6 ms·
Americans Losing Faith in College Degrees, Poll Finds
- anovikov 9y agoThat's fine, that's how it should ideally be. Market seems to have reached equilibrium now, with collages getting as much money as they possibly can.
- santaclaus 9y ago> with collages getting as much money as they possibly can Let me tell you, my craft business is booming.
- rxhernandez 9y agoIt's interesting how this forum seems to react so robotically to things that adversely affect the lower class. Yes, it is good that it looks like people will spend less money on something that might have a very poor roi depending on your circumstances. No it is not okay, that the lower class was duped into believing they needed a piece of paper to be financially secure in life and that many went so far as to get literal pieces of paper from diploma mills that only shows that they were duped. It is not okay that they are in debt for substantial amounts of money they can't get out of. Or let me put it another way. It's like a massive hurricane just ended and you said: "That's fine, that's how it should ideally be. The hurricane lost its energy for some reason that is intrinsic to hurricanes losing their energy." I hope that this doesn't sound too emotionally charged as I have some very close friends that act robotically to just about everything.
- Moshe_Silnorin 9y agoEmpathy breeds terrible policy.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoEmpathy and compassion are mandatory for sound policy. Edit because of HN throttling: I haven't seen unsavory elected folks generate sound policy yet, so I'm sticking to my statement.
- guelo 9y agoThe politics of being outright evil assholes has gained a lot of traction lately.
- icebraining 9y agoMaybe just compassion: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/02/paul_bloom_on_e.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2017/02/paul_bloom_on_e.htm...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lovich 9y agoIf you don't have empathy then the best course of action for policy makers is whatever gets them the most power without getting kicked out of office. While current politics around the globe look more and more like they are following that path, let's not confuse what's actually happening with what is actually good
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to HN?
- pizza 9y agoIs it consistent to want the best public policy for everyone, but also blame empathy for the creation of terrible policy?
- tepe1 9y agoHN is a very carefully controlled bubble. It's almost completely dominated by a crypto-libertarian groupthink. The article [1] is interesting though. What we're witnessing is the complete self-exile of Republicans from the mainstream. Republicans have lost all faith in mainstream media [2], they have lost all faith in experts, they have lost all faith in science, they have lost all faith in America's major democratic institutions [3], they have lost all trust in the world's biggest corporations, and now they have lost all trust in higher education [4]. That's pretty much everything. Here's a significant chunk of the country that has retreated completely into a paranoid fantasy. It's absolutely remarkable. I don't think anything list this scale of mass delusion has been seen in the West since the Nazis. There are no longer any institutions that might meaningfully engage with these people; they reject anything and everything that does not absolutely conform to the Party Agenda. Without any kind of shared reality -- this group has sincerely adopted a platform of "alternative facts" and nonsense conspiracy theory -- no dialogue or compromise is possible. The full impact of this is probably still coming. This sort of complete disconnect reality always leads to complete disaster. The Nazis truly believed they could conquer the world. The Soviets were absolutely convinced that the capitalist West was going to crumble any second. Reality has a way of biting back and forcefully asserting itself no matter how hard you deny it. [1] http://www.cetusnews.com/life/Americans-Losing-Faith-in-College-Degrees--Poll-Finds-.rJg5RE9CF-.html http://www.cetusnews.com/life/Americans-Losing-Faith-in-Coll... [2] http://www.gallup.com/poll/195542/americans-trust-mass-media-sinks-new-low.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/195542/americans-trust-mass-media... [3] http://www.npr.org/2017/06/29/534835094/political-controversies-drive-a-wedge-between-texas-gop-and-the-fbi http://www.npr.org/2017/06/29/534835094/political-controvers...
- vacri 9y agoIt's not that 'the poors were duped'. It's that until very recently, a piece of paper was a very effective salary multiplier.
- rxhernandez 9y agoDefine very recently and effective for whom. University of Phoenix has been around since 1976 and has been popular with people who didn't have the resources to get into traditional colleges since at least the late 90s. I think with nearly 17 years of success and probably millions of for profit alumni can safely be defined as duped.
