12 ms·
The Equifax Breach Exposes America's Identity Crisis
- krzrak 9y ago"We need laws that limit the collection and use of SSNs." The problem shouldn't be defined as "let's still keep SSN secret, but limit its collection", because sooner or later your SSN will leak. The issue is that SSN number shouldn't be considered as secret and some other measures should be used to identify the person.
- bsder 9y agoAnything collected will eventually leak. The issue is that companies shouldn't be collecting ANYTHING, and what they do collect should get purged ASAP. The problem is that every company got addicted to collecting information and nobody made them pay the price for doing so.
- scient 9y agoThere are legitimate use cases where collecting and storing (in some manner at least) is necessary. You cannot just stop companies from collecting information, and furthermore stop them from storing any of it. Thats just naive.
- thanksgiving 9y agoThe private university I went to used to issue student emails that were first three letters of last name followed by last four digits of social security number. It always seemed odd to me. Years later, they've switched and we don't have that problem any more. Companies can generate a unique identifier without using SSN. Of course, the main problem is that they can't do authentication based on that identifier. So why can they do authentication based on SSN?
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoSSN is the only reliable way to disambiguate duplicate names. Differentiating all the John Smiths by mailing address is too intractable, especially when you have JS Jr. and JS III living together. It is used to construct a primary key for the database.
- ihattendorf 9y agoOr just assign duplicates/everyone a generated unique/sequential number?
- WorldMaker 9y agoExcept that's not always been the case, either. SSNs have always been a terrible way to disambiguate people. There are weird, crazy edge cases in SSN history. Cases exactly such as JS Jr getting the same SSN as JS III in a podunk town because the local SSA administrator was feeling lazy that day and JS III was already deceased. The federal SSA website claims that that never happened, but if you have a big enough database (say, Equifax) you can spot all kinds of simple dumb human errors like that. For many, many years the SSA left local administrators in charge: the first 5 digits and the weird way they are hyphenated were local district numbers. For people born before 2011 (!), when the new randomization scheme was switched to, there is a 90% chance you can guess their first five numbers if you know their birth date and birth city (which is why it is so ridiculous that PII rules to keep SSNs safe ever considered it fine to show only the last four, those are only meaningful digits for still the majority of SSNs in the wild). SSNs were never designed for what the credit bureaus and banks and insurance companies (and everybody else) use them for, and there are too many cracks and failure cases. Companies need to admit their failures and come up with a real solution; but companies have so much sunk cost in SSN-keyed databases they aren't likely to ever actually do that. (Maybe this Equifax breach pushes more companies to try. Cynicism says companies remain cheap and invested in their sunk costs.)
- bsder 9y agoReally? I don't buy it. A corporation needs my name, address, and probably email to do business with me. They need a credit card number when I purchase something and never else. That's IT. My phone number is not necessary (and everybody using it for 2 factor just makes everything less secure). What I buy is not necessary to record past fulfillment. When I buy is not necessary to record. Where I am is not necessary to record. etc. If a company stores this stuff and it gets leaked, they should be liable. A couple of egregiously expensive fines will stop companies from collecting this information quite nicely, thank you.
- Kiro 9y agoIn Sweden your SSN is public information. I posted the same comment on another Equifax thread and got some pretty interesting replies relevant to this discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15208223 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15208223
- jaclaz 9y agoI believe that all EU has a similar approach, it is just the US that misuse the SSN. The way it is done in Italy (it is called "Codice Fiscale") it is composed through a public algorithm from name, surname, place and date of birth with a final "control" character (derived by the preceding characters) so - with the exception of the very few cases of total homonimy - it can be recreated "on the spot". Nowadays it is however printed on an electronic card, with both a magnetic stripe and a chip and it is the actual card (together with an ID document[1]) that "authenticates" your identity (in person) while on some government sites you can use the card (with a smart card reader) to authenticate. [1] actually the main thing is the ID document, passport, ID card or - in some cases - driving license, with that you can declare your Codice Fiscale even if you don't have the actual card with you.
