15 ms·
MongoDB has filed to go public
- nl 9y agoThis refers to publicly listing on the stock exchange, as opposed to last time Mongo DBs went public: https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2017/01/11/thousands-of-mongodb-databases-compromised-and-held-to-ransom/ https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2017/01/11/thousands-of-mon...
- jlgaddis 9y agoWasn't that a third-party going public about MongoDB, though? I don't think that counts.
- nl 9y agoAt the time MongoDB shipped with all databases completely public, with no authentication credentials. That meant anyone could connect over HTTP and get your data. From the article: The problem for MongoDB users seems to be that on some systems the default configuration has the database listening on a publicly accessible port as soon as it’s installed. Users are supposed to read the manual and set up access control and authentication after installing the software but it seems that plenty of them don’t. I think that counts.
- jlgaddis 9y agoYeah, I recall. Certainly that was a major screw up but, IMO, the users share part of the blame -- if they had a firewall in place this wouldn't have been an issue.
- nl 9y agoIMO, the users share part of the blame -- if they had a firewall in place this wouldn't have been an issue. Yes of course, users are always responsible. That doesn't mean shipping a product with zero default security was a sensible thing either. I'd note that other database vendors don't do this.
- smt88 9y agoUsers are (almost) always at fault when a car crashes. Should cars not ship with seatbelts or airbags? User error is a guarantee, and great software minimizes the paths to an error and also eliminates classes of error that are easy to eliminate.
- SilasX 9y agoMongo shares the blame for making it the default and making authentication such a pain to deal with: - Command line login never works, you have to get into Mongo shell, then authenticate. - Attaching multiple db permissions to one user has all kinds of gotchas to: I have to switch to each database and re-auth instead of just authing to the user and then switching DBs without further auth. None of it works intuitively.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- johnvonneumann 9y agoHad a good laugh at this.
- nl 9y agoThanks.... I know jokes on HN are risky, but this was both kinda funny and somewhat accurate.
- pulam 9y agoWhat we're all here for: 2015 revenue: $41mm net loss: $77mm 2016 revenue: $65mm net loss: $73mm 2017 revenue: $101mm net loss: $87mm
- beamatronic 9y agoWhat are the chances of that revenue doubling any time soon?
- brianwawok 9y agoI don't see enough suites willing to pay for a 3rd tier database anytime soon.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- koolba 9y agoHow the hell does this company spend $188M a year?! Seriously I'm flabbergasted.
- kilroy123 9y agoSales and marketing?
- camus2 9y agoThey launched Atlas, a cloud service. It sure ain't cheap to operate.
- meritt 9y agoLast year (through Jan '17) spent (very simplified): $29.9M on Cost of Revenue (hosting fees + the people who run things + support/consultants) $78.6M on Sales & Marketing (sales people) $51.7M on Research & Development (programmers) $27.1M on General & Administrative (managers/executives/HR) This was spread across ~820 (as of July) employees. Hosting + Rent + Employees = $188M. Basically they spend $229k per employee which works out to very roughly: ~43% Tech, ~42% Sales, ~15% Management By comparison, Cloudera is quite similar: 42% on Tech, 45% on Sales, 13% on Management. They made $261M last year and spent $448M, losing -$187M across 1,470 employees ($305k per employee)
- djrobstep 9y agoObligatory reminder that Mongo is shit and you should never use it for data you care about.
- redwood 9y agoLet's try to keep the discussion out of the gutter, please.
- meowface 9y agoReliability-wise, it sucks. Maybe it's gotten better recently, but I still probably wouldn't trust it. But is there a document store out there that's faster than MongoDB?
- Operyl 9y agoI was a big fan of a RethinkDB, but growth has stagnated since the parent company shut down. It’s technically a Linux Foundation project now.
- judah 9y agoI'm biased (I work part-time for the company), but RavenDB[0] 4.0 is damn fast, cross platform, and has beautiful tooling. It's built on .NET Core, and our current performance is 140k writes/sec. We also bend over backwards to optimize read speeds: we generated indexes automatically based on your query patterns, discarding unused indexes and throwing server resources behind the hot ones. Also, unlike many other NoSQL databases, we support transactions and atomic writes. [0]: https://ravendb.net https://ravendb.net
- tehlike 9y agoShameless promotion: the guy running the company is pretty solid, too.
- strayamaaate 9y agoWe use ArangoDB currently and are pretty happy with it. Installs and upgrades could be better though. Very curious about RavenDB as I’m writing a lot of .NET Core these days. How would you say it stacks up against ArangoDB? Edit: Ok, just saw the pricing. Ouch.
- opendomain 9y agoThere seems to be some high level execs that just left. I wonder why they left before the IPO - maybe their options were forced to expire? Matt Kroll was their head of sales and he just went to google - how is Mongo going to grow without a good sales team?
