3 ms·
You don't have to be a literal monopoly to be a legal monopoly. Microsoft has never literally been the only place to get an operating system, not even the only
by jerf 9y ago
You don't have to be a literal monopoly to be a legal monopoly. Microsoft has never literally been the only place to get an operating system, not even the only place to get a consumer operating system (Apple has been there for Microsoft's entire OS run, at varying levels of health, sure, but always available). But they were found to be legally a monopoly in terms of abusing monopoly power anyhow.
- amelius 9y agoWhich makes sense, because otherwise a monopolist would just start a small competitor and be done with it.
- sp332 9y agoThe lawsuit in the US involved bundling IE with Windows specifically to push other browsers out of the market. Google has never really been antagonistic toward other app stores. Lots of phones get sold without the Play Store installed.
- Spivak 9y ago> Google has never really been antagonistic toward other app stores. Sure they have. * You have to convince your users to go into their security settings and check the scary box with the even scarier warning. If Chrome started only trusting Google's CA with no option to add others you wouldn't be arguing that 'it's not so bad you can still click though by adding a security exception'. * 3rd party app stores are incapable of actually installing or updating apps -- they're basically glorified downloaders. There's no way to 'trust' another app store so that it can perform these actions on your behalf unless you root your phone.
- sp332 9y agoI don't remember Samsung or Amazon having trouble with that. Google isn't really the "first party" for most phone because they hardly make any phones themselves, even in partnerships.
- Spivak 9y agoI would make the same argument if we were talking about Samsung/Amazon branded phones as well. The issue is that users can't put app stores they like/want in that same privileged position. In my case I would like to put F-Droid there but unless I root my phone the best it can do is download the APK and notify me to install it manually.