4 ms·
I remember reading an article that dug into claims that France took better care of their poor than America. This was true in some areas but overall the quality
by dmix 9y ago
I remember reading an article that dug into claims that France took better care of their poor than America. This was true in some areas but overall the quality of life of the American poor was still better in many ways because they had a far wider selection of services and products at far cheaper prices. So although primary services like day care were less subsidized they were able to do much more with the little money they had.
It's easy to gloss over the realities of peoples day-to-day life when comparing countries with different economies and social structures by only looking at high level statistics or only at the more highly visible government services.
- dx034 9y agoWhat wide selection of services can the poor in the US access? My impression is that many services benefit the rich. Once you have a minimum amount of wealth, products become cheaper. Financial products are a prime example for that.
- adventured 9y agoThe poor in the US have a large entitlement structure, including free healthcare, and countless state / local / federal programs around food security and housing. The top 1/3 in the US pay nearly all income taxes, for example. The bottom 1/2 in the US pay almost no income taxes (the bottom 1/3 have a large negative income tax level), while deriving substantial tax payer benefits. The US has an extremely progressive taxation system.
- wil421 9y agoJust to add there are many non-profit and religious based support networks. Including things like “soup kitchens”, food drives, and shelters that are not government run.
- dmix 9y agoOthers answered re: the service part but I should note I'm not talking only about services but also products such as food, clothing, cars, entertainment, etc. Quality of life is a broad term.
- rs999gti 9y ago> What wide selection of services can the poor in the US access? Medicaid, Food Stamps, SNAP, Disability, Unemployment Benefits, Free Healthcare at any Emergency Room hospital that accepts Medicare, Food Staples (Cheese, Peanut Butter, etc), free phones, free defense lawyer, etc.
- athenot 9y agoComparing the level of care between Medicaid and the basic Sécurité Sociale benefits leads me to question this assertion. Same for public transit, the lack thereof in most of America severly handicaps the poor who do not have a car. Education too: the poor have the opportunity to put their kids through college or even med school. Yes there are higher failure rates among the poor, but 75% of the poor still graduate HS and if they make it past that, they've cleared the hardest hurdle (fewer dropouts among poor in college than MS/HS). http://www.education.gouv.fr/cid5008/les-trajectoires-scolaires-des-enfants-pauvres.html http://www.education.gouv.fr/cid5008/les-trajectoires-scolai...
- dmix 9y agoThis is pretty much the type of analysis I was critiquing. You simply can't measure the quality of life of poor simply via a few highly visible public institutions... or something like GDP per capita. This is isn't about who has better public institutions (which plays a part) but the fact economics and quality of life are complex, deep subjects, and debates about who 'takes care of their poor' are so often reductive and narrowly focused.