- Titan799 9y agoHi Ric Johnson. This post is extremely inaccurate and false. Please remove it. Thank you. Matt Kroll
- fyrerise 9y agoCan you clarify what you mean by this? You're Matt Kroll and you're confirming that you still work for MongoDB? (I'm afraid that nothing is obvious from anyone's usernames.)
- meritt 9y agoJust do a bit of digging. Both names dropped appear to be accurate from usernames/profiles. Matt did indeed leave MongoDB for Google, that much is accurate.
- Titan799 9y agoYes, and that is the only part that is accurate. If you look at my LinkedIn profile, you will see that I was NEVER Head of Sales at MongoDB.
- gamad 9y agoI like MongoDB! It's web-scale: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2F-DItXtZs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2F-DItXtZs
- VirtualAirwaves 9y agoThis is a great video, and accurately sums up MongoDB and NoSQL. I can't imagine why they need to raise money, why they spend so much money as it is, and why they think there's a big growth business in NoSQL.
- SilasX 9y agoI miss XtraNormal, the videos have a special deadpan quality to them.
- jinqueeny 9y agoHaha, I have watched this video for 10+ times! It's hilarious. Couldn't help it...
- dguo 9y agoI'm asking this in good faith. What are the best use cases nowadays for Mongo? I've read that it still makes sense when you are dealing with truly self-contained documents. But even then, what is the advantage over just using Postgres or MySQL and their native JSON types? I've read plenty of negative comments on Mongo. I'd like to hear the other side of the story, if possible.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jacquesc 9y agoI've been using and relying on MongoDB for years (since 2010). It's pleasant to develop for, the query interface is awesome, and the library / ORM support is top notch (Mongoid on ruby, and Mongoose on node). I also use Postgres regularly so I can compare the 2. And in my experience, I always enjoy working with Mongo more. Many people don't care about the developer experience and rather focus on Mongo's lack of features like joins and transactions. There's definitely tradeoffs to choosing Mongo and I wouldn't criticize anyone for picking Postgres over Mongo, however the amount of belly-aching about how Mongo is "the worst" was always pretty ridiculous.
- mrgordon 9y agoIf you’ve been using it since 2010, then your usage predates the aggregation framework. I’ll just state for the record that writing a JavaScript mapreduce (or telling a data scientist to write one) to count records is not a good experience. The other issue that got me was I was running queries that should have used an index but indexOnly kept coming back false. I dig into the Mongo JIRA and sure enough it was a bug and queries were returning incorrect values for whether they were using an index. The reason most people got mad at Mongo was probably their benchmark gaming though. They made unsafe writes the default for a long time so their default configuration benchmark would blow away SQL databases which fsync to disk by default (very reasonably!)
- franciscop 9y agoI have been using Mongoose for long enough (since 2012?) to have felt its pain point. The documentation is lacking (mainly of examples), contradictory and there are way too many breaking changes. This makes searching quite ineffective since you'll have to check every single piece of code you see in-depth to make sure it still works.
- virmundi 9y agoI don't get it. I don't get it. I don't get it. 1) Mongo is not better than Postgresql JSONB and other Postgresql features, especially in 10. 2) There was NEVER a Mongo cluster management tool named Sheriff Bart! It litterally sells itself: Mongo Loves Sheriff Bart. 3) ArangoDB is able to provide many of the Mongo features with some ACID compliance and a better graph solution. It even has joins. I get that people use documents to avoid joins, but really. You still want them.
- redwood 9y agoThis is like saying "The iPhone is not better than Android". There is room for multiple offerings with different strengths and paths to market appealing to different types of users.
- virmundi 9y agoI upvoted you. You raise a good example. To the same simile, if you care about use, freedom and reasonableness, you'd pick Android. So too anything other than Mongo. That's what I don't get, why would anyone want to invest in Mongo? I say that as a Mongo certified develop (best way to learn at the time).
- redwood 9y agoSpeculating, amongst the "Android" options there are four categories: - There are the expensive legacy relational solutions (these are on a long slow death). - There are small open source and sometimes even closed source projects that are either going to be dead or gobbled up; or at least far too many people will fear they will which will prevent adoption. - There are cloud-native lock-in solutions. - There are well-established large community open source projects that stay alive because there's enough stakeholders but they don't have strong commercial backers. All of these categories are a surprisingly interesting market opportunity for a disruptive commercially backed more vertically integrated open source player to target.
- arrty88 9y agoMongo is quick and dirty. If you're writing NodeJS, chances are you don't care about `what's best`.
- coolspot 9y agoCan't wait till vim do IPO. Also emacs, grep and apt-get (appstore!!!) are so hot for IPO. ...or ICO.
- nathancahill 9y agoFiled, but no guarantees it will be underwritten (to disk).
