7 ms·
Two questions for everyone: 1.What do you think are the chances of Nazi's taking over the United States? 2. What do you think are the chances of the US govern
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y ago
Two questions for everyone:
1.What do you think are the chances of Nazi's taking over the United States?
2. What do you think are the chances of the US government using its power and influence to label and suppress opposition?
I think the answers to these questions pretty much determine where you stand. If you think there is a real chance that Nazi's will take over the United States, then any means of opposition is justified, and censorship is a fair price to pay to keep this evil from happening. If you think that there is pretty much zero chance that Nazi's will take over the United States, but that government has a tendency to suppress dissent, then censoring Nazi's(who you think pretty much have no chance of coming to power and making their evil ideology anything more than words) is just opening the door and setting a precedent of suppressing ideas and will likely be used to suppress other less evil (or even good) ideas.
- vixen99 9y agoNazi's? Nazi's what? Do you mean Nazis.
- albertgoeswoof 9y agoA grammar nazi in a nazi thread
- 1_2__4 9y agoAre you asking what we think the chances are the literal supporters of the long-dead German party are going to "take over" the US? Because if so that's a strawman and you know it. If you really want to set it up as a dichotomy I'd characterize the first category as "people who believe in racial superiority, authoritarianism, bellicose and arbitrary foreign policy, and in general favor short-sighted, poorly-executed and simple solutions - most of which involve completely neutering government as we know it - over sober and data-backed policy"... Then I'd say we're already teetering on the edge, and yeah, I'd consider that a lot more likely than the US government using its power and influence to label and suppress opposition. You might notice, by the way, that the first begets the other. So turns out enabling (1) also hastens (2). So it's not really a dichotomy at all, is it?
- aetherson 9y agoFor everyone who's unconcerned that the definition of "Nazi" will expand without limit, note the above. I mean, I don't like Trump either. But he's a very long way from a Nazi. If we can't draw a line between "unlimited war to annex your neighbors" and "unwise brinksmanship with North Korea," or between "explicit campaigns to at the very least expel all Jews or alternately to just genocide them" and "professes to have no problems with minorities but seems to enact some policies that are consistently somewhat hostile to them (but which are a million miles away from expelling them)," then where can we draw the lines?
- Tannic 9y agoNo offense, but have you not been watching for the last thirty years? The US has, under Democrat and Republican alike, invaded and annihilated more countries than the rest of the world combined(1). And who are the people in these countries? Largely non white, powerless people. We literally just sold huge numbers of weapons to a country to help them annihilate their neighbor (Saudi Arabia, and Yemen respectively, which in many parts is in its death throes). I mean hell, in the last administration alone we annihilated the entire civil infrastucture of Libya. Ask yourself this: if you are heavily invested in the idea of your society as some kind of fundamentally virtuous project, as many in the west are, isn't it possible that you can't even see that we are in a flavor of mercenary fascism that is less ideological but equally destrucive and evil? 1. Map of US 20th century interventions: https://williamblum.org/images/uploads/interventions_map.png https://williamblum.org/images/uploads/interventions_map.png
- anigbrowl 9y agoNazi Germany didn't turn into a totalitarian state overnight. It took place relatively slowly over a period of years and remained within the letter, if not the spirit, of the Weimar constitution. I have to say your argument of contrast seems a bit disingenuous.
- defen 9y agoI would say the two main differences are: The leader of the Nazis was writing about the need to exterminate the Jews well before he had any sort of political power, so we can't really say it's surprising he ended up trying to do that once he had power. There's no analogous thing for Trump. Similarly, the judiciary was sympathetic to pre-power Hitler, letting him make long impassioned speeches at his trial for treason, which ended up netting him just 9 months in prison. Trump doesn't need that kind of thing for publicity in this day and age, but I think it's fair to say that the judiciary views him as an embarrassment at best, or hates him.
- mozumder 9y ago> 1.What do you think are the chances of Nazi's taking over the United States? Already happened with Trump. > 2. What do you think are the chances of the US government using its power and influence to label and suppress opposition? Already being done with banning people based on religion.
- creaghpatr 9y agoRepublicans of course know that George W. Bush was hitler, McCain was Hitler, Romney was Hitler, and Trump- you know the joke by now. "Call them Nazis" is a pretty standard tactic in the left wing arsenal. Bush: http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2004/jan/5/20040105-114507-1007r/ http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2004/jan/5/20040105-1145... McCain: http://www.mtv.com/news/1593432/madonna-compares-john-mccain-to-hitler-at-tour-opener-campaign-calls-slam-outrageous/ http://www.mtv.com/news/1593432/madonna-compares-john-mccain... Romney: http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/247789-romney-campaign-tells-obama-to-rein-in-his-supporters-on-nazi-comments http://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/247789-romn... It's kind of a shame that Democrats have trivialized the Holocaust into a political punchline. But you can see the 'concerns' on the left if these 'nazis' get into power. It drives their rationalization for these kind of censorship actions and the tech companies are just taking advantage of an opportunity.