- slau 9y agoThanks for the great content and information. Just a minor nitpick: your identity can't be authenticated. You, as an individual, can be identified, but the only thing that can be authenticated is the piece of plastic (ensuring it is not counterfeit). I wrote down an analogy for the different lingo some months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13635820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13635820
- jaclaz 9y agoYep, sure, you are correct, that's why I put it in double quotes, more accurately the identity can be "verified" or "vaidated" by the ID card (of course authentic) or even more strictly by comparing the photo (and other description data) on the ID card to the looks of the bearer. I just checked and also en.wikipedia has a good description of the algorithm used, JFYI: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_fiscal_code_card https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_fiscal_code_card
- thesumofall 9y agoComing from another country I really have difficulties understanding why e.g., utilities would want to have your SSN. What do they get that they otherwise won’t get? Isn’t a validated address and a credit card number enough for them? What is the scenario that they try to protect against? That someone misses his 30 USD utility payment and has a CC that is not covered? That seems like a rather weak argument
- takeda 9y agoThese databases are there essentially to punish you. If you don't pay your utility bill, they report that to the credit agency, and reduces your chances of getting credit elsewhere. These credit information don't give much benefit to Americans, it gives benefits to businesses[1]. It's essentially just a global black list where business can communicate who not to do business with. This business is there for other businesses and we are the product there. This is why people generally have very shitty experience when they have to interact with them, and this is why Equifax thinks the problem is solved when they provide free one year credit monitoring service. [1] note how Equifax thought it was important notice that the core database - the one storing your credit records was not affected. None of Americans care about this, but if the core database storing record was compromised Equifax would disappear overnight without any help of the government, because none of the businesses would want to use it.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> These [sic] credit information don't give much benefit to Americans, it gives benefits to businesses Americans own, work at and consume the products of businesses. If there is a class American law generally holds above investors, in terms of protection, it's consumers. I would also argue consumers benefit from our credit rating agency system, shitty as it is--it allows more people to get cheaper credit faster and more easily than if we had to establish trust at every commercial interaction.
- njarboe 9y agoI would suggest that getting credit faster and more easily is not a benefit for consumers but a benefit to business also.
- cm2187 9y agoI think we're mixing two different purposes here. Authentication through knowledge of a SSN is an absurd practice, and is a non problem in countries which have a national ID card scheme. Introducing ID cards would be my obvious response to this leak. Not re-issuing SSN until the next major leak. Having a universal unique identifier for every individual across systems is a different matter and I am not convinced this is even desirable. In a world where no organisation is able to protect its data (or even willing since most organisations now are looking for ways to monetize it), this is making it too easy to link an identity across breaches. I don't think your utility companies have any need to know your SSN.
- thirtyseven 9y agoFor the purposes of fraud, it's fairly easy to link accounts across datasets even without a unique key like SSN. You can just guess based on name and address or something and if you're only right 90% of the time that's still a pretty big win.
- cm2187 9y agoPeople move home, particularly in the US which has a quite mobile population. Many people have many variants of their names, including middle names or long composed last names, and you have a huge number of homonyms. So while you may get a 90% hit rate on two, perfectly current, and breached at the same time datasets, I would expect that number to reduce greatly in a typical real world breach.
- vilmosi 9y agoYou would be surprised how difficult that problem is.
- newman8r 9y agoperhaps allowing tokens/passwords to be established for existing SSNs would be an alternative to national IDs. You could even create a separate token each time you needed to supply the SSN, so that if it's ever leaked, the source of the leak could be investigated.
- sagitariusrex 9y agoFor everybody who isn't acquainted with how Social Security Cards work in the US and how they came to be I highly recommend watching "Social Security Cards Explained" by CGP Grey https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus He also explains why US citizens don't have an Identity Card as opposed to many European countries.
- sitharus 9y agoThat’s quite crazy. Though here in NZ we don’t have a National ID number either, we have several different numbers for different purposes. Most places will work with a driver licence or passport number, but given there’s no need to register a change of name it gets a little tricky. If you don’t have any of those you can get a statutory declaration of identity from a local court. You just have to swear you’re the person in front of a justice of the peace and provide a passport photo.
- mdekkers 9y agoThe real crisis here is that Equifax isn't being held responsible for providing meaningful fraud protection beyond one year. When I lived in the UK, the banks were constantly trying to sell me "fraud protection" and "identity protection" - trying to argue with the salesdrones about why you think it is insane that they are trying to sell me protection against their own shoddy information security practices was useless. I'm not a big fan of over-regulating, but this is a specific issue that requires a significantly heavier hand then "i'm going to another bank" as they are all as bad as eachother.
