GMOs that will be created over the next decades at an accelerating pace, the odds that at least one of them turn out to be catastrophically bad enough to entirely erase the benefits of everything else done with them goes up quite distressingly. This makes sense of the idea that A: all current GMO foods are actually quite safe but B: it may still be a bad idea in the long run. Given that things will be GMO'd on an increasing curve as it becomes easier and easier, we've seen only a very small fraction of what will ultimately be done with the technology.
- Kalium 9y agoGiven that humans created a poisonous potato before genetic modification, it should perhaps be considered that our society seems to have already accepted this risk.
- jerf 9y ago"The resulting GMO'd food is obviously poisonous" isn't one of the scary outcomes, though. There's nothing remotely scary about that.
- Kalium 9y agoTraditional agriculture has also produced a number of things that are non-obviously poisonous that have slowly killed lots of people over time. HFCS, tobacco, etc. I think the key takeaway is that these aren't new or different risks. You could say the same thing about iPhone apps, pharmaceuticals, or traditionally bred plants: as you consider the whole lines of $ITEMS that will be created over the next decades at an accelerating pace, the odds that at least one of them turn out to be catastrophically bad enough to entirely erase the benefits of everything else done with them goes up quite distressingly. Thalidomide happened. But it doesn't justify abandoning pharmaceuticals entirely. There just might be some wisdom in that.
- spaceseaman 9y agoWhy are you assuming the same person is making both claims?
- brailsafe 9y agoThe vast majority of people I meet who are heavy proponents of organic food and heavy opponents of GMOs don't even go this far. It troubles me how much money is thrown in the trash over this assumption. Interestingly, I also find that these people aren't talking about climate change. However, I suspect that experiences may vary because the GMO/organic people in my life are vegans.
- alangpierce 9y agoInterestingly, parmesan cheese is traditionally made using rennet from the stomach lining of calves, so it's not vegetarian, but thanks to GMOs, most parmesan cheese in the US is vegetarian-friendly since the rennet can be produced in a lab without killing calves [1]. There are also plenty of startups using genetic engineering to make vegan/vegetarian alternative meats. So while there's certainly a lot of overlap between vegans and anti-GMO people, it seems like it's probably counterproductive to dismiss GMOs entirely if you actually care about animal welfare. [1]: https://io9.gizmodo.com/you-can-thank-genetic-engineering-for-your-delicious-ch-1701156684 https://io9.gizmodo.com/you-can-thank-genetic-engineering-fo...
- wallace_f 9y ago>there's certainly a lot of overlap between vegans and anti-GMO people Yea, these are good points. Just to be precise, rennet was needed in basically all cheese making with just few exceptions, it was not just parmesan.
- BenjiWiebe 9y agoCorrect, we make cheddar and Colby cheese and both need rennet. I can't think of any hard cheese that doesn't need rennet, in fact. Also, the rennet we use is bacterially produced, no calves were killed to make it.
- wallace_f 9y agoInterestingly, most cheeses that don't use rennet are soft, but some of the hardest of all cheeses are the Mongolian cheeses Bayaslag and aaruul. Both are rock hard, but use acid to coagulate the proteins instead of rennet. They are often consumed after soaking in tea, or are sucked on, not chewed. Their shelf life is apparently over years long. Just found that earlier today after doing some research inspired by this thread.
- vvanders 9y agoThe majority of anti-GMO people I know don't debate the science, they generally want to ban them for two reasons: 1. Overuse of pesticides leads to tolerance which leads to an escalation which is some of what you see in this article. 2. One or two large corporations controling the vast majority of food production for the US. Gains in farming are awesome, but they shouldn't be at the expense of autonomy of the farmers who bring us the food.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoGenetic modifications are useful for more than pesticide resistance. We could have better, riper tomatoes in stores if the Flavr Savr hadn't been attacked by alarmists. Instead we get ethylene treated junk.
- dxhdr 9y agoFrom Wikipedia: "The Flavr Savr turned out to disappoint researchers ... as the antisensed PG gene had a positive effect on shelf life, but not on the fruit's firmness, so the tomatoes still had to be harvested like any other unmodified vine-ripe tomatoes. An improved flavor, later achieved through traditional breeding of Flavr Savr and better tasting varieties, would also contribute to selling Flavr Savr at a premium price at the supermarket. ... The failure of the Flavr Savr has been attributed to Calgene's inexperience in the business of growing and shipping tomatoes." Sounds like Flavr Savrs were just a failure. I don't see anything about alarmists.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoIt's been 20+ years. Any flaws could have been worked out by now.
- KGIII 9y agoI prefer this example: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_rice https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_rice The controversy section is very telling. While not directly quoted in the article, I've seen/heard people argue, "It hasn't been proven safe!" Well, yeah? Of course it hasn't. Nothing is ever proven safe, really. It'd be much easier to demonstrate the benefits if, you know, they actually let trials go forward. Some trials have been started, but people keep protesting and doing stuff like burning the fields.
