6 ms·
If we're lucky, this will be the best leak of personal info ever. The primacy of the SSN in American society is idiotic. It's a "secret" that you have to hand
by mikeash 9y ago
If we're lucky, this will be the best leak of personal info ever.
The primacy of the SSN in American society is idiotic. It's a "secret" that you have to hand out to dozens of different organizations. I've long thought that we should phase this out by committing to publish all SSNs (and the associated info, obviously, so it's not just a list of most 9-digit numbers...) which would force all these companies to stop treating it as confidential.
The system is dumb and works poorly, but worked will enough that there was no impetus to fix it. Some people got affected by breaches, and it sucked for them, but it was always a small enough group that most people didn't care.
Now that a majority of people's "secret" info is no longer confidential, maybe they'll realize they can't rely on it anymore.
OK, the odds of this actually coming to pass are not great. But I can hope.
- emodendroket 9y agoYeah, I won't be holding my breath.
- charlesdm 9y agoHe's right though, even if not feasible to implement. A SSN is an ID number that needs to be kept secret. How dumb is that? How about using something like an ID card with attached chip that can be used to digitally sign things? Works great in Belgium.
- emodendroket 9y agoThere is no political will to do such a thing. Even the REAL ID stuff with licenses is pretty weak and taking an eternity to implement.
- LastMuel 9y agoHe's right though, with any luck, the SSNs of a slew of politicians will be included in the data leak and then we may just get the ball rolling on change. Hopefully, this is the one that gets us moving.
- emodendroket 9y agoI mean, the OPM breach didn't.
- minikites 9y agoThere are millions of Americans who genuinely believe a national ID program is "the mark of the beast" and will hasten the arrival of the Biblical End Times: https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=real%20id%20mark%20of%20the%20beast https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=real%20id%20mark...
- visarga 9y agoAmericans have an distinctive hate for ID cards.
- KomradeKeeks 9y agoIf they do something like that in between elections, conservatives will flip. The sentiment goes something like this: - Conservatives gave up on minorities, historically stated that the less they vote, the better - Conservatives push the narrative that voting fraud is a big problem, and that the liberals are doing it (many high profile member's of Trump's family/cabinet are registered to vote in many states simultaneously) - They push for Voter ID laws and push back against weekend voting days, as it makes it harder for hourly/poor/minority voters to show up and vote. So it would probably be a great idea, but since conservatives consider non-white franchising is an existential threat to their cause, they'll probably scream "state's rights" and block it from happening.
- miguelrochefort 9y agoI advocate something similar regarding all secrets (passwords, private keys, credit card numbers, etc). Secrecy (and privacy) aren't sustainable, and relying on them will just end up hurting people. Identity must be solved, not through secrecy, but through transparency. If AI overcomes us, it will be (in part) because we failed to adapt to this reality.
- artursapek 9y agoAre you being sarcastic?
- miguelrochefort 9y agoNo. I'm completely serious.
- i_cant_speel 9y agoHow could we go about not having private passwords or credit card numbers?
- pishpash 9y agoYou authenticate with physical states with enough entropy generation rate, e.g. physical tokens. All security is physical security.
- ceejayoz 9y agoYou first.
- CaptSpify 9y agoI'm sorry that you are getting downvoted for simply expressing an unpopular opinion, but you may be interested in this: https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/08/this-man-has-nothing-to-hide/379041/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/08/this-ma...
- bmelton 9y agoFor anyone who wants an explanation at just how bad the social security number really is, this is the most enjoyable explanation for it I've seen, by CGP Grey https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erp8IAUouus
- karrotwaltz 9y agoWow. Having an ID card seems so normal to me that I would never have thought that the US didn't have any. I've been to the US before and never even noticed. Thanks for the link.
- mikeash 9y agoThere's a substantial faction of the American right wing which is vehemently opposed to any sort of national ID scheme. They don't want the government having a big database of all citizens. Strangely, these tend to be the same people who want to require photo ID to vote.
- talmand 9y agoI believe the majority of these people would be against the Federal government requiring such an ID. They are likely fine with their local government, that they have more control over, handling such IDs which would be required for voting. But, of course, there's not much preventing the local government from sharing the info with the Feds.
- gok 9y agoI hate to play the recently poisoned "both sides" argument, but it really is weirdly widely unpopular. The ACLU in particular is strongly opposed to a national ID system. I say this as someone who would strongly support a federal mandatory national ID system (and the ACLU, generally)
- mikeash 9y agoIn this particular case, I think the "both sides" argument may well have merit. Thanks for pointing that out. I really should just say a big chunk of Americans.
- Zigurd 9y agoMoreover, there is no actual need for credit reporting agencies to have SSNs. They don't need to report payments to the government for tax collection. SSNs didn't prevent credit reporting agencies from commingling my father's credit data with mine.