- takeda 9y agoInstead of heavily regulating I say we should make this service obsolete by passing similar to European laws where people can request what information given company holds about them, request removal and not allowing data collection without permission. Neither of those companies provides anything valuable to ordinary citizens and the data collection they do comes with great price to us as it shown with recent Equifax fiasco.
- mdekkers 9y agowell, Equifax is big in the UK, mostly to keep track of your credit rating, to allow individuals to borrow money. I think you will find on closer inspection that EU data protection laws prove to be surprisingly flexible when it comes to things relating to money. But hey, at least we are protected from evil cookies tracking us! Talk about a fucking sleight of hand....
- selimthegrim 9y agoWould you trust them after this? https://twitter.com/webster/status/906638411930497029 https://twitter.com/webster/status/906638411930497029
- mdekkers 9y agoI don't trust them at all. Never have, never will, and I am not sure I follow the context of your comment....
- codeulike 9y agoI never realised till now that American's SSNs were supposed to be kept secret. That's absolutely ridiculous. The idea of trying to keep the UK equivalent (National Insurance Number) secret is laughable. How can anything function when an important id number is also supposed to be known by very few people?
- raarts 9y agoThe same holds for bank account numbers which seems just as ridiculous to us Europeans.
- sitharus 9y agoI’ve recently seen inside the horror that is the US interbank clearing system. It seems crazy to me. In New Zealand we regularly share bank account numbers for payments, most obviously via TradeMe, our ebay equivalent. If you had my bank account number you could authorise a payment with an approved direct debit provider, who have to keep the approval on file in case of a dispute.
- arjie 9y agoBank account numbers are on cheques. How would anyone keep them secret? By never using cheques?
- afarrell 9y agoI moved from the US to the UK last year. I have seen two paper cheques in that time. It is much more common over here to pay electronically, though both Direct Debit (receiver pull) and Standing Orders (payer push) require one person giving their bank details to someone.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoFWIW paper checks are not nearly as popular in the US as they once were. Especially hand written. They are ironically useful as a "secure" form of receiving payment because ACH is such a big gaping security hole. Receiving paper isolates you from handing out an account number.
- fit2rule 9y agoI lived in the USA for long enough to get a SSN and a credit rating, but I left some time ago. I've now discovered that my details are in this leak. Does anyone have any advice for how a non-US citizen, not currently living in the USA, can secure their data and ensure that its not being used nefariously? I.e. is there a way to permanently retire a SSN and credit rating, remotely (which doesn't involve dying, lol)?
- harryh 9y agoYou can "freeze" your credit with each of the 3 rating agencies (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion) which will prevent anyone (including yourself) from applying for credit using your information.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- animex 9y agoWhat we need is a system like a base key and derivatives keys that can be revoked / issued via some central government system. If someone's SSN gets compromised, revoke the base key and all keys are invalidated. If a individual organization's use of your key get's compromised, revoke and reissue. Most likely this all will have to happen transparently without the user really knowing what's happening under the hood. Perhaps on the blockchain?!
- youdontknowtho 9y agoa federal id smart card would be a great solution, but people won't let it happen because it might be "the mark of the beast". I'm not joking. I have heard that more than once.
- gaius 9y agoa federal id smart card would be a great solution No, it would be a terrible solution, have you seen their track record? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Personnel_Management_data_breach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Personnel_Management... http://www.silicon.co.uk/cloud/aws-cloud-security-221169 http://www.silicon.co.uk/cloud/aws-cloud-security-221169
- youdontknowtho 9y agodo you really think that the individual states can do better?
- mindslight 9y agoBecause it is the "mark of the beast", just as SSNs or surveillance bureau's primary keys are. And no, I'm not joking either. It's entirely sophomoric to trash a book of generational wisdom by taking its metaphors literally for use as strawmen. A actual "beast" was no more a part of their daily routine that it is of yours. If identifying and cataloging people were against people's immediate interest, then it would actually not happen and it wouldn't be a concept worth mentioning. So the apparent fact that the practice looks fine and dandy to you is an indicator of exactly nothing! The problems manifest themselves on the scope of many generations, and true wisdom is to heed warnings from past failed societies rather than laughing them off. (For the record, I'm an atheist).
- youdontknowtho 9y agoso you are opposed to drivers licenses? and for the record, they meant the antichrist as an actual person, not a metaphor...even though there's plenty of evidence that the book is referring to roman coinage and caesar. i really don't know how to reply. you are saying identification is wrong?
