8 ms·
GitHub Desktop 1.0
- alexmorenodev 9y agoLinux?
- 4lch3m1st 9y agoI'm astonished at the fact that this is made in Electron but no Linux version is planned whatsoever. There must be a serious blocking reason for that.
- noja 9y agoMaybe they thought nobody would use it.
- blocked_again 9y agoYeah. Built the entire business model on top of Git, a tool that Torvalds build to maintain Linux but won't release an app for Linux because they think nobody would use it.
- holydude 9y agoVCS existed before Torvalds. They must have a reason for not releasing a Linux version. I mean it's free what the heck do you want ? How can you even complain ? OSS really spoilt people.
- TremendousJudge 9y agoWhat he meant is probably 'nobody would use it because they are comfortable using git from the command line' (I know I am). Anyway, considering it shouldn't be hard to distribute in on Linux, I'm not sure why they didn't do it. Surely it's useful to someone?
- Exuma 9y agoI really like the old version better. I really dislike this "cross platform" crap that runs terrible. It's like using a javascript app. Not only that, they don't even have it for Linux, so what's the point of doing a cross platform interface...
- Karunamon 9y agoAnother blasted electron app. 32GB will be minimum system requirements for a developer at this rate.
- bobwaycott 9y ago> It’s like using a javascript app. It is a JavaScript app.
- danielbarla 9y agoIt's built with Electron, so it's not just like using a javascript app, you are actually using one. That said, I personally don't have a huge issue with Electron apps on face value - some of them (VSCode, for example) seem to outperform their native counterparts quite handily (in this case, VS - install time, upgrade time, cold start time, warm start time, actual usage). That tells me that the implementation choices affect performance as much as the underlying technology.
- Olreich 9y agoVSCode doesn't beat SublimeText, Vim, Emacs, or Notepad++. Electron apps might beat other electron apps (VSCode over Atom), but we're still a long sight off from electron apps beating compiled ones in most cases.
- praveenperera 9y agoLooks nice but I personally prefer the "classic" non-electron app. I'm glad they are still keeping it around.
- VeejayRampay 9y agoGood job to everyone involved. I understand that people don't like Electron apps, that Linux this or that, but it's still a lot of work to maintain this app and I know for a fact that it does help lower the barrier of entry for non-experienced, budding developers around the world, so keep it up.
- sandstrom 9y agoIt makes sense (they can share code between Github Desktop standalone and their Atom-plugin, which does more or less the same thing as Github Desktop). Electron has many benefits (lots of people know JS; CSS is better than the standard macOS tools for GUIs). But with Slack, Atom, Hyper and now Github Desktop running on Electron, the memory usage is getting painful. They all use several hundred MBs each, sometimes with multiple processes so even more in aggregate. Hopefully with more growth of Electron, there will be more shared resources to spend on improving its memory usage.
- pjmlp 9y agoWe were already sharing code between platforms before JavaScript was invented. This Electron craziness looks like milenials just woke up and never experimented how nice it was to use MSHTML and XUL applications. I have high hopes Electron will join them.
- jermaustin1 9y agoHTA anyone? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTML_Application https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTML_Application
- Macha 9y agoXUL applications were never that bad? At least Firefox, thunderbird and songbird, which are the three I'm aware of using. In the case of Firefox and thunderbird, I'd argue they were for a long time superior to their native competitors (FF2 for example easily bet the pants off IE6, Safari for Windows, Konqueror, was Epihany a thing then? though I will give Opera had a much more performance UI). As for Songbird, it had very low bars to beat WMP or iTunes/Windows or whatever media player your Linux distribution included that year. That said, I didn't use Macs during that period, so maybe they were awful on Mac or something. I assume Camino existed for a reason.
- eugenekolo2 9y agoOh, I always wanted to use 4gb of RAM to add files to Git.
- M4v3R 9y agoDid you actually tried it and did it use 4GB of RAM for you? I did and it used about 120 MB of RAM, which is not tiny, but not even in the ballpark of your figure. I know hating Electron apps is the new fad, but it would be nice to check the facts before you grab your fork.
- jrs95 9y agoHow long did you leave it running? In my experience electronic apps tend to leak memory for some reason. Atom starts up at a couple hundred megs, and actually does end up at around 4GB. Same with Slack, although it's gotten better. I used to actually have a launchd script that killed Slack and restarted it every 30 minutes to keep the memory usage down.
- M4v3R 9y agoI left it running when I first wrote the comment. Went back to it just now, after nearly two hours, and the memory usage didn't increase. Still at 120-130 MB. My guess is that compared to Slack, Github app doesn't really do much when idle. Slack fetches user statuses, new messages, notifications and so on. When you have an open channel with ongoing conversations that will add up in the RAM. This app doesn't seem to do anything when idle, so the RAM usage doesn't increase.
