3 ms·
Imagine an alphabet similar to Arabic where each letter may have up to five glyphs, or even an alphabet in which the _position_ of the glyph changes it's letter
by joe_the_user 9y ago
Imagine an alphabet similar to Arabic where each letter may have up to five glyphs, or even an alphabet in which the _position_ of the glyph changes it's letter.
But we don't have to imagine a random alphabet which Voynich might have been written in. We can look at the actual language in the manuscript. It often shows three or four Latin-like glyphs repeated. Unless you have access to some special way these symbols are differentiated or otherwise convey information, a way that all other would-be interpreters have missed, you really don't have an argument.
And as far as European thinking goes - there's no evidence I know of a non-European origin to the manuscript.
Edit: and the languages you cite have a larger, not smaller information content than European languages, see;
https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/6167/most-succinct-written-language/6604 https://linguistics.stackexchange.com/questions/6167/most-su...
- PavleMiha 9y agoIt's an abbreviation? I guess that's the OP's thesis.
- coroxout 9y agoI do agree that the repeated glyphs and almost-repeated "words" are a big red flag against "can this actually mean anything?", and I'm not sure the idea of abbreviations really explains that. However, many medieval documents even in known real languages do contain almost undifferentiated glyphs one after the other: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minim_(palaeography) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minim_(palaeography) Not quite the same, but something similar might conceivably apply to e.g. the Voynich's c-like characters.
- joe_the_user 9y agoWell, I believe what article was saying was the text was shorthand for a sequence of actions - repeated letters implied repeated actions. In this case, sequences herbal infusions, bathing, magnets, etc. IE, there's no text to translate, it's not an abbreviation for any standard text.