- nmstoker 9y agoThe article goes a bit off the rails at the end, with all the focus on using a changeable identifier ("And if this new identifier were easy enough to change (unlike SSNs), breaches, leaks, and other unintended exposures would be less consequential.") There's no reason not to keep SSN as an identifier. Just the same as I wouldn't change my name if I suffered identity theft. Instead there needs to be authentication (eg via a method such as a token, 2FA or whatever) - and it's that which needs to be resettable. Simply making use of SSN alone illegal in certain industries would be a reasonable approach: it would stop current problems whilst not insensing the "mark of the beast" brigade.
- tim333 9y agoThe government could bring in an auth service adding a password to your SSN. Problem solved. Kinda.
- bga 9y agoor a digital signature, or a MAC. Something where we could verify against a publicly-known value safely, and without giving that secret part away to anyone else. The secret would be between the Federal Government and the citizen.
- Simon_says 9y agoWhy should the government have it at all? Just let private citizens manage their own private key.
- nindalf 9y agoAnd what happens when people inevitably lose their private key? How will they regain access to their SSN?
- bga 9y agoExactly. You can't have perfect trust in every citizen to keep track of these things. And if it's a government issued ID in the first place, I see no trouble with them having your private key as well. Just don't reuse that key. This would take a lot of solid investment politically, and technically, to make it even slightly feasible to work for the average Joe.
- Lazare 9y agoAny rational system needs to be able to: 1) Identify someone and 2) Authenticate someone. A moment's thought will suggest that the mechanism used to identify someone has different and at least somewhat conflicting goals to what the mechanism used to authenticate someone has, and these must be different systems. For example: The identification token should be shareable, globally unique, and probably mostly immutable. The authentication token should be secret, not globally unique, and resettable if compromised. The US system currently tries to use SSNs as both a means of identity and authentication: Telling someone your SSN both tells them who you are, and proves that you really are that person. Obviously, this can't work. Either we need an actual unique ID number, and then we treat SSNs as a secret password, OR we need to treat SSNs as non-secret usernames, and add some form of actual authentication. Either will work I suppose, although the second seems more practical.
- jacquesm 9y agoThe only option is the second because SSNs are already widely distributed so have lost their use for authentication.
- Lazare 9y agoAs a practical matter, yes. I mean, in principle we could declare a do-over, and re-issue any compromised SSNs (which would be uh...all of them), but uh...yeah.
- mcherm 9y agoWe HAVE a set of laws and regulations mandating that SSN numbers be kept secret. It doesn't work. We have laws restricting the use of SSNs (it is illegal for most situations to demand an SSN, except for the situations where it is mandatory). They don't work either. There is, however, one simple solution. Inform banks and others who need to verify identity that they may not use knowledge-of-someone's-SSN as a means of verifying identity. After a brief adjustment period for them to change their processes, publish a public list of every citizen's SSN. (Note: the Equifax breach already did half the job here... so that part isn't hard.) There is no problem with having SSN numbers, and we MUST have something of the sort if the government intends to keep track of its citizens. There is no problem with SSN numbers being public, and history has demonstrated that it is impossible to design a system that successfully keeps them secret. The only problem lies in the fact that we treat knowledge of this number as some kind of proof of identity.
- Haul4ss 9y agoSomething non-US folks don't always get about the US -- in a lot of ways, the US is more analogous to the EU than it is to any one country of Europe. That is to say, the US Government is the national entity, but quite a lot of power is still held in the states. There is a 200+ year wariness of federal power here. One of the ways this manifests itself is that identity is established and maintained largely by the states. Your driver's license is basically your national ID here, even though there are 50 different kinds of driver's licenses. In the 1930s we had Great Depression, New Deal, etc. and Social Security. Once Social Security Numbers became a thing, they became wildly popular as a stand-in for a national identifier. And now they're crucial, and they get stolen all the time, and we have nothing better to replace them with. National IDs are a nonstarter politically in the US. One side thinks it is undue encroachment on local rights, and the other side thinks requiring ID disenfranchises the poor and undocumented. That's the tl;dr version of course -- reality is more nuanced.
