9 ms·
Ask Obvious But Good Questions It actually irritates me that you can almost count on karma for saying something like "prove it" to a post that may present fair
by joe_the_user 16y ago
Ask Obvious But Good Questions
It actually irritates me that you can almost count on karma for saying something like "prove it" to a post that may present fairly good evidence already or that is clearly personal opinion not really subject to proof.
But I'm not wholly concerned with Karma. 6 points for something controversial probably implies more impact than 20 point for something simplistic, since the controversial point probably is going to generate a good deal of mod-downs too.
- freakwit 16y agoProve it. (No, really. You're not presenting good evidence here.)
- rick_2047 16y agoI honestly didn't understand what you are trying to say, can you expand and illustrate?
- jacquesm 16y agoI don't see why the questions should be obvious, there simply are no stupid questions and if someone asks a question they deserve an answer, not an automatic upmod. Comments like 'citation needed', 'prove it' are fortunately rare enough on HN that it's not a big problem.
- robryan 16y agoI find many times I've asked questions related to an article that someone involved closer in whatever the topic of the article is could answer I have got up votes but less often answers. I guess it's a form of me to, others interested in an answer to but have nothing to add will up vote.
- simonsquiff 16y agoPeople down-modding controversial comments is my only criticism of HN - if you disagree you shouldn't downmod, rather write a reply explaining why you disagree; the karma of each post will show where the consensus lies. The guidelines do indicate things should work this way - using only downmods for comments that are negatively adding to the conversion - but this doesn't seem to happen enough in practice.