9 ms·
Central bank cryptocurrencies
- trowway21 9y agoLol. So back crypto $ with trillions of $ of debt going back to the Louisiana purchase; kept alive by a pyramid scheme dependant on a certain and limitless supply of debt free immigrants, after they continue to prove they don't require anything concrete to generate demand & subsequently value? Aka: how interested are people in a cryptocurrency worth market value minus 20 trillion $?
- throwanybble 9y agoYour sentiment about fiat is appreciated and understood, but it's inaccurate to claim that USD's total value is equivalent to the current national deficit.
- musgrove 9y agoHe's referring to the debt, not deficit. They aren't the same thing.
- throwanybble 9y agoStand corrected, thanks, meant the "national debt".
- cslarson 9y agoUS GDP is $18.5 trillion so yeah it has some debt but also some decent revenue. Yeah, I'd be interested.
- sova 9y agoYou know, if Tom owes Sally, and Sally owes Jes, and Jes owes Tom, it's really not clean and cut to say "all debt" or "all revenue" because it depends on which node is the focal point.
- neilwilson 9y agoThe banks are in debt to trillions of dollars to people who are 'in credit'. That's what 'in credit' means. It is the accounting term for a liability. Does that keep you awake at night too? For every asset there is a liability - even with cryptocurrencies. What you are missing with government 'debt' is that it creates safe private assets that keep the pension system going.
- beefield 9y ago> For every asset there is a liability - even with cryptocurrencies. I would think that bitcoin is no-ones liability? I mean, there are a bunch of bitcoins that you may or may not be able to sell someone with a price, but there is no-one who has any kind of legal or even moral obligation to give you anything in exchange of a bitcoin.
- option_greek 9y agoLiability will start once you start loaning them out to others and package the loans to other investors who them show them as assets to borrow something from someone else :).
- beefield 9y agoSure. But it is not the bitcoin that is the liability, it is the loan contract.
- SuoDuanDao 9y agoIf I understand your argument, you're saying that I'm a 'creditor' to my bank when I deposit money there that they are obliged to return on demand. Fair enough, but the reason I deal with banks is that it's cheaper than protecting my assets personally. Cryptocurrency is cheaper than dealing with the banks. So if I find a dollar on the beach and pick it up, what liability has been created by my having a new asset? Are you saying that the potential to find the dollar was some sort of collective asset that I've turned into a liability? That seems like an unnecessarily complicated way of looking at things. The only thing that can keep the pension system going is a growing population paying into it. Pensions are the ultimate pyramid scheme, the idea that bonds are a safe private asset... safe compared to what, and how safe on an absolute basis?
- notahacker 9y agoAlternate framing: let's back crypto with payment obligations tied to the economic output of the world's richest economy rather than backing it by optimism. Ultimately I'd have much more confidence in a cryptocurrency backed by enforceable [probably private IRL] debt obligations than one which wasn't.
- sandGorgon 9y agodoes anyone know how will banks and accounts work in such a system ? because funds will be held by individuals and not banks. will banks become the authoritative proof-of-stake entities ?
- sova 9y agoWould not proof-of-stake be an algorithmic calculation, available to anyone with the dataset (blockchain) and the computational power? Right now certain credit card companies charge a fee for calculation of a credit score (at that instant/ on the fly). Presumably in a cryptocoin economy everyone who has access to the dataset and knows the formula could tell you the proof-of-stake. Banks historically act as a time-throttler on transfer of funds, making sure the economy does not move without the inner cogs of the banks turning first. It is widespread now globally. With a cryptocoin economy, banks would not throttle time any longer and would instead help facilitate additions to the blockchain (via fee) as many exchanges currently do. What all factors does one need for proof-of-stake?
- cheaploans345 9y agoShekelCoin
- meri_dian 9y agoVery interesting. I'm intrigued by Fedcoin and how it incorporates the possibility of monetary policy into the cryptocurrency framework. The rigidity and hard ceiling on liquidity of Bitcoin is a major weakness of the currency (I know that Bitcoin enthusiasts see it as a strength) but if technology like Fedcoin can overcome that weakness I'm more bullish about cryptocurrency becoming part of the monetary scheme.
- EGreg 9y agoDeflationary currencies are hoarded, not spent in circulation. Even Aristophanes described it thousands of years ago. That's what advocates of "sound money" need to understand. Sound money is good, but for savings. On top of this you build other, less sound money, which circulates. This is also known as "Gresham's Law".