- goialoq 9y agoif they switch to an Equifax ID, then you'll have to submit an Equifax ID when applying for a loan and a fraudster could do the same they do today. If you switch to dozens up separate IDs, the entire system will get bogged down as everyone forgets all their ID #s
- WorldMaker 9y agoI think the bigger point is that companies like Equifax shouldn't be using ID numbers at all in the way that they rely on them. They use SSNs as a database ID crutch to keep from having to do the actual leg work of talking to people, verifying/reverifying the accuracy their data, and basically doing the job people pay them to do.
- Zigurd 9y agoOthers on this thread have suggested that storing information that can cause me to incur a liability should require insurance against such a damage. I'm confident that with the right incentives in place, commerce will proceed without getting bogged down.
- flavio81 9y ago> The primacy of the SSN in American society is idiotic. It's a "secret" that you have to hand out to dozens of different organizations I'm not from the US. The first time i had an american friend explain me the SSN thing, I thought they were crazy, for the exact same reasons. It is idiotic, as you say. Here in my third-world country there isn't any number or code that I need to keep secret and I need to hand over to other companies at the same time.
- yazan94 9y agoIf you don't mind me asking, because I'm genuinely curious how it works in other countries. Does your country have an equivalent of a 'credit score' like in the US, which would be used by financial institutions when they judge whether or not they can loan you money? If so, how is this score calculated, how does it aggregate all your financial information without a specific identifier, and how do you secure yourself from identity fraud/theft without having a 'secret' number to id yourself?
- snaily 9y agoA personal primary key that's semipublic, and when you do a financial transaction the institution performs know-your-customer identification checks - checking photo ID (with key printed), that sort of thing. Some even have federated systems where you can later ask the financial institution to hand out a 2FA crypto token that you can use to identify yourself to other institutions over the Internet without ever showing up in person.
- rtuulik 9y agoIt probably varies by country, but here you have a unique personal ID-number. First number denotes your sex, next six numbers contain your birtday, and the next four numbers are assigned (probably? not certain) in order of births during that day. Last number acts as checksum, allowing immediate check for typos. That ID number is public and allows government & any companies/organisations you show it to immediately verify that they are dealing with a specific person, instead of having to spend time figuring out which specific person named "John Smith" they are dealing with. Having this number simply makes life more quicker and convinient. It also allows to remove any pointless duplications for cards. For some examples: separate medical insurance card was discontinued, you can verify medical coverage by a simple number query. Same with drivers licences, they still exist in a separate physical forms for foreign trips, but but not inside the country. There is no separate libary cards, I don´t have to carry a separate card for my gym or various retailers. I can verify myself online quickly and securely. I can digitally sign documents and contracts and email them. Honestly, I´m having hard time imagining my life without it. I´m aware that all proposals for national identification methods in the US have failed thanks to fears of "mark of the beast" and big brother, but it seems pretty silly to me. All that data already exists and can be cross referenced. Making average person waste more time and money by having such massive inefficiencies in the system seems rather silly in these times.
- tommoor 9y agoAgree. The best thing that can happen here is the entire 149 million gets published online somewhere - that will force change. Overnight, companies will have to stop assuming SSN is secret.
- octorian 9y agoBack when I started college, my SSN was my student ID number. It felt weird, of course. I think there was a change in the law soon after I started college, because it did soon get changed into a different number of the same length. Later on, I did a brief stint working for the federal gov't. In that setting, they used the SSN as our employee IDs. It was on all the personnel forms, and often seen on "list of people in the department" spreadsheets. Of course in order to comply with some law, these forms would also have a footnote explaining why they needed the SSN. From these experiences, I have a very hard time actually thinking of the SSN as the sort of "secure password" everyone else wants to insist that it is. Unfortunately, I'm not aware of an alternative.
- kimolas 9y agoAn alternative? You mean user-created passwords?
- sliverstorm 9y agoPretty much why I'm not freaking out, yet. If my SSN & other personal details get out, it's my problem. If the SSN & personal details of half the country leak out, it's somebody else's problem. Whose I'm not sure, but it would seem like banks. At this point, virtually all potential credit applicant's details have been leaked, and I believe it's the banks that ultimately lose when they issue credit to a fraud. So if you're the bank, hopefully right about now you're starting to think you need a much better method to authenticate credit applicants.
- svachalek 9y agoBanks never lose. They just create a fee to pass it on, throw a party and hand out bonuses. But... in this case, the overall cost may be high enough that there's a competitive advantage in not needing to charge this particular fee, and that will force the industry to do something about it. Maybe.
- chipperyman573 9y agoBanks are already charging all the fees they think they can while still remaining competitive. If they could have already charged another fee they would have.