3 ms·
No matter how you cut it the failure mode trying to drive a car of known dimensions though a smaller space than those dimensions is pretty inexcusable. >The ma
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
No matter how you cut it the failure mode trying to drive a car of known dimensions though a smaller space than those dimensions is pretty inexcusable.
>The machine learning algorithms that underpin AEB systems have only been trained to recognize the rear of other vehicles, not profiles or other aspects
Does Tesla's software make the assumption that the lane is safely navigable unless it detects otherwise?
IMO it's pushing the envelope of recklessness to have a default software of "good to go" for a non-critical system (whereas something like a shipboard fire suppression system should default to "good to go" in order to prevent corner cases from impacting functionality).
While I understand that you don't want the car braking aggressively when it encounters a bag blowing in the wind or poor lane markings mid-corner not driving into something those are behaviors that are not unexpected from an excessively conservative human driver and preferable to running into the back of a van that's parked on the side of the road.
edit: If you're gonna down-vote you might wanna say why.
- plaidfuji 9y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoyed because it's a good point. How in the world do you let a computer vision decision override the other sensors that are saying "massive wall is moving in front of the car"? And who tf thought training the CV only on the backs of cars was good enough? The edge cases are what cause accidents, not the typical situations.
- mandevil 9y agoBecause a lot of this is transient signals that are crap? One of our robots back in '06 would panic stop every 30 seconds or so whenever there was a dust cloud (this was an army off road formation project, so dust was a fact of life for all the followers) because occasionally there would be enough random scatter returns from the dust to convince the MMWR that there was a wall in front of it. Panic stopping from highway speeds every time your MMWR detected a flyer floating in the breeze near some dust seems like it would be pretty dangerous- especially for the cars behind you that are also traveling at highway speeds. And LADAR doesn't have the range to be useful at highway speeds (from memory, the ratio of range to safe braking distances means you can't get above 25-30kmh with LADAR being useful for you). As for whether having shared autonomy at highway speeds is a good idea, that's a really good question that I hope Tesla is asking itself right now. But if you are trying to do that, cameras pretty much have to be your primary source of truth.