- jrs95 9y agoThat makes sense. I think with Atom the culprit is likely some poorly written plugins more than the editor itself, too.
- juandazapata 9y agoLeave it open for a couple of hours and you'll see those 4GB coming up quickly.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoLet me fix the marketing for you: GitHub desktop is designed for our non Linux users. We felt like you weren't comfortable with a command line so we targeted you. Minimum system requirements quad core CPU and 32GB of ram.
- BoorishBears 9y agoMaking Git more accessible to non-developers (or people not comfortable with a command line) isn't some horrible thing like you're making it out to be.
- reificator 9y agoI think they're more upset that it's on Electron.
- toxican 9y agoSerious question...what use is git to a non-developer? I don't think I've ever used it for anything but code. You're not supposed to use it with huge files, so that kind of eliminates the one case I was thinking of (graphic design versioning). Also if someone is a developer, they're only hurting themselves by not making an effort to get comfortable with the command line. Like half of my workflow wouldn't be possible without a familiarity with it.
- BoorishBears 9y agoGit-LFS lets you use it with large files, and even without Git-LFS you can still use it for smaller projects (it's not efficient at all, but for small teams and small projects you can do it). Github is making a play to be the "Git for Everyone people". Note they call out that the new client has image diffs (great for... graphic design versioning). They're forming a brand that could eventually compete with stuff like Perforce on a smaller scale with designers and artists if they can make them feel at home using "GitHub" (Git + creature comforts from GitHub). And to the developer point, everyone starts somewhere. As a kid Git didn't click until I started using visual clients. And "the command line" is a huge surface to get comfortable with.
- frozenport 9y agoFuture Electron apps will open a new tab in Chrome.
- blocked_again 9y agoBuilds the entire business model on top of git, a tool that Torvalds built to maintain Linux but don't give a fuck to Linux users.
- pjmlp 9y agoSorry, I don't see the value over TortoiseGIT,or any other native client.
- holydude 9y agoI'll add to the Electron hating bandwagon. Not every native app is good and often the UI and design feels crappy. I mean this was the case for decades. But I will still prefer crappy looking performant app over nice looking sluggish electron app. I really really would not want to use a "productivity" type of application that is made in Electron but I also know that many people do not mind. This said we are again in the era where it does not matter to most of the users. If it would people would stop using Atom/VScode and others. We all know that there is not a more cost effective way of building multiplatform apps (all things considered). We will have to cope with this as long as there is not real competition.
- siddhant 9y agoOn a related note - are there any frameworks you could use to write native-ish Mac apps without knowing Objective C or Swift?
- AlphaWeaver 9y agoAtom and VSCode are different beasts! The team at Microsoft has done some serious performance work on Code IIRC and it runs like native on my machine, compared to Atom which is still slow.
- devopsproject 9y ago
- willtim 9y agoThey've gone to all the trouble of building an app using web technologies, but don't offer a Linux version? I develop on Linux because I deploy on Linux. I don't need a virtual assistant or animated emojis. I would quite like a nice Git UI however.
- timlyo 9y agoI still think git-cola is one of my favourite Git Ui's. Anyone know any other good ones?
- ruskimalooski 9y agoGitKraken is the best GitUI I've ever used. I highly recommend it. I use it for personal projects and at work. Professional License is really reasonable.
- toxican 9y agoUgh, that pricing model though. $50/yr for something as 'simple' as a frontend for git when so many comparable alternatives exist for free.
- msoucy 9y agoWhile not perfect, it does help that it's free for non-commercial use
- ruskimalooski 9y agoI have yet to find a single Git Front end that allows drag and dropping of branches. Feel free to enlighten me.
- MaymayMaster 9y ago>Electron Dropped
- cvburgess 9y agoI prefer the old app - not because of electron, but because the UX is worse now (to me, at least). The old mac app made adding a repo super obvious (there was a plus button), branches had cleaner names, and the sync button looked like... a button. Now everything looks slick, but very unintuitive. I would love to see the ease of use increased considering that advanced users would probably favor the terminal anyway.
- favorited 9y agoAny Mac users (Windows coming soon, apparently?) wanting a native Git GUI client should check out Fork. I've been using it for a few months (switched from one of the various forks of GitX) and love it. It's not open source, but it is in a free beta. It's well designed, simple, and actually feels like a Mac app. git-fork.com
- fbnlsr 9y agoGitKraken is also nice. It's built using Electron so it's going to be hated here, but I've been using it for the past year on a somewhat considerable project and it held fine.
