17 ms·
The Terrifying Power of Internet Censors
- Pigo 9y agoMaybe this is a pretty good test of the free-market to self-regulate. Most people wouldn't shed a tear for one hate site going down. But if someone else takes the reigns of this company and starts following Twitter or YouTube's example, what would stop another competitor from filling that void and taking the money from jilted sites? As long as it's possible for new services to compete...
- problems 9y agoThis has sort of happened in some spaces - in certain right-wing communities Twitter has been largely replaced by Gab, Patreon by the aptly named Hatreon, etc. The issue becomes more severe when it runs up against services that are hard or expensive to start or which rely on other uncooperative services - look at what's happened with Daily Stormer and Bulletproof.ai for example - Bulletproof wants to provide them service, but they're unable to find a TLD thus far which will allow their domain to stay online.
- Pigo 9y agoThis is what I was wondering. If it's impossible to be a Cloudflare alternative because they rely on something like ISP's rely on public utilities, it feels like these barriers to entry really hurt the consumer.
- danso 9y agoThat already happened with Daily Stormer: https://www.propublica.org/article/spurned-by-major-companies-the-daily-stormer-returns-to-the-web https://www.propublica.org/article/spurned-by-major-companie... I imagine it might be easier to make some niche profit in Cloudflare's business. Not so sure with Twitter, partly because Twitter itself isn't profitable, but also because the main feature of social media services is their ubiquity and userbase. Even if Voat were decidedly a better site than Reddit, it just wasn't that interesting to revisit a sparsely populated discussion site. Especially one weighted toward folks who wanted to discuss the things that Reddit wanted to ban.
- dannyw 9y agoThere are two services that are gateways for small, independent (but prominent / notorious) internet sites: CloudFlare and Google Project Shield. These are the two only services that provide affordable DDoS protection, even for 100++Gbps, for $200/month or free. Tell me another provider like CloudFlare that will protect a blog against a 100Gbps DDoS for $200 a month. --- By the way, regulating CloudFlare by limiting its ability to choose customers would be unconstitutional under the 1st amendment, would it not? There are a very specific number of protected classes that private individuals or companies can't discriminate against. "Do not discriminate against hate speech" is not a class.
- problems 9y ago> By the way, regulating CloudFlare by limiting its ability to choose customers would be unconstitutional under the 1st amendment, would it not? You're correct from a legal perspective, but Matthew Prince himself called it "dangerous" to do what they did. I think with good reason. While it's legally okay, it definitely raises valid questions, not about what's legal, but about what's right.
- walterstucco 9y agoIf a bar has the right to not accept Nazi customers, and they have it, why not a service provider? The danger is inherent to the kind of service you're using: a private company in the US
- thehardsphere 9y agoNot just a company in the US, but the right of any group of people who are not the government to freely associate in the US. Free association has implicit within it, the right of people to choose who they do not wish to associate.
- walterstucco 9y agoExactly right My point is that especially if you are not from US, a service from a private company in a foregin country, cannot be considered a public utility. If such a service don't want to support nazi propaganda is their right to shut it down. I see no risk for everyone's freedom.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dtech 9y agoSo the real problem here is the monopoly/oligopoly. Usually, a monopolist has more restrictions in what it can do than a healthy market business. Should a monopolist be allowed to not serve a customer because of an ethics difference? (assuming the customer did nothing illegal)
- eplanit 9y agoSituations like this will help drive a mindset that these and most all ISPs should be regulated as Utilities.
- zero_intp 9y agoYou are serious? A IP washing service is by no means a utility. Maybe we can talk about companies that receive a government granted monopoly; certainly we should talk about regulated Title II, but this article claiming that Cloudflair should not choose who they protect is asinine. Anyone is free to try to go raise the money to create a technology company; just as any technology company should have the freedom of self-expression to not take customers outside of protected classes.
- oh_sigh 9y agoThe author of the article makes a point about how it's everyone's right to go onto the street and voice your opinion. But if you'll be attacked and silenced any time you do that, so long as you don't hire the local protection, do you still have that right to free speech if the local protection doesn't like you?
- dispo001 9y agoThe success of censorship is measured in how much you don't know about its topics.
- zebrafish 9y agoInteresting to think about the dichotomy that exists between our country and China when it comes to issues like this. In China, they would just block the content and move on to other things. In the US, because we value every individual's rights, we have to grapple with these tough questions. I think it's worth these headaches to protect our inalienable rights, but others may disagree. It makes me proud, though, that our country is still willing to take on these issues despite the amount of vitriol from both sides.