- nrb 9y agoNot sure if you actually think this is only one side doing this, but just substitute "hitler" for "communist" from the right, with the same fears and motivations. There's no excusing either, but let's discuss this with some intellectual honesty.
- inthon4lyfe 9y ago"intellectual honesty" in this case being "make sure to shit on the right while you point out the foibles of the left, or i might end up reflecting on how i'm playing a pointless, unwinnable game of 'tit for tat' like the hatfields and mccoys"
- creaghpatr 9y agoCommunists don't get banned from the internet so far- nazis do.
- enraged_camel 9y agoYou can absolutely get banned from right-wing forums for being even slightly liberal (aka "communist"). You only have to look at The_Donald to see this in action everyday.
- komali2 9y agoI'm very curious the sort of answers you would get to this question to the general population of Germany in 1926. It may give insight into the perceived risk level we face now.
- orblivion 9y agoHow afraid were they of a communist takeover? Somebody please correct me if I'm wrong (and I'm relatively ignorant to be sure) but my understanding is that there were serious tensions between communitists and Nazis, and that Nazis won out in large part for public fear of communists. Which is to say, if you're comparing then to now, we should look at more than just the movement in isolation.
- bduerst 9y ago>How afraid were they of a communist takeover? How afraid are the working class of a socialist takeover today? The German working class then was afraid of Bolshevism. The American working class today is afraid of socialism. Populist candidates use this fear to suspend rational thinking.
- xyrnoble 9y agoWhat even is a Nazi at this point except for an instance of #2? If #1 justifies any means of opposition then we're already Nazi's. It's just radical egoism on a national scale.
- herbst 9y agoAt this point it more or less lost its meaning. Even in German we use it for everything from grammar nazi to music nazi. More or less just stands for stupid ignorance in the most common way I hear it.
- zzzcpan 9y agoWho do you think supports nazis or other extreme organizations? It's not like you wake up one day and realize you want to join nazis for the greater good. No, there must be some people organizing the whole thing, promoting, putting quite a bit of time and effort into it to attract members. And somebody has to pay for all of this. Often those somebodies are state actors or politicians that want to use those organizations for their own agendas. Like suppressing internet freedom, manufacturing consent and all that.
- Udik 9y agoNeither 1 or 2. I'm much more afraid that: 3) the companies that control the internet (which are free from any duties to allow free speech) will enforce an echo chamber in which only a very limited subset of opinions can be expressed. This is much more realistic, and it's exactly what seems to be happening.
- jchrisa 9y agoIt's totally fine if Kekistan gets erased. The world will be a better place. Your (3) I describe as "companies that control the internet realize their customers don't want to be supporting trolls."
- tgb 9y agoIt's widely regarded today that McCarthyism was terrible even though people of that era believed - not unreasonably - that there was a good chance that Communism would take over the US.
- dclowd9901 9y agoRefusing to stand in the way of an onslaught of backlash that someone would receive for their speech is not censorship. No one has the right to be heard or be free from consequences. They just have the right to not be silenced by our government. In this case, people _outside of the bounds of the law_ are using their own agency to stop the speech. It's no different than me punching you in the face for using a derogatory term. I'm still subject to assault laws, but you might think twice before you use that term again around people. You can call that whatever you like, but reality is, no one can realistically be stopped from stopping other people from speaking.
- AlexandrB 9y agoYou're missing: 3. What do you think are the chances of a small number of unaccountable corporations using their power and influence to suppress speech they don't like? I fear this is the far more likely outcome and is a symptom of there being no truly "public" space on the internet. If it was the government censoring Nazis the answer would be pretty clear-cut - government censorship is bad - and plenty of court precedent would back that up. Since it's now private entities censoring information, what recourse does the censored have? Stop using these products? What if that product is a near-monopoly search engine or a near-monopoly social network? What if no private company is willing to bear the burden of protecting someone's first amendment rights if it costs them revenue?
- angersock 9y ago> What do you think are the chances of the US government using its power and influence to label and suppress opposition? Very long history of this. Go look at basically the entire 20th century for examples. > 1.What do you think are the chances of Nazi's taking over the United States? Negligible. I'm more concerned about the tyranny of people using them as a specter.