5 ms·
Makes me so happy to live in what is probably the country with the most freedom of speech. The USA may be behind other countries in some things but not freedom
by EGreg 9y ago
Makes me so happy to live in what is probably the country with the most freedom of speech. The USA may be behind other countries in some things but not freedom of speech!
If you live in a country with such draconian (and increasing) measures, there is only one thing to do:
Use encryption. If only a few people use it, then they are targeted. If merely 10% of people use an encrypted protocol, it may be blocked. But if EVERYONE uses it, it will be computationally infeasible to decrypt everyone's messages. And banning eg TLS or SSH would be very hard to do.
In addition to this, DECENTRALIZE ALL THE THINGS. When there is no single server, there is nothing to shut down. There is no central owner to intimidate. People will have to go back to the bad old days of "tattle tales" and KGB spies among the regular people.
And seriously, if democracy works at all in these countries, all lawful means must be taken to defend what is left of freedom of speech. Who are these people who are actually making these laws, anyway? Every time they break them, it should be publicized.
- stevenwoo 9y agoLaughing at a confirmation hearing is not protected speech. Though the article says what happened after she laughed is why she got convicted. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/03/us/code-pink-sessions-laughter-trial.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/05/03/us/code-pink-sessions-lau... I think even in the UK parliament the opposition makes fun of and laughs at each other without fear of prosecution.
- CrystalLangUser 9y agoIt's not about laughing, it's about being disorderly. Has little to do with "free speech", stop click baiting.
- alphaalpha101 9y agoIt has everything to do with free speech. It wasn't about being 'disorderly', it was about laughing at a confirmation hearing being considered disorderly.
- Dylan16807 9y agoBut the laugh didn't actually interrupt anything. It wasn't disorderly.
- quotemstr 9y ago> The USA may be behind other countries in some things but not freedom of speech! And that's why it's important to fight those who would introduce Chinese-like censorship to the west in the name of combating "hate speech" or whatever else tickles the moral panic of the day. Efforts like Google's Conversation AI seriously worry me: they have the potential to shape thought the same way that the Chinese approach does. In a sense, it doesn't really matter whether it's the government or a big corporation that performs automated censorship. Either way, your life can be adversely and drastically altered because some god damn neuron tripped over its activation function and called you a monster.
- christophilus 9y ago"In a sense, it doesn't really matter whether it's the government or a big corporation that performs automated censorship." It does matter. If it's a company doing this, you still are free to run your own servers and say anything you want. If it's the government, you don't have that freedom. You can be jailed, fined, executed, exiled...
- quotemstr 9y ago> If it's a company doing this, you still are free to run your own servers and say anything you want The Daily Stormer recently had a different experience. Besides, when your entire life's infrastructure depends on an ecosystem of data services, being suddenly disconnected from that ecosystem is tantamount to banishment. That's definitely the kind of punishment that can discourage speech.
- thegayngler 9y agoIt really can. That's what it is supposed to do. However, some companies don't wish to associate with certain speech. That's as much their right to free speech as anyone else's right to free speech. You can create your own stuff and no one is stopping them. From a government perspective you have free speech. No business has to sponsor your speech if it offends them or hurts their business.
- deleted 9y ago
- alphaalpha101 9y agoThe USA doesn't have freedom of speech in any meaningful sense. You only have to look at the way peaceful protestors are treated to see that. The Occupy Wall Street protesters were treated horrifically. As more and more formerly public places are privatised and the veneration of private property as an ideal above all others continues, the USA is simply running out of places where you're even allowed to protest. And that's not even considering so-called 'free speech zones', as if free speech is limited to a fucking place. This is free speech: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikoi#/media/File:Hikoi_FS.JPG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikoi#/media/File:Hikoi_FS.JPG In the USA these people would be arrested for blocking a road.
- unabridged 9y agoBlocking a road is not free speech. Preventing people from going into a building is not free speech. This is just private citizens attempting to restrict the right of movement of other private citizens. The right to publish any media, no matter how obscene or political, is free speech. And the US has the closest to free speech of any major country.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vacri 9y ago> The right to publish any media, no matter how obscene or political, is free speech. And the US has the closest to free speech of any major country. When it comes to freedom of the press, Reporters Without Borders rates the US quite poorly - it's down at #43, with the UK at #40. When it comes to anglo cultures, the highest any of the 'five eyes' gets is New Zealand, at #13. There is a difference between law and implementation. https://rsf.org/en/ranking https://rsf.org/en/ranking
- unabridged 9y agoThat ranking has little to do with free speech. In most of the countries with the best scores blasphemy is illegal.
- userbinator 9y agolawful means must be taken to defend what is left of freedom of speech ...and some may argue, even unlawful means; including one of the founders of the USA: "The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants." - Thomas Jefferson It's surprising how extremist that quote sounds today --- ask a random US citizen what they think of it, without revealing its author, and you'd probably receive some pretty disappointing answers.
- vacri 9y agoThere really isn't that much difference between US free speech and other western democracies' free speech, despite the first amendment. Yes, it's a little better if it makes it to court, but compared to something like what's going on in China, it really isn't that much different. However, there's still plenty of limitations on free speech in the US. Look at obscenity laws, for example - nudity is much more acceptable in Europe than in the US. Or if you're a 'freedom of expression' fan rather than just 'freedom of speech', why is sex work still illegal? It's not in plenty of other western democracies. As a non-American, it just gets tiring hearing the Americans constantly crap on about how much freer they are than everyone else, when there's really not that much difference.