4 ms·
So in short, robots do the boring and physically demanding tasks, making the humans more efficient. No workers were laid off. I see the benefits of "relieving"
by wongarsu 9y ago
So in short, robots do the boring and physically demanding tasks, making the humans more efficient. No workers were laid off.
I see the benefits of "relieving" humans of boring jobs, but most of the article seems like a weird PR spin. Nobody got fired because Amazon is expanding its warehouses rapidly enough that those people have work to do despite the robots. Without this modernization Amazon would have needed to hire more workers, meaning this is still a net job loss.
- riku_iki 9y agoAnd workers were likely laid off from other companies who lost competition.
- adventured 9y agoThat assumes a zero sum game, which is not how the world actually works. Which is why China could go from $1.x trillion to $11.x trillion in GDP in just ~17 years, while the US - the world's largest economy - simultaneously still managed to add $8+ trillion to its GDP. Global and local economic growth makes it possible to absorb slack labor. Which is why we have 7+ billion people on earth, while simultaneously the global median income has been rising for decades nearly non-stop, the global median living standard is at an all-time high, and famines are at an all-time low. If it worked in any regard as a zero sum game, most of those people would be dead or never would have existed in the first place.
- krapp 9y agoThey do some of the boring and physically demanding tasks. Robots bring the bins, but humans still stand there putting things into them or taking things out of them, and that is still incredibly boring, albeit necessary because those taks require visual acuity and fine motor skills, which are currently kind of hard problems in robotics and AI. And even though those human jobs are standardized as much as possible, there are still inefficiencies in the system, many of which are (in my inexpert opinion) caused by the design of the bins and UI deficiencies in the stowing app. If Amazon really wants to improve employee efficiency, I think they could do well to invest more in their internal tools.
- GCA10 9y agoVery few parents say: "I hope my child can get a shipping center job stacking bins, day after day, and hold that job for 40 years." Shipping-center automation is going to move people out of rote jobs in the same way that farm automation sent a lot of workers off the land. From this story, it sounds as if the people working at Amazon shipping centers have found mildly more palatable jobs that could lead (with more training) to better paying careers in industrial operations, design, etc. We can (and should!) argue about how fast "better" jobs are taking shape. We can explore ways of making that happen more systematically so that children of pallet stackers have a brighter future. But it's a dim world if we think rote labor like pallet stacking ought to be preserved as long as possible.
- notatoad 9y agonobody says they want their kid to have a job stacking bins, but there is a need for low-skill, low-training jobs. "Industrial operations, design, etc" are jobs for skilled employees who want a career. Not everybody wants a career, or wants to go to school. Some people are just looking to stack bins for a few months to fund their travel or surfing or whatever.
- jdietrich 9y ago>Very few parents say: "I hope my child can get a shipping center job stacking bins, day after day, and hold that job for 40 years." For a lot of parents, the possibility of their children having a secure full-time job is a lofty aspiration. Millions of Americans are trapped in cycles of unemployment or in low-wage jobs with no security and no benefits. Vast swathes of the US are blighted by long-term unemployment, crumbling infrastructure and a lack of inward investment. Amazon aren't buying these robots out of some altruistic desire to lighten the burden of their workers. Their treatment of warehouse staff is notoriously dreadful. If Bezos could fire every single worker in his warehouses, I have absolutely no doubt that he would. Better jobs would be great, but at the moment we just need jobs. http://articles.mcall.com/2011-09-18/news/mc-allentown-amazon-complaints-20110917_1_warehouse-workers-heat-stress-brutal-heat http://articles.mcall.com/2011-09-18/news/mc-allentown-amazo... http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/amazon-devastating-expose-accuses-internet-retailer-of-oppressive-and-callous-attitude-to-staff-10458159.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/amazon-devas...