- jacobkg 9y agoMade me laugh =)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aerialcombat 9y agoI would rather want to see Redis go public
- smt88 9y agoI don't want to see any of my favorite software go public. It creates incentives that don't do me any good, like marketing instead of improving the product.
- mazatta 9y agoNow they can lose your money, along with your data!
- biocomputation 9y agoThis made me laugh!
- odc 9y agoFYI, MongoDB now passes the Jespen test suite. It's just as safe as Postgres, while much easier to use.
- tejasmanohar 9y agoFor all the people asking "why don't people just use DynamoDB, BigTable, etc. if they need NoSQL", there are a few incorrect assumptions here-- 1) People need NoSQL. This is rarely the case. That said, Mongo often lets you model structures how you think so it's nice for prototyping. I'm very comfortable with SQL so I wouldn't do this anymore, but I could see value in it once upon a time, especially if you're already using JS across the stack. 2) DynamoDB is not the same at all. Its query and sharding models are entirely different. In most cases, it does NOT allow you to model something usable how you think. Don't get me wrong-- it's a great technology, and we get a lot of value out of it at work, but if you're directly comparing the two, you probably haven't actually used it enough.
- gaius 9y agoMongo is the boo.com of the database industry
- DevinTheDude 9y agoNever heard of the website. Care to explain what you mean?
- gaius 9y agoThe poster child for hype over substance. Those who forget history are doomed to repeat it...
- thisisit 9y agoFor what it's worth, they are at least not trying to sell non-voting shares like Snapchat (a company with much bigger losses). The offering is for Class A shares with 1 vote per share. Though the voting rights between Class A and Class B is still not clear: "Outstanding shares of Class B common stock will represent approximately % of the voting power of our outstanding capital stock immediately following the closing of this offering, with our directors and executive officers and their affiliates holding approximately %, assuming in each case no exercise of the underwriters' over-allotment option."
- octix 9y agoFrom personal experience. 1) MongoDB allows me to be more agile. I don't have to deal with database migrations (No locks when adding new column for example), which allows deployments at any time. 2) Indexed arrays. Allows to add "tags" to any entity which are useful in production (A/B testing, force specific behavior). 3) Easier to manage. I don't need an expensive PostgreSQL consultant to setup and hope for the best. Your mileage can vary.
- drodgers 9y ago> I don't have to deal with database migrations We've actually just started having the pain of Mongo migrations; adding indexes to large collections. If you just create the index on the primary and let it propagate throughout the cluster, then it will block further oplog replication on the secondaries and the whole cluster will go down for majority writes. The proper way is to take each secondary out of the cluster in turn, add the index, then step-down the primary and migrate it. It's just as much of a pain as migrating your favourite SQL database, although at least you don't need to do it for small collections and for adding columns (which is a big bonus).
- octix 9y agoThanks for sharing. "adding indexes to large collections" - how many records are we talking here? Thanks.
- drodgers 9y agoCollections with tens of Gigabytes and hundreds of millions of records can take a few hours per-node to build an index. You'll need to think about index migration strategies before that point though. I'd guess that once you have gigabytes of data in a collection you'll probably have less downtime with an election than you will waiting for the index to build.
- kureikain 9y agoIf it's truely zero downtime if you are doing background indexing.
- bertolo1988 9y agoThe MongoDB Atlas service is really good. You guys should try it.
- _Codemonkeyism 9y agoSill love {field:{$exists:true}}} vs {$set:{field:value}} have to google every time.
- mxschumacher 9y agonice short target
- terrabytes 9y agoMongoDB has is a pretty good example of building a business around open source software.
- smt88 9y agoNot based on how much money they're losing. It's not a viable business yet, and it probably never will be.
- DevinTheDude 9y agoHow can you say it's not a viable business because they're losing money if you don't know their expenses? Uber & Lyft, (and for many years Amazon) were/are losing money. So that means nothing unless you know why they're blowing through cash.
- smt88 9y agoTop post of this thread has their net loss: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15308202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15308202 They also had to report some more detailed financials when they filed to go public: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/21/mongodb-ipo-seeks-to-raise-100-million.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/21/mongodb-ipo-seeks-to-raise-1...
- swyx 9y agolol they literally just made their full financials public
- dustingetz 9y agoi think 50% of comments in this thread are Mongo's PR team trying to head off criticism with fud!
- kureikain 9y agoI have great succesful with MongoDB and at this point, I think it's the best database out there. If you can live without transaction, then think about utilizing MongoDB. - Add index without blocking anything - Array index is transaprent from you. Same query for both of array or a single field. - Partial index allow you to query on index while keep index size small to a certain amount of document - TTL index help you avoid deleting document manually such as session data - Spatial index avoid you to not index document missing field - GEO spatial index is just awesome. Super easy to use - Good enough full text search - Data compression, out of the box - Data compression for replication as wel - Super easy to manage cluster: add, remove, hide node