- nxsynonym 9y agoAs frustrating as these topics can be, I think it's much better to have the discussions then to just shut things down a-la-China. My fear is that this particular case could set a precedence of the "pipe lines" controlling the contents that are passed through. If we allow this to happen in this case, how long until the other bigger pipe lines are allowed to make similar decisions? Is it a slippery slope that leads to Time Warner, Verizon, or AT&T to control what content is allowed to passed through their cell/data networks? I don't know what the correct course of action is, I just hope that we will continue to debate and weigh options and not turn a blind eye to this kind of thing.
- eli_gottlieb 9y ago>Is it a slippery slope that leads to Time Warner, Verizon, or AT&T to control what content is allowed to passed through their cell/data networks? It's not a slippery slope. It's rock bottom. Those companies already proposed exactly that sort of thing, a long time ago. They proposed it with copyright enforcement, and they proposed it when they fought against Net Neutrality and common-carrier rules. They want to control what goes through their pipes. They do not want to be a dumb pipe, they want to rent-seek, they want to play highway robber of the information superhighway. They've told us that. They are proud of that. They believe that is good business. The question is whether we let ourselves hear it.
- aiyodev 9y ago> In China, they would just block the content and move on to other things. In the US, because we value every individual's rights Do we, though? This used to be true but I no longer think it is.
- mi100hael 9y agoSomewhat relevant: Twitter also just suspended the account of the White House Communications Director, Hope Hicks. I'd love to see an org like 18F start providing federated FOSS platforms for govt communication like GNU Social.
- davesque 9y agoThat seems to be the result of a targeted mass-reporting instigated by a group of radical leftists. I wonder if Twitter wouldn't reinstate her account once they realize what happened.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoSeems like you received bad info. WEDNESDAY MORNING, CONSERVATIVE corners of the internet were furious to discover that @HopeHicks45, the Twitter account belonging to Donald Trump's newly official Communications Director, had been suspended. The only problem? That’s not Hope Hicks. @HopeHicks45 was nothing more than an imposter. https://www.wired.com/story/hope-hicks-twitter-suspended/ https://www.wired.com/story/hope-hicks-twitter-suspended/
- mi100hael 9y agoI was unaware, thanks for the follow-up.
- SirHound 9y agoMy main concern with the web is its mutability. If we had a protocol that considered changes versions, we'd be creating a much saner store of information for future generations.
- walterstucco 9y agoGit+static web sites It's been my idea for years now Please don't steal it
- ben_w 9y agoI think github already has…
- walterstucco 9y agoAnd Gitlab too The interest around the idea of immutable web is growing But it's still an hard tool to manage for regular people Now we only need a good backend for it
- TeMPOraL 9y agoHere you're entering a different discussion. Ther are many who would like the Internet to be a permanent record of information, but there are also many who would want it to be ephemeral.
- sanityUnbounded 9y agoI'd say it's more sad than terrifying. Terror implies immediate danger, most people will not feel the danger that shutting down of a Nazi website should entail. Most people are not Nazis. The value of an online community exists within participation from those that visit the website. Anyone that visits can explore the ideology from the perspective of those that believe in it, which is an invaluable tool for education. What happened in Charlottesville was a moment in american history, no matter which side you fall on. What google, godaddy, and cloudflare are doing is (understandably) limiting community engagement on extremist websites. However by doing that it is also restricting those that want to understand who-what-where-when-why-how from accessing the conversations that occurred, and obviously, they did indeed occur. Now, anybody that wants to explore both sides of the event has to do so by navigating a barrage of news articles which loosely throws around the term "nazi", and a smaller subset of opinion articles which view it as a censorship issue. It makes the stance of anti-censorship & anti-nazi an impossibly difficult stance to take because these two issues are being viewed as two sides of the same issue. This is not conducive to a proactive internet culture. For the first time in history we have the opportunity to explore opposing political/race ideologies from inception to protest, and instead of using it to learn about human nature and group think, companies are hitting a mute button to win a popularity contest with investors.
- AstralStorm 9y agoHere's a parable: They came for the anarchists. I am not an anarchist, so I didn't care. Then they came for the communists, neither am I. Then they came for the Muslims. Then they came for debtors and child pornographers. Then they came for me. Or in other words, for every man there is a paragraph (in criminal law). If not, one will be invented.
- Ntrails 9y agoHere is a parable: They came for the murderers and put them in prison. They didn't come for me because I'm not a murderer, and we're broadly ok with seeing murderers as being bad for society. I'm not saying that your quote doesn't have power - it does. But the important aspect of it is that the targets were people the subject knows were being unfairly treated. So yes, if they start locking up homosexuals or Muslims or jews I'll refer to that parable and think "shit - I'd best do something". As things stand I'm not getting out of bed to help a nazi.
