6 ms·
It's been fairly apparent to me that science doesn't really counter religious belief. I've been following the Closer To Truth series on Youtube for a while and
by simonh 9y ago
It's been fairly apparent to me that science doesn't really counter religious belief. I've been following the Closer To Truth series on Youtube for a while and although I find the atheist positions given much more convincing, the religious side always has some way out of a killing blow.
However what that series never seems to really tackle head on, and which I would have expected to be a much more powerful argument, is that although religious philosophers and theologians can always come up with some justification for believing in a universal creator, they never seem to come up with any argument as to what that creator is like. If the universe was created by god, what is that god like and why should I be a Christian rather than a Muslim, or Hindu, or Budhist? If Christian, why a Catholic, say, rather than a Methodist, or Calvinist, etc.
Science, or at least rational philosophy, can strip away much of the cultural detritus of religion. Ultimately though until it can answer why the universe exists, not just how, it can't land a fatal blow.
So to me the argument of science versus religion is kind of secondary. The real question is can't religious people see that they're just projecting arbitrary cultural baggage they happen to have been born into, that keeps changing generation by generation anyway, on a philosophical emperor that inherently has no clothes?
- camus2 9y ago> It's been fairly apparent to me that science doesn't really counter religious belief. Show me how one multiplies fishes. There are 2 differents questions when it comes to religion. One is philosophical : "Does a moral god exist?" The other is historical: "Who wrote the bible or the coran the torah and co, and do these prophets who claim they have seen or talked to the divine told the truth?" These are 2 separated questions. Science obviously can't answer the first one, it's purely philosophical, but science can absolutely answer the second one. Finally, a last question. Does following a religion means believing in "god" or believing in the vision of god from another man? edit: I'm focusing on what I know, AKA Abrahamic religions, and I'm not talking about the morality of religious texts nor whatever wisdom they contain. So don't take my comment as a personal attack against your faith.
- js8 9y ago> Show me how one multiplies fishes. Not to detract from your argument, I think you're generally correct, but in this case: Two fish and 5 loafs of bread are enough to start a fish farm. Of course, I doubt this is what really happened, but this particular miracle is very easy to explain..
- camus2 9y agoThis is the correct answer.
- humanrebar 9y agoCare to explain it, then? I'm not sure what the point of the answer is since the miracle referenced happened in the course of one meeting. A fish farm wasn't in the picture.
- api 9y agoThose objections (fishes, etc.) only apply to literalism.
- lemagedurage 9y agoIf a superior entity created the earth including humanity, then surely it could make an exception to the rules as humanity studies it. Like using cheat codes in The Sims.
- humanrebar 9y agoWhy make exceptions to the rules to aid science? I don't know why God couldn't take premises (fundamental laws of nature) and follow them to their conclusions. Where are cheat codes needed?
- NotAChristian 9y ago>Like using cheat codes in The Sims. Like that time when Moses hacked the Matrix to open the sea?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mannykannot 9y agoReligion is not about the nature of the physical universe, even if a few of its proponents think it extends to that realm. Religion is an aspect of culture concerned with coping with existential dread - our knowledge of the mortality of ourselves and everyone we care about - which is not something that science can help with. There is no point in either party trying to shut down the other.
- humanrebar 9y ago> Religion is not about the nature of the physical universe Why not? > There is no point in either party trying to shut down the other. Agreed! There's definitely plenty of room for tolerance and appreciation of diverse perspectives.
- mannykannot 9y agoI was thinking in terms of the practice of religion. While a religion often has an associated cosmology and other myths about the physical world, they have little effect on most believer's lives (not even in their religious observances, specifically), and religions do not generally change fundamentally, let alone fall, if their beliefs about the physical world are found to be unrealistic.
- humanrebar 9y ago> While a religion often has an associated cosmology and other myths about the physical world, they have little effect on most believer's lives... I'd go the other way and say that religions that have little effect on believers' lives don't mean much. They are just more fluid tribal associations. > ...religions do not generally change fundamentally, let alone fall, if their beliefs about the physical world are found to be unrealistic I think they do. I think Christian Science (not actually a type of Christianity, by the way) has been limited in popularity because of the failure of its beliefs to work in reality (1). So there's probably a lot of survivor bias going on. (1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Science#Child_deaths.2C_prosecutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Science#Child_deaths...