- meri_dian 9y agoAnd that is exactly what is playing out with Bitcoin becoming a speculative investment vehicle rather than a currency.
- mrb 9y agoResearch before talking. Bitcoins are being spent more than ever: the transaction rate keeps increasing and is roughly doubling every 18 months https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions?timespan=all&daysAverageString=7 https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions?timespan=all&d... Preemptive reply to those who think speculators cause the tx rate to increase (often an invalid comment thrown out in HN): no they don't. Speculators typically leave the coins in an exchange wallet (they are not sufficiently technically savvy or motivated to run their own wallet). Buying/selling on an exchange does NOT create a transaction on the blockchain.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- prostoalex 9y ago
- Findeton 9y agoPerhaps you should add https://fiatcoin.net https://fiatcoin.net to the list.
- imaginenore 9y agoI welcome it. It will make the flow of fiat into good cryptocurrencies so much easier. Let the better system win. Monopolies are almost never good.
- mark024 9y agoI'm my country twice until now, the government remained without money, and started printing like crazy, people's cash economies, were melted, or course people would say, that real estate, gold, stocks, but I'm not talking here about so much money, I'm talking about 6 months living expenses for example, bitcoin would have been a great use for this kind of savings, we don't have stocks here, gold is impossible to buy, and no safe to store, etc. If think about there isn't a lot of difference between gold and bitcoin, the main thing is immutability, gold industrial use is a myth.
- gtrubetskoy 9y ago"(preventing double-spending without the use of a trusted authority requires transaction validators (miners) to employ large amounts of computing power to complete "proof-of-work" computations); there is only probabilistic finality of settlement; and all transactions are public. These features are not suitable for many financial market applications." The words "only probabilistic finality" makes it sound uncertain, whereas in reality the uncertainty of a bitcoin transaction is insignificant compared to the uncertainty of a trusted entity, which they advocate. In other words, they still don't understand it.
- rmah 9y agoThey understand it just fine and you simply wrong. Proof of work validation IS probabilistic and central agency validation is not probabilistic. But it does require trust in that central agency. You may not trust that central agency, but that doesn't change the facts.
- runeks 9y agoUsing your definition, all cryptography is also probabilistic. It's technically correct, ie. there's a risk that someone guesses your AES key, but it's practically irrelevant because the probabilities involved are so small (and key sizes can be adjusted to make guessing as improbable to succeed as we want).
- andrewla 9y agoThis is not the aspect that is considered to be probablistic. The problem is that forks can happen by design -- blocks can be orphaned and the tree can be reorganized. So a transaction is only final so long as it is on the main chain; if the main chain switches to a forked chain that does not contain your transaction, then it is not settled; the resulting coins cannot be spent. There are attack scenarios, but even without those it is possible for forks to occur; single-block forks are common (so-called "orphaned blocks") due to some combination of network latencies and chance. Longer forks may be possible if there are more dramatic breaks in network connectivity. The original whitepaper originally advocated waiting for six blocks before a transaction is considered "settled". That's probably high, but the guarantees are strictly probablistic; any software dealing with bitcoins has to be aware of the possibility of reorganizations.
- otakucode 9y agoI have been curious about this idea for a long time. Consider the situation the USA is in right now. What percentage of all transactions which occur in the US economy right now pass through a payment processor? I would imagine the majority, and growing. And payment processors don't just charge for their services. They charge a percentage of the size of the transaction. Their cost to provide the service of moving numbers from one place to another over a wire does not increase for larger numbers, yet they still insist that the parties in the transaction pay more to move larger numbers. This makes payment processors a de-facto taxing body and gives them at least as much control over the monetary supply in a society as any central bank. If the Federal Reserve decided to take actions that private banks or payment processors disagreed with, it is entirely within their legal power to adjust the rates they charge and counteract the central bank. This is very dangerous. It's terribly unfortunate that modern government is so packed with nibshits and the clinically paranoid that they would never again back a currency which offers the same features as cash (untraceable, unfreezable, etc), but even without those, just escaping from the tyranny of payment processors might be worth it.
- sova 9y agoIf we could somehow move from private banks to a public distributed ledger that worked Government-style, we could probably reduce taxes and streamline a lot of things.