- awill 9y agoI wonder what the pricing is going to look like when it's stable. I generally don't like depending on tools when I don't know the future (like if they'll use a subscription model).
- favorited 9y agoHonestly, there's very little to depend on here. There's nothing this app does that you can't do in Terminal, and it would be easy to switch to another GUI tool. This one is just really nice.
- ruskimalooski 9y agoNot what I was hoping for. I use GitKraken for most of my daily Git stuff and the CLI when its needed. I was hoping GUI for more administrative purposes. It would be cool to get desktop notifications when issues are created, code is pushed, etc. I have yet to see a tool/extension that integrated with GitHub this deeply. It definitely seems like this could be useful for those who don't want to mess with the CLI (which is perfectly reasonable IMO).
- mythz 9y agoI decided to install this on a new OSX given I thought newer would be better but I hope this isn't representative of consolidation of a cross-platform Desktop App as it's measurably worse than both existing GitHub Desktop for Windows and OSX. I hope they don't discontinue their existing Windows and OSX Desktop Apps because this experiment is a value downgrade.
- icholy 9y agoAs a Linux user I feel pretty left out. I was looking forward to opening, closing it, and then going back to the terminal.
- realslimshanky 9y agoWhy is it not available for a Linux machine?
- bullfightonmars 9y agoHey guys thanks for the work on this, I've been really impressed with the interaction and performance on the new Github Desktop. I have been using the Github Desktop since Github for Mac was in early versions. It took a little getting used to, but the new version is much smoother and faster. Two additions I would love to see ported over from github.com * A toggle between inline and split diffs * A summary view with all changes on the current branch, not just per file changes
- uwu 9y agoam i using the same clients as everyone here or do people just like complaining about electron at every opportunity? the new client is actually much faster for me, it starts up faster (1.5s to show the gui fully loaded vs 4s to show the gui and another 3s to finish loading what's on the screen) and there's no lag when using it (unlike with the old client) i also prefer the new ui, i find it to be clearer than the old one
- PleaseHelpMe 9y agoFunny it is based on Electron and it doesnt support Linux. Maybe they think Linux developers only live in terminal, or they just hate it when someone criticises Electron consuming too much memory
- strayamaaate 9y agoI’m still using SourceTree, not happily, but everything else I’ve tried is utter shite. It either breaks on big repos, is horribly slow or just a usability train wreck. Has anyone found something that actually works?
- bhj 9y ago+1 for SourceTree, mostly for the per-line committing. Curious what about it makes you unhappy; it's always done what I've asked with minimum fuss.
- strayamaaate 9y agoI find it gets slower with each update - have you tried the latest with 6-8 active repos open? It spends most of its time refreshing, even with very few changes. I’ve also had some broken commits due to changes not being shown until I hit refresh. At least they’ve fixed the large diff lockup’s. And yes, the line and hunk staging is brilliant.
- Kpourdeilami 9y agoI have been using the beta version of Github's Electron app for a while and hadn't suspected it might not be a native app. It feels very snappy and quick. On my laptop, it uses less than 80MB of RAM
- zeugmasyllepsis 9y agoAround 80 MB of RAM with my project open in GitHub's Electron-based desktop app as well. For comparison, gitk is about 14 MB for the same project. Overall, GitHub's desktop app seems to have fairly stable memory use in my experience, though that stable mark seems relatively high compared to native counterparts. Not nearly as bad as some Electron apps, which seem to have no ceiling to their memory usage. Not a horrible price to pay, if you can accept the stable overhead.
- atonse 9y ago80 MB for the electron app? Sign me up. My preferred app (Tower) takes 150MB of memory. Update: I just installed it and while it does take 80 MB, there are two "Github Desktop Helper" processes that total another 100 MB.
- cygned 9y agoIt always configured my repos to use Git LFS - which is not installed because I don't use it. I hope it can be turned off now, I wasn't able to find that setting.
- mdeira 9y agoanother native - but paid - alternative not mentioned so far is Tower (https://www.git-tower.com https://www.git-tower.com). Both the Mac and Windows version are native apps.
- chasing 9y agoElectron, which means it's heavy and feels like a website rather than an app. But worse, the features just don't seem compelling enough to move away from their existing native app.
- uwu 9y ago> heavy and feels like a website rather than an app the electron app is noticeably faster than the old client for me (on windows) electron probably also means it'll be easier for them to add features in the future
- jorgemf 9y agoWhat does this add to something like the git integration in intellij idea? (Linux user here, I cannot test it)
- anotherevan 9y ago“Oh, we got both kinds. We got country and western.”