- davesque 9y agoThis article has some good points. But I think it's interesting to notice that there are certain kinds of information that even we here in the US, and other liberal countries, censor (and have more or less always censored) without a moment's consideration. Take child porn, for example. So that blows a hole in the idea that there's no clear line somewhere. I wonder, then, why are ideas like Nazism, with its close historical proximity to genocide and the death of millions (arguably much more repugnant than pictures of naked children), somehow given more consideration than something like child porn?
- Ygg2 9y agoBecause people have been labeling each other Nazis for the past decades, that the word lost all meaning. What it kinda boils down to is "a person I disagree with".
- davesque 9y agoBut isn't it probably true that the Daily Stormer was run by neo-Nazis? Updated to be more accurate in response to a reply. Use of the term "literal Nazis" in my original post was arguably not appropriate.
- thehardsphere 9y agoIt was run by literal neo-Nazis, I think. Pretty sure the literal Nazis were either put to death, sent to prison, died of old age, or ended up hiding in Argentina somewhere never to be heard from again.
- joshuamorton 9y agoThis is a distinction without a difference. Neo Nazis are people who are working to revive Nazi ideology. They're Nazis.
- thehardsphere 9y ago
- gyardley 9y agoSlippery slope arguments like the one in the article are so tiresome. It's perfectly possible to deny service to Nazis without it snowballing into a problem for the rest of society. After all, plenty of nations have had anti-Nazi laws on the books for generations, and they continue to function just fine for the 99.9999% of society that doesn't want to murder me for my religion.
- tim333 9y agoSeems pretty un-terrifying to me. If you want to read the Stormer, google it, click on the wikipedia page and go to the .onion link with Tor Browser. Nothing's really censored these days.
- imgabe 9y agoWe can't realistically expect service providers to completely allow free speech until we learn to separate the speech from the service on which it occurs. Suppose a bunch of Nazis started frequenting Hacker News and dominated every thread with a discussion of Nazism. The site would pretty quickly become known as "that Nazi place" and everyone who's not a Nazi wouldn't want to go there, even if the people running the site don't share the opinions of the people using it. It's not entirely rational, but if GoDaddy got a reputation as "web hosting for Nazis" that would severely limit their market and hurt their business, so of course they're going to jettison that customer in order to keep all the others.
- milcron 9y agoWe do have DMCA safe harbor. Is that different from what you're talking about?
- imgabe 9y agoI'm thinking more of an economic consequence, rather than a legal one. Customers boycott businesses all the time for speech they find distasteful. A newscaster uses a racial slur and advertisers threaten to pull sponsorship until he's fired. A company owner endorses a candidate or cause that customers don't like so they vow never to do business with them again, etc. etc. I personally stopped using GoDaddy years ago because of their stance on SOPA. So, why couldn't businesses boycott customers for the same? If someone's speech is so odious that nobody wants to be associated with them, even in a remote, business sense, I think that should be allowed as a reasonable consequence.
- lordlimecat 9y agoHacker News is a content curator. Godaddy is network infrastructure. Imagine if Cisco released an IOS update that allowed ISP routers to automatically detect certain types of hate speech and simply RST the connection. Good, or bad for "free speech"? More directly, good, or bad for everyone?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- james1071 9y agoThe problem is as follows: a small number of private companies have huge power over the internet.
- RickJWagner 9y agoYes, I agree.
- james1071 9y agoThe problem is that the US government is able to get private companies to do its bidding without being liable to scrutiny from politicans our the courts.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoTwo questions for everyone: 1.What do you think are the chances of Nazi's taking over the United States? 2. What do you think are the chances of the US government using its power and influence to label and suppress opposition? I think the answers to these questions pretty much determine where you stand. If you think there is a real chance that Nazi's will take over the United States, then any means of opposition is justified, and censorship is a fair price to pay to keep this evil from happening. If you think that there is pretty much zero chance that Nazi's will take over the United States, but that government has a tendency to suppress dissent, then censoring Nazi's(who you think pretty much have no chance of coming to power and making their evil ideology anything more than words) is just opening the door and setting a precedent of suppressing ideas and will likely be used to suppress other less evil (or even good) ideas.
- vixen99 9y agoNazi's? Nazi's what? Do you mean Nazis.
