3 ms·
> original code is barely recognizable Will the original authors still have copyright over it? If yes: Then clearly in the mind of the law the original work i
by belorn 9y ago
> original code is barely recognizable
Will the original authors still have copyright over it?
If yes: Then clearly in the mind of the law the original work is still present.
If no: Then the license choice of the original authors is not longer relevant.
- amelius 9y agoLet me rephrase: users could use the software only to gain free access to the patents. Thus this license is like giving away access to the patents.
- jashkenas 9y agoThe intent is to provide users of the software with full confidence that by using the software, they will not be held liable for infringing on the patents that the authors of and contributors to the software might hold on the software. Other licenses, like Apache, include patent grant withdrawal clauses, where you can lose the right to use the patent if you initiate a lawsuit. The notorious Facebook BSD+PATENTS license includes a similar withdrawal of patent grant, but for any Facebook patent, not just something related to the software in question, and also only if you sue Facebook or a subsidiary — the Apache withdrawal applies to "any entity". Here, there are no withdrawal provisions, hopefully giving you that full confidence as a user. As an author, if you have a patent on something, and then you release an open source project under LIL that uses that patent, you give up the right to sue anyone for infringing on your patent by using your open source project, period. I think that's more in the spirit of open source.
- carussell 9y ago> The notorious Facebook BSD+PATENTS license includes a similar withdrawal of patent grant [...] only if you sue Facebook or a subsidiary This is not true. The Facebook PATENTS grant terminates if a patent assertion relating to the software is made against against "any party".
- DiThi 9y agoI think the question is: What if the author has patents A, B and C, but the original code only uses A and B, and you modify it to use patent C as well? I guess it doesn't apply for derivative works unless the author incorporates the changes in the distribution of the code.