3 ms·
Asteroid mining for use on Earth is pretty silly. Take the example in the article, Platinum. According to Wikipedia, platinum is 0.005 ppm of the earth's cr
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
Asteroid mining for use on Earth is pretty silly. Take the example in the article, Platinum. According to Wikipedia, platinum is 0.005 ppm of the earth's crust, which is 2.3 x 10^22 kg. So there's about 1.1 x 10^14 kg of Platinum on earth, and we mine 200,000 kg per year. We're not going to run out any time soon.
But as the article implies, mining asteroids for use in space makes a heck of a lot of sense. That's a very different market.
- ethbro 9y agoI'd assume any ppm needs to be corrected by an "economically accessible" factor much <1. After all, we're not running the entire crust through a separator and ending up with piles of its different constituents.
- bryanlarsen 9y ago"we're not running the entire crust through a separator and ending up with piles of its different constituents." We're basically already doing that for copper.
- philipkglass 9y agoThe lowest mine reserve copper grade I see reported for any of these big copper projects is 0.25%, for Morenci: http://www.mining.com/these-10-mines-will-set-the-copper-price-for-the-next-decade/ http://www.mining.com/these-10-mines-will-set-the-copper-pri... That's 2500 ppm Cu, significantly higher than the crustal average of 50-100 ppm. If resource concentration isn't important, why don't miners just locate for low-cost infrastructure and extract copper from whatever rocks are close at hand? You could certainly save costs on workers/power/water/transport over going way off into the Andes or the Atacama Desert to extract ore. Likewise, if resource quality doesn't matter to platinum production, why not do the same for the platinum group metals? Just locate your multi-metal production complex wherever power and labor are cheap. If resource quality is unimportant, China should be a bigger platinum producer than the US or Canada. As far as I can tell, the only element ever commercially mined from ores of sub-ppm grade was radium. It was also by far the costliest substance ever produced by mining operations. (Some sub-ppm element concentrations may be exploitable when those elements are secondary, as with iridium as a byproduct of primary copper/nickel production.)
- bryanlarsen 9y agoWe're closing in on only a single order of magnitude difference between the concentration of copper in a copper mine and the concentration of copper in random crust. Considering that you used to be able to find pure copper deposits, I think your data supports my point.
- jessriedel 9y agoThe risk isn't "running out", it's that the cost of extraction becomes prohibitive. As a rule of thumb, asteroids are generally much richer with heavy metals than the Earth's crust because heavy things sink on Earth but they have no where to go on asteroids. These metals persist in small quantities in the crust mostly when they are bound to light elements. So the density and types of ores on asteroids are completely different, vastly changing extraction costs. Whether the benefits of asteroid composition outweigh the costs of space mining is complicated and time-/tech-dependent, and cannot be guessed by just noting that in principle there are sufficient atoms in the Earth's crust.
- bryanlarsen 9y ago"the cost of extraction becomes prohibitive" You're implying that the cost of extraction is going up. It's not, it's going down quite steadily because it's tech-limited, not resource limited.
- jessriedel 9y agoI'm not implying that at all. Everything is on a supply and demand curve, and the claim is that the extraction price increases, not with time, but with amount extracted at a fixed time. So the question is if we hit a point where the 1st ton of asteroid platinum is cheaper than the millionth ton of terrestrial platinum.
- nradov 9y agoThere is no actual evidence that the extraction price of precious metals will increase with the amount extracted at a fixed time. This is entirely speculative, and it seems more likely that extraction prices will decline as extraction technology improves faster than demand increases.
- fractallyte 9y agoYes, but why tear up our planet to get at its metals and minerals? Better to move mining and heavy industry into space, and avoid the environmental damage to Earth.