- lsc 9y agoI'm not saying anyone should go to the university of phoenix; there are better publicly subsidized options out today, but I do know a handful of people who were partly educated there, who did just fine.
- anovikov 9y agoWell in stable market conditions, the tail of the group of people who get diplomas, ranged by their ROI, will get somewhat negative overall ROI. That's how it should be - i.e. most people - the smarter ones for who education makes sense, get positive ROI, and some relatively small group of people who can't really benefit from education but have fooled themselves into thinking they can, get zero or slightly negative ones. Then comes a group of people who clearly can't benefit and know it. The system reached a stable state - colleges get maximum number of clients they possibly can and get max revenue, it doesn't make sense for many more people to join in, and it doesn't make sense for many existing to stay if prices go further up. As with oil production for example (see 'marginal barrel') people at the end of this tail don't really benefit, but the system in general is still good, most people benefit.
- 90s-socal-kid 9y agoI appreciate your comment. I've a few questions to help me understand your perspective. Is the crux of the issue the fact that lower socioeconomic groups are less able to rebound from a financial impact? Or something more specific about targeting lower s.e. groups?
- howlgram 9y agoexcept it's not, it's as natural as a market bubble or a monopoly, look at higher education literally anywhere else, it isn't that expensive. The problem with the market of college is similar to that of medicine, people will pay anything for it because they believe they need it no matter what.
- thrden 9y agoBetween the rising cost of a college degree, anti-free speech movements on campuses, and the declining employability of non-STEM degrees it's not surprising. Hopefully, this will work to reduce the overall cost of colleges.
- csydas 9y agoNon-STEM seeking students really are not a majority in colleges. Per the National Center for Education Statistics on conferred degrees, the number of liberal arts degrees has been on a decline for quite a few decades while STEM and more vocational degrees have been steadily increasing [1]. Slam universities for many reasons, but the students going aren't graduating in arts; they're doing what employers say they want and still not getting jobs. Universities have many problems, but they still are useful. We have all these STEM graduates but no one seems to be hiring them. [1] - https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d16/tables/dt16_322.10.asp?current=yes https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d16/tables/dt16_322.10.a...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rdl 9y agoBig difference between, say, a MIT Physics grad (essentially qualified for anything not requiring psychiatric stability) and a third tier or for profit "Information Systems Management" grad.
- lsc 9y agoUnemployment is at record lows. Where are you getting that people aren't getting jobs?
- flukus 9y agoUnemployment isn't the metric to look at. Just because someone is employed doesn't mean the job is at all related to the degree. Our office cleaner is a recent IT graduate. Not to mention under employment and people that have just givin up.
- pzone 9y agoGood. People shouldn't make decisions about things like whether to go to college on faith, they should make such decisions after earnest deliberation.
- tsunamifury 9y agoEveryone should have access to an education. Period.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ransom1538 9y agoGet a list of jobs. Sort by desc the salaries. Scan for what you could like. Figure out what you need for that particular job and get that. Done.
- dredmorbius 9y agoHow many of those jobs will exist in 10 years, let alone 40?
- meric 9y agoIt's not that inaccurate to presume the net present value of the automation required to replace higher salaried jobs is higher than lower salaried jobs, all else being equal...
- KGIII 9y agoWhich is yet another reason to keep learning and adapting. Going to university should encourage continued intellectual curiosity, not be an end-point.
- dredmorbius 9y agoWhich isn't exactly sorting and ranking jobs by salary.
- eksemplar 9y agoDangerous trend. A large part of the reason my country (Denmark) is as rich as it is because of education. We too talk about the value of certain parts of academia, like Ancient Greek, and whether or not too many people go to the university. It's all become very cost-benefit, and while the discussion is a reasonable one to have, most of our entrepreneurship comes from educational environments and a lot of the benefits of education can't be directly measured. I mean, there is a reason Tesla had to hire a Swedish company to do the interior design of their cars and that Scandinavian design is increasingly more influential in to world. We're not born better artists/designers, but we do have a nurturing environment for those sort of things to grow and a way for the designers to form easy partnerships with business degrees to be successful. I did project management and later general management autodidactic for a while. It worked perfectly fine, but after taking a degree in management I find myself wondering how the hell it ever worked. Gut feeling, a clever mind and a willingness to learn on your own will get you a long way, and you can absolutely succeed without education. But academia not only teaches you tested methods it also teaches you why you use them and how to determine which ones are best suited for a given situation.
