5 ms·
Tech entrepreneurs’ politics: Liberal, with one big exception
- gnicholas 9y agoTLDR: > The tech elite’s mix of views is unique; no other group in the survey favored both greater wealth redistribution and laxer regulation.
- notyourday 9y agoOf course. They were just not asked in details which way they would like the wealth to be distributed.
- gnicholas 9y agoThey probably also didn't ask about details on regulation. Techies heard "regulation" and thought Uber/Airbnb, not runoff wastewater, asbestos, and formaldehyde (which is what many other people would think of when hearing "regulation"). I'd guess techies are similar to other liberals in wanting these other things regulated. They just don't want tech to be regulated.
- pc86 9y agoThe article itself tells you what definitions they used. In the context of regulation and redistribution, they mean this: > the government should [not] tightly regulate business, and should [not] tax the wealthy to fund social programs My default would be "should not" and "should," respectively, which is where most tech founders fell, and puts me in the minority in the other four categories. We can argue about tax rates and deductions until we're both blue in the face but most people agree that the more you make, the more you should pay in taxes, as a general rule. And "tightly" has a distinctively negative connotation to me. I think something should be legal and unregulated until there is some evidence that it needs to be either regulated or outright illegal. Business, generally, should not be tightly regulated, except in rare instances (healthcare, yes; banking, probably; insurance, probably).
- rjsw 9y agoIs that "Far Left" by US standards or by those of the rest of the world ?
- werber 9y agoAmerican : pro choice, universal health care, gay rights, and gun control, but anti labor
- relyio 9y agoFWIW, in France, those who embrace critical theory (https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/critical-theory/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/critical-theory/) in that fashion are branded radical/far-left (Frederic Lordon, Nuit Debout, Le Monde Diplomatique etc.).
- walshemj 9y agoFar left no 80% of sv employees would be described as centre right (probably more socially liberal) in uk terms a wet one nation tory which is what pres Obama is. If sv is so far left why do no sv companies have Union recognition? Far left is those that support Assad and think that stalin was right aka "Tankies".
- josteink 9y agoThat's probably right, but in some areas SV politics seems much more left-leaning and extreme than anything seen in Europe: Diversity, Gender-identity nonsense and third wave feminism (things like making "meritocracy" a borderline fireable offense). I guess it's not as simple and one-dimensional as one would like it to be ;)
- walshemj 9y agomeritocracy doesn't mean what you think it does.
- pc86 9y agoI think it's important to appropriate contextualize things like "left" and "right." Most importantly, why are we comparing Silicon Valley to Europe? They're completely different political climates, in different countries. Comparing political ideologies between two countries is a fool's errand more often than not. Within the context of American politics, San Francisco (and SV to a lesser extent) is one of the most liberal places in the country, probably top 5 and certainly top 10. Even within the context of the California politics specifically (itself the 3rd or 4th most liberal state), it's center left. Trying to frame San Francisco as anything right of center is ridiculous unless you're comparing it only to things like Communism and Socialism. Edit: And let's not forget than most people want to frame themselves as either center left or center right. Very rarely will someone proudly say they are far left or far right, regardless of context.
- walshemj 9y agoits to the right of some conservative's in the uk
- pdog 9y agoAccording to this study, you agree with "libertarian philosophy" if you agree with the following statement > I would like to live in a society where government does nothing except provide national defense and police protection, so that people could be left alone to earn whatever they could. What a joke. Of course, it turns out that technology entrepreneurs are not really libertarians when you ask it like that. What if they asked individuals whether they agree or disagree with the following statement: > I believe that respect for individual rights is the essential precondition for a free and prosperous world. Would they get a different response?
- pricechild 9y agoIt'd be interesting to see their definition of "national defense"...
- pavlov 9y agoIf that's not what True Libertarians think, maybe it's time for some PR to explain to the public what it actually is?
- nolepointer 9y agoWhat we think of as "true libertarian" is, I guess, right-libertarian. There is, therefore, also left-libertarian, which is probably a more appropriate classification.
- looki 9y agoWhat strikes me as incredible is that 44% of Democrats agreed with the original statement. I'm not an American, but isn't that totally incompatible with the party's ideals? EDIT: The fact that the vast majority of them agreed with the two options that are for redistribution of wealth kind of confirm that, in my opinion.
- chamby 9y agoI would say that our two party system is why this seems so strange to foreigners. Americans with nuanced opinions must shoehorn themselves into Republican or Democrat to participate in our democracy. This often means compromising on your ideals to have your voice heard on whatever issue is most important to you at the time.
- maxxxxx 9y agoPeople should drop the "far". This is just propaganda talk to mark something you don't like as extreme.
- thrill 9y agoThe chart in the fine article shows the "technology founders" are about half as libertarian as the general Democrat and nearly twice as likely to support redistribution - but hey, let's not call that or them far left.
- maxxxxx 9y agoWatch what people do, not what they say. Technology founders are either capitalists already or aspiring capitalists. In theory they support redistribution as long as it doesn't come out of their pockets or equity. You can't call them far left on the economical scale. That makes that label meaningless which it is anyways. Americans should stop agonizing about what's left or right, Democrat or Republican and start thinking about issues. There are tons of problems this country has that can't be explained or solved by labeling them left or right. When I came to this country I thought it's a pragmatic country that gets things done but now I wonder it's just a bunch delusional ideologues based on the public conversation.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fortythirteen 9y agoI don't know. I think this[0] qualifies as far-left tactics. [0] http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/street-artist-sabos-facebook-page-shut-down-zuckerberg-stunt-1029102 http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/street-artist-sabos-fa...
