6 ms·
> What LOE (Level of Effort) would it take to replace our current SSN with a public/private key system? More than just a massive bureaucratic shift and public r
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> What LOE (Level of Effort) would it take to replace our current SSN with a public/private key system? More than just a massive bureaucratic shift and public reeducation movement?
You are thinking about this from the wrong direction. The problem isn't that the government hasn't provided a PKI, the problem is that social security numbers are being used for identification.
This was a serious fear when social security was originally created. For many years social security cards had the words "not for identification" printed on them. They contain no biometric data, not even a picture. Their purpose is not identification.
So the solution is obvious. Actually prohibit social security numbers from being used for identification. Don't allow creditors to even ask for them.
Then people will figure something else out on their own. Instead of a credit reporting agency existing at all, new credit applications could ask for your account numbers at existing creditors and then the new creditor can get your credit history directly from them. It would be straight forward to automate this -- and even require you to prove that you're the account holder by presenting your card from the other bank (or signing into its website if online).
There is no need for a national identification system. Having a bad one was the original problem. Replacing it with some differently bad one is no better.
- emodendroket 9y ago> This was a serious fear when social security was originally created. For many years social security cards had the words "not for identification" printed on them. They contain no biometric data, not even a picture. Their purpose is not identification. That's still printed on them. > Then people will figure something else out on their own. Instead of a credit reporting agency existing at all, new credit applications could ask for your account numbers at existing creditors and then the new creditor can get your credit history directly from them. It would be straight forward to automate this -- and even require you to prove that you're the account holder by presenting your card from the other bank (or signing into its website if online). > There is no need for a national identification system. This seems like wishful thinking to me.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> This seems like wishful thinking to me. The correct answer is correct regardless of who wants it to be.
- zamalek 9y agoWhile you are correct, reality nearly always differs.
- chii 9y ago"technically correct" - the best (and worst) kind of correct.
- zdkl 9y agoAh the equally frustrating corollary to "works on my machine"
- emodendroket 9y agoI'm not sure I get the relevance, but I don't see it as self-evident that simply by banning the use of SSNs you will end up with a coherent national identification system (and if you do I'm not sure why that'd be preferable to one run by the government).
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoWe don't need a coherent national identification system. We don't have a global one, the EU doesn't have one, why does the US need one? Centralized identification is bad. There exists no competent, accountable, trustworthy party to administer it. It inherently gets abused to aggregate information about people that should be private. Monolithic systems are slow to adapt, allowing attackers to continuously outflank them. When a bank needs to identify you, let them use your bank account number. When a doctor needs to identify you, let them use your patient ID number. And never the two shall meet.
- 9y ago
- dredmorbius 9y agoSSNs aren't being used for identification (they're ... an identifier), but for authentication. That's a subtle though crucial distinction.
- cm2187 9y agoBut it is used that way for the lack of a better alternative. In my opinion the solution is a free federal ID card, where all the information on the card (including the picture) is digitally signed, to make forgery nearly impossible. The only non trivial element is how to sign the photo. I guess there must be a way to sign a degraded version of the picture so that even an average scan of the ID card would be verifiable. Or the card could contain a small, cheap, water resistant memory chip which contains the picture in digital format. Then you can have a high degree of confidence in this physical document. And there could be other usage of that card. Like if you make it a chip & pin so the card could become an unforgeable digital signature (physical signatures are absurdly unsecure too).
- steventhedev 9y agoMany other countries have these exact cards. They are not new technology. In fact, your US passport has that. Look for the biometric symbol on the front. It means there's a chip inside (not sure how to read off it) that includes your digitally signed identity details, including photo. If you're willing to go the centralized route, then a minimalist ID card would just be a QR code that anyone can open and compare the official photo to you.
- cm2187 9y agoA QR code (of I presume a URL) would be even simpler to use but creates a big point of failure, as you need to secure a central server that contains the picture of every american and needs to be accessed publicly. We know how these things tend to end. Whereas digital signing can be done in an offline, airtight system, as long as the public key is widely available.
- masklinn 9y ago> If you're willing to go the centralized route, then a minimalist ID card would just be a QR code that anyone can open and compare the official photo to you. "Just a qrcode" would be a weird and inconvenient format. Other countries (Estonia, Spain, Belgium) have smartcard IDs. You can add a qrcode to that, but the primary data store can be secured (and accessed and updated) in much the same way a regular smartcard is, you can access it from your home with a regular card reader and the relevant access application. And of course the size is completely standard. And you can add contactless support to it if desirable. Plus the US already has experience with these types of IDs: DoD has issued 17 million Common Access Cards.
- Splatter 9y agoI've worked on several (poorly designed) systems where the SSN is used as a primary key. In itself, the SSN is not for identification, but as a primary key, it is used to aggregate tons of data about a person. Just think of the scores of databases where data elements exist that are associated by SSN. It's the possession of that primary key linking all of our data that is the security issue.
