9 ms·
I think that's less relevant than it used to be. JetBrains is now the de facto best IDE for Java, JavaScript, Python and PHP. It has Android Studio and even sup
by tootie 9y ago
I think that's less relevant than it used to be. JetBrains is now the de facto best IDE for Java, JavaScript, Python and PHP. It has Android Studio and even support for C#. Visual Studio also supports a wide array of languages. I'm in IntelliJ pretty much all the time, no matter the project.
- carlmr 9y agoI program a lot in C, F# and Python. I mostly use visual studio code (electron app similar to Atom, but better). It's great if you're using languages which don't come in one IDE, or where you need to pay for the IDE (F#).
- aquaticor 9y agoTake a look at full Visual Studio, it's a much better IDE for F#, the free version beats vscode for F# dev hands down. Though I like VS code for its portability.
- kllrnohj 9y agoIntelliJ is expensive if you want languages not covered by the free edition (like JavaScript), though, and even if you pay for it some things are frustratingly distinct such as if you have a Java/C++ app you need two different "IDEs" (CLion + IntelliJ), and you need to then juggle between those windows. Android Studio is able to work with both even though IntelliJ Ultimate isn't (why, Jetbrains, why!?), but getting Android Studio to work on non-Android things isn't the nicest of experiences. I'd be more willing to pay for the quality if a nice, unified experience was the result, but it annoyingly isn't. To say nothing of the lack of support for things like Rust. That's what this new generation of IDEs is exciting to me - the unified language server standards. Let the compilers handle understanding the code which is what they are best at. Especially if it helps make IDEs less tied to the build system in general (no, CLion, I don't want to use CMake)
- noir_lord 9y agoIntellij Ultimate costs me £14 a month, with the plugins (which makes it equivalent to Phpstorm, PyCharm, Rubymine and Webstorm) thats less than I spend on coffee in two weeks, it's insane value however you look at it. That said I still spend a chunk of time (maybe 30%) in vscode because for somethings I prefer it (it's git support with git lens is incredible) and for TypeScript it's comparable to Intellij with the advantage you can start it, do an edit and close before Intellij has finished re-indexing.
- tym0 9y agoI keep seeing people writing about these "cheap" intellij subscriptions but on the website it's 400 pounds a year.
- pjmlp 9y agoI really would like to see this utopian world where all other professions outside IT also get their tools for free.
- noir_lord 9y agoMy grandfather was a master carpenter, he had a saying I've always liked "If you use something for more than an hour a day buy the best you can afford". I've never minded paying for developer tools as long as I could afford them, lots of professionals spend a lot more than we do on tools/professional development.
- khedoros1 9y agoHow did he feel about perpetually renting them? Even if the tool is currently perfect, I don't trust that the company's future plans will align with my future needs; I expect that they'll diverge. edit: I stand corrected; didn't see the asterisk and the separate page specifying that an active subscription isn't necessary to continue using the current version of the software.
- 9y ago
- pjmlp 9y agoExpensive?!? It is a bargain compared with what I used to pay for programming tools during the 90's. In other professions people care to buy their tools.
- wolfgke 9y ago> In other professions people care to buy their tools. JetBrains' tools have to be rented.
- dbb01 9y agoThis isn't accurate. When you now pay for a year long "subscription" you own that version and can use it indefinitely. Exactly like buying a version-license previously.
- electrum 9y ago> JetBrains' tools have to be rented. That's not correct. JetBrains subscriptions come with a perpetual fallback license for the version available when you purchased the subscription. This is basically the same as the previous model where you would buy a license for a specific version with free upgrades for some period of time afterwards. Most people would continuously buy the upgrade license they wanted to stay on the latest version. https://sales.jetbrains.com/hc/en-gb/articles/207240845-What-is-perpetual-fallback-license- https://sales.jetbrains.com/hc/en-gb/articles/207240845-What...
- tootie 9y agoLike when you used to have buy your compilers.
- digitalsanctum 9y agoRelative to the productivity gains from IntelliJ it's well worth the price. It's pretty much the only development tool I gladly pay for.
- nine_k 9y agoI don't remember if IntelliJ Community Edition's license disallows usage of third-party plugins for languages already coered by JetBrains's paid products. If not, anyone can create e.g. a free and open Python or Ruby IDE inside the familiar IntelliJ IDE experience, e.g. by adopting IDE-like software used in Emacs, Vim, or Sublime. See also: language servers. I think that the future is "the editor of your choice" + "the language servers you can afford". JetBrains's IDE is already modular, but these modules just happen to run in the same Java process. This limitation of IDE architecture can be overcome, and companies like Microsoft keep pouring efforts into it.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoDunno I used to think it was, for businesses. But if you buy your own personal license you're paying a lot less than you would for Visual Studio overall. I was fortunate to have a discount for having had a student license, so I got like 40% off the price tag or something. I paid under $200 for software that allows me to make thousands every year. Not only do you get all those fancy Java IDE's but you get ReSharper and the whole family for Visual Studio. I say it's underpriced, and every year I renew they lower the price, but my license is perpetual the moment I stop renewing for a year. I think if they charged me $300 a year I'd still find it worth it considering all they give me in return. I'm able to be much more productive in not just .NET, but Python, Java, JavaScript, PHP and other languages, and hopefully someday a Rust IDE comes out of their workshop.
