5 ms·
The bandwidth of a fully laden 747
- tome 16y agoIt's going to take a lot more time than 10 hours to get 427 PB onto those 2.8m cartridges, and then get the cartridges onto the 747.
- sfall 16y agoassuming you use DAT 320 tapes and use 3 Gb/sec, http://h10010.www1.hp.com/wwpc/us/en/sm/WF06a/12169-304612-3446234-3446234-3446234-63890.html http://h10010.www1.hp.com/wwpc/us/en/sm/WF06a/12169-304612-3... It would take about 55 min to load each tape and another 55 min to unload. Being there are 2.8 million tapes it would take 2,566,667 hours to load, and the same to unload. ((427 petabytes) / 5 million) / 60 = 1.49247317 gigabytes per sec
- shalmanese 16y agoExcept you can parralelize the workload significantly.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- shabble 16y agoA more thorough (and dare I say entertaining) version involving SD cards in a station wagon: http://dansdata.com/gz105.htm http://dansdata.com/gz105.htm
- narkee 16y agoIn South Africa, pigeons are "faster than broadband": http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8248056.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8248056.stm
- mansr 16y ago32GB microSD cards (the largest currently available) at ~0.5g each have a much higher data density.
- joe_the_user 16y agoJust to play devil's advocate. There's unit's miss-match here. The information transfer rate that would apply to physically moving a storage device would be bits per second per meter (information-unit/time-unit/distance-unit). Bandwidth is normally measured with bits and seconds, with no distance unit. The two aren't directly comparable. If you somehow you had a 20 Kbs rate to Pluto, it would be a comparable information/time/distance transfer to a fully laden 747.
- jerf 16y agoAll that means is you need to add a distance conversion factor in, and it all works fine, albeit tied to that distance. And, lo: "Now assume it flies from San Francisco to London in 10 hours." The two may not be directly comparable, but that's ok, because they weren't directly compared. Defining the bandwidth of that specific flight is perfectly reasonable and no "devil's advocate" is needed. (And if you want to point out that this isn't a practically useful number... well, yeah. But it's perfectly well-defined and unit-correct.)
- guelo 16y agoThe missing measurement is latency. The ping times of IP over 747 are dreadful.
- Dove 16y agoI was thinking the same thing. The bandwidth of the 747 isn't a constant. It depends on the distance between the endpoints. If I want to transfer data 30 feet from one system to another, pulling the hard drive, tossing it onto a 747 rolling by on the runway, tossing it back, and then reinstalling just blows away any LAN ever built.
- evgen 16y agoWhile shipping tapes fits the original metaphor (station wagon full of mag tape was what we were told to never underestimate back in the 80s) a more practical example would be to use 2T hard disks. You would lose out a bit on information density, but the drives could be slammed straight into a storage array without the transfer step that tape requires. A 2T disk is about 400cc of volume and 660g in weight. A 747-8 freighter has close to 690 m^3 of cargo space. Round that down to 680 and we could put 1.7 million disks into a 747-8 by volume. Unfortunately they would weigh more than one million kilos. By weight it could hold around 212,000 disk drives containing 424 PB. This gets you close to the same numbers that jgc came up with, but in a more useful format for attaching directly to a storage array.
- tomjen3 16y agoYou could do the same with SD cards, the card readers for that are very, very cheap and you could fit a lot more data into it.
- evgen 16y agoTrue, but I was trying to keep this in the realm of reality. A large org could actually shift this much data in a single day from step A (shutdown/pull drives) to Z (start using the new cluster on the other side of the world) using this method. Expecting someone to have a million or more SD card readers is not really a practical plan. I could have probably also increased the density by using blue-ray data disks, but having a similar number of optical drives waiting for disks was also not really practical. At one time this general process was how chunks of yahoomail migrated from our original Four11 colo on stanford campus to the yahoo colos in san jose and sunnyvale (except it was netapp drives and shelves packed into my miata instead of a 747 -- 1T of 18G drives with the top down doing 80-90 southbound on 101...fun times :)
- Vivtek 16y agoI upvoted this only because of its delightful title. I don't even need to read the article - the title alone has made my day brighter.
- jgrahamc 16y agoWell, I made someone smile. Did you ever read my article "Tonight, I'm going to write myself an Aston Martin"?
- rbanffy 16y agoWhat do you mean? An African or European 747?
- amalcon 16y agoIt would be more interesting to compare the cost along with the total bandwidth. It's very expensive to fuel a 747 for a trans-Atlantic flight, but the information density should be high enough to make the cost comparison interesting.
- bd 16y agoVery rough estimate based on passenger ticket prices gives about $20 per GB/s. SF <-> London is about $1,200 for return ticket (Kayak) 747 can have about 400 passengers bandwidth is 12 TB/s (from the post) 400*1200/2 = $240,000 cost of flight $240K / 12,000 GB/s = $20 per GB/s This should be an upper bound. I assume flying cargo (bought in bulk) would be significantly cheaper than flying people with individually bought tickets.
- amalcon 16y ago$20/GB/s for ten hours. If you want to compare to bandwidth prices, it has to be scaled up to a month: 24*30/10 = 72 flights/month $1440 per month per GB/s Like, you, I suspect it would be significantly cheaper than this, but that calculation would require data I don't have.
- bd 16y agoAh, yes. For the lower bound, we can estimate just the price of fuel (no plane amortization, crew and ground personnel costs, airport taxes, etc). This seems to be currently about $54K per flight (London to San Francisco). 747 burns about 5 gallons per mile LHR to SFO is 5,367 miles current jet fuel price is 201.1 cts/gallon 5367*5*2 = $53,670 So monthly price per GB/s should be somewhere between $322 - $1,440.
- sh1mmer 16y agoLast year Carlos (aristus) and I launched http://www.cloud-peering.com/ http://www.cloud-peering.com/ and spoke at a few conferences to highlight exactly this issue. Essentially the biggest interop problem in the cloud is the lack o backhaul sharing. It's the only thing we can't code our way out of.