17 ms·
I'd love to see the $70B number pan out (though $500 per person is less than the damages, I think) -- Equifax is a $17B company, and would presumably stop exist
by hedora 9y ago
I'd love to see the $70B number pan out (though $500 per person is less than the damages, I think) -- Equifax is a $17B company, and would presumably stop existing if that happened.
On the other hand, these things always settle out of court, and Equifax certainly won't settle the suit for more than they're worth.
I said it elsewhere, but I think the right response is to opt out of the class, and sue for $1000 in small claims court. If ~15% of the class does this, they are out of business, and lawyers don't get a dime of the $1000.
Also, I'd love to see a new non-profit website that automated the paperwork.
- sjg007 9y agoIn small claims court, would you not have to show $1000 worth of damages?
- arduanika 9y agoYes, and it's possible using simply arithmetic and market rates! Given that freezing your credit ratings is a necessary precaution after this damage inflicted by their negligently unpartitioned database, we can calculate: 1 legally guaranteed free credit report / year * ($5 freeze before + $5 unfreeze after) * 3 agencies * 33 more years of healthy remaining life God willing = $990 right there. Move apartments or change jobs just once in that interval, and it will bring you up to a round thousand. Bam.
- sjg007 9y agoActual, not theoretical.
- mlrtime 9y agoCould we create a service that automates most of the work required to sue in SCC?
- X86BSD 9y agoWhy not? Wouldn't it be the same as the kid that automated fighting a speeding ticket or traffic infraction ticket?
- pc86 9y agoTraffic tickets aren't generally resolved in SCC. Traffic tickets are very specific. As the actual attorney pointed out, if you make a generic "file a SCC claim here" app its resultant documents will be pretty quickly discarded as insufficient. SCC is not hard, it's cheap, and it's designed to be easy to do and not require legal assistance to do so.
- leesalminen 9y agoI'd pay $20 for a service that can walk me through what to do/say, templates legal forms, etc. I would absolutely take the time to sue Equifax in small claims court.
- fillskills 9y agoI would pay 20% of every penny that I win in the lawsuit
- esMazer 9y agosame here, heck I'd pay $99
- Veratyr 9y agoCalifornia has a convenient free web page that tells you most of the steps: http://www.courts.ca.gov/1007.htm http://www.courts.ca.gov/1007.htm This has all the forms and a link to what to do with them: http://www.courts.ca.gov/9744.htm http://www.courts.ca.gov/9744.htm
- ethanwillis 9y agoI will also crowdfund taking down EQ. Give me a service and I'm ready to pay.
- 9y ago
- xur17 9y agoI saw your post about this in the other thread. If anyone wants to work together on this idea, my contact info is in my profile. If someone has a lawyer we can loop in (or is a lawyer), that would be ideal.
- mLuby 9y agoLikewise.
- dforrestwilson 9y agoI am in the state of Kansas and will be filling out a small claims petition as well.
- ethanwillis 9y agoCan I actually do this? Cause if I can I'm totally doing this.
- jfindley 9y agoIANAL, but I think you'd find it virtually impossible to show $1000 of direct, material damages as a result of having your information leaked[0] and to the best of my knowledge this is the only sort of claim that small claims courts allow - I believe they do not allow punitive damages, nor theoretical ones. 0: Unless your info is actually used in a way that harms you, and you can prove that it was a result of this, but that seems unlikely to be true for the majority of affected people.
- joering2 9y agoMany time the thiefs are actually caugh. If he she admits to stealing your data in this leak AND you are damaged, then here is your proof.
- pc86 9y agoI think it's unlikely you'll actually be damaged. Any real financial impact would have been reversed by your bank. Maybe a fee or two that two parties argue about who should reimburse your for it, however I can't see stuff like that adding up to $1,000 (or even $100).
- ethanwillis 9y agoWell about 2 months ago (when the leak was happening apparently) I had false information showing up on my credit report for a Comcast debt. The weird thing is the Comcast debt couldn't have actually been mine. As the date of the debt was smack dab in the middle of when I had service with Comcast before switching to ATT. Now, during this period I tried to refinance my home and was denied due to a low score with Equifax. I pulled my EQ 2 weeks before trying to qualify and there was nothing. Then I found that after I was denied and pulled it again of course. I submitted a challenge on it, and it was removed within 2 weeks but the damage was already done. So would this count as real damages?
- ovao 9y agoWhy $1,000? And how would you prove damages equaling that amount?