- imdsm 9y ago> in a lot of ways, the US is more analogous to the EU than it is to any one country of Europe Interestingly, this is because the EU was modelled after the USA, though things didn't quite go according to plan so we have the EU instead of the USE. Regardless of political standing, I do recommend https://www.amazon.co.uk/Great-Deception-European-survive-Referendum/dp/1472939662/ https://www.amazon.co.uk/Great-Deception-European-survive-Re... for an in-depth history of the EU.
- umanwizard 9y agoThere's no reason we can't have national IDs. I don't have a drivers' license, but I carry my Passport Card around.
- xtreme 9y agoThe parent just explained why there is not much support from either the people or the politicians for a national ID in the US. Even if you don't agree with him, the assertion that "there is no reason US can't have a national ID card" is clearly false. Of course, an individual can obtain a passport if he wants, but that is only required to travel out of the country and only a small percentage of US citizens do that. P.S. if you don't drive, your state probably offers a state ID card equivalent to the driver license. It is generally cheaper to obtain and replace.
- rampage101 9y agoThe problem is that SSN's are treated like a private key. If somebody has that private key, and some basic information about you, they can basically impersonate you electronically. Meanwhile countries like Estonia use an electronic card reader with a PIN to verify digital identity, making it nearly impossible for somebody to impersonate you. Using this Estonian system, you can tell anybody your personal code ID.
- bonzini 9y agoIn Italy the personal id is computed from name(s), surname, date and place of birth (state of birth if born abroad) and a check digit. Collisions are pretty rare (one every few tens of thousands of people), so it's pretty much a public piece of information. Electronic identification is available on three levels: id+password, id+password+OTP (the most common), id+password+smart card (everybody has one, but in practice it is only used by officers nowadays). Getting a password is free and takes about 15 minutes plus a trip to the post office. It works pretty well, and underneath it's just SAML2 so everyone can use it.
- tannhaeuser 9y agoI don't know. I found the argument convincing that even naming the breach "identity theft" is beginning to push responsibility away from Equifax and make it seem a personal problem of those affected, or a general societal phenomenon. When in reality it's just Equifax's poor security practices. As you probably know, the exploit basically is using Java's ability to dynamically execute code from JVM bytecodes (supplied via XML in this case, but that's just an implementation detail). Once you get remote code execution ability, it's game over for most Java backend apps, because these are executed in a single process/address space and thus lack basic process isolation. Even if JAAS were used to propagate authorization contexts within the Java backend, typically (almost always) Java apps operate in such a way that a single database identity/credential sets is used for any and all database access. Dynamic bytecode execution is a core feature of Java and other JIT execution environments, so you can't use straightforward NoExecute bits (provided by hardware and supported by OS loaders to disallow calling into dynamically allocated memory) to prevent this from happening, and can't contain/isolate execution paths with authorization contexts either. For these reasons, I think this breach should make banks and other financial institutions rethink their Java strategies mid- to long-term.
- dboreham 9y agoAbility to execute data as code is present in many languages. Almost all of them these days. I think you are saying that banks should only use C or C++ ??
- tannhaeuser 9y agoOr use other statically compiled languages instead. Or at least use Java or O/S sandboxing features. At least in the web-facing parts of their apps. In any case, this requires some planning ahead, and a mindset different from "agile". Maybe Java 9's AOT compilation can help in the process, but even if it could produce stand-alone programs, I think the dynamisms in Java code (reflection, annotations, dynamic class loaders) will make this infeasible for most code bases.
- wschroed 9y agoHe is saying they should practice process isolation. Example architecture: https://cr.yp.to/qmail/guarantee.html https://cr.yp.to/qmail/guarantee.html
- traitormonkey 9y agoI wonder how long it will be before some cunt suggests we all need biometric ID cards or some sort of RFID implant.
- imh 9y agoIt makes me wonder why identity has to be a centralized government thing. For most purposes, my google account is my primary identity. If I forget a password, resets go there, so it's my foundational identity online. Per-purpose identity seems like an okay thing. I could have a financial identity, and gaming identity, a communication identity, etc. Just like the government doesn't need to know what I own on steam, it doesn't need to know my credit score. And just like steam doesn't need to know my drivers license/social, maybe my bank shouldn't either? Writing this, I'm realizing how closely identity and privacy are related. For any transaction with memory (like games I buy on steam) there needs to be some identity. Connecting that identity to my other identities is a privacy question. We're probably at a tipping point where we could go either way next. It scares the crap out of me to think about it that way.