7 ms·
Imagine a wildlife photographer trying to get a picture of a bear at night. Maybe she would set up something to attract the bear, then use a motion sensor to tr
by pavlov 9y ago
Imagine a wildlife photographer trying to get a picture of a bear at night. Maybe she would set up something to attract the bear, then use a motion sensor to trigger the camera. Clearly she is the author of the photo, even though the bear actually triggered its taking.
I feel a similar argument could be made for the monkey selfie: the photographer didn't push the button, but he created the circumstances.
- dokument 9y agoSo did the camera manufacturer.
- oba_yozo 9y agoThe question is how directly. For instance, no reasonable person would argue that the photographer's father deserves the IP rights because he helped create a necessary factor in the circumstances by which the photo got taken (the existence of the son). However, if the father didn't exist then clearly the photo would never have been taken. So the manufacturer is involved, but very indirectly. The manufacturer definitely isn't the author. Edit: Clarified my argument
- Retric 9y agoI strongly disagree, it's like someone picking up a rock and then owning the copyright on it's shape. Copywrite implies creative control and unlike a motion sensor camera the 'artist' did not define anything about the picture.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- brailsafe 9y agoWell, conceivably that could happen in the case where you pick up a rock and change it's shape.
- vacri 9y agoThe artist in this case hiked into a south-east asian jungle for the purpose of taking wildlife pictures, and spent days gaining the monkeys' trust in order to get close to them. Sounds more like the photographer defined a hell of a lot about the picture.
- kbutler 9y agoBut not the composition of the picture, the timing of the shot, or what was in the shot. The picture did not capture creative expression of the photographer.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ModernMech 9y agoSo? Isn't the point of copyright to compensate artists for their work? I.e. It's to encourage artists to produce art. Ostensibly, we would like pictures of wildlife. If the artist went through all that trouble to take pictures of monkeys, and we don't give him rights for that, we'll just end up with fewer pictures of monkeys.
- kbutler 9y agoThe purpose is "to promote the progress of science and the useful arts", the method is "by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries". In this case, the Work was created by the monkey. Yes, the camera owner helped, but he doesn't meet the established criteria of the Author in existing copyright law. Nor does the monkey (works of nature are not copyrightable). You can disagree with the law as it exists (I think terms should be drastically shorter, and in no case should copyright be extended retroactively), but it takes an act of Congress or the courts to change it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- chrisbennet 9y agoI agree. Replacing "camera" with "gun" clarifies who the "photographer" is. I.e. if someone set up a trip wire to a gun (booby trap), would the person who tripped the booby trap be a suicide victim or would the person who set up the booby trap be a murderer?
- rhizome 9y agoThe person who set it up: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/lq1w4/is_it_illegal_to_booby_trap_your_house/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/lq1w4/is_it_ille...
- amelius 9y agoI'm not sure. Learning how to use a camera is simpler than learning how to responsibly use a gun.
- int_19h 9y agoOn the other hand, if you gave someone a gun, and they were fidgeting with it and shot themselves, then it's a suicide.
- posterboy 9y agoIf you give a gun to a being of minor intelligence who then shoots itself, that won't be unadultered suicide, that will be negligent homicide at least.
- DonHopkins 9y agoIf you start shooting a video on a phone, and hand it around from person to person, does whoever was holding the camera own the copyright on all of the frames shot while they were holding it?
- kbutler 9y agoYes. Imagine if you hand it to a renowned cinematographer who films something incredibly artistically. The person composing the shot and choosing what is "fixed in a tangible medium of expression" owns the copyright. The owner of the camera doesn't automatically own copyright.
- Asooka 9y agoWait, but then if I hand my camera to someone and ask him to take my picture, I don't own the copyright of my own picture!
- posterboy 9y agoWait, does that mean you don't own the camera nomore neither?
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 9y agoMaybe this is why selfies have become so popular... One could imagine a scenario where copyright trolls would hang around in popular tourist destinations kindly helping people take photos then sue them once the images end up getting posted on social media...
- ghaff 9y agoIn a theoretical sense, probably not. It's not a work for hire. You probably gave at most vague directions about how to compose the photo. The fact that it's your camera is irrelevant. Meanwhile in the real world I somehow doubt that this has ever come up as a legal issue.