- diogenescynic 9y agoBecause the science is usually funded by Monsanto. And they hire paid shills to keyword search the internet and argue nonstop about it, so their deliberate and aggressive propaganda has made me much more suspicious to whatever they are trying to sell, rightly or wrongly. And... it seems like more and more often we're seeing studies that show some of the main components of their products are harmful or not anymore effective than traditional methods. https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/03/14/business/monsanto-roundup-safety-lawsuit.html https://mobile.nytimes.com/2017/03/14/business/monsanto-roun... https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/glyphosate-cancer-data/ https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/glyphosa... https://www.commondreams.org/news/2016/05/18/gmos-safe-eat-says-research-group-takes-millions-monsanto https://www.commondreams.org/news/2016/05/18/gmos-safe-eat-s...
- 2bitencryption 9y agoI never have believed the whole "internet shills" thing on any side of any argument, and I would need some hard, hard evidence to change my mind.
- mmariani 9y agoThere you go https://theintercept.com/2014/02/24/jtrig-manipulation/ https://theintercept.com/2014/02/24/jtrig-manipulation/
- jerf 9y agoInternet shills definitely exist. On the other hand, I've been accused of it three or four times, and, no, nobody's ever paid me for posting things on the internet. So it's also definitely an accusation flung around in cases where it is not justified.
- zolthrowaway 9y agoThat's exactly what an internet shill would want you to think ;)
- matt4077 9y agoI'm one of those people you're trying to strawman. I don't disagree with the science as it regards the safety of GMO crops. I'm sure that I could eat concentrated amounts of whatever protein the added/modified DNA codes for without ever noticing. I, and many other people, are lightly uneasy about the general trend of over-engineering our food supply. The trend points at fewer and fewer varieties of each species being farmed. That results in monocultures and all the inherent risks, such as susceptibility to pests etc. Both selective breeding as well as gene editing also optimise for only those traits with immediate commercial reward: The one or two varieties of Apples you'd end up will be huge, extremely colourful, and have 18 month shelf life. Already we've seen that the market doesn't usually care about taste, and there's a recent paper showing a widespread loss in nutritional value over the last decades. In regards to nutrition, it has been shown again and again that there's more to it that the day's science has firmly established. The discovery of the major categories (protein/fat/carbohydrates) was immediately used to optimise diets in, for example, the newly industrialised cities, or the military. The result was a widespread decline in health among these populations, with fun new pathologies such as beriberi or scurvy. Those mistakes were corrected with the discovery of Vitamins (beriberi: B1 deficiency, scurvy: C deficiency), and, once again, science thought it knew enough to reduce nutrition to its parts, and create healthy foods from scratch. Only they continue to fail, because the are myriads of molecules working in a complex network with gut bacteria etc that all have effects on your health. And the only winning strategy has always been: variety. Note that none of this is really controversial within nutritional science today. But what scientists say is good for you is not always the same as other scientists' new crops. One is human physiology, the other is crop science. I'm also hesitant to embrace such technology because it turns an industry traditionally organised around small, family-owned businesses into the purvey of three or four incredibly large multinationals and their patent portfolio. And while I think today's democracies have established a working regulatory regime for these behemoth, there are just to many stories about rather shady conduct by such companies in countries with weak governments and institutions. I also question the need for further increases in ag yields. Much of the discussion is infused by the fear of exponential population growth that was all the rage in the 80s (Club of Rome etc.), but we're actually seeing a gradual flattening of growth, and aren't too far of from "peak humanity". Hunger is no longer the #1 problem of humanity, and where it still exists, it is caused not by a lack of production, but by organisational deficiencies (see North Korea vs South Korea, or Venezuela today vs Venezuela 1995).
- ajmurmann 9y agoI'm not sure it's safe to assume that it's all the same people. I for one believe we need to strongly act on climate change. I also believed that GMOs can be a great blessing. However, I also believe that Monsanto has awful business practices and they are giving GMOs a terrible name.
- zeofig 9y agoBecause the science is questionable, in the case of GMOs. There really are highly unknowable dangers inherent in GMOs and generally in non-organic food production. For instance, they MIGHT be inherently dangerous on both a health and economic level because: 1. Inducing rapid genetic change (i.e. making GMOs) could alter the nutritional profile of foods in ways that are difficult to test. 2. Similarly, it could reduce the ability of the plants to fight diseases. 3. Combined with 2., producing crops with less and less biodiversity could very conceivably lead to massive crop death due to disease. This is very much a "black swan" scenario and just because it hasn't happened (much) already, doesn't mean it won't. In fact, you need only to look at bananas to see this in action. 4. The benefits of GMOs often require externalities to realise i.e. fertalisers, pesticides, mechanised agriculture. 5. Largely related to 4., the true (mid to long term) economic benefits of GMOs are hard to quantify. In my opinion, this comes down to the production process fundamentally requiring a bunch of energy and oil-derived products to work. These costs are massively subsidised and are largely hidden and unknown. There are some articles that address these issues. I've read some of them. All the articles I've read, like many scientific articles (outside the likes of maths/physics/chemistry etc.), were unconvincing because they had insufficient data and failed to account for obvious confounding factors in any way. It is also entirely obvious at this point that scientific articles are frequently produced with data that has been heavily manipulated or even fabricated. I use the term "scientific" here to refer to the style and place of publication, rather than any abstract principle of quality.