- Judgmentality 9y agoWhat did you learn from your management courses? Genuinely curious, as I've always found that people with degrees in management were no better (and probably slightly worse) than people that just figured it out. My evidence is anecdotal and limited, so I'd be interested to hear what you found useful about your program.
- geomark 9y agoMy anecdata from working quite a few years at big tech companies where most of the staff began as technical and then some went off to get business degrees to advance into management, is that the biggest change was they started using a lot of business school buzz words and attached much more importance to spreadsheets and presentations than they used to.
- Judgmentality 9y ago
- SmirkingRevenge 9y agoThe traditional college path just isnt scalable enough anymore, at least for undergrad degrees. Undergrad level education needs to be cheap and attainable from anywhere. Moocs are getting us there, hopefully the trend continues.
- lsc 9y agoI'm not saying that MOOCS aren't valuable; they certainly are, but they aren't college. You don't get the socialization, among other things. This is super obvious to me, as someone without an education who works with people who mostly have very high end educations. It's a huge difference, even when I can compete technically, it's really obvious that I am really different and lacking the background the others have.
- SmirkingRevenge 9y agoYea, I agree - I think the challenge is to figure out how to get some or all of those benefits for MOOC users - or those otherwise pursuing education off-campus or remote settings. Lack of college-type socialization (and network building) in MOOCS is a thing that can be solved. Forking out 10's of thousands of dollars or more in tuition along with all the other life-altering changes required to attend a university for 4 dedicated years is really a poor value for a bit of socialization/networking, IMHO - unless maybe you are at a really elite university.
- lsc 9y agoI think the "life altering changes" required to attend a university for four years are... a big part of the point of going. I think the cost, well, if that is worth it depends largely on what you value and the marginal value of your dollar. I look around my hometown when I visit my parents, not a particularly wealthy place, and I see a lot of those giant trucks, any one of which could have covered four years at a public university.
- sbr464 9y agoThere simple needs to be a revolution in this space. I would say, from personal experience, that Galvanize, a software bootcamp/school etc. is the most organized & on point pushing to replace tradition CS programs. But CS is only a micro slice of the job economy. Why can't their (or others) model of short term/extremely focused programs be applied to other in-demand, specialized, fields? Examples? Non-MD Psychiatrists that review specific cases, other mental health specialties, highly technical pharmacist/software/hardware/etc technical jobs (sry lack of clarity) but taught in this new learning style vs 6-8+ traditional college curriculums.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Why can't their (or others) model of short term/extremely focused programs be applied to other in-demand, specialized, fields? Examples? Non-MD Psychoatrists We had these. They were called apprenticeships. [1] [1] https://www.dol.gov/apprenticeship/ https://www.dol.gov/apprenticeship/ Companies became accustomed to making the rules though labor-wise over the last decade (including externalizing the cost of an employee's education). This is slowly changing due to a tight labor market [2] (forcing employers to finally invest in their workforce) but it will take time. [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-06/it-s-boom-times-for-recruiters-as-u-s-job-market-tightens https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-06/it-s-boom...
- sbr464 9y agoCompletely agree
- dragonwriter 9y ago> We had these. They were called apprenticeships Apprenticeships tend not to be “short-term”.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoA country cannot bootcamp its way to prosperity. Education takes time.
- maxxxxx 9y agoAt least in the US the path that will most likely lead to a decent career is still through college. As long as there aren't good vocational programs then people losing faith in college is not a good thing. It's more that people are losing faith in the whole system and just check out.
- tabeth 9y agoI'm surprised it took this long. The value is opaque. Education is just selection bias. College should be free up front and cost commensurate with your first few years of income. Incentives would then be aligned properly
- vlunkr 9y agoYeah! Where's that magic wand that makes it free again?