- kbutler 9y ago> Wait, but then if I hand my camera to someone and ask him to take my picture, I don't own the copyright of my own picture! Yes, that is correct. Copyright resides with the person who provides the creative expression in taking the photograph, not in the subject or person who provides the equipment. This most often comes up in the context of portrait photography/family photos. People expect that they can automatically make copies of the pictures of themselves that they paid someone else to take, but unless the contract is specifically written and signed by the photographer that the work is a "work for hire" and specifies that the copyright is owned by some other person, the copyright remains with the photographer.
- kbutler 9y agoThe difference is in composing the photo and choosing the triggering of the shot. In the motion sensor scenario, the photographer frames the shot and defines the conditions under which a photograph will be taken. In the monkey selfie, the photographer did not frame the shot, did not direct the camera, did not control conditions under which the photo would be taken (beyond the manufacturer's button). This there was not creative input by the photographer in the actual image captured.
- bigtunacan 9y agoI'm not so sure about that. Slater spent a couple of weeks with the monkeys to get this photo shot. I would suspect that he also then put the camera into a video recording mode or continuous burst plus time reviewing for a workable frame and then likely some Photoshopping.
- kbutler 9y ago"sweat of the brow" is not a consideration in us copyright law.
- pavlov 9y agoIf the camera was in a continuous shooting mode, I take it you're suggesting that the initial frames were authored by the photographer, and at some point the authorship changed after the monkeys had moved the camera enough? And the final frames in the sequence again became authored by the photographer when he grabbed the camera back? What if it had been wind moving the camera, rather than monkeys? Do you feel his authorship would have been equally lost in the middle of that sequence of frames?
- kbutler 9y agoSlater didn't assert that. """ They were quite mischievous jumping all over my equipment, and it looked like they were already posing for the camera when one hit the button,” he told The Telegraph in 2011. “The sound got his attention and he kept pressing it. He must have taken hundreds of pictures by the time I got my camera back, but not very many were in focus. He obviously hadn’t worked that out yet." """ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/howaboutthat/8615859/Monkey-steals-camera-to-snap-himself.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/howaboutthat/8615... There is some doubt whether Slater actually used a remote trigger, but that wouldn't have been as good a story as the "monkey selfie", so the image may not have gone viral, though he'd have a better case to own the copyright.
- soneil 9y agoThe 'creative input' bit gets really dodgy here. If you put a camera on the table in front of me, I pick it up, point it at my face, and press the button - I think it'd be fair to claim the copyright there belongs to me, not the person who put the camera on the table. If you replace me with a monkey, you have the original claim in a nutshell. I think the actual problem here is the strange assumption that copyright naturally exists, and must be assigned somewhere. And that if it can't be assigned because the obvious recipient isn't a legally defined 'person', it strikes out like a lost child looking for someone else to cling to.
- posterboy 9y agoSomething about enjoying the fruits of misdeeds (to be extremely critical). But your example is not specific enough for a fair claim.
- soneil 9y agoWhat specificity is missing? I think it’s fairly simple. Firstly, I think we can completely ignore "misdeeds". Nothing in the creation of this photograph occurred contrary to anyone else's wishes. In a nutshell, there was two slightly different versions of events here, which lead to opposing conclusions. The first version was the tagline the photo was originally published under. A "monkey's selfie". Now, if I say "pass me my phone", or "may I borrow your phone", and then take a 'selfie' with it; I think it's pretty clear that the "creative input" was mine, not yours. So the question becomes "if I, a monkey, am not legally recognised as a person capable of copyright - does it fall to you, or does it simply fail to be copyrighted". So that's the example I was trying to frame. That if that monkey was me, the copyright claim wouldn't even be a question (nor would anyone be looking at the photo). But ironically, the description that created the commercial demand of the photograph, also destroyed the photographer's ability to commercially exploit it. Then we got the later, long-form version of events. That the camera was intentionally staged for this, a wide-angle intentionally selected for this, the remote intentionally positioned for this, etc. "how the sausage is made", but basically the photographer reasserting that the "creative input" was his. The whole thing then got lost in a limbo; a court in the US, and the ICO in the UK, have both said animals cannot own copyright. Neither has opined on whether an animal is capable of "creative input". If they are, the monkey was likely the primary source of creative input, not the photographer (in which case there simply is no copyright). If they're not, then he'd be the sole creative input, and the copyright is his. Ultimately I think the photographer shot himself in the foot. (I do have other questions though. If a US court has said a monkey cannot own copyright, how was this PETA case even a thing? How are PETA able to assert themselves as the IP agent for an Indonesian monkey? And why are the actions of a British photographer, acting in Indonesia, being opined in a US court?)