4 ms·
How China Sidestepped QWERTY
- lkramer 9y agoInteresting enough article, however it's a bit odd captioning a Japanese woman using (presumably) a Japanese typewriter with the text "Early Chinese typewriters had thousands of keys to search through."
- wholien 9y agoThat's my first thought as well, but the picture could have been a kanji (or just straight Japanese) typewriter, which is similar enough to a Chinese typewriter that it makes sense to use the image. But with that in mind, the caption does not make sense. The author or whoever inserted images probably did not know the woman was Japanese.
- GrumpyNl 9y agoGoogle is your friend ;) https://www.google.nl/search?q=chinese+typewriter&safe=off&dcr=0&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjc497x9qbWAhWLfFAKHYelBowQ_AUICigB&biw=1920&bih=928#imgrc=mmJHxtbnJossyM https://www.google.nl/search?q=chinese+typewriter&safe=off&d...:
- fhood 9y ago....maybe....we hope....privacy issues notwithstanding.
- zokier 9y agoThe author probably knew that she was Japanese considering that he wrote the book about the subject matter, although the picture might have been captioned by some editor. I'd suspect that it is the same image that appears on his book in chapter called "Controlling the Kanjisphere", so I guess it covers japanese typewriters: https://books.google.com/books?id=UTIxDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA207&lpg=PA207&dq=5.2+Photograph+of+Japanese+typist+Kay+Tsuchiya,+1937+(author%E2%80%99s+personal+collection)&source=bl&ots=gyhLoLerhD&sig=k-aelmjMbFrGDIN3_3IVJvW6Fw4&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwix8sipsafWAhWlIJoKHXIsCuwQ6AEINTAF#v=onepage&q=5.2%20Photograph%20of%20Japanese%20typist%20Kay%20Tsuchiya%2C%201937%20(author%E2%80%99s%20personal%20collection)&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=UTIxDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA207&lpg=...
- 627467 9y agoDo we know for sure that's not a Chinese typewriter being used by a Chinese/Japanese/Korean woman dressed in a kimono during, say, Manchu Kuo China (for example)?
- vacri 9y agoBecause a Japanese woman could never type on a Chinese typewriter?
- maoeurk 9y agoIt's worth pointing out that in China, QWERTY with pinyin (Latin characters representing pronunciation with an IME mapping it to Chinese) is the most popular input method. Japanese similarly is primarily done with QWERTY and an IME. Other layouts do exist but they're not very common. Chinese input is quite varied though. Taiwan uses Zhuyin (or bopomofo) which is a phonetic alternative that doesn't use Latin. Hong Kong, Cantonese, and/or misc. types of Chinese may use other methods like Cangjie (which does use a QWERTY layout). Cangjie is notable for not being phonetic at all -- likely similar to the typewriter input methods mentioned in the article. Words are typed as ordered sequences of pseudo-radicals (pieces of Chinese characters) that are memorized by their associations to Latin letters and color[0]. Although there's no real reason either Japanese or pinyin IMEs should have to use QWERTY -- in fact it's likely quite suboptimal as neither make use of all the keys, or at least not as a primary function (many IMEs are configurable and/or allow non-standard characters to map to more complex sequences of input). I personally use both through Dvorak (which, being optimized for English, is similarly suboptimal). As for voice input, Chinese is easier than Japanese because of the larger phonetic inventory and use of tones to form minimal pairs. Although the different types of Chinese (regional dialects (as opposed to different Chinese languages)) and their variations in pronunciation complicate things. Japanese does have pitch accent, but it's not really consistent across Japan, so I don't know how helpful it would actually be for a voice recognition system. Purely from personal experience, I can rarely get Japanese voice recognition to work if trying to search for a word in isolation. It's quite good with sentences though. This might just be an artifact of my poor pronunciation though. I think typing in general, as it is now, is pretty primitive and has a lot of room to be improved. I've been tempted to try to make some new, and possibly more efficient, input methods, but haven't been able to justify giving any a try yet. I do think even an IME at the level of what currently exists in Chinese and Japanese would be wonderful to have for English though. Intelligent auto-complete, shortcuts, semantically aware insertion of unicode (Emoji are actually natural to use in IME-using languages; just type what you want and select the emoji that pops up). [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cangjie_input_method#/media/File:%E5%80%89%E9%A0%A1%E8%BC%B8%E5%85%A5%E6%B3%95_%E6%8B%86%E7%A2%BC.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cangjie_input_method#/media/Fi...
- addicted 9y ago
- dracodoc 9y agoThe title make it look like something relate to alternative keyboard layout, but it's actually just typewriter before computer age. I also don't like this kind of claim: > Ultimately, their work led to today's sophisticated predictive-text engines, which benefit from increasing processing power and cloud integration. I highly doubt the modern IME and text engines ever take any hint from this part of history.
- yorwba 9y agoThe MingKwai does sound similar to the Wubi (五笔 ⸺ 5 strokes) method. You type the individual components of a character or word, and any ambiguity is resolved by selecting from a short list. For example, 比如 (= "for example") is typed "xxvk", where "x" → 匕, "v" → 女, "k" → 口. 名字 (= "name") is typed "qkpb", where "q" → 夕, "k" → 口, "p" → 宀, "b" → 子. Of course most keys can stand for several characters (or components), and it can be hard to tell which one to use (for me), but the amount of ambiguity is surprisingly small.
- dracodoc 9y agoIt's familiar because that's the only way to do it with shape. You either select a character by shape or by pinyin. The key challenge here is to design a system that 1. can cover most characters with relative small shape collection 2. use less selection steps 3. easy to learn and memorize Wubi is optimized on the goal to determine a character with 4 shapes with almost no alternative candidate, so the raw input speed is optimized (4 keystroke for one character, and you don't need to select in most time), but it require a lot of time learning. That enabled typewriter as an job. Later people found pinyin + good word prediction can achieve acceptable speed, the typewriter job doesn't exist anymore. However it's still quite painful to input ancient Chinese prose, because most of them are single character word, so you have to select from a long list of characters with same pinyin (in word mode you just input pinyin of two characters, the pinyin combination have much less alternatives). Some pinyin have about 20-30 common used characters, like "ji", "yi" etc.
- kwoff 9y ago"transformed the Chinese keyboard into a 'smart' peripheral, much more sophisticated at taking instructions from the user than its static, rather stupid alphabetic cousin" - also can ensure what you type conforms to CCP dictates - see also: newspeak - pinyin ban incoming?