- tabeth 9y ago"cost commensurate with your first few years of income"
- 90s-socal-kid 9y agoOnly if you accept that college value == first few years comp, and that second order effects wouldn't outweigh this economic coercion.
- nether 9y agoFinally the obsession with white collar careers is ending. I much prefer the German system of presenting trades and office jobs as equally valid. This is the first step to revitalizing skilled trades in the US.
- rdl 9y agoIf I had the choice of loans for a college degree or skipping the degree, I'd personally skip the degree. My "hack" when I knew I couldn't pay for MIT was to get accepted and then just not pay -- I got to take the classes up then got retroactively deregistered around finals time. I kept that up for about 2y until I found a great startup opportunity. If I had been saddled with $100-200k of debt, I would have been pushed into taking a high cash comp/high stability job rather than doing crazy startups. Ironically unpaid tuition directly to the bursar vs a loan is just regular debt, and would be discharged through bankruptcy (although MIT just forgave mine). For the very rich (for whom tuition is still insignificant) or the poor and minorities (who win from various forms of non loan financial aid), it seems like college is a rational choice. Otherwise, unless you really need the degree for a specific credentialed career (government, law, or medicine), I would probably discourage college. I do wish I could do a phd in infosec+economics somewhere today, but that is really the only thing I can't readily do without an undergrad degree.
- 0xbear 9y agoHopefully a renaissance in vocational training will follow. We have plenty of English major burger flippers as it is.
- LeicaLatte 9y agoFair enough. Thanks to the internet, going to college to study is definitely an antiquated idea.
- lovich 9y agoI see a lot of people talking about the increasing cost of college being part of the reason people are losing faith in degreees. I too, agree that this is a large part. However, did nobody else experience the dumbing down of colleges like I have? I was told growing up that college courses were taught by educated, experienced professors. Yet every year I was there though I got more and more adjunct professors who were working second jobs at supermarkets to make ends meet and TAs who were required to teach a course for their graduate degree but should have never passed the course they were teaching in the first place. The absolute worst I had was an economics course where some TA spent _every_, _single_ class at the whiteboard muttering to herself and trying to draw the charts in our textbook from memory but failing utterly to do so. The entire class complained to the university and they didn't even respond. We all just stopped caring because we given decent grades anyway and pushed through in our degrees. It is no wonder that people lose faith in the colleges when they let that happen and still award you with a degree like you learned something
- InclinedPlane 9y agoYup. A bachelor's degree from most US colleges is about 3 years of "can you read and learn from reading, at least well enough for the tests?" and maybe a year or so of actual college-level education. I enjoyed my college education and felt I got a lot out of it, but it certainly is possible to get through college without actually gaining much education. Partly that's the fault of the student, but getting a degree from an accredited college or university should actually mean something.
- lsc 9y agodo you see the conflict inherent in arguing both that you want to spend less money on a good and that you want the people providing that good to be more skilled? I mean, it's natural to want both of those things, and sometimes, there's some inefficiency that can be fixed that makes things both better and less expensive, but... not usually. Usually, if you want better workers to do a task, you have to pay more, and that costs money. My own impression is that instructor quality varies a lot by institution, though I have never met a college professor who wasn't dramatically better than what you'd expect based on pay.
- NiklasMort 9y agoThe American Education System is nothing but a slave factory for the bank system. I mean whats the percentage of students in debt? Pretty sure above 50%. Want to be a MD to save lives? Sure here is your 250,000$ student debt oh and don't forget malpractice insurance etc.
- avenoir 9y agoI wonder how much money is spent on students playing catch-up after enrolling into colleges because they can barely read, write or do basic math. I've seen plenty of this kind of thing in study groups during my 2 years of community college and it was really fascinating to witness this level of illiteracy especially having lived in Eastern Europe where even the poorest of poor received good public education. It's absolutely awful and there had to be significant money invested to keep that going. Our public schools are an absolute disaster and cutting costs to higher education should start here. I don't know what this entails. Perhaps paying teachers more in order to attract more talent? Replace GEDs with night schools for adults without age restrictions?