6 ms·
Google's fight to keep search a secret
- llimllib 16y ago> Simply put, there are a growing number of regulators, agitators, and regular people who just don't trust Google when it comes to the integrity of its search results. More simply put, there are a growing number of * who would like to get a piece of that google action.
- kiba 16y agoWhy does the hell that somebody think that they have the right to force Google to have its algorithm published? It's not like the government is propping up Google or that if anybody is locked in as a user in the search market. There are already a huge number of search engine and information filters.
- alnayyir 16y agoThey want to look like they're "doing something" and in the process keep the populists happy.
- alnayyir 16y agoTo clarify, Google does not de facto nor de jure have a monopoly even if they are wildly popular. I'll call Google a monopoly when they buy off Microsoft to shut down Bing and buy out DuckDuckGo. Their practices are occasionally questionable, but that doesn't constitute a monopoly in and of itself.
- AlisdairO 16y agoA monopoly is merely having sufficient market share. Which isn't necessarily bad, although it usually is. What you're talking about is abusing a monopoly.
- alnayyir 16y ago>A monopoly is merely having sufficient market share It's not, but it's clear that the legal nature of it seems to be besides the point. Who needs rule of law when you have uninformed opinion being passed around the campfire?
- AlisdairO 16y agothere's quite a well cited wikipedia article that appears to disagree with you: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly . I'm very open to being shown different sources and proven wrong, however.
- alnayyir 16y agoGoogle doesn't have a market-share that constitutes monopoly in anything, especially in a market (search) where the switch cost is nothing. You'd be closer to the mark accusing the iPhone of having a monopoly on telephony simply because it costs money to buy a different one.
- jessriedel 16y agoI generally agree, but there is an issue if Google has a monopolistic market share, even if there are many other options. As you say, there is very little customer lock-in, so there should be a high bar for calling Google a monopoly. On the other hand, there is a large entry cost for the search martket.
- bigiain 16y agoIs there really a "large cost of entry"? I somehow doubt Duck Duck Go has a multi-billion dollar war chest backing it... And Google's "monopoly" is very much based on it's reputation - remember how quickly we all jumped ship from Alta Vista - and surely Bing and Yahoo provide enough competition that if Google _were_ manipulating search returns in obviously monopolistic ways, people would notice and publish evidence soon enough?
- jessriedel 16y agoFirst, Duck Duck Go may be popular with HNers, but it has insignificant market share. It clearly did not have the capital to make a dent. Second, Google has an astounding 63% market share, which would be considered a monopoly in almost all industries. Third, people "noticed" Microsoft's monopolistic tactics, but that doesn't mean that they weren't effective or didn't continue for a long time, largely unpunished.
- jsz0 16y agoI think it would be completely reasonable to ask Google for detailed advance warning of algorithmic changes that may effect the Internet economy. Making them disclose the entire algorithm is too much and invites further gaming of the system.
- sliverstorm 16y agoEasy, they have money and other people want a slice of their pie. The "I'm entitled to it" arguments like this come first, the more indirect arguments come later.
- moultano 16y ago"Google needs to figure out a way to shore up the public's confidence in its integrity " [citation needed] I haven't heard "the public" complaining about not knowing how Google ranks results. That seems to be limited to spammers and the journalists they dupe into their sob stories.
- patio11 16y agoThe best lie the devil ever told was convincing the world he did not exist, and the best triumph of Google's PR campaign is convincing developers that any developer interested in Google rankings who is not an employee of theirs is by definition a web spammer. Disclaimer: I am very freaking interested in Google rankings, since they determine my ability to eat.
- ars 16y agoThen you are a "spammer", because you care for your results to be high, but I care for the results to be useful. Can you honestly say you would prefer that your site be ranked lower than that of a competitor with better information?
- lol 16y agoWhere exactly does he say he wants to beat competitors with better information? Oh right, nowhere. He probably wants to beat out a bunch of pointless white noise. But hey... thanks for being a retard who thinks it's cool to accuse people of spamming because they're interested in making sure they show up in an appropriate place in the search marketplace!
