4 ms·
The problem with the semantic web is you need a universal ontology. i.e. you need everyone to agree on the same thing. Cory Doctorow's Metacrap explains more ht
by rmc 16y ago
The problem with the semantic web is you need a universal ontology. i.e. you need everyone to agree on the same thing. Cory Doctorow's Metacrap explains more http://www.well.com/~doctorow/metacrap.htm http://www.well.com/~doctorow/metacrap.htm
- _pius 16y agoThat's a strawman. You in fact don't need a "universal ontology," you just need people to agree on first principles (e.g. URLs are unique, there are things called triples, etc.)
- keefe 16y agoYes. Absolutely correct. I worked at a semweb company for years, it's all about making a small functional ontology for a particular purpose. Of course, that leads to the question : is that ontology actually relevant or is it just important that the data is structured?
- joe_the_user 16y agoI think you do need a universal ontology if you want to make the kind of progress the semantic web people talk about. If you just have a bunch of small, separately created ontologies, the situation can indeed seem great until each expands. Then the intersections and ambiguities become huge. Sure, if you weren't concerned exactness and lack of ambiguity, you could expand the world of triples into a giant, poorly organized collection of information. It would be kind of like the web. The approach "works" but we, uh, already have the web. Also, the Doctorow document excellent. Anyone expected naive metadata to be extensible should have a reply to it.
- _pius 16y agoIf you just have a bunch of small, separately created ontologies, the situation can indeed seem great until each expands. Then the intersections and ambiguities become huge. Inferencing solves this problem.
- neilk 16y agoThat's a reason why the Semantic Web won't wake up and become conscious, like many bad sci-fi stories. However, if you think of it "vocabularies for people to tag their own stuff in a structured way", which Google can then index and traverse, then it's more realistic. That said, the Semantic Web people are indeed guilty of hyping this technology as being able to "reason" on its own.
- robryan 16y agoI think even small agreed upon ontologies in different areas would be a big step up from the virtually none that we have. Current services like the experimental google squared currently have nothing to work with. Even a complicated mesh of partially interlinking ontologies would be better. What about Facebook's new metadata? What are people in the semantic web area saying about that?