- jessriedel 9y ago> Over all, the study showed that tech entrepreneurs are very liberal — among some of the most left-leaning Democrats you can find. They are overwhelmingly in favor of economic policies that redistribute wealth, including higher taxes on rich people and lots of social services for the poor, including universal health care. Their outlook is cosmopolitan and globalist — they support free trade and more open immigration, and they score low on measures of "racial resentment." > On most culture-war issues, they are unrepentantly liberal. They oppose restrictions on abortion, favor gay rights, support gun control and oppose the death penalty. > ...The study found one area where tech entrepreneurs strongly deviate from Democratic orthodoxy and are closer to most Republicans: They are deeply suspicious of the government’s efforts to regulate business, especially when it comes to labor. They said that it was too difficult for companies to fire people, and that the government should make it easier to do so. They also hope to see the influence of both private and public-sector unions decline.
- bmmayer1 9y ago...so in other words, libertarian
- actsasbuffoon 9y agoI don’t think higher taxes are something libertarians are generally in favor of.
- pc86 9y ago> some of the most left-leaning Democrats you can find > economic policies that redistribute wealth > universal health care > support gun control Is that what a libertarian is to you?
- baursak 9y agoWhy did you change the original NYT title, which is "Silicon Valley’s Politics: Liberal, With One Big Exception"? What on Earth is "Far Left"? Surely Silicon Valley's politics are nowhere near Marxist or anarchist. EDIT: apologies, you obviously didn't change it.
- CPLX 9y agoIt was the NYT that changed it, not the poster on HN. The NYT changes headlines constantly, it's actually sort of fascinating to watch in real time, which you can do by following this automated Twitter account: https://twitter.com/nyt_diff/status/905407322658402304 https://twitter.com/nyt_diff/status/905407322658402304
- baursak 9y agoOh wow, thanks! Apologies to GP.
- quuquuquu 9y agoDamn dude, awesome work finding this. Completely changes the dynamic of the accusation above. It seems NYT follows the "post now, edit later" approach
- ghaff 9y agoIn addition to the usual copyedit tweaks, headlines are the thing that editors are more likely to go in and make more attention-grabbing, even if they become less neutrally factual in the process. This isn't really anything new although of course historically it was done before the issue actually went to press.
- lftl 9y agoI wonder if it's even really about the editing process. It seems possible to me that they intentionally start with a more provocative headline to get more early traction for an article, and then switch to the more neutral title as an article gains views. I could even imagine it being A/B tested early to see which headline will get them the most shares.
- CPLX 9y agoIf they side with moneyed corporate interests and management against labor then they aren't left wing. The lack of an actual labor party in this country is a disaster, and is underpinning the wildly unpredictable and regressive nature of our current politics.
- peoplewindow 9y agoAccording to the article they only surveyed people who are management and corporate interests - founders and billionaires!
- trentnix 9y agoIt's mostly virtue signaling as far as the eye can see.
- beepboopbeep 9y agoJust want to say-- I will never come back to this site if it devolves into the political bull shit of reddit. If you folks want to reddit-ize HN, go for it, but be ready to reap what you sow.
- fortythirteen 9y agoTo be fair, I think SV has been far too politicized and that's why you see it here.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- flashdance 9y agoFar-left is a bit of a stretch for me, this sounds slightly to the right of Canada's big-tent Liberal party, which is centre-left on a radical day. For reference, a far-left party is the ML party of Canada. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_of_Canada_(Marxist–Leninist) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communist_Party_of_Canada_(M... That doesn't remind me of Elon Musk for some reason...
- flashdance 9y agoIt appears the title has been un-editorialized! I take this back.
- nextstep 9y agoMostly virtue signaling. The piece finally address labor at the very last graphic: most entrepreneurs think labor unions should have less influence. The NYT painting this as “far-left” is a sign of how far to the right the US has come.
- beager 9y agoAt first blush, sounds like these folks are generally liberal as a result of their upbringing and higher education, and then they run into a spot in entrepreneurship where liberal ideology restricts business growth (ideologically to the benefit of the consumer). Reconciling high ideals with how they might restrict your business is always a struggle. Some may use those ideals to their advantage, some may embrace the cognitive dissonance, some may turn on their ideals altogether.
- pixelperfect 9y agoBiggest surprise of the article for me: only 36% of Democrats and 41% of Republicans believe "florists raising prices on holidays is fair."
- nolepointer 9y agoYeah, seriously, this is Econ 101.
- d--b 9y agoNow this is an interesting study. In some ways it reflects the shift that happened in France lately, where the new president is doing pretty much that: increasing taxes on capital and decreasing regulations for businesses while being very liberal regarding social matters. I also suspect that in silicon valley there is a difference between the 30+ age group and the 30-. It's a shame they didn't make that data available but it sounds to me that younger people are more libertarian than people in their 30s.
- uoaei 9y agoIf HN's signalling is anything to go off with respect to political leanings, SV is mostly libertarian with a dash of social democracy to rein in the big players. This is hardly what anyone outside of an entrenched centrist news media institution would consider "far left."
- jancsika 9y agoSomeone who hasn't read the article: please define far left. I think you'll find after reading the article that the term has been misinterpreted in order to follow a story arc.
- gnicholas 9y agoTotally agree. I actually left "far" out of the original title when I posted on HN, because I didn't remember it being there - and because after having read the article I didn't get that impression. Granted, I live in CA, so perhaps my definition of "far left" is different than others, but I can see that others here seem to share my sense that this was exaggeration on the part of the NYT.
- cortexio 9y agoWhy is this flagged? HN is pro censorship?
- lj3 9y agoThis isn't a study, it's a survey. Of course they're all going to say they're as far left as they can possibly be. Saying anything else will make them a target of the unhinged left wing nutbag brigade.