4 ms·
The paradigm works well as long as the designer has a clear idea of what the user wants to do and as long as the designer('s boss') and the user's goals are ali
by xg15 9y ago
The paradigm works well as long as the designer has a clear idea of what the user wants to do and as long as the designer('s boss') and the user's goals are aligned - and as long as the designer could anticipate all use-cases.
Nothing is more infuriating than finding out that something that should be straight-forward to do is hard or even impossible because the option got taken away in the name of UX.
Actually, there is one thing more infuriating: If that UX was also inspired by business goals and not user interests.
- Karunamon 9y agoThis mindset (well, part of it) is what put me off GNOME. They forgot who they were designing for. Parts of the UI look like they were designed for touch, with all the compromises that entails; yet their average user is currently someone who use mouse and keyboard on a desktop. Being opinionated is fine, and for the most part Apple makes the right calls. But it’s not as simple as dictating “thou shalt...” via the UI and calling it a day, and then flatly refusing when questioned. It’s the UX equivalent of a bad manager who only learned the “be an asshole” from Steve Jobs-style leadership while forgetting all the reasons he could get away with that.
- 0xF2 9y agoApple does not get away with it because of force, or because of Steve Jobs' style. Apple can actually provide two different experiences, one via the UNIX cli (with a lot of knobs) and one in the Mac OS X UI (with high UX). Browsers do the same with chrome:// and about:config. In a properly modular design, you often do not need to choose whether to upset the expert user or to make the naïve ones happy.
- Gys 9y ago> Actually, there is one thing more infuriating: If that UX was also inspired by business goals and not user interests. Like.... Facebook ? I do not use it myself but ended up checking somebody else's page for a specific comment. Took me a while ! I remember a while ago (4-5 years ?) there was some fuss about Facebook deciding not to improve UX because tests showed users would spend less time on it. But cannot find anything at the moment.
- kettlecorn 9y agoStores like Walmart and Target are intentionally designed to be inefficient and maze like in an effort to get you spend more time browsing (and buying). Facebook is the digital equivalent of that.
- maxerickson 9y agoA grid of shelved aisles with wider walkways connecting them is not maze like. The milk is in the back on purpose, but products are grouped relatively sensibly too.
- sverige 9y agoYes, Ikea is far more annoyingly maze-like than Walmart or similar stores. In fact, it's so bad that I'll never hike through another Ikea again.
- leethargo 9y agoActually, the IKEA nearest to me in Berlin was restructured some months ago and got rid of the maze, by adding a lot more shortcuts. They also have signs with a floor plan whenever you could take a shortcut.
- bmn__ 9y agoIkea stores are Hilbert curves, not mazes. Mazes have split paths and lots of dead ends, those features make them disorienting. Hilbert curves are a single twisty path, which only makes it long, but not disorienting. The design of the path through the storey was not chosen to annoy you, but to make optimal use of display and saleroom space.
- sverige 9y agoWhile the design may not have been chosen for that purpose, it does indeed annoy me. And I suspect that it was designed that way more to force people to look at the goods in every single department, rather than to optimize the use of space. But yes, Hilbert curve rather than maze, makes sense.
- CamperBob2 9y agoThe paradigm works well as long as the designer has a clear idea of what the user wants to do and as long as the designer('s boss') and the user's goals are aligned - and as long as the designer could anticipate all use-cases. The advice in the article works well for simple things. Simple things can, and should, be perfect. Unfortunately not everything can be simplified until it makes sense to an unskilled operator (or an unskilled designer). Ideally, complex things are composed of simple things... but if that were true, wouldn't we'd all be running UNIX command-line desktops? Contrary to the author's leading premise, the best designs don't just work by taking options away from the user. They hide those options until they're needed... and when they are needed, they make those options easy to find. And that's hard work, the sort of hard work that can't be waved away with a list of trendy bullet points from some respected design guru who mysteriously never seems to be around when you need to use a different printer than the one the OS thinks you want.
- FooHentai 9y ago>The advice in the article works well for simple things. Simple things can, and should, be perfect. That seems backwards, as the argument being put forwards is that UX is all about trading off a complex, options-rich interaction with a simple, options-poor interaction. So good UX delivers simple things. The hard work comes in the skilful reduction of a potentially complex interaction to a simpler one, and recognising that there are tradeoffs.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]