- pfarnsworth 9y ago$15/month for identify protection/tracking X 12 X 40 years. You can't even dispute $15/month, since that's how much Equifax charges for their identity protection, so that must be how much it's worth since they caused these damages. That makes it more like $7200 in damages, not including the cost of money over time, inflation, etc.
- spathi_fwiffo 9y agoThat exceeds the $$ limit for claims is many states.
- actsasbuffoon 9y agoFor anyone reading this: I believe it’s a one time $10 per credit bureau to freeze your credit. Equifax would obviously like to charge you more if you’re willing. Do not sign up for Equifax’s service. It is a rip-off for a number of reasons.
- spiznnx 9y agoI'm sure equifax would respond by offering you free credit monitoring for life (which costs them nothing to do)
- k_sh 9y agoWho said the hypothetical plaintiff was interested in _Equifax's_ credit monitoring services? They've already demonstrated they can't keep data safe.
- airza 9y agofuture payments are usually discounted rather than inflated (IE money you have to pay now is more of a burden than money you have to pay in the future)
- flippyhead 9y agoIn.
- stcredzero 9y agoI said it elsewhere, but I think the right response is to opt out of the class, and sue for $1000 in small claims court. There's usually no enforcement of penalties in small claims court.
- platypii 9y agoSubmit it to debt collectors and put it on Equifax's credit report
- jsloss 9y agoThis. So much this.
- walshemj 9y agosend in the bailiffs to confisticate goods ideally the c level execs Porsche
- actsasbuffoon 9y agoAnd because their security will probably still be a joke after this is all over, someone can hack their database again to ensure they actually put the claim in there.
- ddoolin 9y agoThen what's the point of it?
- hello_newman 9y agoI don't know how many times you have been to Small Claims Courts but there are multiple ways to enforce penalties in Small Claims; a judgment from a judge, a till-tap, levy their wages, place a levy on their bank account, placing a sheriff in their area of business (for a fee) and will stay there until he's collected all the funds, submit to a collections agency etc. Don't speak on something if you don't know what you're talking about.
- 9y ago
- nashashmi 9y agoThe ideal way to recompensate $500 or $1000 dollars is to sign up everyone for credit/id theft protection, for say, 5 years. I don't know where else they get their revenue from, but free credit protection will hurt them significantly in the long run.
- Chaebixi 9y agoI've heard that those credit monitoring plans are a joke, and provide very little value besides the simulation of "doing something."
- X-Istence 9y agoThey just tell you after the fact that a new credit line has been established. It's still on you as the consumer to go prove that it wasn't you and that you didn't open it... And guess what, the same questions that they ask you to prove you are who you say you are, are the ones that have likely been stolen!
- jstarfish 9y agoLifelock themselves were subject of a data breach in 2015.
- criddell 9y agoIf they are out of business, they sell their assets which are office chairs, fax machines, and a giant database with information on everybody. Are you not worried about the sale of that data?
- airza 9y agoi think that cat's already out of the bag..?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rhino369 9y agoIn a situation like this, if they get bankrupted, the company continues to operate. The ownership is just transferred to the creditors.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoTheir business revolves around selling access to that database. So no, not worried about them selling data that they already sell. Very annoyed that they exist to collect & sell the data, of course.
- 90s-socal-kid 9y agoIsn't the potential impact from selling access to the data versus selling the data different?
- billh 9y agoThis class action will likely be settled in the same way the Ticketmaster case was settled ... with a coupon book good for 2 free credit reports.
- bm1362 9y agoIs that what the lawyers received for taking the Ticketmaster case?
- rayiner 9y agoProbably for good reason. $500 per class member is an insanely high damages estimate. 99.9% of people will suffer zero damages because their identities will not be stolen. Even the ones who do have their identities stolen will likely be made whole by the credit card companies. The real damages here are going to be to the banks and credit card companies that will have to absorb the costs of all the fraud. As to the Ticket Master case, you can read the complaint yourself and see if $5 or so per class member settlement value was reasonable: http://www.ticketfeelitigation.com/docs/Fourth_Amended_Complaint.pdf http://www.ticketfeelitigation.com/docs/Fourth_Amended_Compl.... The theory was that TicketMaster didn't disclose that it was marking up fees for things like UPS delivery and order processing, and that if customers had known they wouldn't have ordered the tickets. That's a weak damages theory, because customers don't care about line items they care about the bottom line. Either they'll pay $X for the tickets or they won't. Unsurprisingly, that weak damages theory lead to a small per-class-member settlement.
- heartbreak 9y agoAll of the identities have been stolen. It’s a matter of whether they’re used at this point.
