7 ms·
Reminds me a little of traffic. Yesterday I was cruising down the highway in the leftmost lane, going about 80 with a line of other cars. The other two lanes we
by ModernMech 9y ago
Reminds me a little of traffic. Yesterday I was cruising down the highway in the leftmost lane, going about 80 with a line of other cars. The other two lanes were actually more clear, but cars were going much slower.
I notice this one car, weaving in and out of traffic in these two lanes, trying desperately to get ahead, constantly cutting people off. They did this for 40 miles, weaving in and out, sometimes getting ahead of me by quite a bit, sometimes falling behind.
If they had just stayed in the left lane and cruised, they would have arrived at their destination at exactly the same time.
My point is, it seems to be human nature to be bad at estimating long term averages, whether it be stock picks or just driving down the road. Checkout lanes are another example that comes to mind.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoI think the weaving in and out behavior can be explained in some part by the boredom of just cruising in a single lane for miles and miles. That being said, downvoted because the traffic analogy was very tangential to the point at hand and would only serve to derail conversation.
- differentView 9y agoUnless you only noticed that one car that was terrible at getting ahead. Better drivers might have passed you only once and you didn't notice them because you never saw them again.
- mstanown 9y agoAs it happens when one doesn't acknowledge Survivorship Bias.
- foobarian 9y agoI wish Waze had an "A/B test mode" where you can bookmark the current cohort of drivers around you, and then N minutes later see where they ended up. Whenever traffic apps claim my main route home is backed up and I end up taking some weird backroads, I wonder if I would have been better off sticking with the main route.
- ramblerman 9y agoThis is a poor analogy, and will only serve to induce responses to the analogy rather than the topic at hand.
- mojoe 9y agoThe analogy works even deeper -- I've seen articles talking about how large amounts of lane changing actually slows traffic overall.
- perl4ever 9y agoSome people think you should not be in the left lane unless you are passing at that moment. In some places, there are even signs saying "keep right except to pass". Perhaps this person was driving aggressively because they were enraged at the line of traffic on the left. Which is to say, they may not have been doing it for a quantitative benefit as you assume. This might strengthen rather than weaken the analogy to the stock market though...since it could be that people invest in hedge funds not to increase their average return but to reduce the regret of not owning "winners" and having something to talk about.
- matthewmcg 9y agoIt's not just some people. It is actually the law in most states (albeit a seldom-enforced one). Don't cruise in the left lane.
- quuquuquu 9y agoMost people cruise at a speed that is faster than everyone else in the other (non-left) lanes. But, please don't be the car that is cruising at 60mph in the left lane. It is a leading cause of accidents.
- e12e 9y agoIe speeding?
- quuquuquu 9y agoSome states are 70mph, and most cops won't pull people over unless they're doing 10-15mph over. Unless you are just really unlucky XD
- soundwave106 9y agoNot sure why the downvotes. (Some states are 80mph actually!) Speeding enforcement in the United States is fairly loose, with usually roughly a 10mph buffer. (The exception being various "speed traps", atypically mostly rural towns that rely on ticket revenue for an outsized portion of their town budget.) I think this adds to the problem with left lane issues; even if the "true" speed limit is 80mph, if the "posted" speed limit is 70mph, some people will do no more than 70mph no matter where they are.
- alkonaut 9y agoThis was tested in an experiment I can't find now. One group of drivers was asked to stick to one lane, the other group was told to switch lanes when possible to get ahead. The outcome: as expected switching lanes gained next to nothing. But importantly the reported experience was significantly worse for those that stayed in one lane. So switching lanes doesn't reduce commute time but the perceived commute time - and that is not insignificant! This however isn't a poor performance because of switching a lot - these funds make money but the managers keep too much of it. The bet was on whether someone who invested in these funds would do better than the S&P - not whether the stocks in those funds did.
- goialoq 9y agoThat's because changing lanes is excited and camping is boring. This can be easily fixed by playing a game on your phone while camping.
- KC8ZKF 9y agoThis was tested by the Mythbusters television show. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZefgUVg3qx0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZefgUVg3qx0
- rhizome 9y agoAs far as driving goes, you never know why someone else is in a hurry. Sometimes they're trying to get to an emergency. Hope you were comfortable with your band of other left-lane cruisers, though.