- Tichy 16y agoWhat if my site is better, but my competitors site ranks higher? Definitely the case for one of my sites. I know for a fact that the "just provide good content" line by Google is complete bullshit.
- ars 16y ago
- ohashi 16y agoThis is silly. The users aren't the ones complaining. It's those who have everything to lose and cannot cope with a new reality.
- waterlesscloud 16y agoI'm only half a Google fan, I think they do a lot wrong, but keeping their search algorithm a secret isn't one of those things. If people really didn't trust Google, they'd go elsewhere. There's an agenda at work here, very obviously.
- gnok 16y agoThat's a bit of a strawman argument. There's a wide gap between the "totally trust" and "do not trust" groups. I would think most people would fit in that gap. The ones who do go elsewhere are in the "do not trust" group. I can't be sure, but I would think the "totally trust" and "do not trust" groups are minorities in Google's user-verse.
- Ardit20 16y agoHow is that a strawman argument? He is stating that he does not blindly follow google, nor does he criticise google at every turn. He is a sceptic. As you say most of us are. We use it because on balance we like it. If we saw any evidence to suggest that something is wrong, then we will not like it, thus do something about it.
- benologist 16y agoI think the government should focus on the spam Google funds. I don't even remember the last time I saw a trashy spam site that wasn't plastered with Google ads. Between SEO and spammers machine-generating or just copy-pasting content it's no wonder a lot of people feel left out of search results.
- SoftwareMaven 16y agoIf Google is forced to out their algorithm, Coke better be forced to out its recipe. They are both trade secrets at the heart of a competitive market space, though I think it would be far more catastrophic for Google's algorithm to be outed than Coke's recipe.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- pwim 16y ago"if search engines were forced to disclose their algorithms and not just the signals they use, or, worse, if they had to use a standardized algorithm, spammers would certainly use that knowledge to game the system, making the results suspect." Regardless of whether or not it would be a good idea for Google to be required to open their algorithm, I don't like this reason. It is security by obscurity. Spammers can only take advantage of flaws in Google's algorithm. By opening it to the public, I'm sure the algorithm itself would be improved. The real reason Google doesn't want to expose it is that it is a competitive advantage. They should be upfront about that at least.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoInteresting. Search engine providers who are also advertisers have a agent problem -- there is moral hazard. Anybody who has money betting on where an item shows up in a result list should not also be able to create the list. This is like going to the Ford car dealership and asking for an analysis of all the types of cars to buy. Even if the Ford guys give you an independently-created report recognized as the world's best authority on car purchases, it doesn't feel right. In ethics, if it looks wrong, it is wrong. Having said that, regulating anything that returns a list is idiotic. Even regulating Google because of it's gatekeeper status doesn't work -- these things always sound good for the edge cases, but once you let the camel's nose in under the tent, the rest of the camel is soon to follow I think what's called for here is an industry-sponsored certification program. Use outside auditors, establish quality metrics, create a set of public ethical guidelines. You can always have trusted outsiders check your work against those guidelines, even in IP-rich, and trade secret areas. Companies do this all the time. Google's (and Microsoft before it) main problem is that it is successful. Lots of political-type folks see that success and imagine all sorts of ways that the government can/should get in there and muck around. In this case I'm on Google's side. But as far as thinking Google is somehow magic, that SEO is evil, that "writing good content" is all you need for rankings? All of that is bullshit put out by Google to make themselves more of an authority than they actually are. They run a program to put things in an ordered list. People are going to hack the program. Neither of these two things are good, bad, or especially interesting. The interesting thing here, to me, is the degree of Google fanboy-ism that some folks have. Wish I could bottle that up. Google is just an advertising agency who had some cool ideas on ranking a decade or more ago. They are not a bunch of knights riding in on white horses. Oddly enough, their success is the very thing that's hurting them.