- vel0city 9y agoTrue, but in the US you can not really sue for possible harms. You can only sue for actual harms which can be remedied by the court. Leaking your information isn't a harm the court can remedy. Abuse of the leaked information is a harm the court can remedy.
- Chaebixi 9y ago> I said it elsewhere, but I think the right response is to opt out of the class, and sue for $1000 in small claims court. If ~15% of the class does this, they are out of business, and lawyers don't get a dime of the $1000. IANAL, but can't you only sue for actual damages not hypothetical damages? According to this [1] your identity with SSN is only worth $30 on the black market. To get $1000 out of them you'd probably need to have your identity actually stolen and prove it was stolen from Equifax. [1] http://www.bankrate.com/finance/credit/what-your-identity-is-worth-on-black-market.aspx http://www.bankrate.com/finance/credit/what-your-identity-is...
- jpambrun 9y agoStress is a damage and mental health is valuable.
- heartbreak 9y agoThe tests for stress/mental health damages are very stringent.
- gknoy 9y agoThe damage is not the cost of getting a new SSN, but the cost of verifying that your info is safe (still safe?). This is why companies routinely list the _cost_ of dealing with hacking incidents (scrub all the servers, pay people overtime, etc). I think it's fair to assign costs similarly for equifax.
- balls187 9y agoInfo monitoring is what, like $29.99 a month? Perhaps reasonably ask for 3 years of monitoring, so $980 But those aren't actual costs incurred yet.
- Chaebixi 9y agoThat's retail and the pricing seems highly inflated. Does anyone actually buy these services at that price point? Credit real time monitoring should be an entitlement for those whose data is being collected.
- pgnas 9y agoThey should be driven out of business. Their #1 commodity, the only reason they exist and they don't spend the time or money to protect it?
- joshdance 9y agoHow hard is it to sue in small claims court?
- g051051 9y agoAre you kidding? This is a 100% instant dismissal if it even gets to a judge. The allegations are groundless...the plaintiffs have no knowledge of Equifax's security systems in order to have any sort of standing to make any claims regarding the quality of it. The sad truth is you can do everything right to the best of your ability and still get hacked. So just the fact that they were hacked isn't sufficient evidence that they were negligent.
- lr4444lr 9y agoBut then you would have to show $1000 of actual personal damage, which I doubt few if any can, unless you're thinking Equifax will just settle these one after another. But they're just as capable of multiplying out how many of these will have to happen before the losses devastate them like you just did and at some point will actually show up and make you prove your case.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dbatten 9y agoThis is the genius of small-claims court. Equifax has to either send a representative (which would cost them more than $1000), or they lose by default. You don't actually have to prove anything.
- scolson 9y agoIt really isn't genius at all. At least in my state, either party can object to the small claims status by simply sending a letter. Then it moves over to normal court with normal lawyers. Already you are out the small claims filing fee (yes, you have to pay the court to even bring a small claims case). Once in normal court, you would need to hire a lawyer, and they would just find some local representation. At this point, you would probably withdraw the case because it isn't worth that investment. But suppose you kept going. Their local council is going to proxy their attempts to change venue to where they are located. Unless you had a really compelling argument, they would probably win the change of venue. Now you need to find another lawyer somewhere else, and it is probably an expensive locale like New York or LA where they have a firm on retainer. Still want to push the case? Me neither. By all means, try the small claims route. But don't think for one second that it is a slam dunk.
- dzdt 9y agoThat is an incredibly pro-corporate anti-individual jurisdiction. Where is this?
- clamprecht 9y agoThey still have the death penalty for humans in the US, why not companies?
- __MatrixMan__ 9y agoThey do, it's called corporate dissolution. Not sure what precedent there is for a class action suit that results in dissolution, but it would be a pretty good precedent to set IMO.
- desireco42 9y agoI love your idea. I would be game if something is happening in that direction.
- IgorPartola 9y agoIf you can write up the process in detail for my state, I will give you 15% of what I win from them. If you automate it as much as possible, 20%.
- philipps 9y agoDoes anyone have experience with this process and could share some tips, e.g. is it likely to be successful, is it open to non-citizens, how much paperwork are we talking about?
- otakucode 9y agoToyotas negligent practices with regard to software killed at least 2 people. Their developers did not even have a bug tracking system at all. They followed only 6 of 90+ industry standard recommended practices. They lied about the system using error-checking RAM when it actually did not. None of that was enough to get a court to declare them negligent. Equifax will be fully acquitted. If a computer is involved, companies can get away with literally killing people. This is court precedent.