2 ms·
Same here - it is really just one rule to remember, instant PC expert. That is also why I don't understand everybody raving about Macs. Macs are not consistent
by Tichy 16y ago
Same here - it is really just one rule to remember, instant PC expert. That is also why I don't understand everybody raving about Macs. Macs are not consistent with the second mouse button rule (they used to have only one button), therefore there is no way to become an instant expert on a Mac. I always hate using a Mac because it makes me feel so helpless.
My mother learned the second mouse button rule after a while, btw. Don't give up :-)
- dkersten 16y agoAnd even if they only have one button, they still have the command+click combo (which, IMHO, is much more complicated than simply having a second dedicated click button).
- Tichy 16y agocommand+click is horrible, as are the overhyped gestures. There is no way to accidentally discover them. For several weeks I had to Google whenever I wanted to rename a file on my Mac. I still have to Google for the key combination for showing the desktop (cmd+some function key, but there are 12 function keys).
- preek 16y agoJust hit enter when you clicked on a file. That's the same F2 does in Windows. Just the enter button is closer to regular use than F2. As to showing the desktop: FN+F11. But you can configure that in System Preferences -> Exposé and Spaces. Easy enough. I use it every day. Besides you're a linux guy. You should take a look at the visor terminal (visor.binaryage.com). It enables a Quake2 like terminal via hotkey all the time. That's a great productivity booster!
- Tichy 16y agoI can not remember cmd+f11 (my guess would have been f3). I don't use it often enough. I can remember the little button next to the start menu that looks like the desktop. I can remember to try second mouse button when I want to do something special with a file. Key combinations are impossible to discover by exploration. With the right mouse button, you can solve every problem by exploration.
- dkersten 16y agoWait.. are you trying to tell us its easy by introducing yet more odd and complicated buttons to the mix? Command + Click is too complicated - use Enter or FN+F11 instead? What??? I'm really not buying into your argument here!
- weaksauce 16y agoTo be fair the macs have a second button now but you need to enable it I think. (though it might be enabled out of the box I cannot recall) if you want to use another mouse with more than one button you are certainly able to and it will work as you expect it to. But if you cannot do any of that the context menu is only a ctrl+click away.
- jimbokun 16y ago"That is also why I don't understand everybody raving about Macs. Macs are not consistent with the second mouse button rule (they used to have only one button), therefore there is no way to become an instant expert on a Mac." Although you may have answered your own question, as it seems that the right-click button does not fit the mental model of non-computer-experts (at least, that is what we have been discussing). Maybe the Mac works better for those people because it does not assume that the user will just right-click to figure out how to do something? Right-click does work well, of course, in most contexts on the Mac. Interestingly, though, I've been finding myself appreciating having a big obvious button to click even when I know the functionality I want is also in the right-click menu. I suspect Fitt's law has something to do with it.
- glhaynes 16y agoYes. There has traditionally been a drive toward putting all major functions of a Mac app in the menu bar — even if they also additionally got a shortcut such as through a "right-click" contextual menu. This leads one to expect to be able to find any available option through scanning a single set of options (categorized roughly by the thing or type of action they effect) rather than having to mentally union all the options from several disparate places to get a complete mental model of the app's actions and options.