5 ms·
Is it inevitable? I'd love it if I can pay for things by just scanning a QR code, but the number of merchants accepting Bitcoin feels like it's going down, even
by StavrosK 9y ago
Is it inevitable? I'd love it if I can pay for things by just scanning a QR code, but the number of merchants accepting Bitcoin feels like it's going down, even though Stripe has made it trivial to support.
I would very much like to see everyone move away from speculation and into actual use, but it's not looking good...
- mparr4 9y agoBitcoin is a value store. It likely won't ever be widely used to purchase a cup of coffee. Other cryptocurrencies (eg. Litecoin) will pop up to fill this niche.
- StavrosK 9y agoIn this future, why isn't the cryptocurrency that's used to buy a cup of coffee also used as a store of value?
- 21 9y agoFor the same reason you don't buy coffee with a treasury bond. Bitcoin at the moment is just not a good debit card/pocket money for a number of reasons. While this might change, the rest of the world isn't staying put either. In EU/US now you can have almost realtime bank transfers, which was one major pain point in the past.
- StavrosK 9y agoI'm not asking why you can't buy a cup of coffee with the store of value. I'm asking why the currency you buy a cup of coffee with can't be the store of value.
- Taek 9y agoLitecoin has the same fundamental bottleneck as bitcoin, every node most must process every transaction. And, the Bitcoin network will eventually have lightning (it's in beta testing now, not just theory anymore), which will more cleanly enable things like coffee purchases.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoExcept Litecoin afaik has changed that when they did their fork of the Bitcoin codebase. The problem isn't as bad as you might think, compare blockchain size of Litecoin to another blockchain with similar amount of transactions / coins, the filesize of the entire blockchain is ridiculous. The other alternative is to host your wallet on a remote server that has already downloaded the whole blockchain, or use someone else's service that does the very same, Electrum comes to mind in the case of BTC. Edit: Litecoin adopted "segwit" or "Segmented Witnesses" so the blockchain size isn't what it used to be. Some were pushing for this with Bitcoin, others were pushing another direction, hence Bitcoin Cash. Disclaimer: I am not a complete and total expert in the crypto world, just still picking up things here and there. There's definitely way too much to digest in my free time, and I was mining some BTC for fun back in 2010...
- AgentME 9y agoBitcoin has segwit too. Litecoin's blockchain is smaller because it has fewer transactions on it. One of Litecoin's claims to fame is that it has a smaller block confirmation time. It's not some technological break-through but just the tweaking of a constant with trade-offs. Adjusting the block time down means network latency and bandwidth are a bigger deal to miners and can increase the block orphan rate, possibly resulting in a small push toward miner centralization compared to a higher block time. Though as the Lightning Network comes to Bitcoin (and Litecoin), users will be able to make transactions without waiting for block confirmations (while still getting the same guarantees against counterparty risk and doublespends), decreasing the benefit of shorter block times.
- ericb 9y agoThe current bitcoin core team is optimizing for tiny blocks which means less space for transactions. They are doing this for reasons that don't hold up well if you examine them compared to other solutions (a whole nother ball of wax). Tiny blocks means higher fees, which is a disincentive to use bitcoin as currency (it still works as a store of value). Bitcoin core is trying to solve this with a centralized layer 2 lightening network, which sort of defeats the point of a decentralized currency. Bitcoin cash, however, is a fork that is planning on scaling on layer 1 with bigger blocks and smaller fees. I would keep an eye on how adoption goes for bitcoin cash in the next year or so. I would also watch Monero usage in actual cash transactions, as it is the most fungible.
- corford 9y ago>Monero usage in actual cash transactions Monero is even worse than Bitcoin when it comes to scaling issues. Quite a few projects are working on strong privacy/fungability coins without the scaling problems but it's hard. Zencash is the one I'm watching.
- ericb 9y ago> Monero is even worse than Bitcoin when it comes to scaling issues. True, and fees are higher because of it, but they are working on that. I should have explained why I mentioned it. I list it mainly because it wins on fungibility, so I can see where it might follow a similar adoption pattern to bitcoin, where it becomes the darknet currency of choice, then expands outward. I think this is more likely if either the traceability of bitcoin becomes an issue, or if bitcoins with "tainted history" become harder to spend.
- mrb 9y agoIt is a very narrow-minded view to think that "customers paying merchants" is the only use case of Bitcoin... There is a lot more growth and potential in other areas: remittances, store of value, B2B payments, informal person-to-person transactions, paying foreign remote employees, collecting donations internationally, etc. It is all these areas that people are not seeing and thinking about when evaluating Bitcoin. Paying the proverbial cup of coffee in Bitcoin is probably the least interesting use case for Bitcoin. And why would you think that Bitcoin's use is not looking good? The transaction rate, the best indicator of actual use, is sharply increasing: https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions?timespan=all&daysAverageString=7 https://blockchain.info/charts/n-transactions?timespan=all&d... (this indicator is not typically impacted by mere speculators: buying coins and leaving them on an exchange does not create a transaction)
- branchless 9y agoTransaction rate is all down to speculation. Payment systems already work fine with minimal cost. Store of value: yes you cannot overissue but the speculation tide could go out removing the store of value. Gold was/is volatile.
- mrb 9y ago«Transaction rate is all down to speculation.» Did you read what I wrote? "this indicator is not typically impacted by mere speculators: buying coins and leaving them on an exchange does not create a transaction" «Payment systems already work fine» It took me 7 days to move $300k from one bank account to another, because of closures on weekends & ACH limits. This is not "working well". With Bitcoin I can move $100k+ in ~10 minutes. I have had many instances of credit card payments being declined while travelling internationally due to false positives from anti-fraud systems. This is not "working well". In 2013 I couldn't even pay my rent using my bank's electronic payment system, even though my landlord and I had the same bank, because of arbitrary policy limit of $2k/mo for personal payments. This is not "working well". I have had paypal steal ~2% through forex fees for a transfer to my family overseas. This is not "working well". I have had fraudulent merchants stealing my CC info and created a bunch of hassle that took me time to sort out. This is not "working well". And so on. Bitcoin may not be perfect, but it solves all these scenarios incredibly well.
- corford 9y agoI think it will get there eventually. Segwit adoption, lightning network support, successfully navigating the upcoming fork etc. will bring transaction fees and confirmation times down. Even if 1BTC hits $100K in a few years, the smallest fraction of a bitcoin is 0.00000001 (or $0.001).
- 21 9y agoIsn't touching your contactless card (or NFC phone) kind of like scanning the QR code? It's certainly faster - 0.3 sec I would say for the read, 5 sec for the confirmation. What is the major difference in your view, from the usability point of view, since you didn't mentioned politics in your post, just convenience?