6 ms·
This is a cultural holdover from the late 19th and earlier 20th century when novel results were much more plentiful. But now nearly all of the low-lying scient
by lisper 9y ago
This is a cultural holdover from the late 19th and earlier 20th century when novel results were much more plentiful. But now nearly all of the low-lying scientific fruit has been picked so the scientific endeavor needs to adjust its expectations. Unfortunately, culture changes more slowly than science.
BTW, the lack of new results is actually a good thing. It means we've got a lot of stuff figured out.
- dekhn 9y agoor it could mean we're stuck in a local minima due to structural barriers
- jansho 9y ago> BTW, the lack of new results is actually a good thing. It means we've got a lot of stuff figured out. Not necessarily. If anything, the more we find out, the more we realise how much we don't know. Take quantum physics, that stuff slowed down since the 1930s. It's not a bad thing, the journey's always fun too. But let's not kid ourselves that we're close to figuring everything out.
- smallnamespace 9y agoPersonally, I interpret GP as we have already proven many of the true hypotheses that can be simply and easily formulated, based on the categories and concepts that we currently find intuitive. And this shouldn't really be a surprise. Our cultures and societies have had thousands of years of evolution; our human instincts have had at least hundreds of thousands of years. In that time, both culture and instinct have picked up many true facts about the world that have helped us survive. A lot of science has been taking those facts and systematically investigating how far they hold. So these both can be true: the more questions we ask, the more questions we have to answer, but also that many of the 'easy' hypotheses have been mined out, and any true advance in science will by necessity pull us further and further from the realm where our basic instincts and intuitions can usefully guide us. Quantum mechanics being the prototypical example, of course.
- jansho 9y ago> the more questions we ask, the more questions we have to answer, but also that many of the 'easy' hypotheses have been mined out. Like a tree? The main branches are the most visible, and so the most tackled. The smaller branches are only realised when you're deep enough in it. That's where our age's advantage comes in, as we have many more qualified 'explorers' than before, but it also makes it all the more important that the foundational branches are solid. But then again it may be closer to readjusting our lens. The big questions (of the natural kind, not innovation like AI) today still pertain what we take for granted, like quantum mechanics is making us question the nature of reality again. But much like the discovery of waves once threatened the credibility of light as particles, I'm optimistic that reconciliation can happen, and to ascend to another level ... but where can we stop? When can we say "This is it"? Just musing..
- Retric 9y agoWhen you can do multiple experiments and predict the results to 8+ digits of accuracy there is little room for improvement. Your theory also needs to predict the same 8+ digits for all existing experiments while being either simpler or allowing for some new prediction that's also accurate and in disagreement with existing theory. There really are very few edge cases left for QM 2.0
- freshhawk 9y agoBut the things we realize we don't know are much harder to figure out, they take more resources (time, money, study participants, analysis, etc). That's the reason things are, and should be, slowing down. We are, clearly, close to figuring out most of the easy stuff. For our current definition of "easy" based on the amount of work, computing power and strength of the mathematical tools that we consider normal.
- jonathanstrange 9y agoMy father used to illustrate the progress of science as an island in the Sea of Unknown. The more you expand the island by gaining new knowledge, the more you get into contact with the unknown.
- dnautics 9y ago> This is a cultural holdover from the late 19th and earlier 20th century when novel results were much more plentiful. I'm not sure about that. As a former working scientist, I would say that the primary driver of this is the promotion and funding structure of science. I do agree thta a lot of low-lying fruit has been picked.
- lisper 9y ago> the primary driver of this is the promotion and funding structure of science Well, yeah, obviously. I'm saying that structure is there because it's a holdover from previous generations where novel results were easier to obtain.
- dnautics 9y agoHave you read this? http://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/saving-science http://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/saving-science
- lisper 9y agoNo, I haven't. Thanks for the link.
- sethrin 9y agoIf we are to measure science by its technological results, then we would judge Arrhenius' paper on global warming to be a failure because it didn't result in any iPhones being sold. The author illustrates a difference in value systems, but it's sort of inherent to those that one can't meaningfully argue one against the other. I think the problem is with our incentives, not our institutions.
- fsloth 9y agoThe funny thing is the results where gained either through paced pondering or by ridiculously talented individuals like von Neuman. Big science for non-applied fields is an oxymoron. Once a principle is figured out you can chuck a ton of people at it. But before that arrives, you can't pretend everyone is von Neuman and put them racing against each others. It seems there is no room for time and craftmanship in the publish-or-perish approach to science.
- Balgair 9y ago> But now nearly all of the low-lying scientific fruit has been picked so the scientific endeavor needs to adjust its expectations. Of our current energy/resolution paradigms We know that ~20% of the universe is Dark Matter and that ~75% is Dark Energy. All we really know about Dark Matter is that it falls down and doesn't really interact with itself or anything else, really. Dark Energy? Yeah, whatever it is, it pushes galaxies apart, that's about all we got. There are a LOT of pretty easy discoveries to be made yet, but we just don't have the engineering to make them yet. The LHC was a marvel of engineering, but it can't even come close to the energy required to produce (theorized) Dark Matter particles. If you tried to make a bigger one, you'd need an LHC with a radius larger than the Earth's. That's not going to happen anytime soon, not by a long shot. We need another method than particle colliders, probably a very large space-based telescope to stare at black-holes with jets. Biology is also rife with 'easy' things to do, but ones that we just don't have the tech for yet. Strangely, with all of the data that the Googs and the Zuck have, we have not seen a similar paradigm shift in psychology, criminology, or economics. At least in public literature.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lisper 9y agoI didn't say there was nothing left to be discovered, I said that most of the low-lying fruit has been picked. Obviously there's a lot left to be discovered, but what's left is manifestly more difficult to figure out than what has already been figured out.
- ebcode 9y agoFood for thought: it could be that the already-picked "low-lying fruit" is responsible for new discoveries being harder to make. Once you get into a certain mode of thinking, or come to view the world a certain way, it becomes harder to see the world as operating any differently. So, maybe it's not so much that we have stuff "figured out", as it is that we have mental models that, while they work well enough to make certain predictions, also constrain our thinking in terms of what phenomena are possible. The "EM drive" controversy is one example of this tension.
- mfukar 9y agoWhat constitutes the "low-hanging fruit" changes constantly. I suspect that trying to quantify them at any given point in time is as infeasible as it is useless.