16 ms·
Protecting a drug patent by selling it to a Native American tribe
- charlesdm 9y agoThat is one interesting revenue model. So these guys are basically given $15m a year to do nothing?
- senthil_rajasek 9y agoYou could say the same about any rent collector.
- bgroins 9y agoAs a former landlord, I don't think this is an accurate comparison.
- charlesdm 9y agoI would, if it was an interesting use case. You don't see people being handed $15m a year ("for free") every day.
- prklmn 9y agoNo you can't. How many rent collectors do you know have put no monetary investment into what they're renting?
- maxerickson 9y agoIt happens often enough that there is a term for it -- slumlord.
- kafkaesq 9y agoThe commenter was just simplifying. By "doing nothing" what they really meant was "by not doing all that much work". Compared to people who, you know, actually do hard, serious work for (much less of) a living.
- ada1981 9y agoYou might also look at "doing nothing" in a broader context of "doing nothing" in the face of the genocide that occurred to pave the way for the United States. So, this is one of the small benefits they can enjoy as a result of not contesting the authority of the US government to occupy the USA.
- dogma1138 9y agoRent collectors aren't equivocal. But legislative and tax loopholes and corporate shelter nations/jurisdictions are.
- spo81rty 9y agoExcept landlords pay hundreds of thousands of dollars for a property and hope to make a profit from it. The renters could destory the place and pay nothing.
- pkaye 9y agoOr the landlord/owner could go bankrupt and own nothing because it is all shielded under a corporation... What is exactly your point?
- spo81rty 9y agoIf they go bankrupt they still lose their initial investment. That isn't shielded by anything. Writing it off as a tax loss only covers a small percentage of the loss and assumes you have another gain to offset.
- toast0 9y agoIt's venue/legal standing shopping. They are being paid to maintain their status and their solvency, and for the use of their standing. I guess the next step for patent holders if this doesn't pan out is paying small countries to hold patents with their actual sovereign immunity instead of almost immunity. On the other hand, maybe the patent itself can be sued a la civil forfeiture, which would make the standing of the patent holders irrelevant.
- charlesdm 9y agoHey, with the crackdown on tax avoidance, tax havens are in need of new revenue channels. It's not the worst idea in the world.
- protomyth 9y agoA trial over the issue recently concluded in U.S. District Court in Texas and a decision in that case has not yet been reached. The deal announced with the Mohawk tribe will not have any bearing on the federal court case. If the company loses that case, its patents would be invalidated regardless of the deal with the tribe. A court hack, not a guarantee to keep the patent.
- devdoomari 9y ago...what if those tribe suddenly decide to revoke licenses to the original patent owner? Or they suddenly decide to license to another entity for more money?
- monochromatic 9y agoI'm sure it's written as an irrevocable, exclusive license.
- protomyth 9y agoIt would also impact future profits in the same space. Absolutes tend to be better for business than chaotic whim.
- monochromatic 9y agoOne of the comments here[0] raises an excellent point: >I don’t understand how this strategy would work. >The PTAB decisions about state colleges/universities are based on Eleventh Amendment immunity. On those cases, the IPR statute is trumped and cannot impede on the states’ sovereign immunity under the 11th Amendment. >But Native American tribes do not enjoy 11th Amendment immunity; their immunity is a function of federal common law and Congress has near plenary statutory authority over the tribes. Congressional statutes can abrogate or supersede tribal immunity, without constitutional issues. >Tribal immunity is more about immunity from the states over Native American tribes, based on federal supremacy over Native American affairs. >But AIA is federal. So the argument is simple; by enacting the AIA and subjecting issued patents to AIA reviews, and not making any exception for patents owned by Native American tribes, it abrogated any sovereign immunity that may have applied. >The patents obviously weren’t invented or originally prosecuted by the tribe; given the fact that the immunity is federal common law and policy-based (and not 11th Amendment-based), I can see that policy-based arguments about how manipulative this is, will be very receptive. [0]https://patentlyo.com/patent/2017/09/allergan-creating-sovereign.html https://patentlyo.com/patent/2017/09/allergan-creating-sover...
- rayiner 9y agoIt’s not a good argument. As the Supreme Court reaffirmed a couple of years ago in Bay Mills, while Congress can abrogate tribal immunity, the intention to do so must be “unequivocal.” Congress does not need to make an “exception” for Indian tribes in any specific law—tribal immunity is the “background” against which all legislation is enacted.