- albertgoeswoof 9y agoA grammar nazi in a nazi thread
- 1_2__4 9y agoAre you asking what we think the chances are the literal supporters of the long-dead German party are going to "take over" the US? Because if so that's a strawman and you know it. If you really want to set it up as a dichotomy I'd characterize the first category as "people who believe in racial superiority, authoritarianism, bellicose and arbitrary foreign policy, and in general favor short-sighted, poorly-executed and simple solutions - most of which involve completely neutering government as we know it - over sober and data-backed policy"... Then I'd say we're already teetering on the edge, and yeah, I'd consider that a lot more likely than the US government using its power and influence to label and suppress opposition. You might notice, by the way, that the first begets the other. So turns out enabling (1) also hastens (2). So it's not really a dichotomy at all, is it?
- briholt 9y agoITT Nazi hysteria. The only thing between us and the Fourth Reich is Twitter and an intrepid band of internet commenters.
- blfr 9y agoit wasn’t until Cloudflare, a website security and performance service, dropped the site as a client that The Daily Stormer truly lost its ability to stay online Daily Stormer lost its ability to stay online on the clearnet because its registrars kept dropping it. First GoDaddy and Google for .com (or .net) and then national registries when they tried ccTLDs (.al and others). They did manage to find a replacement for Cloudflare -- BitMitigate. https://bitmitigate.com/a-commitment-to-liberty.html https://bitmitigate.com/a-commitment-to-liberty.html
- mrguyorama 9y agoShould we encourage or require companies like google and cloudflare to cater to fringe groups? Ordinarily, a business, especially in the United States, has the freedom to not conduct business with all but a few protected classes. Is being a neo-nazi, or a member of antifa, or of the old Animal Liberation Front now supposed to be a protected class? If yes, does that mean we also require the bakery down the road to post advertisements for local hate group gatherings? Do we want to commit to taking away a business's freedom of association? If a Nazi walks into the coffee shop I'm at and starts trying to rally people around the their ideology, I'm going to do one of two things, either leave or attempt to talk the nazis down, and when that (typically) doesn't work, also leave. If the Nazi comes back every day and does the same, it can reasonably affect that coffee shop's business. Does the coffee shop not have the freedom to kick the Nazis out?
- istorical 9y agoIf you think of internet communication as a utility, then perhaps we should? Would you think it's OK for an electricity or a water company to decide who it wants to serve based off that company's fallible determination of an individual or group's beliefs? I think if only because communication is such a basic human right, then we shouldn't risk the 'false guilty verdicts'. If you think about it - giving a business the right to cut off customers decreases the chance of guilty people being empowered and skating by without punishment (which is awesome!), but increases the chance of innocent people being victimized through a 'false conviction'. I'd argue that for very fundamental services, it's not the job of the business to try to play judge and jury and determine who is right and who is wrong, if only because the risk of an innocent party (like a false conviction putting an innocent person behind bars in the legal system) is so high stakes.
- mrguyorama 9y agoSo since food and water are also basic human rights, should we disallow Walmart from turning away Nazis? If I was a jewish business owner, why shouldn't I have a right to turn away someone advocating for my death? At that point isn't it just self defense?
- qq66 9y agoInteresting to see Matthew Prince (Cloudflare CEO) basically begging for regulation of his own business. I think that he wants to be legally forced to serve everyone so that he doesn't have to be accountable to Twitter hordes for doing so, he can just say that it's the law.
- Jerry2 9y agoGoogle is the most terrifying company today. De-google yourselves as much as you can, folks. This company cannot be trusted. I know this post will get flagged and deleted because so many google employees post here and flag everything. But it must be said. Do not trust Google.
- psyc 9y agoI'll back you on this opinion. I was a huge fan of early Google (98-04). They seemed like a noble, cute, altruistic steward of the Internet, and they did a lot of good. IMO we have to acknowledge that things have changed. The factors that made them succeed wildly, allowed them to grow into a profoundly self-interested, monopolistic behemoth with entirely too much power. They no longer even appear well-intentioned, and we ought to update our expectations accordingly.
- DINKDINK 9y agoI'll add another point. Even if you believe, today, that Google is good/noble, it's still best for the market to promote competition. If you allow too much power to concentrate into an oligopoly, the cost to capture the market drops to a level where coercive actors have the capability to do so.