- Others 9y agoThis is tangential, but the IntelliJ Rust plugin is fantastic, and just got officially supported! (http://intellij-rust.github.io http://intellij-rust.github.io)
- rootlocus 9y agoIf you check the changelog [1] you'll see the rust plugin has been officially support for a little over a year. 1. https://intellij-rust.github.io/thisweek/ https://intellij-rust.github.io/thisweek/
- Others 9y agoI meant "officially supported by JetBrains" (https://intellij-rust.github.io/2017/07/31/changelog-47.html https://intellij-rust.github.io/2017/07/31/changelog-47.html)
- ci5er 9y agoI get your pain ... the Verilog Synopsis integration party took about a decade to get over, and at $20K+/seat, it hurt to have to shell out for 2~3 independent-but-each-necessary licenses (as an indie). But, for JetBrains, at $200/seat/year ... as an Indie making anything more than $150/hour, why would you even worry about it? EDIT: I'm mostly a vi guy, so I don't really know my ass from a hole in the ground w.r.t. IDEs. It's just ridiculous to me that a professional might complain about a $200 tool being expensive. But, your constraints are not my constraints, so I'm probably being overly judgemental. And, for that, if I am, I am sorry.
- babaganoosh89 9y agoNot true for Javascript, the cool thing about VS code is that it will automatically download the typescript definition files even if you aren't using typescript. So you get much nicer hover and autocompletion than intelliJ/webstorm.
- ArlenBales 9y agoHe did say IDE, VS code is still considered an editor (like Atom, Sublime Text, etc.)
- Rotareti 9y agoI'm not using JS anymore, but when I did I remember IntelliJ Idea using the typescript definitions as well. There was a section for it in the settings menu.
- manyxcxi 9y agoI love IntelliJ for most languages. When it comes to JS/HTML/CSS though I use VS Code... I find it's IntelliSense and TypeScript support superior. Especially when I'm on a project using webpack/sass/etc. IDEA just seems to get lost. It either can't find a method definition or is constantly complaining about various things.
- Rotareti 9y agoDid you try WebStorm? Idea is a Java IDE. AFAIK you don't get the same experience from Idea+Plugins that you get from the dedicated version (in this case WebStorm). If you extend Idea with plugins you get what's available for the limited community editon.
- manyxcxi 9y agoI have IDEA Ultimate, which, as you said, allows the same functionality via plugins but isn't the same experience. WebStorm is somewhat better, but I'm not going to pop for another license when I technically already have that functionality covered. I haven't tried WebStorm since 2016, so my last experience is dated but I've just gotten to like VS Code for front end work.
- robohamburger 9y agoI still use vim over pycharm and I write quite a bit of python and spent quite a bit of time using pycharm and setting it up. Most big IDE features break down in large code bases and for simple code bases, vim's python support is fine.
- OJFord 9y ago> Visual Studio... Isn't it basically an Atom alternative? What makes it, and not Atom, an IDE rather than 'augmented text editor', to borrow GP's phrasing?
- PetitPrince 9y agoI think you are mixing up Visual Studio Code, the free and open source text editor with Visual studio, the closed source and paid IDE.
- OJFord 9y agoAh, guilty as charged, thanks!
- sasmithjr 9y agoNot sure if they mean Visual Studio or Visual Studio Code. VSCode is an Electron-based editor similar to Atom; full-fat Visual Studio does support many languages by itself, but it's Windows only.
- disordinary 9y agoThat's not 100% true, there is Visual Studio Mac which is based off Xamarin Studio but has a lot of the internals from Visual Studio in it like InteliSense and Roslyn
- yaseer 9y agoI agree; I use intellij for the consistent experience across languages. It's difficult to beat vim (or Emacs) for quick edits. But for deep-dive coding I'm gladly sold in on jetbrains.
- mmgutz 9y agodefacto "BEST" for Javascript? I think you would be suprised how many people do not use JetBrains products at all if you went to a JavaScript meetup.
- tootie 9y agoBest != most used. I think most Java developers still use Eclipse.
- hobarrera 9y ago>>>> JetBrains is now the de facto best IDE for Java, JavaScript, Python I can't speak for most languages, but for Python it seems to be very far from the "de facto"; I've only seen a few people, and most people strongly dislike it.