- nkurz 9y agoHere's a couple summaries of the January 2017 University of Florida Research Foundation case: http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/03/16/ufrf-eleventh-amendment-defense-ptab-creates-ipr-immunity-iprs-public-universities/id=79341/ http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/03/16/ufrf-eleventh-amendment... https://patentlyo.com/patent/2017/02/sovereign-university-challenge.html https://patentlyo.com/patent/2017/02/sovereign-university-ch... And here's a later case involving the University of Maryland Baltimore where the reasoning was reaffirmed: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=e8a324fd-4be6-4515-918e-77f35efac275 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=e8a324fd-4be6... I post this here as a response to 'rayiner' not because he can't find these links on his own, but because I'd be interested in his opinion one of the suggestions in that last Lexology link: Third, public universities and hospital systems may see their research sponsors begin to stop demanding full ownership of patents resulting from sponsored research and/or clinical studies, in favor of a more natural joint ownership structure. Presumably, since all owners of a patent are necessary parties to an IPR (and district court litigation), even a private, for-profit entity that is a joint owner of a patent with a public university or hospital may be able to benefit from assertions of sovereign immunity in IPRs. Does this multiple ownership theory of immunity make sense to you? Instead of transferring the entire patent to a sovereign Indian nation, would it be possible for them to make gift of some tiny percentage of ownership of the patent, and still gain all the benefits of sovereign immunity? I have to say, from the outside the whole thing seems like a farce. Regardless of the form the review takes, Covidien's argument that a patent review is directed against the patent, rather than the owner, sure makes intuitive sense. It makes some sense that a sovereign state would be immune from charges of infringement, but seems absurd to me that the US government would no longer be allowed to review the claims of a patent because the ownership changed.
- dagaci 9y agoWhile this is a nice outcome for the Tribes, and they probably need the extra income. I can't help but believe that this is simply just another method by which corporations are allowed to hold the people hostage, and increase monopolistic powers. Drugs companies in the US are so completely protected from any meaningful international competition. And now even inside the US they are working on ways to take this further. Your healthcare cost so much because of nonsense like this! Its the people who are getting Screwed again.
- jjawssd 9y agoThe particular tribe in question has become relegated to the status of what Yuri Bezmenov calls "useful idiots." When the tribe is no longer useful they will be disposed of. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K4kHiUAjTvQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K4kHiUAjTvQ
- a3n 9y agoIANAL, but it seems the initial transfer would be the "attack" against the scheme. It's a gamble.
- amelius 9y agoIsn't this like "hacking" the justice system, and shouldn't it be punished accordingly?
- cletus 9y agoSo people seem aghast at this move e.g. Calls of "rent collecting" (which I assume really means "rent seeking" [1]). Michael Carrier (in the article) notes the tribe "played no part" in the drug's development. So the question that occurs to me is what about the tax arrangements made by tech companies to "sell" patents to foreign entities and then lease back the rights in what is transfer pricing [2] by any other name? Those countries and entities played no part in that development either. Not that I'm defending patents in general or in this case. I just wonder if people view the situations similarly. One claim by the company is clearly absurd, calling the patent review board "double jeopardy". It's no mor doubl jeopardy than hearing a case in Federal district and appellate courts is (yes, yes, I know appellate courts don't try facts). The review process is meant to streamline th process and is simply the first step in a judicial review process. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent-seeking [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_pricing
- pkilgore 9y agoYour last paragraph sounds odd to an attorney... an appeal is essentially a continuation of the same trial. Really the big problem is that double Jeopardy is a criminal law concept, so Saunders' argument makes no sense. Civil litigation like patent litigation is subject only to the restrictions of res judicata. If 300 million people want to challenge a patent 300 million times, they can (assuming standing, jurisdiction, etc...). But also, we've been reexamining patents forever, which is basically a slower IPR with standard and process tilted in Patent Owner's favor. That could also be done separate from, concurrent with or in addition to civil litigation. I thought the Federal Circuit did a pretty good job on this issue, but then again, their record in front of SCOTUS recently is just awful.
- leksak 9y agoI'm mostly surprised to read that this will be a much needed boost to their 50 million dollar annual budget when they are "only" 13000 people. How bad are their margins on that casino? Or what else eats into that budget? My city has a population of 120k (and that's tallying a lot of people that doesn't even live near the place colloquially referred to as the city) and had an annual budget of 125 million dollars (not in the US) and we have free health care, subsidised public transportation and a whole slew of other nice benefits.
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoThat's $3884/head.
- leksak 9y agoCompared to $1041/head ;) but maybe some stuff that we enjoy here is coming out of the government coffers and not the city coffers although reading the budget reports I've not found any substantial costs "left" out. Maybe they shoulder more costs directly.