- mbrock 9y agoThat argument if you deploy it against for example gender becomes rather inpalatable for most people. Gender roles are to a very large extent made up of "arbitrary cultural baggage" but reasoning like that provokes almost an allergic reaction for people who after all base their identity and personality on them. I imagine there are quite a lot of people who, if you insist on the argument that their male identity is an arbitrary construction, would literally hurt you rather than accept your argument... which probably says more about the specific nature of the male gender construct, but still. Cultural constructs are extremely important and fundamental for people's identities, communities, narratives, etc. If you strip away enough cultural baggage, there is a reasonable fear that you would end up with no recogngizable human mind, no basis for any action or thought. Christianity went through a phase of rational universalism, scholasticism etc, but now it doesn't seem to want to engage in the arena of global universal truth. Instead Christians are either "nationalistic", "pluralistically tolerant", or "individually mystical", I would say. The concept of divinity is also extremely abstract, nuanced, slippery, and multifaceted; there are a lot of different theological theories, and they change over time. My major point is that religions tend to have a privileged position as the root or ground of a whole cultural complex, and that makes them really hard to be rational about; you'd first have to convince someone that they ought to subject the very root of their identity and community to rational scrutiny, which does appear risky; that's why Camus said "to begin to think is to begin to be undermined."
- freeflight 9y ago> Ultimately though until it can answer why the universe exists, not just how, it can't land a fatal blow. That's an impossible goal to set because you are pretty much asking for "a purpose" which is an utterly human concept completely alien to the universe and its mechanics. It's a philosophical question that can never be really answered by hard science. We can ask how something happens on a mechanical level, but there is no bigger purpose, there is no "grand plan" behind all of it (which would assume a planer exists with a goal in mind) stuff just exists without any ultimate designs. In my experience, it's that whole notion a lot of religious people struggle with, they can't let go of the idea that there always has to be a "why" a "bigger purpose" to their suffering or happiness, when in all actuality it's more often than not these emotions are the result of individual circumstances and/or pure chance.
- macns 9y ago> Ultimately though until it can answer why the universe exists, not just how, it can't land a fatal blow. Well if it wasn't for Science, we wouldn't even know a universe exists.
- beojan 9y agoChristians, Muslims and Jews believe in the same God, its the historical details they differ in. Buddhism is more a moral and spiritual framework than a religion (a lot of Buddhists are also Hindus). Ultimately, all that science can tell us on this matter is that it is possible that God does not exist, and it is also possible that God does exist. The matter is outside the scope of science, but atheism (as opposed to agnosticism) is just as (if not more) arbitrary a belief as any mainstream religion.
- humanrebar 9y ago> Christians, Muslims and Jews believe in the same God On the contrary, while all claim to believe in the God of Abraham, the characteristics of each God are different enough to describe different gods. For example, Jews and Muslims do not believe Jesus is God and existed before the world was created. Both consider the Christian Trinity to be heretical.
- beojan 9y agoThey all believe in the same God, they just don't believe the same things about Him. The details are important ones, but still, they're details.
- humanrebar 9y ago> The details are important ones, but still, they're details. Except for each describes salvation differently and each describes its method to salvation to be mutually exclusive from the others. Those aren't details. Not about the religion itself and not about the character of God. I could believe in "medicine" which is filling a pool with water, adding a milligram of penicillin, then drinking a gulp from the pool. You could believe in medicine that is taking penicillin in doses as prescribed by a qualified physician. We both self-identify as believing in "medicine". What counts as an "important" detail?
- beojan 9y ago> Except for each describes salvation differently and each describes its method to salvation to be mutually exclusive from the others. Christianity entirely builds upon Judaism, and Judaism doesn't provide a path to salvation that Christianity doesn't (not the opposite though). Islam is more distantly related, but they still believe in the same God. It's more like I believe the US is free, democratic, and on the whole a good place to live, while someone in North Korea believes the US is a hellhole. (I live in Europe and haven't spent any significant time in the US, so my perspective isn't inherently superior to the North Korean's.) We have very different conceptions of the US, but we're still talking about the same US.