- iotku 9y agoThere's a lot of arguments under the claim that because you are being censored my a private company rather than the government that you don't have the right to complain about it. After all, they're private businesses they can do whatever they want, at least I'm not being oppressed by the government! First of all, there's actually a notable connection between many of these large companies and the US government (or other governments) so they idea that they hold no responsibility in regards to free speech ends up a bit weaker. They're operating under the grace of the government they're under, if the government wants to shut them down it's bad news for them, so they generally want to cooperate and comply with government orders. While they're not being directly operated by the government, they do have to keep them happy. Secondly, there's pretty much no offline public meeting place left to share ideas, if you get blacklisted from the Internet you have significantly less ability to express your ideas or opinions to be debated, debunked, or proven. What do you have left? Shouting in the middle of Starbucks on a busy afternoon? You're banned on social media, you can't operate your own website without being blasted off of the Internet and even if you did have valid claims nobody would be able to hear them. As a result your ability to exercise your speech has been dramatically diminished, while people you disagree with retain all of their rights because they have "the right ideas". It's not hard to agree that neo-nazi ideas are unacceptable, inflammatory, and against my ideals and the majority of others, but it's not only their rights that are at risk. If the tables were turned and our idea's of what's right and wrong, moral, and otherwise acceptable were in the minority of opinion people would be extremely concerned about the right of arbitrary companies being able to restrict our ideas. Ultimately we hope the best ideas can win out, but that's not possible if no alternative ideas are allowed to form. While the current problems may be from a quite arguably minuscule amount of people that are pretty disagreeable today, there's no telling what the future will bring in regards to new ideas which may shake up current social norms. What you use to hurt people you disagree with today, may be used against you tomorrow. Finally, you can just ignore people and things you don't like. It's not a hard thing to do without censoring someone/something so hard that they get a platform under the reasoning that they're being censored by evil companies or governments. There was nothing forcing me to go to a website that I didn't want to go to, the majority of the sites that got censored would just be ignored or forgotten by the majority of people. Nobody would be talking about these neo-nazi sites outside of a small fringe group of people if it wasn't for efforts to erase them from the Internet for having "the wrong ideas", there's always going to be people looking to get attention and the only way to battle that is to not give them the attention they seek. People have the right to say things that are incorrect, disgusting, immoral, or otherwise wrong. I have the right to ignore those people. Censorship is not ignoring them, it's acknowledging them to the point of an extreme which you then have to justify with some moral grandstanding about how you saved the world from a problem they weren't having.
- intopieces 9y agoIf a company has the fiduciary duty to make money for its shareholders, can it simultaneously be forced to allow content on its servers that risks its ability to earn profit? These companies are happy to take anyone’s money until the glare of bad PR starts to take money from their pockets. It seems like this kind of “censorship” is exactly the kind the freedom-loving West is looking for. Market-based.
- flowctrl 9y agoHate speech is a special category of speech, and is treated as such in the legal systems of many countries (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech). It has and does lead to violence toward the groups to which the hate speech is directed. The legal system in the USA fails to acknowledge this fact, and one of the consequences is racial violence. Cloudflare, ISPs, and other companies or non-governmental entities should not be obligated to enable or allow hate speech via the services that they provide. Haters should have to bear the full cost and social consequences of propagating their message.
- MSDOStoevsky 9y agoAs is evidential within that wikipedia links's first paragraph, there are different definitions of "hate speech," and its difficult to properly regulate. Above that, the US has a long tradition of upholding the liberal values of philosophers John Locke, and John Stuart Mill. And the latter even argues that it is unethical to limit things considered as hate speech. Its not necessarily a failing, it is by design.
- HumbleGamer 9y agoI was under the impression that CloudFlare removed them not due to their content, but due to the site beginning to act as if CloudFlare was a collaborator or in support of them. If that was the case, it only seems logical they would want to distance themselves from that site and the ongoing drama. We also arent equating the response of their customers. Didn't Godaddy's response generate from a Tweet to them about it? Trust and believe, support tickets were sent to registrars asking for a clear stance on this.
- ahuxley2013 9y agoAnyone heard of the program "Persona"? Or sock puppets? This notion, that there is a party that represents the interest of say, the left, and another party that represents the interest of the right leaning people in the U.S. is childish thinking. They are the same, there is no difference. In books written by international relations scholars, they discuss this openly. "American Politics : The promise of disharmony" by Samuel P. Huntington states it openly, that the idea that the two party system should have the appearance of that, that one represents the left, the other of the right. But in fact they are the same, and so when the peoples "creedal passions" take hold they can "throw the rascals out" and have no substantive change in the continuity of governance. Nothing changes. Nothing. Trump is doing what he is told. The reactions from the left, some of it is genuine, some of it is manufactured since the leftist groups are usually run by government operatives wannabes. The leadership that is, they are in lock step with the COG, they go along to get along. They want a seat at the table. As the left wing dissolves into their goofy tribalism and hokey dances. The right wing also has their crazies like the small white nationalist movement. While everyone runs around like a chicken with their head cut off, screaming about nazis and minorities, there is a love of fascism in America, in the corporate arena.