- alkonaut 9y agoThey will figure out that they need some form of 2FA. There is a very simple and crude way of 2FA: Mail. If you say "I'm bob smith with SSN 12345", then you gave them your id. You didnt' verify that you are in fact bob smith with SSN 12345. Now they have to verify with some degree of certainty that you are. So they lookup your address, and send a regular paper mail describing what needs to be authorized, and you sign and return it (or call a number and enter a code, or visit a website, or whatever). This kind of crude 2FA can still be circumvented by someone stalking you mailbox, but it's a lot better than nothing. Now: what this requires is a mapping from name+ssn (or some unique identifier) to an up to date address. Having that has several other benefits when it comes to e.g. automatic voter registration etc.
- ghaff 9y agoHistorically something like this, with our without transactions involving SSN, was pretty common. Forget the PIN associated with your frequent flyer account? The airline would send you a new PIN in the mail that would arrive in about a week or so. There are obvious latency issues with this though and it would mostly be considered less than optimal today.
- alkonaut 9y agoRight. So this mail 2FA is clearly not good enough for general use, but you really only need to use it once. Just like the airline just mailed the PIN for the next auth, so would a reasonable digital ID work too. Make a national digital ID app. Applicants fill in a web form saying they want to have it. They enter their personal ID number (SSN or equivalent). The one time key for the digital ID is then sent to the mail address. The user installs the digital ID app on their smartphone/computer and enters the key from the mail. Now they can use that app to 2FA anything: fill in their tax returns online, buy things online, send money to anyone else, login to their internet bank or any other website (by open API), manage social security and other systems, apply for schools etc. This must sound like science fiction in the US but it's been a reality for 5-10 years where I live.
- 9y ago
- hn_throwaway_99 9y ago> Instead of a credit reporting agency existing at all, new credit applications could ask for your account numbers at existing creditors and then the new creditor can get your credit history directly from them. How would this even be remotely viable? Why would you expect people to be honest about their credit histories in cases where they had late payments or some sort of default?
- cuckcuckspruce 9y agoPlaces that extend credit often take into account incomplete data - my girlfriend was denied for an apartment lease because she didn't have __enough__ credit history.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> How would this even be remotely viable? Why would you expect people to be honest about their credit histories in cases where they had late payments or some sort of default? Why would you expect people to not just give someone else's social security number?
- djsumdog 9y agoOr creating a real citizen identification number: An ID that is connected to your photo and your finger prints at the federal level .. You know, like every other high income country in the world. In America this would be impossible though. People would cry about state's rights, sign of the beast, privacy, etc.
- noxToken 9y ago> In America this would be impossible though. People would cry about state's rights, sign of the beast, privacy, etc. I don't understand this logic, so perhaps someone can help me out. Nearly all US citizens has a SSN or tax ID number that is tied to them at the federal level. The first is a pseudo-random (I use that term loosely) group of digits that is basically required for you to get anything accomplished in the US. There are no safeguards built in to the SSN, yet it is the most ubiquitous form of unique identification used in the US with no easy way to escape it. If yours gets compromised, you're screwed, and no one is willing to help you. A driver's license is a step down from that. Most Americans will have a state drivers license or state issued ID. No, it's not federal, but you're still entered into a government database where the information can be shared nationally if needed. On the other hand, a bonafide identification system with real safeguards to protect your identity would alleviate so many headaches, and it would be no more invasive than an SSN. What is the actual drawback to a national ID?
- jinfiesto 9y agoDo you live in the US? There's a deeply ingrained distrust of the government basically everywhere. You're right that it's beyond rational. I've had conversations here where people would rather the government do literally nothing about a problem than attempt solutions that could not possibly be worse than the status quo because of how deep government distrust runs.
- noxToken 9y agoI do. That's why it baffles me. It's so very irrational to me. I don't trust the government to get a lot of things right, but a simple ID system (even when poorly implemented) can't be any worse than SSN as ID. Lots of significant things use an SSN as a key - medical records, tax information, credit history, financial accounts. An SSN is one of the identifying things that the government definitely has access to. They could easily strong-arm their way around different agencies/companies with an SSN, so protection from government (in my eyes) is a non-argument. A nationalized ID is supposed to protect us from unscrupulous 3rd parties. If you get someone's name and SSN, you can do a quick public records look up for an address. Confirm it with one company (say a cable co.) and you have unfettered access to that person's life. I don't think the government could actually do worse than SSN as ID. It's a pseudo-random number with the person's place of birth and time of birth as "seeds". I already assume that Uncle Sam has (or at least access to) troves of data on me. So can they do me a favor and at least give me a half-assed ID system?